THRIVING after the FALL
Book Two PAIRING after the FALL

The Log · PAIRING · Read the chapter

Chapter 11: The Abbess and the Monks

60 claims, 16 to check first

C11-01 Check first open Opening, The rule of the house

Fontevraud founded 1101 by Robert of Arbrissel, France; houses of monks and nuns under the abbess; monks owe obedience as son to mother; suppressed 1790

To check against
OR-06; primary history of Fontevraud
The verdict
OPEN
C11-03 Check first open Opening, worker with no body, Numbers

Kivimäki et al., Lancet 2015, IPD-Work: 25 studies, 603,838 (CHD, 8.5 years), 528,908 (stroke, 7.2 years); ≥55 h vs 35–40 h stroke RR 1.33 (1.11–1.61), CHD RR 1.13; dose steps 1.10 (41–48 h), 1.27 (49–54 h)

To check against
OR-05; Kivimäki et al. 2015 Lancet 386:1739
The verdict
OPEN
C11-05 Check first open Hormone section, Numbers, Contested

Dual-hormone meta-analysis: 30 papers, 33 studies, 49 effect sizes, N = 8,538, r = −0.061, attributed to Dekkers et al. 2019 Hormones and Behavior; PS-05 attributes the same figures to Geniole 2016

To check against
OR-02 vs PS-05; chapter 10's resolution; the paper itself
The verdict
OPEN
C11-08 Check first open Hormone section

Huang et al. 2026, 826 working men aged 22–40; ED prevalence 54.37 per cent in high-stress group, ten-fold odds; cortisol rise precedes testosterone decline by 2–4 weeks, ED by a further 4–6 weeks

To check against
OR-05 cites a press release, not the paper; International Journal of Clinical Practice
The verdict
OPEN
C11-10 Check first open Abbess section, Numbers

Eagly and Johnson 1990, Psychological Bulletin, 162 studies: task d = 0.00, interpersonal d = 0.04, democratic vs autocratic d = 0.22; PS-03 gives 161 studies

To check against
OR-02 vs PS-03; Eagly & Johnson 1990
The verdict
OPEN
C11-13 Check first open Abbess section, Numbers

Paustian-Underdahl, Walker and Woehr 2014, Journal of Applied Psychology, 99 samples, N = 101,676: overall d = −0.05; other-ratings d = −0.12 favouring women; self-ratings favour men

To check against
OR-02; the paper
The verdict
OPEN
C11-22 Check first open Rule of the house, case against

Ogilvie, The European Guilds 2019: >5,000 quantitative and 12,000 qualitative observations, eight centuries; guilds as cartels; excluding women raised members' wages; Württemberg guilds repeatedly re-passed exclusions (A Bitter Living 2003)

To check against
OR-06, HC-04; Ogilvie 2019, 2003
The verdict
OPEN
C11-30 Check first open Worker with no body, Numbers, Contested

Schoep et al. 2019 BMJ Open, 32,748 Dutch women: 13.8 per cent absenteeism, mean 1.3 days/year; 80.7 per cent presenteeism, 33 per cent self-reported productivity loss, 8.9 days/year; no employer-side validation

To check against
OR-04; Schoep et al. 2019
The verdict
OPEN
C11-36 Check first open Worker with no body, Contested

2019 review: >55.5 h/week preterm OR 1.21 (1.11–1.33); OR-04 calls this a "10 per cent increase" in the same sentence (internal discrepancy)

To check against
OR-04; the review (unnamed)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-39 Check first open Worker with no body

Fawcett Society 2022, 4,014 UK women: 10 per cent left a job, 14 per cent reduced hours, 8 per cent declined promotion, 44 per cent ability compromised, 41 per cent colleagues treated it as a joke

To check against
OR-04; Fawcett Society, Menopause and the Workplace 2022
The verdict
OPEN
C11-42 Check first open Worker with no body, Numbers

Pega et al. 2021, Environment International (WHO/ILO): >2,300 surveys, 154 countries; 745,194 deaths in 2016 attributable to ≥55 h; 72 per cent male; largest attributable occupational burden

