THRIVING after the FALL
Book Two PAIRING after the FALL

The Log · PAIRING · Read the chapter

Chapter 7: The Second Shift That Wasn’t

69 claims, 35 to check first

C07-01 Check first open §Opening, §The month that was not there

German ZVE 2022 diary is a booklet cut into ten-minute slices with columns for main activity, secondary activity and who was present

To check against
CO-02 says time-use diaries are "generally in 10-minute intervals" and names no primary; it does not say so for the ZVE. Check Destatis ZVE 2022 method report (Tagebuch, 10-Minuten-Takt, Nebentätigkeit, "mit wem"). Marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-02 Check first open §Opening, §The month that was not there, §Numbers to carry

ZVE 2022: 20,000 people in Germany filled in the diary

To check against
CO-02 [16] Destatis ZVE 2022 results page. Check whether 20,000 is persons, households or diary days (Destatis reports about 10,000 households)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-04 Check first open §The month that was not there

Hochschild: the double day added up to an extra month of twenty-four-hour days a year

To check against
CO-02 [8]; check the wording in the book itself (the phrase is Hochschild's own)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-06 Check first open §The month that was not there, §Numbers to carry, Load-bearing

Gershuny & Sullivan 2019: 50 years, 14 rich countries; total work 450 to 500 minutes a day (about eight hours) for both sexes, barely moved in four decades

To check against
CO-02 [13], which is a CTUR working paper (2018, "Gender Symmetry, Gender Convergence and Historical Work-time"), not the Annual Review paper. Check that the figures and the "14 countries" appear in the ARS paper
The verdict
OPEN
C07-07 Check first open §The month that was not there

Gershuny and Sullivan "work from that archive" (affiliation with the MTUS)

To check against
CO-02 names no affiliation. General knowledge: Centre for Time Use Research (UCL, formerly Oxford), which maintains the MTUS. Marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-11 Check first open §The month that was not there, §Numbers to carry, Load-bearing

Gender Care Gap 43.4 per cent: women over 18 do 1 hour 16 minutes more unpaid work a day, nearly 30 hours a week against 21

To check against
CO-02 [16, 18]; Destatis ZVE 2022 press release and BMFSFJ notice
The verdict
OPEN
C07-13 Check first open §The month that was not there, §The kinds of minutes, §Numbers to carry

Mothers of children under six do about 10.5 hours a week less paid work than women without children; fathers keep full-time jobs and trim leisure a little

To check against
CO-02 [16]; Destatis ZVE 2022. Check the comparison group (childless women vs all women) and the fathers' leisure statement
The verdict
OPEN
C07-15 Check first open §The kinds of minutes, §Case against

Offer & Schneider 2011, American Sociological Review 76:809–833: 402 mothers, 291 fathers (693 parents), dual-earner, 500 Family Study, random pager (ESM); multitasking 48 vs 39 hours a week

To check against
CO-02 [22, 24]; Offer & Schneider 2011. Check exact hours (paper gives decimals)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-17 Check first open §The kinds of minutes, §Case against, §In practice, Load-bearing

Daminger 2019, American Sociological Review 84:609–633: 70 interviews, 35 couples; four stages (anticipate, identify, decide, monitor); deciding shared almost equally, anticipating and monitoring done by the woman even where chores are split; term "cognitive labour"

To check against
CO-02 [27, 28]; [27] is a couples-app blog, [28] the paper on ResearchGate. Check "almost equally" for deciding and that anticipating is "disproportionately" not exclusively female
The verdict
OPEN
C07-18 Check first open §The kinds of minutes, §Case against

Aviv et al. 2024, Archives of Women's Mental Health: 322 mothers of young children; cognitive-labour split more skewed than physical; tracked depression, burnout, relationship functioning; cross-sectional

To check against
CO-02 [31, 32]; [31] is an app blog, [32] Springer Medizin abstract. Check first author, N, journal, year and the cross-sectional design
The verdict
OPEN
C07-19 Check first open §The kinds of minutes

