The Library · Document 235 · PAIRING · The argument tested
Nature, prehistory and the naturalistic fallacy
Asks how evolutionary evidence can guide how the sexes live together without the naturalistic (Moore 1903) or moralistic fallacy (Davis 1978). Men carry 61 to 65% more muscle than women (Lassek and Gaulin 2009). Women start partner violence about as often, but men cause most injuries (Archer 2000). Extra-pair paternity runs at 1 to 2% a generation over five centuries (Larmuseau et al. 2019). Whether prehistoric foragers waged war is contested (Fry and Söderberg 2013 against Mirazón Lahr et al. 2016). Some figures were lost from the PDF text.
Open the PDF 18 pages · 398 KB
- Number
- 235
- Letter code
- SY-02
- Book
- PAIRING after the FALL
- Shelf
- The argument tested
- File
- 235 SY-02 Nature, prehistory and the naturalistic fallacy.pdf
- Pages
- 18
Used in
The rows that check it
- 19 open
- 8 to check first
- P-27 open Check first Hyde 2005: 46 meta-analyses, 78 per cent of differences small or near zero
- C05-04 open Check first David Hume, 1739, noticed the unannounced step from is to ought
- C05-05 open Check first G. E. Moore named the naturalistic fallacy in Principia Ethica, 1903
- C05-06 open Check first Bernard Davis, microbiologist, named the moralistic fallacy in Nature, 1978
- C05-10 open Check first Larmuseau and colleagues matched Y-chromosome analyses to genealogical records over 500 years in the Low Countries; Trends in Ecology & Evolution 2016 and Current Biology 2019
- C05-11 open Check first Extra-pair paternity about 1 to 2 per cent per generation over five centuries
- C05-12 open Check first Extra-pair paternity about 0.4 per cent in tightly knit farming villages
- C05-13 open Check first Extra-pair paternity about 5.9 per cent among the poorest classes in crowded industrial cities
- P-16 open Grip-strength sex difference exceeds two standard deviations
- P-17 open Men about 60 per cent more muscle mass, most of the extra in the upper body (Lassek & Gaulin 2009)
- P-39 open Naturalistic fallacy: Hume 1739, Moore 1903; moralistic fallacy: Bernard Davis, Nature, 1978
- C05-08 open Rousseau's noble savage and Hobbes's nasty savage as the two shelves' creation myths; neither matches the archaeology
- C05-09 open Evolutionary psychology's "dual mating strategy" hypothesis: provisioning from a reliable partner, better genes from more formidable men
- C05-14 open "Given what we are, arrangement X under condition Y tends to produce Z" is the prehistory report's formulation
- C05-15 open Sarah Blaffer Hrdy: human infants too costly for a mother and father alone; cooperative breeding with grandmothers and other kin
- C05-16 open Robert Sapolsky: testosterone lowers the threshold for whatever the culture already rewards with status
- C05-17 open "Biology dictates the cost of a social arrangement, not its moral worth" is the report's phrase
- C05-24 open Upper-body strength d about 2 standard deviations, holds in every occupational cohort tested; women produce on average 60 to 75 per cent of men's
- C16-72 open Lassek and Gaulin 2009 muscle mass: about 60 per cent more in men (Preface) against 65 per cent (SY-05)