THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 239 · PAIRING · The argument tested

Germany: two gender models as a natural experiment

Treats divided Germany as a natural experiment in two gender models. Joint taxation in the West favoured a male breadwinner, while universal childcare in the GDR made full-time work normal for mothers, leaving a gap of about 350 hours a year in mothers' paid work decades after 1990. Eastern wives can out-earn husbands without extra housework or higher divorce risk (Lippmann et al. 2020). Western mothers who move east adopt its norms, while eastern mothers who move west keep theirs (Boelmann et al. 2025). Hakim's preference theory is contested.

Open the PDF 15 pages · 324 KB

Number
239
Letter code
SY-06
Book
PAIRING after the FALL
Shelf
The argument tested
File
239 SY-06 Germany, two gender models as a natural experiment.pdf
Pages
15

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 56 open
  • 21 to check first
  • P-10 open Check first Boelmann, Raute & Schönberg 2025, AEJ: Applied: 350-hour annual gap in maternal labour supply; 50 per cent sample of social-security data; no gap for fathers
  • P-11 open Check first East German mothers recover 70 per cent of pre-birth earnings at seven years, West German 45 per cent
  • P-12 open Check first Working-mother stigma accounts for 73 per cent of the 350-hour gap
  • P-13 open Check first Lippmann, Georgieff & Senik 2020, Economic Journal, SOEP 1991–2012: in the West, a wife crossing 50 per cent of household income raises her housework, exit and divorce risk; in …
  • P-54 open Check first FReDA: women primarily responsible for laundry in 71 per cent of couples, cooking in 58 per cent; couples revert to unequal split at first birth; about 20 per cent of …
  • C07-19 open Check first FReDA: men primarily responsible for outdoor tasks and repairs in 80 per cent of couples (Preface carries laundry 71, cleaning 66, cooking 58)
  • C07-20 open Check first FReDA: couples who begin symmetrical almost invariably revert to an unequal split at the birth of the first child, "on both sides of the old border"
  • C07-21 open Check first FReDA: about one woman in five in a "female-overburdened" household is thinking about leaving (roughly 20 per cent contemplating separation)
  • C07-22 open Check first FReDA fixed-effects models: a man's life satisfaction rises with more hours on routine domestic work and fewer on paid work; men also report satisfaction from episodic outdoor …
  • C07-28 open Check first Lippmann, Georgieff & Senik 2020, Economic Journal: SOEP 1991 to 2012 (21 years); West German wives raise housework in the year after their income passes the husband's, East …
  • C13-01 open Check first Ehegattensplitting introduced in West German law in 1958 and still in force; mechanism pool, halve, tax, double
  • C13-16 open Check first Steiner and Wrohlich 2004 microsimulation found splitting a primary driver of low full-time employment of married women; first names Viktor and Katharina
  • C13-25 open Check first Babyjahr 1976: paid year after a birth, job held open, option of reduced hours, no penalty on return
  • C13-29 open Check first Boelmann, Raute and Schönberg, AEJ: Applied Economics, 2025: 50 per cent random sample of social-security records; collective model of family labour supply; East German mothers …
  • C13-30 open Check first Equalising wages across East and West would nearly double the mothers' hours gap; working-mother stigma accounts for 73 per cent of the gap
  • C13-34 open Check first Lippmann, Georgieff and Senik, The Economic Journal, 2020: SOEP 1991 to 2012; when a wife's income crosses 50 per cent of household income, West German couples show more housework …
  • C13-37 open Check first Bauernschuster and Rainer, Journal of Population Economics, 2012: East Germans 22 percentage points more likely to hold egalitarian sex-role attitudes; first names Stefan and …
  • C13-38 open Check first Births outside marriage: West Germany 10.6 per cent in 1950, 5.8 in 1965; Germany 33.1 per cent in 2023; over 50 and over 60 per cent in many eastern districts
  • C13-44 open Check first Lois, Comparative Population Studies, 2020: ALLBUS 1982 to 2016, nine waves, 26,389 respondents, age-period-cohort separation; western egalitarian drift stalled for men born …
