THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 227 · PAIRING · Cities, states and the world

Women in political power and what states do

Reviews what women in office change. Randomly reserved council seats in India shift spending towards women's priorities, such as water (Chattopadhyay and Duflo 2004, 265 councils). A ten-point rise in Indian women's legislative share cuts neonatal mortality by a third (Bhalotra and Clots-Figueras 2014), and female legislators raise growth 1.8 points a year in 4,265 close elections (Baskaran et al. 2023). Women reduce corruption only where voters can punish it (Esarey and Schwindt-Bayer 2018). Dube and Harish (2020, 193 reigns) find queens more likely than kings to wage war.

Open the PDF 15 pages · 329 KB

Number
227
Letter code
SO-01
Book
PAIRING after the FALL
Shelf
Cities, states and the world
File
227 SO-01 Women in political power and what states do.pdf
Pages
15

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 27 open
  • 12 to check first
  • P-45 open Check first Dube & Harish 2020, JPE: 193 reigns, 18 European polities, 1480–1913, queens 39 percentage points more likely to be at war
  • C14-01 open Check first India's 1993 constitutional amendment reserved one-third of village council chair (Pradhan) posts for women, with the reserved councils chosen at random ("randomly reserved" in …
  • C14-02 open Check first Chattopadhyay and Duflo 2004: 265 village councils in West Bengal and Rajasthan. Women-led councils in West Bengal spent more on drinking water. Women in the village spoke about …
  • C14-04 open Check first Bhavnani 2009: in Mumbai wards where a reservation had lapsed, a woman was about five times as likely to win the next open election as in a never-reserved ward
  • C14-05 open Check first Bhalotra and Clots-Figueras 2014: a ten-percentage-point rise in women's share of Indian state legislature seats cut neonatal mortality by 2.1 percentage points, about a third of …
  • C14-06 open Check first Bhalotra, Clarke, Gomes and Venkataramani 2023: after a parliamentary gender quota in developing countries, maternal mortality ratio fell 8 to 12 per cent, skilled birth …
  • C14-08 open Check first Baskaran, Bhalotra, Min and Uppal: 4,265 close elections to Indian state assemblies, constituencies won by a woman grew 1.8 percentage points a year faster by night-light …
  • C14-18 open Check first Dube and Harish 2020, "Queens": 193 reigns, 18 European polities, 1480 to 1913, polities under a queen 39 percentage points more likely to be at war in a given year. Instruments: …
  • C14-19 open Check first Dube and Harish: unmarried queens more likely to be attacked, married queens more likely to be aggressors (more than married kings), explained by the husband acting as …
  • C14-21 open Check first Hudson et al. 2012, Sex and World Peace: the physical security of women predicts a state's peacefulness better than wealth, democracy or religion. Critics: endogeneity, rich …
  • C16-52 open Check first Hudson, Caprioli, Bowen and McDermott 2012, Sex and World Peace: WomanStats database, more than 130,000 data points, 175 countries; physical security of women the best predictor …
  • C16-54 open Check first Dube and Harish 2020, Journal of Political Economy: 193 European reigns, 1480 to 1913, polity under a queen 39 percentage points more likely to be at war in a given year
  • C14-03 open Roads finding: SO-01 says women-led councils in Rajasthan spent less on roads, SO-07 says women-led councils in West Bengal spent more on water and roads. Report-to-report …
  • C14-07 open United States 1937, arrival of sulfa drugs: maternal deaths fell 15 per cent further in states that had enfranchised women early. SO-01's text attributes this to the 2023 JEEA …
  • C14-09 open Dollar, Fisman and Gatti 2001: across more than 100 countries, one standard deviation more women in parliament goes with 20 per cent of a standard deviation less perceived …
  • C14-10 open Esarey and Chirillo 2013: the women-corruption relationship holds in democracies and vanishes in autocracies. Title "Fairer Sex or Purity Myth?"
  • C14-11 open Esarey and Schwindt-Bayer 2018: across 76 democratic-leaning countries, women reduce corruption only where electoral accountability is high. SO-01 text says American Journal of …
  • C14-12 open Barnes and Beaulieu 2014 and 2018: voters hold women politicians to a higher ethical standard and punish a woman's scandal harder
  • C14-13 open Croson and Gneezy 2009: women on average more risk-averse and more sensitive to context in laboratory games
  • C14-14 open Nelson 2015: 147 estimates from 25 studies of risk aversion, publication bias inflates the sex gap, within-sex variation dwarfs between-sex
  • C14-15 open DellaVigna and Pope: 93 per cent of between-subject comparisons contradict the claim that women's social preferences are more context-sensitive. SO-01 text says 2022, works-cited …
  • C14-16 open Female heads of state sit in the tails of the distributions and are statistically hard to distinguish from male peers on competitiveness, risk tolerance and dominance (paraphrased …
  • C14-20 open Dube and Harish's affiliations: not given in SO-01, left as (to be checked) in prose. S. P. Harish given with initials only
  • C14-50 open Taylor et al. 2000, tend-and-befriend: 200 studies, 14,548 participants, 66 per cent male in the earlier stress literature. Rests on oxytocin, which the Preface's verdict undercuts
  • C14-53 open Cut material logged in the working notes for other chapters: Paffenholz 2014/2015 (40 peace processes), Krause, Krause and Bränfors 2018 (International Interactions, 2,299 …
  • C16-55 open Bhalotra and Clots-Figueras 2014: a ten-point rise in women's share of an Indian state legislature cut neonatal mortality by 2.1 percentage points, a third of the baseline
  • C16-57 open Critics hold the Hudson correlation may be consequence or a third factor