FReDA: men primarily responsible for outdoor tasks and repairs in 80 per cent of couples (Preface carries laundry 71, cleaning 66, cooking 58)

To check against
SY-06 [43] (BZgA Forum 1/2023, "Gender roles, housework, couple conflicts. A first look at FReDA"); FReDA 2021–2023
The verdict
OPEN
C07-20 Check first open §The kinds of minutes, §Case against, §In practice

FReDA: couples who begin symmetrical almost invariably revert to an unequal split at the birth of the first child, "on both sides of the old border"

To check against
SY-06 [44] (BiB FReDA policy brief, 9 July 2025, "Shared, fair, satisfied?"). SY-06 does not split this finding by East and West; the Preface says "East and West alike" on the same source. Check the brief for a regional breakdown. Also: the paragraph ending §The kinds of minutes says the reversion is "absent in half of one country", which conflates it with Lippmann's income-threshold response (C07-28); internal consistency to resolve
The verdict
OPEN
C07-21 Check first open §The kinds of minutes, §What the ledger costs, §In practice

FReDA: about one woman in five in a "female-overburdened" household is thinking about leaving (roughly 20 per cent contemplating separation)

To check against
SY-06 [44]; BiB policy brief 2025. Check the figure and the definition of "female-overburdened"
The verdict
OPEN
C07-22 Check first open §The kinds of minutes, §In practice, Load-bearing

FReDA fixed-effects models: a man's life satisfaction rises with more hours on routine domestic work and fewer on paid work; men also report satisfaction from episodic outdoor tasks

To check against
SY-06 [45] (ResearchGate, "The Division of Labour Within the Household and Life Satisfaction", about 42,000 observations, 2021–2023); authors of the primary not named in the document
The verdict
OPEN
C07-25 Check first open §What the ledger costs, §Numbers to carry, Load-bearing

Killewald 2016, American Sociological Review 81:696–719: more than 6,300 couples, PSID 1968 to 2013; married before 1975, wife's full-time work raised divorce risk; after 1975, no effect of her job or income

To check against
CO-02 [40, 41] (ASA news release and ResearchGate); CO-06 [50]. CO-06 adds that pre-1975 couples splitting housework 50-50 were 36 per cent more likely to divorce (not used)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-26 Check first open §What the ledger costs, §In practice, §Numbers to carry, Contested

Husband not in full-time employment: divorce hazard roughly 30 per cent higher (CO-02) or 3.3 vs 2.5 per cent a year, 33 per cent (CO-06); carried as a range

To check against
CO-02 [40], CO-06 [50]; Killewald 2016 (predicted annual probabilities 3.3 vs 2.5 per cent). Marked (to be checked). Report-to-report discrepancy logged
The verdict
OPEN
C07-28 Check first open §What the ledger costs, §Case against, §In practice

Lippmann, Georgieff & Senik 2020, Economic Journal: SOEP 1991 to 2012 (21 years); West German wives raise housework in the year after their income passes the husband's, East German wives do not

To check against
SY-06 [15, 26]; Lippmann, Georgieff & Senik 2020 Economic Journal 130:1445–1470. Preface rows carry the same claim
The verdict
OPEN
C07-29 Check first open §What the ledger costs, Decoration

Germany: nearly 45 per cent of employed women part-time vs about 11 per cent of men; older women draw 53 per cent of older men's pension income ("half a pension")

To check against
CO-02 [45] (German Politics 2021 article), [46] (Ageing & Society pension-gap paper); years and definitions not given. German gender pension gap is often reported at 46 to 49 per cent; check which measure gives 53
The verdict
OPEN
C07-30 Check first open §What the ledger costs, Contested, §Numbers to carry

Kornrich, Brines & Leupp 2013, American Sociological Review 78:26–50: NSFH Wave II, 1992 to 1994, about 4,500 couples; traditional split had more sex; husbands doing more cooking, cleaning, shopping reported less, "about 5.2 times a month"

