THRIVING after the FALL
Book Two PAIRING after the FALL

The Log · PAIRING · Read the chapter

Chapter 15: The Long Argument

73 claims, 31 to check first

C15-06 Check first open The oldest folder

Thomas Laqueur, Making Sex, 1990: one-sex model until the eighteenth century, two-sex model invented for political reasons when Enlightenment equality threatened hierarchy

To check against
HC-03, Laqueur 1990
The verdict
OPEN
C15-09 Check first open The oldest folder

Michael Stolberg, "A Woman Down to Her Bones", Isis, 2003: anatomists established skeletal and pelvic sex differences long before the Enlightenment

To check against
HC-03, Stolberg 2003
The verdict
OPEN
C15-11 Check first open The oldest folder

Female skeletons drawn by Felix Platter in 1583 and Caspar Bauhin in 1597, "by 1600"

To check against
HC-03 (Stolberg 2003)
The verdict
OPEN
C15-13 Check first open The oldest folder

Sun Simiao, Beiji Qianjin Yaofang, c. 651 CE, set up women's medicine (fuke) as a separate discipline on physiological grounds (menstruation, pregnancy, birth, recovery)

To check against
HC-03, Sun Simiao
The verdict
OPEN
C15-15 Check first open The oldest folder

The Trotula is three texts (Monica Green, critical edition 2002); De curis mulierum by Trota of Salerno, a real woman; Trota held infertility could lie in the man's seed as often as the womb; her treatments little touched by humoral theory. No date for Trota given in HC-03

To check against
HC-03, Green 2002
The verdict
OPEN
C15-16 Check first open The oldest folder

Hildegard of Bingen, twelfth century, Physica and Causae et Curae: female pleasure in conception, the "phlegmatic man" and "sanguine woman", viriditas as a varying vital force

To check against
HC-03, Hildegard
The verdict
OPEN
C15-18 Check first open The oldest folder; Contested

Direkvand-Moghadam et al. 2014, Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research: 17 studies, 18,803 women, PMS pooled prevalence 47.8 per cent (CI 32.6 to 62.9, omitted in text)

To check against
HC-03, Direkvand-Moghadam 2014
The verdict
OPEN
C15-19 Check first open The oldest folder; case against

PMS prevalence 12 per cent in France and 98 per cent in Iran; the 86-point swing is the chapter's arithmetic

To check against
HC-03, Direkvand-Moghadam 2014
The verdict
OPEN
C15-20 Check first open The oldest folder

Van der Wijden et al., Cochrane, 2003: lactational amenorrhoea method over 98 per cent effective in first six months with exclusive breastfeeding, pregnancy rates 0.45 to 2.45 per cent

To check against
HC-03, Van der Wijden 2003
The verdict
OPEN
C15-26 Check first open The household ledger

Sparta: women owned about 40 per cent of the land by Aristotle's time, managed estates and helots, Aristotle blamed this for Spartan decline

To check against
HC-01 (Aristotle, Politics)
The verdict
OPEN
C15-28 Check first open The household ledger

Han China: Zhangjiashan bamboo legal texts compiled c. 196 to 186 BCE, Barbieri-Low and Yates 2015, state-mandated small households, women heading households and inheriting, the Widow Wan case against male relatives. First names of Barbieri-Low and Yates not in HC-01

To check against
HC-01, Barbieri-Low & Yates 2015
The verdict
OPEN
C15-31 Check first open The household ledger

Yossef Rapoport 2005, Mamluk Egypt and Syria: daughters inherit half a son's share, mahr paid to the bride and kept by her, husband forfeits deferred mahr on divorce, khul'

To check against
HC-01, Rapoport 2005
The verdict
OPEN
C15-32 Check first open The household ledger; Numbers to carry

Divorce in medieval Islamic cities "approaching 30 per cent"

To check against
HC-01, Rapoport 2005
The verdict
OPEN
C15-38 Check first open The household ledger

Becker 2024, Review of Economic Studies: over 1.3 million people, over 100 countries; pastoralist ancestry predicts restricted female mobility, infibulation, anti-abortion attitudes; paternity-certainty mechanism. First name not in SO-05

To check against
SO-05, Becker 2024
The verdict
OPEN
C15-39 Check first open The household ledger; Contested

Schulz, Bahrami-Rad, Beauchamp and Henrich 2019, Science: 146 nations, Church Marriage and Family Program (cousin-marriage, polygyny, arranged-marriage bans), Kinship Intensity Index, WEIRD psychology. Critic (Woodley of Menie) sourced in SO-05 to a personal website

