C14-01 Check first open §Opening, §The lotteryIndia's 1993 constitutional amendment reserved one-third of village council chair (Pradhan) posts for women, with the reserved councils chosen at random ("randomly reserved" in SO-01, "drawn by lot" in the SO fact sheet)
- To check against
- SO-01. Primary: Chattopadhyay and Duflo 2004, *Econometrica*
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-02 Check first open §Opening, §The lottery, §Numbers to carryChattopadhyay and Duflo 2004: 265 village councils in West Bengal and Rajasthan. Women-led councils in West Bengal spent more on drinking water. Women in the village spoke about twice as often at meetings with a woman in the chair
- To check against
- SO-01, SO-07. Primary: Chattopadhyay and Duflo 2004, *Econometrica*. First name Raghabendra not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-04 Check first open §The lottery, §In practice, §Numbers to carryBhavnani 2009: in Mumbai wards where a reservation had lapsed, a woman was about five times as likely to win the next open election as in a never-reserved ward
- To check against
- SO-01. Primary: Bhavnani 2009, *American Political Science Review*. First name Rikhil not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-05 Check first open §The lottery, §Numbers to carryBhalotra and Clots-Figueras 2014: a ten-percentage-point rise in women's share of Indian state legislature seats cut neonatal mortality by 2.1 percentage points, about a third of the baseline (33.5 per cent), via antenatal visits, iron supplements and facility births
- To check against
- SO-01. Primary: Bhalotra and Clots-Figueras 2014, *American Economic Journal: Applied Economics*. First names Sonia and Irma not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-06 Check first open §The lottery, §Numbers to carryBhalotra, Clarke, Gomes and Venkataramani 2023: after a parliamentary gender quota in developing countries, maternal mortality ratio fell 8 to 12 per cent, skilled birth attendance rose 5 to 8 points, prenatal care rose 4 to 8 points, fertility fell 6 to 7 per cent, girls' schooling rose about half a year
- To check against
- SO-01. Primary: Bhalotra et al. 2023, *Journal of the European Economic Association*. First names Damian, Joseph, Atheendar not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-08 Check first open §The lotteryBaskaran, Bhalotra, Min and Uppal: 4,265 close elections to Indian state assemblies, constituencies won by a woman grew 1.8 percentage points a year faster by night-light luminosity, male candidates three times as likely to carry criminal charges, women's asset accumulation about 10 percentage points a year lower
- To check against
- SO-01. Primary: Baskaran et al. 2018 (working paper) and 2023, *Journal of Economic Growth*. Both years given in SO-01. First names Thushyanthan, Brian, Yogesh not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-18 Check first open §Opening, §Queens, §The strongest case against, §In practice, §Numbers to carryDube and Harish 2020, "Queens": 193 reigns, 18 European polities, 1480 to 1913, polities under a queen 39 percentage points more likely to be at war in a given year. Instruments: whether the previous monarch had a first-born son and whether the previous monarch had a sister
- To check against
- SO-01. Primary: Dube and Harish 2020, *Journal of Political Economy*. Preface carries the same figures
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-19 Check first open §Opening, §QueensDube and Harish: unmarried queens more likely to be attacked, married queens more likely to be aggressors (more than married kings), explained by the husband acting as co-executive in charge of army and treasury. "Dual executive" wording
- To check against
- SO-01. Primary: Dube and Harish 2020
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-21 Check first open §Queens, §The strongest case against, §In practiceHudson et al. 2012, *Sex and World Peace*: the physical security of women predicts a state's peacefulness better than wealth, democracy or religion. Critics: endogeneity, rich stable democracies both protect women and avoid war
- To check against
- SO-01 (no country count, no co-author names). Primary: Hudson et al. 2012, *Sex and World Peace* (co-author list to confirm, see C14-22)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-22 Check first open §QueensHudson's co-authors given as Caprioli, Bowen and McDermott, and WomanStats as 130,000 data points across 175 countries. Both from SY-05, a synthesis report whose book sources are Goodreads and Bookey. SY-05 says the 2012 book was "updated in 2020 as *The First Political Order*", whose co-authors differ from the 2012 book's. Carried with (to be checked). Preface carries 175 countries
- To check against
- SY-05, no primary source named. Primary: *Sex and World Peace* 2012 and *The First Political Order* 2020, WomanStats project documentation
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-30 Check first open §Two columns in the statute bookNorway: law conscripting women passed 2013, in force 2015, first NATO member to do so. Mixed dormitories. Hellum 2014 (Norwegian Defence Research Establishment, FFI) at Skjold and Heggelia: shared rooms produced "de-genderisation", less harassment, all-female rooms more interpersonal drama. Women 14 per cent of the force by 2020 against a 20 per cent target (DCAF)
- To check against
- SO-04. Primary: Hellum 2014, FFI report, and the DCAF report (title and year not given in SO-04). First name Nina not in document. Spelling of "de-genderisation" anglicised from the document's "de-genderization"