To check against
CO-02 [56] (ASA press release). Figures garbled in both text extraction and PDF ("5.2 ... alongside wives reporting 5.6"). Press release reported about 1.5 fewer times a month for husbands in egalitarian households. Marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-31 Check first open §What the ledger costs, Contested

Carlson, Hanson & Frisco 2016, Journal of Marriage and Family 78:975–995: MARS 2006, 932 couples; equal-sharing couples sex 6.8 times a month, half a time more than traditional, twice as often as man-does-most

To check against
CO-02 [57, 59, 60]; [57] is a different Carlson paper ("Stalled for Whom?"), [60] Cornell Chronicle. Check that N = 932 is couples and that the comparison is "more than twice"
The verdict
OPEN
C07-33 Check first open §What the ledger costs, §Case against, §In practice, Load-bearing

Johnson, Galambos & Anderson 2016: 1,315 pairfam couples followed over time; hours and a 50-50 split did not predict sexual frequency; her perceived fairness and his judged contribution did, for both partners

To check against
CO-02 [61, 62]; journal not named in document (Archives of Sexual Behavior 45). [61] is a MIDUS pdf (US data, different paper); check attribution
The verdict
OPEN
C07-35 Check first open §What the ledger costs, §In practice, Load-bearing

Mikula 1998, "fairness paradox": objective inequality predicts dissatisfaction poorly, perceived unfairness predicts it well

To check against
CO-02 [52] is a bogus citation ("Google Sports Data"); [53] Mikula, "Perceived Justice in the Division of Family Labor: Antecedents and Consequences" (1998, chapter). Check Mikula used the phrase "fairness paradox" and the year; first name Gerold from general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C07-36 Check first open §Two clocks in one bed, §Numbers to carry, Contested

Bull, Scherwitzl et al. 2019, npj Digital Medicine: 612,613 cycles from 124,646 users (CO-05) or 124,648 (BI-04) of the Natural Cycles app

To check against
CO-05 [61], BI-04 [3, 4]; Bull et al. 2019 npj Digit Med 2:83. Report-to-report discrepancy on user count logged
The verdict
OPEN
C07-37 Check first open §Two clocks in one bed, §Numbers to carry

Mean cycle 29.3 days, SD 5.2; only 13 per cent of cycles exactly 28 days; only 24 per cent of ovulations on day 14 or 15; luteal phase about 12.4 days and stable; follicular phase varies

To check against
CO-05 [61, 62] (SD and 24 per cent), BI-04 [3, 6] (13 per cent sourced to an obgyn blog and a Konstanz gynaecologists' page, 12.4 days). Check all in Bull 2019
The verdict
OPEN
C07-42 Check first open §Two clocks in one bed, §Case against, Load-bearing

Leeners et al. 2017, Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience 11:120: 88 women, 68 completed a second cycle; visuospatial working memory, divided attention, cognitive bias at four points per cycle with hormones measured; first-cycle progesterone–working memory association gone in cycle two; authors called it a false positive; no consistent link to oestradiol, progesterone or testosterone between or within women

To check against
CO-05 [3, 4, 5]; Leeners et al. 2017. "Only study in the field that replicated itself before publishing" is the narrator's claim, not the document's
The verdict
OPEN
C07-43 Check first open §Two clocks in one bed, §Case against, §Numbers to carry, Load-bearing

McNulty et al. 2020, Sports Medicine 50:1813–1827: 78 studies (73 in the network analysis), women not on hormonal contraception; early follicular vs rest ES −0.06, 95 per cent credible interval −0.16 to 0.04; evidence rated low quality; advise against population-wide rules

To check against
CO-05 [10, 11, 1]; McNulty et al. 2020. Discrepancy 78 vs 73 logged in working notes; text uses 78
The verdict
OPEN
C07-45 Check first open §Two clocks in one bed, §In practice, Contested

Baker & Driver 2007, Sleep Medicine Reviews: luteal progesterone raises core temperature about 0.4 °C and blunts the nocturnal fall; REM down; light (stage 2) sleep and spindles up; subjective sleep quality drops in the last week before the period

