THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 237 · PAIRING · The argument tested

Replication map: what holds and what fell

Grades claims about sex differences by how well they replicate. Male upper-body strength (d above 2), the things versus people gap in interests (Su, Rounds and Armstrong 2009), mate preferences across 45 countries (Walter et al. 2020) and the fall in fathers' testosterone (Gettler et al. 2011) hold. Ovulatory shifts in mate preference, power posing (Ranehill et al. 2015) and oxytocin as a general cuddle hormone fell. The female empathy advantage vanishes when men are paid (Klein and Hodges 2001). Many effect sizes were lost from the PDF text.

Open the PDF 19 pages · 436 KB

Number
237
Letter code
SY-04
Book
PAIRING after the FALL
Shelf
The argument tested
File
237 SY-04 Replication map, what holds and what fell.pdf
Pages
19

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 26 open
  • 12 to check first
  • P-24 open Check first Gettler et al. 2011, PNAS: fatherhood lowers testosterone; cohort in Cebu, Philippines, followed 4.5 years
  • P-27 open Check first Hyde 2005: 46 meta-analyses, 78 per cent of differences small or near zero
  • P-32 open Check first Su, Rounds & Armstrong 2009: things–people d = 0.93, N = 503,188
  • P-34 open Check first Del Giudice, Booth & Irwing 2012: 16PF, N = 10,261, Mahalanobis D = 2.71, overlap about 10 per cent
  • P-42 open Check first Pahlke, Hyde & Allison 2014: 184 studies, 1.6 million students, 21 nations, trivial effects once controlled
  • P-47 open Check first Breda et al. 2020, PNAS: about 300,000 pupils; controlling for the "maths is not for girls" stereotype removes the paradox
  • C05-19 open Check first Carney, Cuddy and Yap, Psychological Science, 2010: two minutes of expansive posture raised testosterone, lowered cortisol, increased financial risk-taking
  • C05-20 open Check first Ranehill and colleagues, Psychological Science, 2015, pre-registered, 200 participants: no effect on testosterone, cortisol or risk; felt-power effect survived
  • C05-21 open Check first The original Carney 2010 sample was much smaller than 200
  • C05-23 open Check first Pahlke, Hyde and Allison 2014: 184 studies, 1.6 million pupils, 21 countries; advantage of single-sex schooling shrinks to g = 0.10 (girls) and 0.06 (boys, mathematics) once …
  • C05-25 open Check first Su, Rounds and Armstrong 2009: things-versus-people d = 0.93 across 503,188 respondents in 47 interest inventories; engineering d = 1.11
  • C05-41 open Check first Breda, Jouini, Napp and Thebault, PNAS, 2020: 300,000 pupils in 64 countries; the "maths is not for girls" stereotype is stronger in richer, more equal countries and explains away …
  • P-16 open Grip-strength sex difference exceeds two standard deviations
  • P-40 open Power posing: Carney, Cuddy & Yap 2010; Ranehill et al. 2015 null on hormones and risk; Carney disavowed
  • P-41 open Ovulatory shifts in preference for masculine faces failed in hormone-measured replications
  • P-43 open "Women speak more" fails: EAR recorder studies show equal word counts
  • P-44 open Oxytocin: no robust main effect on trust (Nave et al. 2015); parochial altruism replicates (De Dreu et al. 2010, Science)
  • P-46 open Gender-equality paradox: Schmitt et al. 2008 (17,637 people, 55 cultures); Falk & Hermle 2018 (80,000 people, 76 countries); Stoet & Geary 2018
  • C05-22 open Carney, lead author, later publicly disavowed the power-posing finding
  • C05-24 open Upper-body strength d about 2 standard deviations, holds in every occupational cohort tested; women produce on average 60 to 75 per cent of men's
  • C05-26 open Gettler 2011: 394 men in the Philippines followed for five years; fatherhood lowers testosterone; replicated since
  • C05-27 open Hyde 2005: 78 per cent of psychological sex differences small (d < 0.35); Del Giudice: multivariate D = 2.71 with about 10 per cent overlap; both reproduce; the replication report …
  • C05-28 open Greenberg and colleagues, PNAS, 2018: more than 500,000 people on the Reading the Mind in the Eyes test; women score higher across ages and countries
  • C05-29 open Klein and Hodges 2001: paying men to be accurate removes the empathic-accuracy gap
  • C05-59 open Two of the chapter's figures (Ranehill N, Pahlke g) were stripped from the TXT extraction and read from the PDF page image
  • C16-72 open Lassek and Gaulin 2009 muscle mass: about 60 per cent more in men (Preface) against 65 per cent (SY-05)