PAIRING · Part III · Emancipation 2.0
The numbers and sources
Chapter 14: Queens at War
The narrated edition tells this chapter with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.
- 53 open
- 15 to check first
Numbers to carry
The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.
- 39 percentage points: how much likelier a polity was to be at war in a given year under a queen than under a king, 193 reigns, 18 European polities, 1480 to 1913 (Dube and Harish, Journal of Political Economy, 2020, per SO-01). Row C14-18.
- 2.1 percentage points, a third of the baseline: the fall in neonatal mortality for a ten-point rise in women's share of an Indian state legislature (Bhalotra and Clots-Figueras 2014, per SO-01). Row C14-05. 8 to 12 per cent: the fall in maternal mortality after a national quota (Bhalotra et al. 2023, per SO-01). Row C14-06.
- Twice as often: how much more women spoke in village council meetings with a woman in the chair, 265 councils (Chattopadhyay and Duflo 2004, per SO-01 and SO-07). Row C14-02. Five times: a woman's odds of winning a seat once reserved against one never reserved (Bhavnani 2009, per SO-01). Row C14-04.
- 63 per cent longer: men's federal sentences for the same arrest offence and history, and twice the odds of avoiding prison for women (Starr, American Law and Economics Review, 2014, per SO-04). Row C14-35. 22 against 4 per cent: the share of French mixed co-offender pairs in which the man, or the woman, got the longer sentence (SO-04, attribution open). Row C14-36.
- 23.9 against 11.2 per cent, relative risk 2.13: stress fractures in women and men under identical Israeli anti-aircraft training (Finestone et al., Military Medicine, 2005, per SO-04). Row C14-31. 12.0 against 1.3, relative risk 9.23, in light infantry (Finestone et al. 2014, per SO-04). Row C14-32.
Every figure
One row for each figure or finding in the data edition's chapter, whether or not the narrated edition kept it. Layer says whether it belongs to physiology, behaviour or culture. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.
| Figure | What it measures | Study (authors, year, venue, N) | Document | Row | Layer | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1993, one chair in three, chosen at random | India's constitutional amendment reserving village council chairs for women, with reserved councils drawn at random | Chattopadhyay and Duflo 2004, Econometrica | SO-01 | C14-01 | culture | robust |
| 265 councils, more spending on drinking water in West Bengal, women spoke about twice as often | What a woman in the chair does to a council's budget and to the women in the room | Chattopadhyay and Duflo 2004, Econometrica, 265 councils in West Bengal and Rajasthan | SO-01, SO-07 | C14-02 | culture | robust |
| Fewer roads in Rajasthan (SO-01) or more roads in West Bengal (SO-07) | Road spending by women-led councils | Chattopadhyay and Duflo 2004, Econometrica | SO-01, SO-07 | C14-03 | culture | contested |
| About five times | A woman's odds of winning the next open election in a Mumbai ward where a reservation had lapsed, against a never-reserved ward | Bhavnani 2009, American Political Science Review | SO-01 | C14-04 | culture | robust |
| 2.1 percentage points, a third of the baseline of 33.5 per cent | Fall in neonatal mortality for a ten-point rise in women's share of Indian state legislature seats, via antenatal visits, iron supplements and facility births | Bhalotra and Clots-Figueras 2014, American Economic Journal: Applied Economics | SO-01 | C14-05 | culture | robust |
| Maternal mortality ratio down 8 to 12 per cent, skilled birth attendance up 5 to 8 points, prenatal care up 4 to 8 points, fertility down 6 to 7 per cent, girls' schooling up about half a year | Effects of adopting a parliamentary quota for women in developing countries, staggered adoption dates | Bhalotra, Clarke, Gomes and Venkataramani 2023, Journal of the European Economic Association | SO-01 | C14-06 | culture | robust |
| 15 per cent | How much further maternal deaths fell after the 1937 arrival of sulfa drugs in US states that had enfranchised women early | Attributed by SO-01's text to Bhalotra et al. 2023 and by its works cited to a separate 2023 paper (UCLouvain) | SO-01 | C14-07 | culture | open |
