The Library · Document 198 · PAIRING · Cultures in history
Natural experiments: when societies forced convergence or divergence
Reads Shaker and Oneida communes, the kibbutz, divided Germany and the Gulf as natural experiments. In later kibbutz generations about 75% of women work in education and services and 75% of men in farming and industry (Tiger and Shepher 1975), a finding critics contest. In 1989, 89% of GDR women work against 56% in the West, and East German wives out-earn husbands without added divorce risk (Lippmann 2020). Japanese women do 224 minutes of unpaid work a day, men 41. States rewrite public norms but not housework.
Open the PDF 16 pages · 358 KB
- Number
- 198
- Letter code
- HC-06
- Book
- PAIRING after the FALL
- Shelf
- Cultures in history
- File
- 198 HC-06 Natural experiments, when societies forced convergence or divergence.pdf
- Pages
- 16
Used in
The rows that check it
- 17 open
- 8 to check first
- P-09 open Check first Female labour-force participation 1989: GDR about 89 per cent, FRG 56 per cent
- P-13 open Check first Lippmann, Georgieff & Senik 2020, Economic Journal, SOEP 1991–2012: in the West, a wife crossing 50 per cent of household income raises her housework, exit and divorce risk; in …
- C11-57 open Check first Kibbutz from 1910; Tiger and Shepher 1975: agriculture 88/12, construction 99/1, management and politics 67/33, education 17/83, childcare and services 15/85; women 2 per cent vs …
- C13-23 open Check first 1989: about 89 per cent of East German women of working age in the labour force against 56 per cent in the West; Rosenfeld, Trappe and Gornick, Annual Review of Sociology, 2004; …
- C13-34 open Check first Lippmann, Georgieff and Senik, The Economic Journal, 2020: SOEP 1991 to 2012; when a wife's income crosses 50 per cent of household income, West German couples show more housework …
- C13-35 open Check first In 1992 almost 30 per cent of East German wives out-earned their husbands against 16 per cent in the West; "the gap has not closed"
- C13-48 open Check first Tiger and Shepher, Women in the Kibbutz, 1975: three generations of records; by the second and third generations about 75 per cent of women in education, health and services and …
- C13-50 open Check first Japan, OECD 2020: women 224 minutes a day of unpaid work against men's 41, the widest gap in the OECD; men 452 minutes of paid work a day, the longest in the OECD
- C13-04 open The GDR took the opposite bet "for forty-one years"; western rules laid over the whole country in 1990
- C13-20 open GDR constitution of 1949 wrote in the right to work and to equal pay
- C13-21 open GDR lost workers to the war and to the open border until 1961; labour shortage as motive
- C13-22 open Public childcare covered "nearly every child" by the late 1980s
- C13-26 open Trappe and Rosenfeld documented the double burden from GDR surveys; men's domestic hours did not move; the state "did not challenge male privilege at home"
- C13-41 open Post-1990 convergence on a "modernised breadwinner" (he full-time, she part-time) in both halves
- C13-42 open HC-06's phrase "almost insurmountable friction" for the state's reach into the private negotiation; SY-06's open question labelled the productivity paradox
- C16-02 open In the West, the year a wife's payslip overtakes her husband's, the household reacts (more housework, exit, divorce); not in the East
- C16-43 open Kibbutzim re-established a sex division of labour within two generations; cause disputed (Tiger and Shepher 1975 against critics)