To check against
SO-05, Schulz et al. 2019
The verdict
OPEN
C15-42 Check first open The household ledger; Numbers to carry

Goldin and Katz 2002, Journal of Political Economy: state-by-cohort variation in laws giving unmarried women under 21 access to the pill; motherhood before 22 down 14 to 18 per cent; labour-force participation at 26 to 30 up about 8 per cent

To check against
SO-05, Goldin & Katz 2002
The verdict
OPEN
C15-44 Check first open What the scriptures filed

Genesis 2:18 'ezer kenegdo; David Freedman 1983; 'ezer used 21 times in the Hebrew Bible, mostly of God rescuing Israel; "a strength facing him" rendering

To check against
HC-02, Freedman 1983
The verdict
OPEN
C15-46 Check first open What the scriptures filed

Six Talmudic categories: zachar, neqeva, androgynos (Rabbi Meir: "unique creature"), tumtum, ayelonit, saris, with the definitions given

To check against
HC-02 (table)
The verdict
OPEN
C15-49 Check first open What the scriptures filed

John Paul II, Theology of the Body, 129 general audiences 1979 to 1984; Patrick Snyder as critic

To check against
HC-02
The verdict
OPEN
C15-54 Check first open What the scriptures filed

Glick and Fiske 1996, JPSP, Ambivalent Sexism Inventory, six studies, 2,250 respondents, hostile and benevolent sexism as complementary justifications that go together. First name of Glick not in HC-02

To check against
HC-02, Glick & Fiske 1996
The verdict
OPEN
C15-55 Check first open The last unsettled fight

Schmitt et al. 2008: 55 nations, personality gaps up to d = 0.70 in the most equal nations. DISCREPANCY: HC-07 gives N = 17,637 and no d; DH-10 gives d up to 0.70 and no N

To check against
HC-07 and DH-10, Schmitt, Realo, Voracek & Allik 2008, JPSP
The verdict
OPEN
C15-56 Check first open The last unsettled fight

Mac Giolla and Kajonius 2018, International Journal of Psychology: about 130,000 people, 22 countries, r = 0.69 between gender-equality index and personality gaps

To check against
HC-07
The verdict
OPEN
C15-57 Check first open The last unsettled fight

Schwartz and Rubel 2005, JPSP: 127 samples, 77,528 people, 70 countries; men higher on power and achievement, women on benevolence; median d = 0.15, maximum 0.32 (power); gaps wider with equality

To check against
HC-07
The verdict
OPEN
C15-58 Check first open The last unsettled fight; Numbers to carry

Falk and Hermle 2018, Science: Global Preferences Survey, 80,000 people, 76 countries, about 90 per cent of world population and income; six preferences measured by self-report and incentivised choices

To check against
HC-07, Falk & Hermle 2018
The verdict
OPEN
C15-59 Check first open The last unsettled fight; Numbers to carry

Falk and Hermle: risk d = -0.168, patience d = -0.050, altruism d = 0.106, positive reciprocity d = 0.055, women more trusting and less negatively reciprocal

To check against
HC-07
The verdict
OPEN
C15-60 Check first open The last unsettled fight; Numbers to carry

Falk and Hermle: gap width correlates r = 0.67 with log GDP per capita and r = 0.56 with their Gender Equality Index; near zero in poorest, largest in richest

To check against
HC-07
The verdict
OPEN
C15-62 Check first open The last unsettled fight

Stoet and Geary 2018, Psychological Science: in nearly all countries more girls capable of college-level STEM than enrol; gap widest in equal countries; follow-up 2.5 million adolescents across five PISA waves 2006 to 2018. DISCREPANCY: 472,242 pupils and 67 countries (HC-07, HC-02) versus over 300,000 and 73 countries (SY-05, per chapter 5). Sample figures not repeated in this chapter

To check against
HC-07, Stoet & Geary 2018 and follow-up
The verdict
OPEN
C15-63 Check first open The last unsettled fight; case against; Numbers to carry

Breda and Napp 2019, PNAS: 300,000 pupils, 64 countries; within-pupil reading-minus-maths gap 0.80 SD larger for girls; controlling it cuts the intention gap by 75 per cent and removes gaps in maths self-concept and interest. DISCREPANCY: other reports give 300,000 and 64 for Breda 2020 as well

To check against
HC-07, Breda & Napp 2019
The verdict
OPEN
C15-64 Check first open The last unsettled fight

Nosek et al. 2009, PNAS: over 500,000 IATs, 34 countries, 70 per cent implicitly pair science with male, national stereotype strength predicts national science gap