To check against
BI-04 [18, 20] and CO-05 [58]; BI-04's [18] is a different PMC paper (24-hour temperatures in young men and women), CO-05's [58] a sleep-clinic blog. Check against Baker & Driver 2007 Sleep Med Rev 11:? itself
The verdict
OPEN
C07-47 Check first open §Two clocks in one bed, §In practice, Contested

PMDD prevalence 3 to 8 per cent (BI-04) or about 5.5 per cent (CO-05); both carried

To check against
BI-04 [41] (an Authorea preprint), CO-05 [18] (PMC primer). Check DSM-5 text and Hantsoo & Epperson 2015. Report-to-report discrepancy logged
The verdict
OPEN
C07-49 Check first open §Two clocks in one bed, Load-bearing

Schmidt et al. 1998, New England Journal of Medicine 338:209–216: leuprolide in women with and without PMDD; symptoms vanished; add-back of oestradiol or progesterone at ordinary doses returned symptoms in the PMDD group only

To check against
BI-04 [48 EurekAlert, 49 PubMed]; Schmidt, Nieman, Danaceau, Adams & Rubinow 1998 NEJM. "Quietly added" implies blinding; check design (double-blind add-back)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-50 Check first open §Two clocks in one bed

Peter Schmidt's group at the National Institute of Mental Health in Bethesda

To check against
BI-04 names no place. the BI digest scenes list (line 73) gives "NIMH Bethesda" but merges the 1998 design with the 2017 study's 22 women and month-one return. General knowledge: NIMH Behavioral Endocrinology Branch, Bethesda, Maryland. Marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-51 Check first open §Two clocks in one bed, Load-bearing

Schmidt, Eisenlohr-Moul et al. 2017, American Journal of Psychiatry 174:980–989: 22 women with PMDD; leuprolide suppression, single-blind placebo month, three months steady add-back; symptoms returned in month one of add-back and subsided in months two and three while hormones stayed high; change not level

To check against
CO-05 [16]; BI-04 [47]. Check author order (Schmidt first, Eisenlohr-Moul among co-authors)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-55 Check first open §Two clocks in one bed, §Case against, Load-bearing

Randler et al., Chronobiology International 2014 and 2017: 565 people; women peak 18:00 to 24:00 whatever their chronotype; men more often ready in the morning; only strong-lark women show a second peak 06:00 to 09:00

To check against
CO-05 [52, 55, 53]; [55] "Chronotype, gender, and time for sex" (2014), [52] "Similarity in chronotype and preferred time for sex" (2017). Check which paper carries N = 565 and the exact time windows
The verdict
OPEN
C07-57 Check first open §Two clocks in one bed, §In practice, Load-bearing

Roenneberg et al. 2006, Current Biology: MCTQ asks when you sleep on free days, corrected for weekday sleep debt; chronotype normally distributed; drifts late through adolescence, peak lateness 19.5 years in women, 21 in men, then advances; "social jetlag" as flying several time zones west every Friday and back on Monday

To check against
CO-05 [30, 32, 33]. Attribution likely merged: the MCTQ is Roenneberg, Wirz-Justice & Merrow 2003 (J Biol Rhythms); the 19.5/21 figures are Roenneberg et al. 2004 Current Biology ("A marker for the end of adolescence"); "Social jetlag" is Wittmann, Dinich, Merrow & Roenneberg 2006 Chronobiology International 23:497–509. Check which paper carries each claim
The verdict
OPEN
C07-60 Check first open §Two clocks in one bed, §Case against, §In practice, Decoration

Drews et al. 2020, Frontiers in Psychiatry: 12 couples aged 18 to 29, four laboratory nights; limb movement about 1.5 times higher together; REM about 10 per cent higher, 23 vs 21 per cent of the night; longer unbroken REM stretches (22.0 vs 13.4 min)

