THRIVING after the FALL
Book Two PAIRING after the FALL

The Log · PAIRING · Read the chapter

Chapter 13: The Wall

52 claims, 22 to check first

C13-01 Check first open §Opening, §Pool, halve, tax, double

Ehegattensplitting introduced in West German law in 1958 and still in force; mechanism pool, halve, tax, double

To check against
SY-06 (present tense, no statute named); primary would be EStG §26b and §32a, not in the library
The verdict
OPEN
C13-05 Check first open §The paragraph and the cover

Hausfrauenehe: wife needed husband's consent to work, revocable if the job interfered with her duties in the home, until the 1977 reform

To check against
HC-05; no statute named (would be BGB §1356 old version and the 1976 marriage law reform in force 1 July 1977); Preface marker 1
The verdict
OPEN
C13-07 Check first open §The paragraph and the cover

Stern cover 6 June 1971, 374 women, Romy Schneider among them, organised by Alice Schwarzer after the French Manifeste des 343; led to Emma

To check against
HC-05; Preface rows P-09 and P-10 carry the same; HC-05 names no primary (Stern issue 24/1971)
The verdict
OPEN
C13-08 Check first open §The paragraph and the cover

1974 Fristenlösung (legal in the first three months); 1975 Federal Constitutional Court struck it down, BVerfGE 39, 1, reading Article 2 of the Basic Law; fallback to indications

To check against
HC-05; primary would be BVerfGE 39, 1 (25 February 1975), not in the library
The verdict
OPEN
C13-09 Check first open §The paragraph and the cover

GDR legalised abortion on demand in the first twelve weeks in 1972, "three years earlier" than 1975

To check against
HC-05; primary would be the GDR law of 9 March 1972, not in the library
The verdict
OPEN
C13-10 Check first open §The paragraph and the cover

1993 compromise: abortion remains an offence under §218, unpunished in the first twelve weeks after counselling and a waiting period; still in force

To check against
HC-05; primary would be BVerfGE 88, 203 (1993) and the 1995 amendment; HC-05 gives 1993 only
The verdict
OPEN
C13-11 Check first open §The paragraph and the cover

1977 "partnership marriage" reform struck the housewife marriage from the law

To check against
HC-05; no statute named
The verdict
OPEN
C13-16 Check first open §Pool, halve, tax, double

Steiner and Wrohlich 2004 microsimulation found splitting a primary driver of low full-time employment of married women; first names Viktor and Katharina

To check against
SY-06 text says "published in CESifo"; SY-06 works cited gives DIW Discussion Paper 421; first names from general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C13-18 Check first open §Pool, halve, tax, double

Older women draw about half (53 per cent) of the pension income of older men; pension follows lifetime earnings

To check against
CO-02 via chapter 7 line 43 and the log; year and definition (gender pension gap, Destatis) not stated in CO-02 summary
The verdict
OPEN
C13-23 Check first open §Mummy politics

1989: about 89 per cent of East German women of working age in the labour force against 56 per cent in the West; Rosenfeld, Trappe and Gornick, Annual Review of Sociology, 2004; first names Rachel, Heike, Janet

To check against
HC-06; Preface row P-01; Gornick's first name from general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C13-25 Check first open §Mummy politics

Babyjahr 1976: paid year after a birth, job held open, option of reduced hours, no penalty on return

To check against
SY-06; no primary source named; the Preface carries the same year
The verdict
OPEN
C13-29 Check first open §What the records say, §Where the wall stops, §Numbers 1

Boelmann, Raute and Schönberg, AEJ: Applied Economics, 2025: 50 per cent random sample of social-security records; collective model of family labour supply; East German mothers about 1,800 hours a year, West about 350 fewer; no gap between fathers

To check against
SY-06; the 350 hours and 73 per cent are cited in SY-06 to ECONtribute 2026 [2] "Economic Incentives or Social Norms?", the 70/45 to ECONtribute 2021 [25]; the AEJ Applied 2025 attribution is SY-06's; check that all figures are in the published version
The verdict
OPEN
C13-30 Check first open §What the records say, §Numbers 1

Equalising wages across East and West would nearly double the mothers' hours gap; working-mother stigma accounts for 73 per cent of the gap

To check against
SY-06; Preface marker 4
The verdict
OPEN
C13-32 Check first open §What the records say, §Numbers 3

Kleven, Landais, Posch, Steinhauer and Zweimüller, AEA Papers and Proceedings, 2019: long-run child penalty about 61 per cent in West Germany, about 20 in the United States, 21 to 27 in Scandinavia; "ten years on"

To check against
HC-05 gives 61; FA-05 via chapter 8 gives 60 with a different author list (Kleven, Landais and Søgaard, the Denmark paper); the "ten years" horizon is the author's gloss on "long-run" and must be checked against the paper (which reports 5 to 10 years after birth)
The verdict
OPEN
C13-34 Check first open §What the records say, §Numbers 2

Lippmann, Georgieff and Senik, The Economic Journal, 2020: SOEP 1991 to 2012; when a wife's income crosses 50 per cent of household income, West German couples show more housework by her, higher exit from employment and higher divorce risk in the following year; East German couples none

