THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 199 · PAIRING · Cultures in history

The gender-equality paradox

Examines the finding that sex differences in personality, preferences and STEM choice are larger in richer, more equal countries, as in Costa (2001, N = 23,031) and Falk and Hermle (2018, 76 countries, r = 0.67 with log GDP). The causal story is disputed. Stoet and Geary's STEM result is corrected after Richardson (2020), Breda (2020) finds stereotypes against girls in maths stronger in egalitarian countries, and Fors Connolly (2020) finds no divergence within countries over time. Gaps in sexual behaviour and maths converge (Herlitz 2024).

Open the PDF 15 pages · 331 KB

Number
199
Letter code
HC-07
Book
PAIRING after the FALL
Shelf
Cultures in history
File
199 HC-07 The gender-equality paradox.pdf
Pages
15

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 37 open
  • 20 to check first
  • C05-25 open Check first Su, Rounds and Armstrong 2009: things-versus-people d = 0.93 across 503,188 respondents in 47 interest inventories; engineering d = 1.11
  • C05-36 open Check first Falk and Hermle, Science, 2018: 80,000 people in 76 countries; gaps in risk, patience, altruism, trust near zero in poor countries and largest in rich ones; r = 0.67 with log GDP …
  • C05-37 open Check first Stoet and Geary 2018, Psychological Science: 472,242 fifteen-year-olds in 67 countries (PISA); girls matched or beat boys in science in about two thirds of countries
  • C05-38 open Check first Finland, Norway and Sweden: fewer than 25 per cent women among STEM graduates; Algeria, Tunisia and Turkey: 35 to 40 per cent
  • C05-40 open Check first Richardson and colleagues 2020, same journal: the STEM result rested on an undisclosed "propensity" measure; with the plain graduate share the correlation shrinks or vanishes; a …
  • C05-41 open Check first Breda, Jouini, Napp and Thebault, PNAS, 2020: 300,000 pupils in 64 countries; the "maths is not for girls" stereotype is stronger in richer, more equal countries and explains away …
  • C05-42 open Check first Fors Connolly, Goossen and Hjerm 2020, Sex Roles: eight ESS rounds, 235,339 people, 32 countries; cross-section reproduced; no within-country widening as equality rose
  • C13-49 open Check first Falk and Hermle, Science, 2018: 80,000 people, 76 countries; sex differences in economic preferences largest in richer and more equal countries; r = 0.67 with log GDP per capita, …
  • C15-55 open Check first Schmitt et al. 2008: 55 nations, personality gaps up to d = 0.70 in the most equal nations. DISCREPANCY: HC-07 gives N = 17,637 and no d; DH-10 gives d up to 0.70 and no N
  • C15-56 open Check first Mac Giolla and Kajonius 2018, International Journal of Psychology: about 130,000 people, 22 countries, r = 0.69 between gender-equality index and personality gaps
  • C15-57 open Check first Schwartz and Rubel 2005, JPSP: 127 samples, 77,528 people, 70 countries; men higher on power and achievement, women on benevolence; median d = 0.15, maximum 0.32 (power); gaps …
  • C15-58 open Check first Falk and Hermle 2018, Science: Global Preferences Survey, 80,000 people, 76 countries, about 90 per cent of world population and income; six preferences measured by self-report …
  • C15-59 open Check first Falk and Hermle: risk d = -0.168, patience d = -0.050, altruism d = 0.106, positive reciprocity d = 0.055, women more trusting and less negatively reciprocal
  • C15-60 open Check first Falk and Hermle: gap width correlates r = 0.67 with log GDP per capita and r = 0.56 with their Gender Equality Index; near zero in poorest, largest in richest
  • C15-62 open Check first Stoet and Geary 2018, Psychological Science: in nearly all countries more girls capable of college-level STEM than enrol; gap widest in equal countries; follow-up 2.5 million …
  • C15-63 open Check first Breda and Napp 2019, PNAS: 300,000 pupils, 64 countries; within-pupil reading-minus-maths gap 0.80 SD larger for girls; controlling it cuts the intention gap by 75 per cent and …
  • C15-64 open Check first Nosek et al. 2009, PNAS: over 500,000 IATs, 34 countries, 70 per cent implicitly pair science with male, national stereotype strength predicts national science gap
  • C15-65 open Check first Breda, Jouini and Napp 2020, PNAS: in 71 of 72 countries girls more likely than equally able boys to attribute failure to lack of talent; gap largest in wealthy OECD countries
  • C15-66 open Check first Herlitz et al. 2024, Perspectives on Psychological Science: 54 articles, 27 large-scale studies; paradox holds for personality, verbal ability, episodic memory, negative emotions; …
  • C16-60 open Check first Falk and Hermle 2018, Science: 80,000 people, 76 countries, six preferences; women's risk-taking 0.168 SD below men's; gap width correlates 0.56 with the gender-equality index
  • P-46 open Gender-equality paradox: Schmitt et al. 2008 (17,637 people, 55 cultures); Falk & Hermle 2018 (80,000 people, 76 countries); Stoet & Geary 2018
  • C05-33 open Costa, Terracciano and McCrae 2001: 23,031 people in 26 cultures; women higher in neuroticism and agreeableness; gaps widest where sex roles are loosest
  • C05-34 open Schmitt, Realo, Voracek and Allik 2008: 17,637 people in 55 nations; personality gap predicted by wealth, health and education
  • C05-35 open Lee and Ashton 2020: 347,192 people in 48 countries; emotionality d = 0.84 in the HEXACO model
  • C05-39 open "The most equal societies on the index used" refers to the Global Gender Gap Index
  • C05-43 open Herlitz and colleagues 2024: re-analysis of 27 large studies (54 articles reviewed); paradox holds for personality and reverses for mathematics and partner preferences
  • C15-01 open Opening scene: a Finnish fifteen-year-old in a 2018 PISA round, hundreds of thousands of pupils in dozens of countries, data collated by the OECD in Paris. Illustrative, not a …
  • C15-02 open The attribution-of-failure item the girl answers paraphrases the "lack of talent" measure in Breda, Jouini & Napp 2020
  • C15-61 open Luigi Guiso, Monte, Sapienza and Zingales 2008, Science: PISA 2003, 40 countries, maths gap disappears with equality, reading gap expands
  • C15-67 open "Nobody has yet run the study that would decide it": a within-person longitudinal test of the paradox. Chapter's own statement of HC-07's open question; Fors Connolly 2020 used …
  • C15-69 open Reference-group effect and measurement invariance critique, as stated
  • C15-71 open Fors Connolly, Goossen and Hjerm 2020: within-country equality gains do not widen gaps (one sentence, as chapter 5 reported)
  • C15-72 open "In any country, most women and most men sit inside each other's range" on Falk and Hermle's preferences: inference from d values of 0.168 and below
  • C16-09 open Sex gaps in interest, risk and personality widened, not closed, in the richest and most equal countries
  • C16-61 open Breda, Jouini, Napp and Thebault 2020, PNAS: 300,000 15-year-olds, 64 countries; "maths is not for girls" stereotype stronger in richer countries; paradox vanishes once controlled
  • C16-62 open Fors Connolly, Goossen and Hjerm 2020, Sex Roles: no within-country divergence in values as equality rose, 235,339 people, 32 countries
  • C16-71 open Stoet and Geary 2018 sample: 472,242 adolescents in 67 countries against over 300,000 in 73 countries