To check against
CO-05 [47, 48, 49, 50]; the table is cited partly to a mattress retailer's blog [47] and to Neuroscience News. Check all figures in Drews et al. 2020 Front Psychiatry 11:583
The verdict
OPEN
C07-67 Check first open Working notes only

London UCL ISEH study, 241 participants, women 10 ms faster and 25 per cent fewer errors while menstruating: listed as mark for checking 5 in the working notes but NOT present in the chapter text

To check against
BI-04 [17] sources it to a Facebook post (likely Ronca et al. 2024, Neuropsychologia). Either cut the note or find the paper before the claim returns to the text
The verdict
OPEN
C07-03 open §The month that was not there, §Case against ("fifty kitchens")

Arlie Hochschild, The Second Shift, 1989, built on interviews with and observation of 50 dual-earner couples

To check against
CO-02 [8, 9, 10]; Hochschild & Machung 1989 (Viking). The 50-couple figure is sourced to a 2015 ResearchGate retrospective, no second report
The verdict
OPEN
C07-05 open §The month that was not there, §Case against, Load-bearing, §Numbers to carry

Multinational Time Use Study: collecting since 1961, more than 1.2 million diary days, 30 countries

To check against
CO-02 [11, 12]; Gershuny & Sullivan 2019 Annual Review of Sociology 45:301–320. Check that the 1.2 million and 30 figures are the paper's and not the MTUS website's at a later date
The verdict
OPEN
C07-08 open §The month that was not there

Leisure gap in total hours is an artefact of early measurement or of particular sub-samples

To check against
CO-02 [8]; wording is CO-02's gloss on Gershuny & Sullivan; check it is their reading
The verdict
OPEN
C07-09 open §The month that was not there, §Numbers to carry

Women do about 60 per cent of unpaid and 40 per cent of paid work, men the reverse

To check against
CO-02 [13] (table says men perform more than 60 per cent of paid work)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-10 open §The month that was not there, §Case against

Paid work converged to 250 to 300 minutes a day; unpaid 180 to 250 and converging slowly; routine tasks still mostly with women in every country; core housework fell sharply for women

To check against
CO-02 table [13, 14]; [14] is a Council on Contemporary Families blog. "In every country in the archive" is a strong claim; check the paper supports it
The verdict
OPEN
C07-12 open §The month that was not there, §Numbers to carry

2012/13 Gender Care Gap 52.4 per cent, 1 hour 27 minutes

To check against
CO-02 [17] (bpb datasheet); check Destatis ZVE 2012/13
The verdict
OPEN
C07-14 open §The kinds of minutes

Working mothers in every rich country report more exhaustion, time famine and work-family conflict than working fathers

To check against
CO-02 framing (Greenhaus & Beutell 1985 cited for the construct); no primary named for the cross-national claim
The verdict
OPEN
C07-16 open §The kinds of minutes

Mothers' multitasking was childcare on housework and came with distress; fathers' was leisure or paid work on something and did not; fragmented time restores less

To check against
CO-02 [22, 25]; [25] is an Oxford thesis on time fragmentation, not Offer & Schneider
The verdict
OPEN
C07-23 open §The kinds of minutes, §What the ledger costs, §Case against

"The German family panel" used for both FReDA (2021–2023, integrating pairfam) and pairfam (Johnson 2016, 1,315 couples)

To check against
SY-06 [40, 41] for FReDA; CO-02 for pairfam. Two panels under one name in the text; check the reader is not misled
The verdict
OPEN
C07-24 open §The kinds of minutes

Interruptibility, not strength, decided task allocation (Campfire Contract, chapter 2)

To check against
chapter 2 row C02-06 (Brown 1970, American Anthropologist)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-27 open §What the ledger costs, §The month that was not there

"the year I was born" is 1975; "my generation", "my parents' generation", "my mother's generation in the West" (part-time job plus all the housework)

To check against
biographical, no document; awaiting the author's word that the mother's arrangement is fair to state
The verdict
OPEN
C07-32 open §What the ledger costs

Era, not error: 1992–94 vs 2006 surveys, "three years later", "fourteen years apart"