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-31 Check first open §Two columns in the statute book, §In practice, §Numbers to carryFinestone, Milgrom, Moran et al. 2005: Israeli Anti-Aircraft Forces, identical basic training, stress fractures in 23.9 per cent of women (33) against 11.2 per cent of men (42), relative risk 2.13, women's fractures in tibia, femur and pelvis
- To check against
- SO-04. Primary: Finestone et al. 2005, *Military Medicine*. First names Aharon, Charles, Daniel not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-32 Check first open §Two columns in the statute book, §In practice, §Numbers to carryFinestone et al. 2014: light infantry, stress fractures 12.0 per cent of women against 1.3 per cent of men, relative risk 9.23
- To check against
- SO-04. Primary: Finestone et al. 2014, venue not given in SO-04
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-35 Check first open §Two columns in the statute book, §In practice, §Numbers to carryStarr 2014: US federal cases followed from arrest to sentence, men's sentences 63 per cent longer than women's for the same arrest offence and criminal history, women twice as likely to avoid prison if convicted, about 30 per cent of the incarceration gap unexplained, gap about six times the racial gap
- To check against
- SO-04. Primary: Starr 2014, *American Law and Economics Review*. First name Sonja not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-36 Check first open §Two columns in the statute book, §Numbers to carryFrance, all convictions 2000 to 2003: women's sentences 15 days shorter, a third of the 45-day mean. Mixed co-offender pairs (same crime, same judge, same day): man longer in 22 per cent, woman longer in 4 per cent. One standard deviation more female judges shrinks the gap by about 10 per cent. SO-04 attributes this only in a table to "Breda 2020". Carried with (to be checked)
- To check against
- SO-04. Primary: to identify (Breda 2020 or the French study SO-04 summarises)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Roads finding: SO-01 says women-led councils in Rajasthan spent less on roads, SO-07 says women-led councils in West Bengal spent more on water and roads. Report-to-report discrepancy, carried in the text with (to be checked)
- To check against
- SO-01 against SO-07. Primary: Chattopadhyay and Duflo 2004
- The verdict
- OPEN
United States 1937, arrival of sulfa drugs: maternal deaths fell 15 per cent further in states that had enfranchised women early. SO-01's text attributes this to the 2023 JEEA paper, its works cited to a separate 2023 paper (UCLouvain). Carried with (to be checked)
- To check against
- SO-01. Primary: to be identified (Bhalotra et al. 2023 JEEA or the separate 2023 working paper)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-09 open §The fairer sex, auditedDollar, Fisman and Gatti 2001: across more than 100 countries, one standard deviation more women in parliament goes with 20 per cent of a standard deviation less perceived corruption. Title asks whether women are "the fairer sex"
- To check against
- SO-01. Primary: Dollar, Fisman and Gatti 2001, *Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization* (venue kept out of prose to avoid the -ize spelling). First names David, Raymond, Roberta not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-10 open §The fairer sex, auditedEsarey and Chirillo 2013: the women-corruption relationship holds in democracies and vanishes in autocracies. Title "Fairer Sex or Purity Myth?"
- To check against
- SO-01. Primary: Esarey and Chirillo 2013, *Politics and Gender*. First name Gina not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-11 open §The fairer sex, audited, §In practiceEsarey and Schwindt-Bayer 2018: across 76 democratic-leaning countries, women reduce corruption only where electoral accountability is high. SO-01 text says *American Journal of Political Science*, works-cited PDF filename says BJPS
- To check against
- SO-01. Primary: Esarey and Schwindt-Bayer 2018, venue to confirm (AJPS or BJPS)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-12 open §The fairer sex, audited, §In practiceBarnes and Beaulieu 2014 and 2018: voters hold women politicians to a higher ethical standard and punish a woman's scandal harder
- To check against
- SO-01. Primary: Barnes and Beaulieu 2014 and 2018, venues not given in SO-01. First names Tiffany and Emily not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-13 open §The fairer sex, auditedCroson and Gneezy 2009: women on average more risk-averse and more sensitive to context in laboratory games
- To check against
- SO-01. Primary: Croson and Gneezy 2009, *Journal of Economic Literature*. First name Rachel not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-14 open §The fairer sex, audited, §The strongest case againstNelson 2015: 147 estimates from 25 studies of risk aversion, publication bias inflates the sex gap, within-sex variation dwarfs between-sex
- To check against
- SO-01. Primary: Nelson 2015, *Feminist Economics*. First name Julie not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-15 open §The fairer sex, audited, §The strongest case againstDellaVigna and Pope: 93 per cent of between-subject comparisons contradict the claim that women's social preferences are more context-sensitive. SO-01 text says 2022, works-cited NBER number (w35324) suggests 2025. Carried with (to be checked)
- To check against
