THRIVING after the FALL
Book Two PAIRING after the FALL

The Log · PAIRING · Read the chapter

Preface: The Other Half of the Question

58 claims, 21 to check first

P-01 Check first open §1

*Stern* cover of 6 June 1971, 374 women, "Wir haben abgetrieben!", Romy Schneider among them, organised by Alice Schwarzer after the French manifesto of 343

To check against
HC-05; *Stern* archive, issue 24/1971
The verdict
OPEN
P-02 Check first open §1

West German wife needed husband's consent to take a job until the 1977 marriage-law reform

To check against
HC-05 names no primary source. Check §1356 BGB as amended 1957/58 (Gleichberechtigungsgesetz) and the 1. EheRG of 14 June 1976, in force 1 July 1977
The verdict
OPEN, marked in the text for checking
P-09 Check first open §2

Female labour-force participation 1989: GDR about 89 per cent, FRG 56 per cent

To check against
HC-06; Rosenfeld, Trappe & Gornick 2004
The verdict
OPEN
P-10 Check first open §2

Boelmann, Raute & Schönberg 2025, AEJ: Applied: 350-hour annual gap in maternal labour supply; 50 per cent sample of social-security data; no gap for fathers

To check against
SY-06; AEJ: Applied Economics 2025, doi 10.1257/app.20220567
The verdict
OPEN, marked in the text for checking
P-11 Check first open §2

East German mothers recover 70 per cent of pre-birth earnings at seven years, West German 45 per cent

To check against
SY-06 cites the 2021 ECONtribute working paper; check the published version
The verdict
OPEN, marked in the text for checking
P-12 Check first open §2

Working-mother stigma accounts for 73 per cent of the 350-hour gap

To check against
SY-06 cites ECONtribute DP 405 (2026); confirm which paper carries this figure
The verdict
OPEN, marked in the text for checking
P-13 Check first open §2

Lippmann, Georgieff & Senik 2020, Economic Journal, SOEP 1991–2012: in the West, a wife crossing 50 per cent of household income raises her housework, exit and divorce risk; in the East none of this

To check against
SY-06; HC-06; Economic Journal 130(629)
The verdict
OPEN
P-15 Check first open §3

Leyk et al. 2007: N = 2,187; grip strength 541 N men, 329 N women; 90 per cent of women below 95 per cent of men; national-level female athletes at about the 25th male percentile

To check against
HC-04; Leyk et al. 2007, Eur J Appl Physiol 99:415–421
The verdict
OPEN
P-26 Check first open §3

Eisenegger et al. 2010, Nature: women in Zurich, 0.5 mg sublingual testosterone, fairer Ultimatum offers; belief of having received it lowered offers

To check against
Reports disagree on N: 120 (SO-07), 60 (BI-05). Number removed from the text. Nature 463:356–359
The verdict
OPEN
P-27 Check first open §4

Hyde 2005: 46 meta-analyses, 78 per cent of differences small or near zero

To check against
SY-01, SY-02, SY-04; American Psychologist 60(6):581–592
The verdict
OPEN
P-28 Check first open §4

Zell, Krizan & Teeter 2015: 106 meta-analyses, more than 12 million people, mean d = 0.21

To check against
SY-01, SY-05, CO-03 (all agree: 106 meta-analyses, >12M, d = 0.21); American Psychologist 70(1):10–20
The verdict
OPEN
P-32 Check first open §4

Su, Rounds & Armstrong 2009: things–people d = 0.93, N = 503,188

To check against
SY-04, HC-01; Psychological Bulletin 135(6):859–884
The verdict
OPEN
P-34 Check first open §4

Del Giudice, Booth & Irwing 2012: 16PF, N = 10,261, Mahalanobis D = 2.71, overlap about 10 per cent

To check against
SY-01, SY-04, HC-05; PLoS ONE 7(1):e29265
The verdict
OPEN
P-42 Check first open §6

Pahlke, Hyde & Allison 2014: 184 studies, 1.6 million students, 21 nations, trivial effects once controlled

To check against
SY-04; Psychological Bulletin 140(4):1042–1072
The verdict
OPEN
P-45 Check first open §6

Dube & Harish 2020, JPE: 193 reigns, 18 European polities, 1480–1913, queens 39 percentage points more likely to be at war

To check against
SO-01; Journal of Political Economy 128(7)
The verdict
OPEN
P-47 Check first open §6

Breda et al. 2020, PNAS: about 300,000 pupils; controlling for the "maths is not for girls" stereotype removes the paradox

To check against
SY-01, SY-04; PNAS 117(49):31063–31069
The verdict
OPEN
P-52 Check first open §7 (Part III)

Hudson et al. 2012, Sex and World Peace, WomanStats: 175 countries; violence against women the best predictor of state peacefulness

To check against
SY-01; Hudson, Ballif-Spanvill, Caprioli & Emmett 2012, Columbia UP; WomanStats project
The verdict
OPEN
P-54 Check first open §9