  • C16-03 open Check first 350 hours a year more paid work by East German mothers; about 1,800 hours for an East German mother; no gap for fathers; 73 per cent of the gap attributable to stigma, none to …
  • C16-06 open Check first Seven years after a first child an East German mother is at 70 per cent of her old earnings, a West German mother at 45
  • P-03 open Ehegattensplitting introduced 1958; secondary earner taxed at partner's marginal rate
  • P-04 open West Germany: half-day schools, almost no public childcare under three; Rabenmutter stigma
  • P-05 open GDR constitution 1949 guaranteed women the right to work and equal pay
  • P-06 open Near-universal public childcare in the GDR by the late 1980s
  • P-07 open Babyjahr introduced 1976, one paid year with job guarantee
  • P-08 open Schmarotzer as the East German label for stay-at-home mothers
  • P-14 open East-to-West migrant mothers keep East behaviour; West-to-East migrants adopt East behaviour within a few years
  • C07-23 open "The German family panel" used for both FReDA (2021–2023, integrating pairfam) and pairfam (Johnson 2016, 1,315 couples)
  • C07-63 open "The eastern half of the panel, where the same bodies tip differently" at the first birth
  • C07-64 open Lactation as the one bodily bottleneck no agreement moves
  • C13-02 open Half-day school and near-absent public care for under-threes as the West German norm; no date range
  • C13-03 open 350-hour gap equals "about a month and a half" of a working year
  • C13-12 open West German feminists did not, on the whole, demand public childcare and distrusted state crèches; quote "entirely on an individual basis"
  • C13-15 open Splitting advantage largest when one income is zero; second earner's first euro taxed at the husband's marginal rate
  • C13-17 open Rabenmutter (raven mother) and Schmarotzer (parasite) as the two nouns, with the definitions given
  • C13-19 open "With the best Catholic intentions": the West German model as conservative welfare state and subsidiarity
  • C13-20 open GDR constitution of 1949 wrote in the right to work and to equal pay
  • C13-21 open GDR lost workers to the war and to the open border until 1961; labour shortage as motive
  • C13-22 open Public childcare covered "nearly every child" by the late 1980s
  • C13-24 open Fertility fell and from the 1970s policy turned to Muttipolitik
  • C13-27 open Early-1990s meeting of West German feminists and the East's Independent Women's Association (UFV); mutual misreading; crèches and Babyjahr dismantled
  • C13-31 open West German mothers who moved east adopted eastern hours and kept them on returning west; West German mothers in firms with more East German colleagues returned to work sooner …
  • C13-39 open Klüsener and Goldstein, Population, Space and Place, 2016: the East-West non-marital birth divide predates the division; first names Sebastian and Joshua
  • C13-41 open Post-1990 convergence on a "modernised breadwinner" (he full-time, she part-time) in both halves
  • C13-42 open HC-06's phrase "almost insurmountable friction" for the state's reach into the private negotiation; SY-06's open question labelled the productivity paradox
  • C13-43 open FReDA: symmetrical couples revert to the traditional split at the first birth almost invariably
  • C13-45 open Hakim 2000 preference theory: roughly 20 per cent home-centred, 20 work-centred, 60 adaptive preferring part-time
  • C13-46 open Frodermann et al., Social Forces, 2020, "Money Matters!": vignette experiment in which a mother's wage being essential collapses the belief that mothers should stay home; first …
  • C13-47 open Elterngeld introduced 2007, earnings-related, with months reserved for fathers; effect on fathers' hours still open
  • C13-51 open Biography: mother born 1946, so twelve in 1958; narrator born 1975; "outlived her" (mother died 2021, splitting in force)
  • C16-01 open Income splitting in the West German tax code since 1958 ("has had a view on the matter since 1958")
  • C16-02 open In the West, the year a wife's payslip overtakes her husband's, the household reacts (more housework, exit, divorce); not in the East
  • C16-04 open Public crèches for under-threes a rumour in West Germany when the narrator was born (1975)
  • C16-07 open Reunified Germany's family panel: couples who start symmetrical tip at the first birth, East and West alike, and do not tip back; the East kept the same woman doing most of the …
  • C16-12 open Half-day school as West German design