- SO-01. Primary: DellaVigna and Pope, NBER working paper, year to confirm. First names Stefano and Devin not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-16 open §The fairer sex, auditedFemale heads of state sit in the tails of the distributions and are statistically hard to distinguish from male peers on competitiveness, risk tolerance and dominance (paraphrased from SO-01's own wording)
- To check against
- SO-01, no primary source named
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-17 open §The fairer sex, audited, §In practiceWomen on monetary policy committees vote for higher rates than men at the same expected inflation (chapter 10 owns the finding, referred to here in one line)
- To check against
- SO-07. Primary: Masciandaro, Profeta and Romelli 2020, *European Journal of Political Economy*. Verified under chapter 10
- The verdict
- OPEN
Dube and Harish's affiliations: not given in SO-01, left as (to be checked) in prose. S. P. Harish given with initials only
- To check against
- SO-01. Primary: title page of Dube and Harish 2020
- The verdict
- OPEN
Standard Cross-Cultural Sample assembled by Murdock and White 1969. DH-07 gives 186 societies in one place and 185 in another. No society in the sample has women holding military leadership ("zero out of 185" in DH-07)
- To check against
- DH-07. Primary: Murdock and White 1969, *Ethnology*, and the SCCS variable on military leadership (source for the zero to be identified)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Sanday 1981, *Female Power and Male Dominance*: 156 societies scaled on women's economic control, political voice and symbolic standing. Inner versus outer orientation. Outer orientation (stress, migration, endemic war, reliance on hunting large animals and fighting) travels with high interpersonal violence and rape-prone cultures
- To check against
- DH-07. Primary: Sanday 1981, *Female Power and Male Dominance*, Cambridge University Press
- The verdict
- OPEN
Divale and Harris 1976, "male supremacy complex": warfare rewards young men with patrilocal residence, polygyny, political monopoly and subordination of women
- To check against
- DH-07. Primary: Divale and Harris 1976, *American Anthropologist*
- The verdict
- OPEN
Low: pathogen stress and male war mortality are the two best predictors of non-sororal polygyny, with controls for shared ancestry. Year and venue not in DH-07, carried with (to be checked)
- To check against
- DH-07. Primary: Low (year and venue to identify). First name Bobbi not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
Henrich, Boyd and Richerson 2012: about 85 per cent of societies in the ethnographic record permit polygyny (DH-07 says "over 80 per cent" of Ethnographic Atlas societies). Normative monogamy reduces the pool of unmarried men, murder, rape and robbery, the spousal age gap, and raises paternal investment
- To check against
- SO-05 (85 per cent), DH-07 (over 80 per cent). Primary: Henrich, Boyd and Richerson 2012, *Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B*. First names Joseph, Robert, Peter not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
(SO-02, still to be written) gap. The gap names Valerie Hudson and Andrea den Boer on surplus young men and state violence. den Boer appears in no document in the library. Carried with (to be checked)
- To check against
- No document. Primary if SO-02 is produced: Hudson and den Boer's book on surplus men (title and year from the drafter's memory, not the library, so not written here)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Whyte 1978, *The Status of Women in Preindustrial Societies*: 93 societies, factor analysis finds about ten dimensions of women's standing that barely correlate
- To check against
- DH-07. Primary: Whyte 1978, Princeton University Press. First and middle names Martin King not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-33 open §Two columns in the statute bookMoran et al. 2012, US Navy: about 10 per cent of women against about 3 per cent of men, hazard more than fourfold in the first six months of training. Carried with (to be checked)
- To check against
- SO-04. Primary: Moran et al. 2012, venue not given
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-34 open §Two columns in the statute book, §In practiceIndividual women with high baseline fitness complete the tours (the overlap point). SO-04's wording, no figure
- To check against
- SO-04, no primary source named
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-37 open §Two columns in the statute bookContested custody cases ending in sole physical custody for the mother: 80 to 84 per cent, no primary source in SO-04. Carried with (to be checked)
- To check against
- SO-04, no primary source named
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-38 open §Two columns in the statute bookBauserman 2002 meta-analysis: joint-custody children closer to intact-family children than sole-custody children, joint-custody parents reported less conflict, d = 0.24
- To check against
- SO-04. Primary: Bauserman 2002, *Journal of Family Psychology*. First name Robert not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-39 open §Two columns in the statute bookNielsen 2018: 60 studies, joint-custody children better on every measure in 34, equal or better in 14, worse on one measure in 6
- To check against
- SO-04. Primary: Nielsen 2018, venue not given in SO-04. First name Linda not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-40 open §Two columns in the statute bookMcIntosh 2010 and 2013 (Australia) led courts to deny infant overnights to fathers. Warshak 2014 consensus report with 110 signatories said the evidence did not support that and overnights keep fathers involved