To check against
HC-07, Nosek 2009
The verdict
OPEN
C15-65 Check first open The last unsettled fight; case against; Numbers to carry

Breda, Jouini and Napp 2020, PNAS: in 71 of 72 countries girls more likely than equally able boys to attribute failure to lack of talent; gap largest in wealthy OECD countries

To check against
HC-07, Breda, Jouini & Napp 2020
The verdict
OPEN
C15-66 Check first open The last unsettled fight; In practice

Herlitz et al. 2024, Perspectives on Psychological Science: 54 articles, 27 large-scale studies; paradox holds for personality, verbal ability, episodic memory, negative emotions; reverses for sexual behaviour, partner preferences, maths

To check against
HC-07, Herlitz 2024
The verdict
OPEN
C15-01 open Opening

Opening scene: a Finnish fifteen-year-old in a 2018 PISA round, hundreds of thousands of pupils in dozens of countries, data collated by the OECD in Paris. Illustrative, not a documented person.

To check against
HC-07 (Finland among Stoet & Geary's equal countries; 2018 the last PISA wave named); OECD seat from general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C15-02 open Opening

The attribution-of-failure item the girl answers paraphrases the "lack of talent" measure in Breda, Jouini & Napp 2020

To check against
HC-07 on Breda, Jouini & Napp 2020, PNAS
The verdict
OPEN
C15-03 open Opening; The oldest folder

Hippocratic writers, fifth and fourth centuries BCE: female flesh looser and spongier, takes up more fluid, menses clear the surplus; a treatise on the diseases of women

To check against
HC-03, Hippocratic Corpus, Diseases of Women
The verdict
OPEN
C15-04 open The oldest folder

Aristotle, Generation of Animals: one seed, male gives form and female matter, carpenter and wood, rennet and milk, female as "infertile male" from insufficient heat

To check against
HC-03, Aristotle, Generation of Animals
The verdict
OPEN
C15-05 open The oldest folder

Galen, second century CE: two seeds, female seed colder and weaker, female organs the male's turned inward

To check against
HC-03, Galen, On Semen and Usefulness of Parts
The verdict
OPEN
C15-07 open The oldest folder

Katharine Park and Robert Nye, "Destiny is Anatomy", 1991 (New Republic), as a rebuttal of Laqueur

To check against
HC-03, Park & Nye 1991
The verdict
OPEN
C15-10 open The oldest folder

Helen King, The One-Sex Body on Trial, 2013: Laqueur ignored menstruation as the defining fact of pre-modern female physiology, treating it as a "local variant" of flux

To check against
HC-03, King 2013
The verdict
OPEN
C15-14 open The oldest folder

Si Wu Tang prescribed for painful periods and "still prescribed"

To check against
HC-03 (continued use and modern trials of Si Wu Tang; "still prescribed" is the chapter's wording)
The verdict
OPEN
C15-17 open The oldest folder

Ibn Sina (Avicenna), 980 to 1037, Canon of Medicine: two seeds, female orgasm needed to release female seed, Aristotle's rennet metaphor

To check against
HC-03, Avicenna
The verdict
OPEN
C15-21 open The oldest folder

Díaz 1988, 236 Chilean women; Cooney 1996, 419 Rwandan couples

To check against
HC-03 (Bellagio Consensus 1988 also named there, not used)
The verdict
OPEN
C15-22 open The oldest folder

Men's resting metabolism slightly higher than women's, contrary to the "cold" female

To check against
HC-03, no primary source named
The verdict
OPEN
C15-24 open The household ledger

Martin Whyte 1978: ten independent dimensions of women's status (as chapter 2 reported)

To check against
DH-07 via chapter 2; DH-10 gives 52 variables, 93 societies
The verdict
OPEN
C15-27 open The household ledger

Rome: marriage cum manu to sine manu, sui iuris; Livia and Agrippina as wealthy women

To check against
HC-01
The verdict
OPEN
C15-29 open The household ledger

Japan: Heian 794 to 1185 uxorilocal marriage (Wakita Haruko 1992), ie system c. 1100 to 1600, Edo loss of status

To check against
HC-01, Wakita 1992
The verdict
OPEN
C15-30 open The household ledger

Vedic India: Stephanie Jamison 1996, the patnī indispensable to śrauta ritual, Gargi Vachaknavi and Maitreyi, later Manusmriti

To check against
HC-01, Jamison 1996
The verdict
OPEN
C15-33 open The household ledger

Coverture, William Blackstone's formulation, feme covert and feme sole, married women trading as femes soles by town custom, Married Women's Property Acts late nineteenth century