To check against
OR-05; Pega et al. 2021; concept note §8
The verdict
OPEN
C11-44 Check first open Worker with no body

US BLS CFOI: 5,283 fatal injuries 2023 (5,486 in 2022, cut from text); men 91.4–93.0 per cent of fatalities 2011–2024; ~53 per cent of workforce; fatality rate >9× women's

To check against
OR-05; BLS CFOI releases
The verdict
OPEN
C11-46 Check first open Worker with no body

Milner, Page and LaMontagne 2013: unemployment suicide RR 1.70 (OR-05 also gives 1.58 as the unadjusted figure); 1.15 after adjustment for prior mental health; 2.50 in first five years; higher in men

To check against
OR-05; PLoS One 2013 and BJP 2014
The verdict
OPEN
C11-51 Check first open Separate doors, case against, In practice, Numbers

USMC Ground Combat Element Integrated Task Force 2015: ~100 female volunteers, one year; 134 tasks, 93 significant differences, 88 favouring all-male; 30 tasks with ≥30 per cent gap, 28 favouring all-male; higher female injury; ITB female graduation 36–46 per cent vs ~98 per cent male

To check against
OR-07; USMC 2015 report
The verdict
OPEN
C11-53 Check first open Separate doors, Contested

Hilton and Lundberg 2021, Sports Medicine: male advantage 10–12 per cent running, ~30 per cent weightlifting at matched mass, ~65 per cent open powerlifting; 12 months testosterone suppression removes ~5 per cent; OR-07 also gives baseline "30–80 per cent" (internal discrepancy with "10–50 per cent")

To check against
OR-07; Hilton & Lundberg 2021
The verdict
OPEN
C11-57 Check first open Separate doors, case against

Kibbutz from 1910; Tiger and Shepher 1975: agriculture 88/12, construction 99/1, management and politics 67/33, education 17/83, childcare and services 15/85; women 2 per cent vs men 9 per cent of senior central positions (Adar 1992, Palgi 1997)

To check against
OR-06; Tiger & Shepher 1975; HC-06 (chapter 13)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-02 open Opening, worker with no body

UK average age at menopause 51

To check against
OR-04; NHS or NICE figure
The verdict
OPEN
C11-04 open Hormone section

Mehta and Josephs 2010, Hormones and Behavior, dual-hormone hypothesis; executive study, testosterone predicted subordinates only when cortisol low

To check against
OR-02, OR-05; Mehta & Josephs 2010; OR-05 names no author for the executive study
The verdict
OPEN
C11-06 open Hormone section, Numbers

Grebe et al. 2019 p-curve: ~16 per cent power in published dual-hormone literature; seven unpublished datasets show no interaction

To check against
OR-02; Grebe et al. 2019
The verdict
OPEN
C11-07 open Hormone section

Immunoassays unreliable at female testosterone concentrations; oestradiol and power motivation in women rarely studied

To check against
OR-02
The verdict
OPEN
C11-11 open Abbess section

Vecchio 2002 critique; 197 of 370 primary studies self-ratings (OR-02 gives 162 studies in the same paragraph)

To check against
OR-02; Vecchio 2002
The verdict
OPEN
C11-12 open Abbess section

d = 0.22 corresponds to about 90 per cent overlap (chapter 4's table gives 92 per cent at d = 0.20)

To check against
Chapter 4 conversion table
The verdict
OPEN
C11-14 open Abbess section

Badura et al. 2018, Journal of Applied Psychology, 1,632 effect sizes, 120 samples, N = 32,579; men emerge more, gap shrinking; agency drives emergence, emotional ability drives rated transformational leadership

To check against
OR-02; Badura et al. 2018
The verdict
OPEN
C11-15 open Abbess section

Eagly and Karau 2002, Psychological Review, role congruity theory

To check against
OR-02
The verdict
OPEN
C11-16 open Abbess section

Eagly, Makhijani and Klonsky 1992 meta-analysis: identical autocratic behaviour rated worse in women

To check against
OR-02; Psychological Bulletin 1992
The verdict
OPEN
C11-17 open Abbess section, In practice

