Woolley et al. 2010: 40 three-person groups in study 1, 152 groups of three to five in study 2, 192 in all
- To check against
- OR-01 (text and summary table "~192 groups, 3 to 5"). Primary: Woolley et al. 2010, *Science*
- The verdict
- OPEN
The Log · PAIRING · Read the chapter
58 claims, 24 to check first
Woolley et al. 2010: 40 three-person groups in study 1, 152 groups of three to five in study 2, 192 in all
The c factor explained 43 per cent of the variance in group performance across tasks
c correlated with average Reading the Mind in the Eyes score, with equality of turn-taking (r = −0.41 with the variance in speaking turns), and with the proportion of women, the last largely mediated by the eyes-test scores
Kirkland et al. 2013, 42 studies, 4,290 healthy adults, female advantage on the eyes test. OR-01 gives both Hedges' g = 0.177 and Cohen's d = 0.47 for the same analysis; chapter 4 found only 0.177 in the PS-02 PDF. Text carries 0.177 and withholds OR-01's derived "32 per cent of men above the average woman"
Credé and Howardson, "The structure of group task performance: a second look at the evidence for the collective intelligence construct", *Journal of Applied Psychology*. OR-01 dates it 2017; the chapter's plan says "Credé et al. 2019". Re-examined six published samples
Average variance extracted (Fornell and Larcker formula) 22 to 35 per cent across the datasets, against a conventional 50 per cent threshold
Meta-analysis of 857 groups across eight independent samples: c correlates r = 0.26 (95 per cent CI 0.10 to 0.40) with external criterion tasks
Hoogendoorn, Oosterbeek and van Praag 2013, *Management Science*: about 550 business students, 45 teams of 12, real ventures, assigned sex ratios; 50/50 teams outperform male-dominated on sales and profit; profit rises to 50 per cent women then flattens; no mediator found among conflict, friendship, decision process, atmosphere, monitoring, learning. First names and place not in OR-01
Apesteguia, Azmat and Iriberri 2012, *Management Science*: business simulation, teams of three, undergraduates and MBA students; three-women teams outperformed by all other combinations; bottom decile 0.47 SD below mean, top decile 0.09 below; MBA optimum two men and one woman; less aggressive pricing, less R&D, more social sustainability
Hardt, Mayer and Rincke 2024, *Management Science*: 1,368 subjects, 342 four-person teams, audio-only chat, sex-neutral task; all-male teams more topic words and better performance; men in mixed teams speak more, women less; men almost 70 per cent more words than women in mixed teams; high-skilled women speak less than low-skilled men (skill proxied by GPA)
Niederle and Vesterlund 2007, *QJE*: 40 men and 40 women, adding sets of four two-digit numbers for three minutes, no performance difference, 73 per cent of men and 35 per cent of women chose the tournament; title "Do women shy away from competition? Do men compete too much?"