To check against
SY-06 (regression and placebo exercises); HC-06 ("replicated across multiple datasets", unnamed)
The verdict
OPEN
C13-35 Check first open §What the records say, §Numbers 2

In 1992 almost 30 per cent of East German wives out-earned their husbands against 16 per cent in the West; "the gap has not closed"

To check against
HC-06; the persistence claim is HC-06's, no end year given
The verdict
OPEN
C13-37 Check first open §What the records say, §Numbers 4

Bauernschuster and Rainer, Journal of Population Economics, 2012: East Germans 22 percentage points more likely to hold egalitarian sex-role attitudes; first names Stefan and Helmut

To check against
SY-06; first names from general knowledge; survey and item not named
The verdict
OPEN
C13-38 Check first open §What the records say, §Numbers 5

Births outside marriage: West Germany 10.6 per cent in 1950, 5.8 in 1965; Germany 33.1 per cent in 2023; over 50 and over 60 per cent in many eastern districts

To check against
SY-06 attributes to Destatis but cites germanpedia.com [31] and a ResearchGate figure [29]; check Destatis directly
The verdict
OPEN
C13-44 Check first open §Where the wall stops, §In practice, §Numbers 4

Lois, Comparative Population Studies, 2020: ALLBUS 1982 to 2016, nine waves, 26,389 respondents, age-period-cohort separation; western egalitarian drift stalled for men born around 1956 and later and for women born after 1966; eastern cohorts soften from a higher level; first name Daniel

To check against
SY-06; first name from general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C13-48 Check first open §The strongest case against

Tiger and Shepher, Women in the Kibbutz, 1975: three generations of records; by the second and third generations about 75 per cent of women in education, health and services and about 75 per cent of men in agriculture, industry and management; sample began at 30; Spiro 1979 concurred; mothers drove the return of children to family sleeping; critics Rosenfeld 1958, van Teeffelen 1977 (patriarchal region, tokenism)

To check against
HC-06; chapter 11 carries the kibbutz in full (the log)
The verdict
OPEN
C13-49 Check first open §The strongest case against

Falk and Hermle, Science, 2018: 80,000 people, 76 countries; sex differences in economic preferences largest in richer and more equal countries; r = 0.67 with log GDP per capita, 0.56 with the equality index; Fors Connolly 2020 finds no within-country divergence

To check against
HC-07; chapter 5 carries the paradox (the log)
The verdict
OPEN
C13-50 Check first open §The strongest case against, §In practice

Japan, OECD 2020: women 224 minutes a day of unpaid work against men's 41, the widest gap in the OECD; men 452 minutes of paid work a day, the longest in the OECD

To check against
HC-06, sourced to an isvd.or.jp column, not to the OECD table
The verdict
OPEN
C13-02 open §Opening, §Pool, halve, tax, double

Half-day school and near-absent public care for under-threes as the West German norm; no date range

To check against
SY-06; no primary source named
The verdict
OPEN
C13-03 open §Opening

350-hour gap equals "about a month and a half" of a working year

To check against
Author's arithmetic at 40 hours a week; 350 hours is SY-06 citing Boelmann, Raute and Schönberg (ECONtribute 2026 [2])
The verdict
OPEN
C13-04 open §Opening, passim

The GDR took the opposite bet "for forty-one years"; western rules laid over the whole country in 1990

To check against
Author's count 1949 to 1990; HC-05, HC-06 for 1990
The verdict
OPEN
C13-06 open §The paragraph and the cover

Abortion a crime under Paragraph 218 of the criminal code, with prison

To check against
HC-05
The verdict
OPEN
C13-12 open §The paragraph and the cover

West German feminists did not, on the whole, demand public childcare and distrusted state crèches; quote "entirely on an individual basis"

To check against
SY-06 [12], [13] (a literary study and a motherhood paper, not movement documents); quote is SY-06's own wording
The verdict
OPEN
C13-13 open §The paragraph and the cover

Davidoff and Hall, Family Fortunes, 1987: separate spheres written in Birmingham and Essex, 1780 to 1850, from sermons, wills and house plans

To check against
HC-04
The verdict
OPEN
C13-14 open §The paragraph and the cover, §In practice ("Scandinavia chose the other options")

Lewis 1992, Journal of European Social Policy: Britain and Germany strong male-breadwinner states, Sweden and Denmark weak

To check against
HC-04; the Scandinavian "other options" (individual taxation) is the author's gloss on Lewis's weak-breadwinner column
The verdict
OPEN
C13-15 open §Pool, halve, tax, double

Splitting advantage largest when one income is zero; second earner's first euro taxed at the husband's marginal rate

To check against
SY-06
The verdict
OPEN
C13-17 open §Pool, halve, tax, double, §Mummy politics

Rabenmutter (raven mother) and Schmarotzer (parasite) as the two nouns, with the definitions given

To check against
SY-06 [11], a Reddit thread; no cultural-history source in the library
The verdict
OPEN
C13-19 open §Pool, halve, tax, double