Koenig et al. 2011: three paradigms, 40, 22 and 17 studies; leader stereotype masculine, weakening, weakest in education

To check against
OR-02; Koenig et al. 2011 Psychological Bulletin
The verdict
OPEN
C11-18 open Abbess section, In practice

Ryan and Haslam 2005, British Journal of Management, FTSE 100 glass cliff; Haslam and Ryan 2008 "think crisis, think female" and scapegoating

To check against
OR-02; the two papers
The verdict
OPEN
C11-19 open Rule of the house

Anglo-Saxon double monasteries c. 600–900 as mission stations; abbesses royal widows or princesses; Hild of Whitby; McNamara on viriliter

To check against
OR-06; Foot 2006 (CUP); McNamara
The verdict
OPEN
C11-20 open Rule of the house, In practice

Second Council of Nicaea 787, Canon XX, banned women living in monasteries of men; new double monasteries banned in the East (OR-06's summary line says "canonically banned" without the East qualifier)

To check against
OR-06; conciliar text
The verdict
OPEN
C11-21 open Rule of the house

Gilbertines of Sempringham: same food and drink for nuns and canons

To check against
OR-06; Gilbertine Rule
The verdict
OPEN
C11-23 open Rule of the house

Bennett 1996: Brigstock, Northamptonshire, early 14th century, >300 women brewing, a third of adult women; hops, capital and guilds pushed women out

To check against
OR-06; Bennett, Ale, Beer, and Brewsters 1996
The verdict
OPEN
C11-24 open Rule of the house

Paris seamstresses' guild 1675 with Colbert's backing; monopoly on women's and children's clothing, boys to age eight; 419 apprentices a year (1746–1759); >2,000 mistresses; largest apprentice group in Paris

To check against
OR-06; Crowston, Fabricating Women 2001
The verdict
OPEN
C11-25 open Rule of the house

Wunder, He Is the Sun, She Is the Moon 1998: Arbeitspaar, working couple, division of portfolios

To check against
OR-06; Wunder 1998
The verdict
OPEN
C11-26 open Worker with no body

Goldin's U-curve: 162 countries and US census from 1890; falling through early industrialisation, rising with education

To check against
HC-04; Goldin 1995 World Development
The verdict
OPEN
C11-27 open Worker with no body

Davidoff and Hall, Family Fortunes 1987: Birmingham and Essex middle class 1780–1850, separate spheres

To check against
HC-04
The verdict
OPEN
C11-28 open Worker with no body

Hartmann 1976 (Signs) vs Humphries 1977 (Cambridge Journal of Economics) on the family wage; Horrell and Humphries 1992, 1,350 household budgets 1787–1865

To check against
HC-04; the papers
The verdict
OPEN
C11-29 open Worker with no body

Jane Lewis 1992 typology: strong male-breadwinner states UK and Germany, weak Sweden and Denmark; Illich's shadow work

To check against
HC-04; Lewis 1992 Journal of European Social Policy; Illich 1981
The verdict
OPEN
C11-31 open Worker with no body, case against, Numbers

Japan menstrual leave since 1947 (Art. 68 Labour Standards Act), 0.9 per cent uptake in 2020 ministry survey; South Korea 2001, ~19 per cent uptake 2018 poll, employer pays if not taken; Spain 2023, state pays 60 per cent, medical diagnosis

To check against
OR-04; national statutes and surveys
The verdict
OPEN
C11-32 open Worker with no body, case against

Gruber 1994 AER: mandated maternity benefits priced back onto women's wages; Buriakova, Fitzpatrick and Machin 2022 OECD: sex-specific leave reduces women's hiring into permanent and high-paying roles

To check against
OR-04; Gruber 1994; the 2022 paper (venue not given in OR-04)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-33 open Case against

Study of 955 young women (mean age 19.56): 54.6 per cent prefer explicit menstrual leave

To check against
OR-04 (study unnamed)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-34 open Worker with no body

Wang et al. 2019 meta-analysis, 21 studies, 195,538 women: irregular menstruation OR 1.30, dysmenorrhoea OR 1.35, early menopause HR 1.09