FReDA: women primarily responsible for laundry in 71 per cent of couples, cooking in 58 per cent; couples revert to unequal split at first birth; about 20 per cent of over-burdened women contemplate separation; men report higher life satisfaction with more routine domestic work

To check against
SY-06; BiB FReDA policy brief 2025 and Forum 1/2023
The verdict
OPEN
P-55 Check first open §10

Ellis et al. 2024, Nature: 18 toothed-whale species; menopause arose by extending female lifespan about 40 years

To check against
AN-01; Nature 627 (2024)
The verdict
OPEN
P-56 Check first open §10

Foster et al. 2012, Science: post-reproductive mother's death raises adult sons' mortality; 13.9-fold (AN-01) or 8.3-fold (AN-06)

To check against
Science 337:1313; resolve the discrepancy
The verdict
OPEN, marked in the text for checking
P-03 open §1

Ehegattensplitting introduced 1958; secondary earner taxed at partner's marginal rate

To check against
SY-06; Steiner & Wrohlich 2004, CESifo / DIW DP 421
The verdict
OPEN
P-04 open §1

West Germany: half-day schools, almost no public childcare under three; *Rabenmutter* stigma

To check against
SY-06 (sources include a Reddit thread; find a primary: Rosenfeld, Trappe & Gornick 2004, Annual Review of Sociology)
The verdict
OPEN
P-05 open §2

GDR constitution 1949 guaranteed women the right to work and equal pay

To check against
SY-06; Bauernschuster & Rainer 2012, J. Population Economics
The verdict
OPEN
P-06 open §2

Near-universal public childcare in the GDR by the late 1980s

To check against
SY-06; Bauernschuster & Rainer 2012
The verdict
OPEN
P-07 open §2

*Babyjahr* introduced 1976, one paid year with job guarantee

To check against
SY-06; Bauernschuster & Rainer 2012
The verdict
OPEN
P-08 open §2

*Schmarotzer* as the East German label for stay-at-home mothers

To check against
SY-06 (source 11 is Reddit; find a primary)
The verdict
OPEN
P-14 open §2

East-to-West migrant mothers keep East behaviour; West-to-East migrants adopt East behaviour within a few years

To check against
SY-06; Boelmann, Raute & Schönberg 2025
The verdict
OPEN
P-16 open §3

Grip-strength sex difference exceeds two standard deviations

To check against
SY-04 (d > 2.0); SY-02 (d about 2.5, thesis source). Compute from Leyk 2007 means and SDs
The verdict
OPEN
P-17 open §3

Men about 60 per cent more muscle mass, most of the extra in the upper body (Lassek & Gaulin 2009)

To check against
SY-01 (65%), SY-02 (61–65%), SO-05 (61%); Lassek & Gaulin 2009, Evolution and Human Behavior 30:322–328
The verdict
OPEN
P-18 open §3

Women out-survive men in famines and epidemics (Zarulli et al. 2018, PNAS)

To check against
HC-01; Zarulli et al. 2018, PNAS 115(4):E832–E840
The verdict
OPEN
P-19 open §3

Neolithic Central European women's humeri 11–16 per cent stronger than modern elite rowers' (Macintosh et al. 2017)

To check against
HC-01; Macintosh, Pinhasi & Stock 2017, Science Advances 3(11)
The verdict
OPEN
P-20 open §3

Women about 1.6 times men's body fat; gluteofemoral fat as a DHA store for infant brains

To check against
SY-01; Lassek & Gaulin 2008, Evolution and Human Behavior 29:26–34
The verdict
OPEN
P-21 open §3, §10

Menopause in humans and almost no other mammal; five toothed-whale species

To check against
AN-01; Ellis et al. 2024, Nature
The verdict
OPEN
P-22 open §3

Baseline testosterone–aggression correlation close to zero across 45 studies (Geniole et al. 2020)

To check against
AN-08 (point estimates lost in extraction; CI 0.028–0.080); Geniole et al. 2020, Hormones and Behavior 123
The verdict
OPEN
P-23 open §3

Testosterone rises with competition and winning in both sexes

To check against
SY-01 (van Anders); find the specific meta-analysis (Geniole et al. 2017, Hormones and Behavior, on competition outcomes)
The verdict
OPEN
P-25 open §3

Fatherhood raises prolactin and oxytocin

To check against
SY-01 (Hrdy, Father Time 2024); find the primary studies
The verdict
OPEN
P-29 open §4

At d = 0.21 the distributions overlap about 85 per cent; probability that a random woman outscores a random man about 42 per cent

To check against
SY-05's arithmetic; recompute (overlap coefficient and common-language effect size for d = 0.21)
The verdict
OPEN
P-30 open §4

Maths d = 0.05 across 1.29 million people (Lindberg et al. 2010)

To check against
SY-01; Lindberg, Hyde, Petersen & Linn 2010, Psychological Bulletin 136(6)
The verdict
OPEN
P-31 open §4