To check against
arithmetic from C07-30 and C07-31; the "script changed" reading is Carlson et al.'s argument per CO-02
The verdict
OPEN
C07-34 open §What the ledger costs

Same-sex couples divide more equally, not 50-50, by time, resources and preference; talk about it explicitly; report arrangements fairer even when hours unequal (Goldberg 2013, Umberson 2015)

To check against
CO-02 [49] (Massey thesis), [50] (Goldberg, Smith & Perry-Jenkins, JMF, dated 2012 in the listing, not 2013); Umberson, Thomeer & Lodge 2015 JMF. CO-06 adds Australian 2011 Census (female same-sex couples twice as likely to split exactly equally), not used
The verdict
OPEN
C07-38 open §Two clocks in one bed

Older cycle research assigned hormonal state by calendar counting; a woman may ovulate on day 12 one month and day 20 the next

To check against
BI-04 [1] and its own gloss; no primary for the "day 12 / day 20" illustration
The verdict
OPEN
C07-39 open §Two clocks in one bed

Chapter 5 cross-reference: fertile-day preference for masculine faces did not survive salivary hormones (Jones et al. 2018, Psychological Science, N = 584)

To check against
BI-04 [29]; chapter 5 row C05-58 says that claim rests on the Preface's sources. Check chapter 5 actually "told" it as stated
The verdict
OPEN
C07-40 open §Two clocks in one bed

Roney & Simmons 2013, Hormones and Behavior: daily saliva, oestradiol predicts desire up, progesterone down

To check against
BI-04 [35] (UCSB lab pdf)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-41 open §Two clocks in one bed

Arslan et al. 2021: 26,000 diary entries, mid-cycle peak in in-pair and extra-pair desire

To check against
BI-04 [37] (cited to a PMC paper on life-history strategy, not Arslan); journal not named; chapter 3 row C03-43
The verdict
OPEN
C07-44 open §Two clocks in one bed

Overlap "about 98 per cent" for d = 0.06

To check against
narrator's arithmetic from the chapter 4 formula (2Φ(−d/2) ≈ 0.976); chapter 4 row C04-06
The verdict
OPEN
C07-46 open §Two clocks in one bed

Direkvand-Moghadam et al. 2014, Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research: 17 studies, pooled PMS prevalence 47.8 per cent ("about 48"), self-report inflated by recall

To check against
BI-04 [39, 40]
The verdict
OPEN
C07-48 open §Two clocks in one bed, §In practice

PMDD diagnosis needs two cycles of daily charting because recall exaggerates (C-PASS, Eisenlohr-Moul et al. 2017, American Journal of Psychiatry)

To check against
BI-04 [44, 45]
The verdict
OPEN
C07-52 open §Two clocks in one bed, §In practice

Women with PMDD have the same hormone levels as controls; the brain responds to the rate of change

To check against
BI-04 [47], CO-05 [16]; Schmidt 1998 and 2017
The verdict
OPEN
C07-53 open §Two clocks in one bed, §In practice

The right drugs (SSRIs) act within a day or two in PMDD rather than the weeks an antidepressant takes for depression

To check against
BI-04 [53] (a paper on allopregnanolone levels, not the primary for onset time); check e.g. Hantsoo & Epperson 2015 or Steinberg et al. 2012 for the 24-to-48-hour onset
The verdict
OPEN
C07-54 open §Two clocks in one bed

Testosterone peaks in the early morning, falls through the day, and moves with the season (Svartberg 2003, Brambilla 2003, both JCEM)

To check against
CO-05 [23] (a Korean journal article, not the primaries). Svartberg et al. 2003 JCEM 88:3099–3104 (Tromsø, seasonal); Brambilla's JCEM diurnal paper may be 2009 and the 2003 attribution wrong. Chapter 3 row C03-19 for the morning peak
The verdict
OPEN
C07-56 open §Two clocks in one bed, §Case against, Contested

Whether the women's evening peak is endocrine or the shape of the working day is unknown "and the report says so"