"With the best Catholic intentions": the West German model as conservative welfare state and subsidiarity

To check against
SY-06 (Esping-Andersen typology referenced); "Catholic" is the author's characterisation of subsidiarity
The verdict
OPEN
C13-20 open §Mummy politics

GDR constitution of 1949 wrote in the right to work and to equal pay

To check against
SY-06, HC-06; primary (GDR constitution 1949, Art. 7 and 18) not in the library
The verdict
OPEN
C13-21 open §Mummy politics

GDR lost workers to the war and to the open border until 1961; labour shortage as motive

To check against
SY-06, HC-06
The verdict
OPEN
C13-22 open §Mummy politics

Public childcare covered "nearly every child" by the late 1980s

To check against
SY-06 phrase; HC-06; no coverage percentage given in either
The verdict
OPEN
C13-24 open §Mummy politics

Fertility fell and from the 1970s policy turned to Muttipolitik

To check against
SY-06; no fertility figures given
The verdict
OPEN
C13-26 open §Mummy politics, §The strongest case against

Trappe and Rosenfeld documented the double burden from GDR surveys; men's domestic hours did not move; the state "did not challenge male privilege at home"

To check against
HC-06 (Trappe and Rosenfeld, year not given), HC-05 (quoted phrase)
The verdict
OPEN
C13-27 open §Mummy politics

Early-1990s meeting of West German feminists and the East's Independent Women's Association (UFV); mutual misreading; crèches and Babyjahr dismantled

To check against
SY-06 [22], a book preview; no primary
The verdict
OPEN
C13-28 open §What the records say

"Thirty-five years since the rules were made the same"

To check against
Author's count from 1990
The verdict
OPEN
C13-31 open §What the records say, §In practice

West German mothers who moved east adopted eastern hours and kept them on returning west; West German mothers in firms with more East German colleagues returned to work sooner after a birth; sizes not given

To check against
SY-06 (direction only)
The verdict
OPEN
C13-33 open §What the records say

Kleven 2024 NBER working paper: mothers socialised in the East carry a smaller child penalty than those socialised in the West, regardless of current residence

To check against
HC-05; working paper number, exact year and effect size not given
The verdict
OPEN
C13-36 open §What the records say

Kan and Gershuny, European Sociological Review, 2016, review the doing-gender or gender-deviance-neutralisation literature (Bittman et al. 2003 Australia and United States)

To check against
HC-04
The verdict
OPEN
C13-39 open §What the records say, §Numbers 5

Klüsener and Goldstein, Population, Space and Place, 2016: the East-West non-marital birth divide predates the division; first names Sebastian and Joshua

To check against
SY-06 (gives J. R. Goldstein; Klüsener's first name from a cited URL); Joshua from general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C13-40 open §What the records say

Summary: the regime moved "its birth register by a factor of five"

To check against
Author's ratio of 10 to 12 per cent (West, 1950s to 1960s) against 50 to 60 (East districts, recent); not a document figure
The verdict
OPEN
C13-41 open §Where the wall stops

Post-1990 convergence on a "modernised breadwinner" (he full-time, she part-time) in both halves

To check against
HC-06 (Rosenfeld, Trappe and Gornick 2004), SY-06
The verdict
OPEN
C13-42 open §Where the wall stops

HC-06's phrase "almost insurmountable friction" for the state's reach into the private negotiation; SY-06's open question labelled the productivity paradox

To check against
HC-06, SY-06 (both are the research documents' own wording, not a cited author's)
The verdict
OPEN
C13-43 open §Where the wall stops, §In practice

FReDA: symmetrical couples revert to the traditional split at the first birth almost invariably

To check against
SY-06; chapter 7 owns the figures (the log)
The verdict
OPEN
C13-45 open §Where the wall stops

Hakim 2000 preference theory: roughly 20 per cent home-centred, 20 work-centred, 60 adaptive preferring part-time

To check against
SY-06 (Hakim, Work-Lifestyle Choices in the 21st Century, 2000, per SY-06 works cited)
The verdict
OPEN
C13-46 open §Where the wall stops

Frodermann et al., Social Forces, 2020, "Money Matters!": vignette experiment in which a mother's wage being essential collapses the belief that mothers should stay home; first name Corinna

To check against
SY-06; first name from general knowledge; sample and country not given
The verdict
OPEN
C13-47 open §Where the wall stops, §In practice

Elterngeld introduced 2007, earnings-related, with months reserved for fathers; effect on fathers' hours still open

To check against
SY-06 lists as open question; "months reserved for fathers" (Partnermonate) is the author's gloss, check SY-06 wording
The verdict
OPEN
C13-51 open §Opening, §Where the wall stops, §In practice

Biography: mother born 1946, so twelve in 1958; narrator born 1975; "outlived her" (mother died 2021, splitting in force)

To check against
The author's own account; splitting's 2021 status per SY-06 present tense
The verdict
OPEN
C13-52 open §What the records say

Kleven's method: follow a woman's earnings through her first birth against a man's and call the long-run gap the child penalty

To check against
HC-05 (event-study description)
The verdict
OPEN