| 4,265 close elections, 1.8 percentage points a year faster growth, men three times as likely to carry criminal charges, women's asset accumulation about 10 points a year lower | Effects of a woman narrowly winning an Indian state assembly seat, growth measured by night-time light from satellites | Baskaran, Bhalotra, Min and Uppal 2018 (working paper) and 2023, Journal of Economic Growth, 4,265 close elections | SO-01 | C14-08 | culture | robust |
| One standard deviation more women in parliament, a fifth of a standard deviation less perceived corruption, more than 100 countries | Cross-country correlation of women's share of seats with perceived corruption | Dollar, Fisman and Gatti 2001, Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, more than 100 countries | SO-01 | C14-09 | culture | contested |
| Holds in democracies, vanishes in autocracies | Whether the women-corruption relationship depends on regime type | Esarey and Chirillo 2013, Politics and Gender, "Fairer Sex or Purity Myth?" | SO-01 | C14-10 | culture | robust |
| 76 democratic-leaning countries | Women reduce corruption only where electoral accountability is high | Esarey and Schwindt-Bayer 2018, American Journal of Political Science (SO-01 text) or British Journal of Political Science (works-cited filename), 76 countries | SO-01 | C14-11 | culture | robust |
| Higher ethical standard, harsher punishment of a woman's scandal | Voters' treatment of women politicians caught in scandal, experiments | Barnes and Beaulieu 2014 and 2018, venues not given | SO-01 | C14-12 | culture | robust |
| Women more risk-averse and more context-sensitive on average | Review of laboratory games | Croson and Gneezy 2009, Journal of Economic Literature | SO-01 | C14-13 | behaviour | contested |
| 147 estimates from 25 studies | Publication bias inflates the sex gap in risk aversion, within-sex variation dwarfs between-sex | Nelson 2015, Feminist Economics, 147 estimates, 25 studies | SO-01 | C14-14 | behaviour | robust |
| 93 per cent | Share of between-subject comparisons contradicting the claim that women's social preferences are more context-sensitive | DellaVigna and Pope, NBER working paper, 2022 in SO-01's text, NBER number w35324 suggests 2025 | SO-01 | C14-15 | behaviour | robust, year open |
| No figure | Female heads of state sit in the tails of the distributions and are hard to tell from male peers on competitiveness, risk tolerance and dominance | SO-01's own wording, no primary source named | SO-01 | C14-16 | behaviour | open |
| Higher rates at the same expected inflation | Women on monetary policy committees vote more hawkishly than men | Masciandaro, Profeta and Romelli 2020, European Journal of Political Economy, verified under chapter 10 | SO-07 | C14-17 | behaviour | robust |
| 193 reigns, 18 polities, 1480 to 1913, 39 percentage points | How much likelier a polity under a queen was to be at war in a given year, instruments: first-born son and sister of the previous monarch | Dube and Harish 2020, Journal of Political Economy, "Queens", 193 reigns | SO-01 | C14-18 | culture | robust |
| Unmarried queens more often attacked, married queens more often aggressors, more so than married kings | The split in the queens finding and the dual-executive explanation | Dube and Harish 2020, Journal of Political Economy | SO-01 | C14-19 | culture | robust as pattern, mechanism inferred |
| No figure | Dube and Harish's affiliations, S. P. Harish given with initials only | Title page of Dube and Harish 2020 | SO-01 | C14-20 | not applicable | open |
| No figure in SO-01 | The physical security of a state's women predicts its peacefulness better than wealth, democracy or religion | Hudson et al. 2012, Sex and World Peace | SO-01 | C14-21 | culture | contested |
| 130,000 data points, 175 countries | Size of the WomanStats database, and Hudson's co-authors given as Caprioli, Bowen and McDermott | SY-05, a synthesis report whose book sources are Goodreads and Bookey, no primary source named | SY-05 | C14-22 | culture | open |
