THRIVING after the FALL
Book Two PAIRING after the FALL

PAIRING · Part III · Emancipation 2.0

Chapter 15

The Long Argument

Its governing metaphor: the drawer, opened

4,466 words · 6 movements

The Opening

A girl of fifteen sits at a desk in a school in Finland, in the spring of 2018, with a booklet in front of her that pupils her age in dozens of countries are filling in that spring. The mathematics is done. Now come the questions about herself. Whether she enjoys reading. Whether, when she does badly at something, it is because she lacks the talent for it. She ticks a box. The booklet goes into a pile, the pile into a crate, the crate into a database with a four-letter name, and from there her tick travels to Paris, to be laid beside the ticks of girls in Tunis and Seoul and Lima and argued over by people she is never going to meet.

She has just joined the oldest argument in this book.

It was being conducted in Greek in the fifth century before Christ, in a treatise on the diseases of women. It was conducted in Latin by an abbess on the Rhine, in classical Chinese by a Tang doctor who decided that women needed their own medicine, and in Hebrew by rabbis who found that two categories were not enough for the bodies in front of them. It was conducted in law codes written on bamboo and in dowry contracts in Cairo and in the stone of a female pharaoh's temple, where she is carved with a beard. It is conducted now in American journals, in standard deviations, and it has not been settled, because the people having it have never agreed what it is about.

The opening of the chapter. It goes on in the book.

The Story

  1. The oldest folder
  2. The household ledger
  3. What the scriptures filed
  4. The last unsettled fight
  5. The strongest case against
  6. In practice

The numbers and sources

The chapter tells its story without footnotes. Its figures, each with the study, the document and the row in the log behind it, the case for and against, and what is still open are on a page of their own.

  1. Numbers to carry
  2. Every figure
  3. The case for and the case against
  4. Where the sources disagree
  5. Open questions
  6. The documents