Markowsky and Beblo 2022: 110 studies, 409 effect sizes, unadjusted gap 13 percentage points; largest for maths tasks with student samples, attenuated for verbal tasks, other ages, team competition
Buser, Niederle and Oosterbeek 2014, *QJE*: 1,480 Dutch secondary students aged 15, four tracks; competitiveness accounts for up to 23 per cent of the sex gap in track choice, controlling for ability, risk and confidence
Gillen, Snowberg and Yariv 2019, *Econometrica*: measurement error 30 to 40 per cent of the variance in elicited risk and confidence; attenuation bias; replication on the Caltech Cohort Study with duplicate elicitations as instruments; sex gap in entry entirely explained by risk attitudes and overconfidence
Bird et al. 2024, *PNAS*: pre-registered RCT, 1,000 men, 11 mg intranasal testosterone or placebo, nine primary hypotheses, 80 per cent power for d = 0.23, no treatment effect on any outcome
Dual-hormone meta-analysis: 30 papers, 33 studies, 49 effect sizes, N = 8,538, testosterone × cortisol interaction r = −0.061, significant but negligible. OR-02 (PDF p. 2) attributes it to Dekkers et al. 2019, *Hormones and Behavior*; PS-05 (PDF p. 2) to "Geniole et al. (2016)", *Psychoneuroendocrinology*, effect size stripped; PS-05's works cited item 1 links a paper titled "A meta-analytical evaluation of the dual-hormone hypothesis...", which is the Dekkers title. Chapter 4 read r = −0.061, p = 0.026 from the rendered PS-05 PDF. Text carries Dekkers 2019
Gneezy, Leonard and List 2009, *Econometrica*: Maasai of Tanzania (patriarchal, women little property) and Khasi of Meghalaya, India (matrilineal, youngest daughter inherits); ball-tossing task; Maasai 50 per cent of men and 26 per cent of women compete; Khasi 54 per cent of women and 39 per cent of men; Khasi women more competitive than Maasai men
Flory, Leibbrandt and List 2015, *Management Science*: field experiment, about 7,000 job seekers; opt-in competitive pay 72.5 per cent of men and 46.7 per cent of women applied; opt-out 76.4 and 75.3. OR-03 calls the opt-in gap "25%"; arithmetic gives 25.8 points, text says "nearly 26"
Bowles, Babcock and Lai 2007, *OBHDP*: four experiments; evaluators penalised women more than men for initiating salary negotiation, penalty "nearly tripled" (figures stripped in OR-03 text and PDF p. 5); women less inclined to negotiate with a male evaluator; mediated by anticipated social cost
Exley and Kessler 2022, *QJE*: over 4,000 online adults and over 10,000 school-aged youth; self-evaluation gap 13 points, equal to 24 per cent of the mean, with performance controlled; persists when private; present from sixth grade; employers hired and paid women less when shown self-evaluations
Chattopadhyay and Duflo 2004, *Econometrica*: 1993 constitutional amendment reserving one third of village council chief posts for women by lot; 265 councils in West Bengal and Rajasthan; female leaders invest more in drinking water and (West Bengal) roads, male leaders more in education; women constituents twice as likely to raise concerns. the SO digest records that SO-01 and SO-07 disagree on roads
Ahern and Dittmar 2012, *QJE*: quota caused a 12.4 per cent decline in Tobin's Q and worse operating performance, via younger, less experienced boards
Eckbo, Nygaard and Thorburn 2022: original event dates wrong, no correction for cross-correlation of returns; corrected valuation effect indistinguishable from zero; supply of qualified women sufficient. Venue: ECGI Working Paper (OR-01) versus *Management Science* 68(6): 4112–4134 (SO-07)
Mazei et al. meta-analysis, 10,888 participants: male negotiation advantage vanishes when negotiating on behalf of others
Woolley's task battery: visual puzzles, brainstorming, moral judgements, resource negotiation, drawn from the McGrath task circumplex; place of the experiments not named
General intelligence g accounts for 30 to 50 per cent of the variance in a battery of tests, one of the most replicated findings in psychology
Average and maximum individual intelligence of members were only moderate predictors of c
Co-authors Chabris, Pentland, Hashmi and Thomas W. Malone; first names of the first three not in OR-01
The Reading the Mind in the Eyes Test shows a photograph of the eye region and asks the viewer to choose the word for the emotion; developed by Baron-Cohen and colleagues
Greenberg et al. 2022, *PNAS*, four datasets, 312,739 people, 57 countries, on-average female advantage on the eyes test across the lifespan and almost all languages tested
Engel et al. 2014, *PLOS One*: eyes-test scores predicted c equally well in online text-based groups
