PAIRING · Part III · Emancipation 2.0
Chapter 14
Queens at War
4,467 words · 6 movements
The Opening
A woman is standing up in a village council meeting in West Bengal, and the room is not used to it. In 1993 India changed its constitution so that one chair in three at the head of a village council would be reserved for a woman, and which villages got one was decided at random, so that nobody could later say the places with women in charge were the places that had wanted them. She is reading out the budget. More of it than last year goes on drinking water, which is what the village's women complain about most when anyone asks. Along the wall sit those women, who in an ordinary year get through the whole meeting without a word, and this year they are speaking up about twice as often as they do when a man has the chair. Nobody told them to. The chair changed, and the room changed with it.
Hold that picture, and a second one beside it. Somewhere in early modern Europe a queen is at war. Not defending. Attacking. Her husband is running the treasury and the army while she runs the state, and together they are a more dangerous neighbour than any king whose consort is kept out of the room. Across every reign that two economists could find in Europe between 1480 and 1913, a state was markedly more likely to be at war in a given year under a queen than under a king.
Both pictures come from the same kind of evidence: the lottery, the accident of birth, the thing that decides who holds power without asking anyone's opinion of women. It is the only kind this chapter trusts, because the countries which put women in charge are already different from the countries which do not. And the queen is the chapter's standing image because she breaks the folk theory on both shelves at once. She is not the gentler sex in a crown. She is not a man in a dress either. She is a person with a different set of constraints, and the constraints, it turns out, are most of the story.
The opening of the chapter.
The Story
- The lottery
- The fairer sex, audited
- Queens
- Two columns in the statute book
- The strongest case against
- In practice
The numbers and sources
The chapter tells its story without footnotes. Its figures, each with the study, the document and the row in the log behind it, the case for and against, and what is still open are on a page of their own.