- To check against
- SO-04. Primary: Warshak 2014, *Psychology, Public Policy, and Law*. McIntosh venues not given. First names Jennifer and Richard not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-41 open §Two columns in the statute book, §In practiceConradt and Roper 2003: in models of group decisions with conflicting interests, despotic decisions cost the group more than shared ones because shared decisions land nearer the group's median interest
- To check against
- SO-07. Primary: Conradt and Roper 2003, *Nature* (SO-07 also cites a 2005 *Trends in Ecology and Evolution* review). First names Larissa and Timothy not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-42 open §Two columns in the statute bookMavisakalyan and Tarverdi 2019: higher share of women in parliament goes with stricter climate policy and lower CO2 emissions, instrumental-variable design
- To check against
- SO-07. Primary: Mavisakalyan and Tarverdi 2019, *European Journal of Political Economy*. SO-07 also attributes a Hofstede analysis (18 countries, 20 years) to them but cites a 2025 paper, not used. First names Astghik and Yashar not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-43 open §Two columns in the statute bookGarikipati and Kambhampati 2021: 194 countries matched on wealth and demography, women-led countries locked down earlier and had about half as many COVID-19 deaths in the first wave of 2020
- To check against
- SO-07. Primary: Garikipati and Kambhampati 2021, *Feminist Economics*. First names Supriya and Uma not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-44 open §The strongest case againstWindsor et al. 2020: critique that the countries which elect women are high-trust, low-hierarchy countries, which explains the pandemic and climate results. Venue not given in SO-07
- To check against
- SO-07. Primary: Windsor et al. 2020, venue to identify. First name Leah not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-45 open §Two columns in the statute book, §In practiceCapital Jury Project: 1,200 juror interviews, 353 capital cases, 14 US states. White male jurors most willing to sentence to death, women weigh mitigating evidence more heavily. Bowers as lead. Venues and years not in SO-07
- To check against
- SO-07. Primary: Bowers et al., Capital Jury Project publications (to identify). First name William not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-46 open §Two columns in the statute book, §In practiceDoepke and Tertilt 2009, "Women's Rights: What's in it for Men?": men extended property rights and later the vote to women as the return on children's education rose, because women spend a larger share of household resources on children
- To check against
- SO-05. Primary: Doepke and Tertilt 2009, *Econometrica*. First name Matthias not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-47 open §The strongest case againstPost and Byron 2015: 140 studies, women on boards show a small positive relation with accounting returns, strongest where shareholder protection is strong, near-zero with market performance
- To check against
- SO-07. Primary: Post and Byron 2015, *Academy of Management Journal*. First names Corinne and Kris not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-48 open §The strongest case againstSila, Gonzalez and Hagendorff 2016: no effect of women directors on equity risk in a large sample of US firms
- To check against
- SO-07. Primary: Sila, Gonzalez and Hagendorff 2016, *Journal of Corporate Finance*. First names Vathunyoo, Angelica, Jens not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-49 open §The strongest case againstMatsa and Miller 2013: Norwegian quota boards laid off fewer workers and earned less in the short run
- To check against
- SO-07. Primary: Matsa and Miller 2013, *American Economic Journal: Applied Economics*. Chapter 10 owns the Norway boardroom (Ahern and Dittmar, Eckbo). First names David and Amalia not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-50 open §The strongest case againstTaylor et al. 2000, tend-and-befriend: 200 studies, 14,548 participants, 66 per cent male in the earlier stress literature. Rests on oxytocin, which the Preface's verdict undercuts
- To check against
- SO-01. Primary: Taylor et al. 2000, *Psychological Review*. First name Shelley not in document
- The verdict
- OPEN
"Economic-marginalisation theorists predict" that equality for women means more women in prison (the correction over-shooting)
- To check against
- SO-04, no primary source named
- The verdict
- OPEN
C14-52 open §Queens, §Two columns, §In practice, §Working notesChapter cross-references: chapter 2's ledger of who cooks (Murdock and Provost), chapter 8's father's brain, chapter 10's central bankers and teams, chapter 13's leave, chapter 15's plough and Church material. Each owned and verified under its own chapter
- To check against
- Cross-chapter, not verified here
- The verdict
- OPEN
Cut material logged in the working notes for other chapters: Paffenholz 2014/2015 (40 peace processes), Krause, Krause and Bränfors 2018 (*International Interactions*, 2,299 delegates, 116 agreements), UNSCR 1325 (to chapter 16), Mandel and Semyonov 2006 (*American Sociological Review*, 22 countries, to chapter 11), Lott and Kenny 1999 (*Journal of Political Economy*, public health spending up 35 per cent after suffrage, Sheppard-Towner 1921, to website)
- To check against
- SO-01, SO-04. Verified by whichever chapter picks them up
- The verdict
- OPEN