To check against
HC-01
The verdict
OPEN
C15-34 open The household ledger

Iceland's Grágás excluded women from the Thing and reduced inheritance; women ran farms, carried the household keys, could divorce by declaration before witnesses

To check against
HC-01
The verdict
OPEN
C15-35 open The household ledger

Dahomey: Edna Bay, Wives of the Leopard, 1998; the Mino women's regiments; the kpojito as queen mother and office of state

To check against
HC-01, Bay 1998
The verdict
OPEN
C15-36 open The household ledger

Hatshepsut assumed the full pharaonic titulary and was depicted with false beard and male kilt; office conceptually male

To check against
HC-01
The verdict
OPEN
C15-37 open The household ledger

Haudenosaunee (Iroquois): matrilineal, Clan Mothers chose and could depose sachems

To check against
HC-01
The verdict
OPEN
C15-40 open The household ledger; In practice

Giuliano and Nunn 2021, Review of Economic Studies: seventy 20-year generations from 500 to 1900 AD, climate variability, traditions persist where environment is stable

To check against
SO-05, Giuliano & Nunn 2021
The verdict
OPEN
C15-41 open The household ledger; In practice

Doepke and Tertilt 2009, Econometrica, "Women's Rights: What's in it for Men?": men extended rights as returns to education rose because women spend more of household resources on children's schooling

To check against
SO-05, Doepke & Tertilt 2009
The verdict
OPEN
C15-43 open The household ledger

Barbara born 1946, the author born 1975

To check against
The author's biography (brief)
The verdict
OPEN
C15-45 open What the scriptures filed

Daniel Boyarin, Carnal Israel, 1993: Rabbinic Judaism refused to renounce the body

To check against
HC-02, Boyarin 1993
The verdict
OPEN
C15-47 open What the scriptures filed

Gilbert Herdt 1994, Sambia kwolu-aatmwol, 5-alpha reductase deficiency; the word pre-dates the enzyme. First name not in DH-10; Morgan Holmes disputes Herdt's "third sex" reading (not used)

To check against
DH-10, Herdt 1994
The verdict
OPEN
C15-48 open What the scriptures filed

Aquinas: grace perfects nature, sexes complete each other

To check against
HC-02
The verdict
OPEN
C15-51 open What the scriptures filed

Dong Zhongshu, Han dynasty, mapped yin and yang onto nei/wai, inner and outer

To check against
HC-02
The verdict
OPEN
C15-52 open What the scriptures filed

Ardhanarishvara half Shiva, half Parvati/Shakti; Tantric use against caste and purity rules

To check against
HC-02
The verdict
OPEN
C15-53 open What the scriptures filed

Bugis five genders (Sharyn Graham Davies): makkunrai, oroané, calalai, calabai, bissu

To check against
HC-02, Davies
The verdict
OPEN
C15-61 open The last unsettled fight

Luigi Guiso, Monte, Sapienza and Zingales 2008, Science: PISA 2003, 40 countries, maths gap disappears with equality, reading gap expands

To check against
HC-07
The verdict
OPEN
C15-67 open The last unsettled fight

"Nobody has yet run the study that would decide it": a within-person longitudinal test of the paradox. Chapter's own statement of HC-07's open question; Fors Connolly 2020 used repeated cross-sections, not the same people

To check against
HC-07, open questions section, no primary source
The verdict
OPEN
C15-68 open Case against

Ilmarinen and Lönnqvist 2024: difference scores overstate the relation between sex differences and equality, artefact of calculation. First names not in HC-02

To check against
HC-02, Ilmarinen & Lönnqvist 2024
The verdict
OPEN
C15-69 open Case against

Reference-group effect and measurement invariance critique, as stated

To check against
HC-07, no primary source named
The verdict
OPEN
C15-70 open Case against

Formozov: independent effect of equality indices fragile once development controlled; self-report scale translation artefact. First name "Andrey" from a source URL in HC-01

To check against
HC-01, Formozov (publications page)
The verdict
OPEN
C15-71 open Case against

Fors Connolly, Goossen and Hjerm 2020: within-country equality gains do not widen gaps (one sentence, as chapter 5 reported)

To check against
HC-07, Fors Connolly 2020, Sex Roles
The verdict
OPEN
C15-72 open In practice

"In any country, most women and most men sit inside each other's range" on Falk and Hermle's preferences: inference from d values of 0.168 and below

To check against
HC-07 (d values); inference, no primary source
The verdict
OPEN
C15-73 open Case against

concept note required this chapter's case against to meet Breda 2020

To check against
the concept note §11 risk 10
The verdict
OPEN