To check against
CO-05 lists it among its own open questions; no primary
The verdict
OPEN
C07-58 open §Two clocks in one bed

Roenneberg "and colleagues in Munich"

To check against
CO-05 names no city; inferred from "Munich ChronoType Questionnaire" (LMU Munich). First name Till from general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C07-59 open §Two clocks in one bed, §In practice

Chronotype similarity predicts relationship satisfaction, sexual satisfaction and sleep quality across dating, newlywed and older couples (Randler 2014, Sprajcer 2022, Diaz-Morales 2019)

To check against
CO-05 [52, 54, 57]; Sprajcer et al. 2022 (PubMed 35762311), Díaz-Morales & Parra-Robledo 2019 ("three types of couples"). Check years and that "gap matters more than direction" (§In practice) is supported
The verdict
OPEN
C07-61 open §Case against

Abraham, Feldman et al. 2014, PNAS 111:9792–9797: 89 first-time parents; mothers' network also active in primary-caregiving fathers raising infants without a mother; fathers' connectivity rose with hours of childcare

To check against
CO-02 [1, 2, 7] for the three groups; the "rose with hours of childcare" finding is in FA-01, not CO-02. Chapter 8 rows C08-11, C08-12. First names Eyal, Ruth from general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C07-62 open §Case against

Partners cannot detect fertility (Gangestad 2019, Schleifenbaum 2022)

To check against
BI-04 [7] (QUB pdf of a 2024 Hormones and Behavior paper) and [38] (Schleifenbaum's 2022 Göttingen dissertation); journal and co-authors for Gangestad 2019 not given
The verdict
OPEN
C07-63 open §In practice

"The eastern half of the panel, where the same bodies tip differently" at the first birth

To check against
SY-06 [2, 25]: Boelmann, Raute & Schönberg 2025 AEJ Applied (East German mothers back at 70 per cent of pre-birth earnings after seven years, West 45), social-security data, not FReDA. Text attributes it to "the panel"; check the attribution or reword
The verdict
OPEN
C07-64 open §In practice, Working notes assumption 1

Lactation as the one bodily bottleneck no agreement moves

To check against
SY-06 physiology paragraph (gestation, birth, lactation fall on females); no primary named
The verdict
OPEN
C07-65 open §In practice

"Cycle syncing" is a product; a marketing trend

To check against
CO-05 Layer 3; no primary named
The verdict
OPEN
C07-66 open §In practice, Contested

A cooler bedroom in the luteal week as the one piece of cycle-aware living with a replicated mechanism

To check against
mechanism from C07-45; CO-05's "16 to 18 °C" figure is sourced to a mattress retailer's blog [47] and is kept out of the text. "Replicated" is the narrator's word; check Baker & Driver's review supports it
The verdict
OPEN
C07-68 open whole chapter, Working notes assumption 6

First names supplied from general knowledge, not from the documents: Jonathan Gershuny, Oriel Sullivan, Shira Offer, Barbara Schneider, Allison Daminger, Alexandra Killewald, Sabino Kornrich, Julie Brines, Katrina Leupp, Daniel Carlson, Sarah Hanson, Michelle Frisco, Jonathan Bull, Brigitte Leeners, Kelly McNulty, Peter Schmidt, Christoph Randler, Till Roenneberg, Gerold Mikula, Eyal Abraham, Ruth Feldman. "Scherwitzl" left without a first name (two Scherwitzls are co-authors of Bull 2019)

To check against
no primary; check each paper's author list
The verdict
OPEN
C07-69 open Lists, Working notes

Items in the chapter's own lists that do not appear in the text: Hakim vs Frodermann 2020 (Contested), Schoep presenteeism and OR-04 shift-work risks (Library, assumption 4), Folke & Rickne, Coates & Herbert, Gettler 20.5 per cent (working notes, cut order); working-notes word count (about 5,700) and six marks for checking (five in text)

To check against
housekeeping: the lists outrun the draft; prune or restore before print
The verdict
OPEN