Riedl et al. meta-analysis: 22 studies, 1,356 groups, 5,279 individuals, average variance extracted 43.6 per cent; "same academic cluster" as Woolley; year and venue not given in OR-01's text, works cited links a PNAS paper "Quantifying collective intelligence in human groups"
Principal axis factoring: single-factor eigenvalue 1.05, 17 per cent of variance, against a threshold of 1.38
Credé and Howardson's two artefact explanations (low-effort responding, nested data) and their caution against abandoning individual selection
OR-01's statement that the behavioural finding (social sensitivity and equal turn-taking predict group performance) is "generally accepted" while c is contested
Low-ability men entered the tournament too often and lost; high-ability women entered too rarely; gap driven by male overconfidence and a residual preference
Dariel et al. 2017: 53 papers, average tournament entry 52 per cent men, 34 per cent women
Buser 2016: after a loss women reduce effort regardless of prize, men only when the prize is large; responses to outcomes explain about 11 per cent of variation in women's effort and 4 per cent in men's; about half the sex gap in repeated competition
Nelson: male and female distributions of economic preferences overlap by 80 to 90 per cent; a random woman is more competitive or more risk-taking than a random man up to 40 to 45 per cent of the time
Price 2020, *Economics Bulletin*: pure replication of Niederle and Vesterlund, null result
Zethraeus et al. 2009, *PNAS*: 200 postmenopausal women, testosterone or placebo, no effect on risk aversion, altruism or competitiveness
Dekkers et al. 2022, *Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews*: 52 studies, 94 measurements, testosterone–risk correlation near zero, 95 per cent CI [−0.0431, 0.0389]; point estimate stripped in text and PDF
Gong and Yang: matrilineal Mosuo and patriarchal Yi, Yunnan; Mosuo men more generous than Mosuo women in a dictator game (2015, *Experimental Economics*); Mosuo girls initially more risk-taking than boys, more risk-averse than boys by age 11 after schooling with the Han majority
Hauge and Kotsadam 2023, *Economic Journal*: 1,943 Norwegians, parents from 59 countries; sex gap in competition smaller for ancestries from more gender-equal countries, bidirectional
Niederle, Segal and Vesterlund 2013, *Management Science*: a quota guaranteeing equal representation among winners increased female entry, drawing in able women, without lowering the performance threshold
Informing advisers that women self-promote less eliminated a 12-percentage-point gap in ambitious career advice
Babcock, Recalde, Vesterlund and Weingart 2017, *AER*: women volunteer for non-promotable tasks 50 per cent more often than men; baseline probability about 20 percentage points higher; managers of both sexes ask women more; women accept more
Norway's 2003 law requiring 40 per cent women on boards
Post and Byron 2015, *Academy of Management Journal*: 140 studies; female board representation positively related to accounting returns, near zero with market performance
Sila, Gonzalez and Hagendorff 2016, *Journal of Corporate Finance*: no evidence that female board representation affects equity risk
Masciandaro, Profeta and Romelli 2020, *European Journal of Political Economy*: forward-looking Taylor rule; higher share of women on central bank boards associated with higher interest rates for the same expected inflation; selection or signalling as explanations
Couzin et al. 2011, *Science*: golden shiners, trained minority (yellow) and majority (blue); minority steers when alone; adding 5 to 10 uninformed fish restores majority control
Conradt and Roper 2003, *Nature*: democratic (shared) decisions are less extreme and carry lower consensus costs than despotic ones
Byrnes, Miller and Schafer 1999: 150 studies, men take more risk in 14 of 16 categories; financial risk d about 0.43 (figure from chapter 4's PDF reading; stripped in PS-05 text and PDF text layer)
Saccardo, Pietrasz and Gneezy 2022: field experiment, 97,678 working-age adults (N from chapter 4's PDF reading; stripped in PS-05 text and PDF text layer); women's participation fell 25.5 per cent under competition outside STEM; gap absent among STEM adults; authors read it as selection
Bear and Woolley 2011: solo women in majority-male groups are less talkative and less influential than women in balanced groups
Chapter 11 will treat the dual-hormone hypothesis; chapter 14 owns Chattopadhyay and Duflo and the state; chapter 4 carried Niederle, Gneezy, Byrnes and Saccardo; chapter 3 owns hormones; chapter 5 left the paradox open
The narrator's mother's generation "fought for the seat"