Verbal ability tilts slightly to women (Hyde & Linn 1988, d = -0.11)

To check against
SY-01; Psychological Bulletin 104(1)
The verdict
OPEN
P-33 open §4

Physical aggression d about 0.45; mental rotation d about 0.57

To check against
SY-05 via Zell 2015; HC reports give mental rotation from 0.56 to 1.0 (Voyer 1995); settle on one figure
The verdict
OPEN
P-35 open §4

Kaiser et al. 2019 replication: D = 2.06, overlap about 30 per cent

To check against
SY-01 (HC-05 gives 2.06/2.10); Kaiser, Del Giudice & Booth 2020, J. Personality 88(3)
The verdict
OPEN
P-36 open §4

Male brains about 10 per cent larger; sex explains about 1 per cent of structural variance after size (Eliot et al. 2021, "Dump the dimorphism")

To check against
SY-01, AN-10 (gives 11 per cent); Neurosci Biobehav Rev 125:667–697
The verdict
OPEN
P-37 open §4

Joel et al. 2015, PNAS: more than 1,400 brains, only a few per cent internally consistent

To check against
SY-01 (1.2–6%), HC-02 (0–8.2%); PNAS 112(50):15468–15473
The verdict
OPEN
P-38 open §4

Chekroud et al. 2016, PNAS: classifier predicts sex from structural MRI at 93 per cent

To check against
SY-01; PNAS 113(14):E1968
The verdict
OPEN
P-39 open §5

Naturalistic fallacy: Hume 1739, Moore 1903; moralistic fallacy: Bernard Davis, Nature, 1978

To check against
SY-02 (sources are Wikipedia and a blog); check Davis, B. D. (1978) "The moralistic fallacy", Nature 272:390
The verdict
OPEN
P-40 open §6

Power posing: Carney, Cuddy & Yap 2010; Ranehill et al. 2015 null on hormones and risk; Carney disavowed

To check against
SY-04; Psychological Science 26(5):653–656; Carney's 2016 statement
The verdict
OPEN
P-41 open §6

Ovulatory shifts in preference for masculine faces failed in hormone-measured replications

To check against
SY-04 (no primary named); check Jones et al. 2018, Psychological Science, and Jünger et al. 2018
The verdict
OPEN
P-43 open §6

"Women speak more" fails: EAR recorder studies show equal word counts

To check against
SY-04 (no primary named); PS-03 via the OR and PS digest names Mehl et al. 2007, Science 317:82: 396 students, women 16,215 words/day, men 15,669, range 500–47,000
The verdict
OPEN
P-44 open §6

Oxytocin: no robust main effect on trust (Nave et al. 2015); parochial altruism replicates (De Dreu et al. 2010, Science)

To check against
SY-04; Perspectives on Psychological Science 10(6); Science 328:1408
The verdict
OPEN
P-46 open §6

Gender-equality paradox: Schmitt et al. 2008 (17,637 people, 55 cultures); Falk & Hermle 2018 (80,000 people, 76 countries); Stoet & Geary 2018

To check against
SY-01, HC-07, SY-04; note the 2020 correction to Stoet & Geary
The verdict
OPEN
P-48 open §7 (Part II)

Gottman's predictors: out-of-sample positive predictive value about 29 per cent (Heyman & Slep 2001)

To check against
SY-01; J. Marriage and Family 63(2)
The verdict
OPEN
P-49 open §7 (Part II)

Grandmother presence improves child survival

To check against
DH-08 names Sear & Mace 2008, Evolution and Human Behavior 29(1), 45 populations: maternal grandmothers most consistently raise child survival, fathers in about a third of populations; FA-03 gives the shares as mother 100% of studies, maternal grandmother 69%, father 32%, older siblings 83%
The verdict
OPEN
P-50 open §7 (Part II)

Team collective intelligence linked to share of women (Woolley et al. 2010, Science); questioned by Credé et al. 2019

To check against
SY-01 cites Credé et al. 2019; OR-01 cites Credé & Howardson 2017, J. Applied Psychology, as the failed psychometric replication. Science 330:686
The verdict
OPEN
P-51 open §7 (Part III)

Vienna gender-mainstreamed parks and transport (Eva Kail, from 1991)

To check against
SO-03 (some sources are magazine and blog); find the City of Vienna's own documentation
The verdict
OPEN
P-53 confirmed §8

Research library: 81 reports of 15 to 20 pages

To check against
Count in the Google Docs folder (81) and the PDF folder (80; SO-02 missing)
The verdict
CONFIRMED (count)
Found
the project's working notes
P-57 open §10

Nattrass et al. 2019, PNAS: grandmother's death raises grandcalf mortality 4.5-fold

To check against
AN-01 (AN-09 attributes to Brent 2015); PNAS 116(52)
The verdict
OPEN
P-58 open §10

Pod named in the closing scene; "Southern Resident" and "twenty years since her last calf" are placeholders

To check against
AN-01; Center for Whale Research records
The verdict
OPEN, marked in the text for checking