To check against
OR-04; the paper (venue not given)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-35 open Worker with no body

Bonde et al. 2013, Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health, 30 papers: fixed nights miscarriage RR 1.51 (1.27–1.78) across five studies

To check against
OR-04; Bonde et al. 2013
The verdict
OPEN
C11-37 open Worker with no body

Wallace et al. 2023 (nuMoM2b, n = 5,191): ~75 per cent higher odds of gestational diabetes for afternoon/night shift

To check against
OR-04; AJOG 2023
The verdict
OPEN
C11-40 open Worker with no body, In practice

BSI BS 30416 published May 2023: fabrics, PPE time, fans, windows, shift changes

To check against
OR-04; BSI
The verdict
OPEN
C11-41 open Worker with no body, In practice

Grandey, Jack and Brewis on medicalisation and gendered ageism of menopause

To check against
OR-04; Grandey et al. 2020 review (venue given as Gender, Work & Organization for Brewis)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-43 open Worker with no body

Stroke RR: Kivimäki 2015 1.33 vs Pega 2021 1.35; CHD 1.13 vs 1.17 (two sources, two figures, text uses Kivimäki's)

To check against
OR-05
The verdict
OPEN
C11-45 open Worker with no body

Fatal trades: structural iron, roofing, fishing, logging, construction, heavy transport

To check against
OR-05; BLS
The verdict
OPEN
C11-47 open Worker with no body

Boston College The New Dad (Harrington, Humberd, Ladge): ~1,000 Fortune 500 fathers, 95 per cent flexibility critical, 53 per cent would consider stay-at-home

To check against
OR-05; the report
The verdict
OPEN
C11-48 open Worker with no body, In practice

Rudman and Mescher 2013, Journal of Social Issues: flexibility stigma and femininity stigma for men; men given flexibility work more hours (OR-04 attributes "flexibility stigma" to Williams, Blair-Loy and Berdahl 2013)

To check against
OR-05, OR-04; both papers
The verdict
OPEN
C11-49 open Separate doors

MacCoun 1996 RAND: 66 cohesion-performance correlations, 49 studies; task cohesion not social cohesion predicts performance

To check against
OR-07; MacCoun 1996
The verdict
OPEN
C11-50 open Separate doors, case against

Hellum 2014, Norwegian unisex dormitories de-dramatised sex (OR-07 cites a blog post)

To check against
OR-07; Hellum 2014
The verdict
OPEN
C11-52 open Separate doors

Gepstein et al. 2014, IDF Caracal: 85 men, 235 women, three years; more stress fractures in women; attrition 28 per cent women vs 37 per cent men (heights 162 vs 174 cm, fat 18.9 vs 12.6 kg, VO2 36.8 vs 50.48 cut from text)

To check against
OR-07; Gepstein et al. 2014
The verdict
OPEN
C11-54 open Separate doors

Wong, Shi and Chen 2018, PLoS ONE: 2,059 high-school and 456 college students; single-sex schooling and mixed-gender anxiety

To check against
OR-07; the paper
The verdict
OPEN
C11-55 open Separate doors

Haudenosaunee: Grand Council of 50 male chiefs nominated and deposed by Clan Mothers; Quaker doubled plan of men's and women's business meetings, Lucretia Mott (OR-07 cites an archive and a local history society)

To check against
OR-06, OR-07; chapter 2 (DH-06)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-56 open Separate doors, In practice

Agarwal 2009, 2010: 135 community forest institutions (65 Gujarat, 70 Nepal), sampled 2000–01; Nepal all-women committees mean 20.9 ha vs 41.6 ha others, better regeneration; critical mass 25–33 per cent

To check against
OR-06; Agarwal, Ecological Economics 2009; Gender and Green Governance 2010
The verdict
OPEN
C11-58 open Case against, In practice

Galley 2013, Continuity and Change: 1833 Factory Inquiry, women excluded from overseer roles

To check against
HC-04; Galley 2013
The verdict
OPEN
C11-59 open Worker with no body

Narrator born 1975; Germany in Lewis's strong male-breadwinner column

To check against
concept note biographical anchor; HC-04
The verdict
OPEN