| 186 or 185 societies, zero with women in military leadership | Standard Cross-Cultural Sample, assembled 1969, count given two ways in DH-07 | Murdock and White 1969, Ethnology, and the SCCS military leadership variable | DH-07 | C14-23 | culture | robust, count open |
| 156 societies | Inner and outer orientation, outer orientation travelling with high interpersonal violence and rape-prone culture | Sanday 1981, Female Power and Male Dominance, Cambridge University Press, 156 societies | DH-07 | C14-24 | culture | robust |
| No figure | The male supremacy complex: warfare rewards young men with patrilocal residence, polygyny, political monopoly and the subordination of women | Divale and Harris 1976, American Anthropologist | DH-07 | C14-25 | culture | contested |
| No figure | Pathogen stress and male war mortality as the two best predictors of non-sororal polygyny, with controls for shared ancestry | Low, year and venue not in DH-07 | DH-07 | C14-26 | culture | open |
| About 85 per cent (SO-05) or over 80 per cent (DH-07) | Share of societies in the ethnographic record permitting polygyny, and the group-level effects of normative monogamy | Henrich, Boyd and Richerson 2012, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B | SO-05, DH-07 | C14-27 | culture | robust |
| No figure | Surplus young men and state violence, sex ratios, polygyny and instability | Hudson and den Boer, not in any document in the library | none, (SO-02, still to be written) | C14-28 | culture | open |
| 93 societies, about ten dimensions | Dimensions of women's standing barely correlate with one another | Whyte 1978, The Status of Women in Preindustrial Societies, Princeton University Press, 93 societies | DH-07 | C14-29 | culture | robust |
| 2013 law, in force 2015, first NATO member, 14 per cent of the force by 2020 against a 20 per cent target | Norway's conscription of women, mixed dormitories and de-genderisation at Skjold and Heggelia | Hellum 2014, Norwegian Defence Research Establishment report, and a DCAF report, title and year not given | SO-04 | C14-30 | culture | robust, 14 per cent open |
| 23.9 per cent (33 women) against 11.2 per cent (42 men), relative risk 2.13 | Stress fractures under identical basic training in the Israeli Anti-Aircraft Forces, women's fractures in tibia, femur and pelvis | Finestone, Milgrom, Moran et al. 2005, Military Medicine | SO-04 | C14-31 | physiology | robust |
| 12.0 against 1.3 per cent, relative risk 9.23 | Stress fractures in light infantry | Finestone et al. 2014, venue not given | SO-04 | C14-32 | physiology | robust |
| About 10 against 3 per cent, hazard more than fourfold | Stress fractures in the first six months of US Navy training | Moran et al. 2012, venue not given | SO-04 | C14-33 | physiology | open |
| No figure | Individual women with high baseline fitness complete the tours | SO-04's wording, no primary source named | SO-04 | C14-34 | physiology | open |
| 63 per cent longer, twice as likely to avoid prison, about 30 per cent of the gap unexplained, about six times the racial gap | US federal sentencing from arrest to sentence, same arrest offence and criminal history | Starr 2014, American Law and Economics Review | SO-04 | C14-35 | behaviour | robust |
| 15 days shorter, a third of the 45-day mean, man longer in 22 per cent of mixed co-offender pairs and woman in 4, one standard deviation more female judges shrinks the gap by about 10 per cent | French sentencing, every conviction 2000 to 2003 | Attributed in a table only to "Breda 2020" | SO-04 | C14-36 | behaviour | open |
| 80 to 84 per cent | Contested custody cases ending in sole physical custody for the mother | No primary source in SO-04 | SO-04 | C14-37 | culture | open |
| d = 0.24 | Joint-custody children closer to intact-family children, joint-custody parents reporting less conflict | Bauserman 2002, Journal of Family Psychology, meta-analysis | SO-04 | C14-38 | behaviour | robust |
| 60 studies, better in 34, equal or better in 14, worse on one measure in 6 | Outcomes for children in joint custody | Nielsen 2018, venue not given, 60 studies | SO-04 | C14-39 | behaviour | robust |
| 110 signatories | Consensus report that the evidence did not support denying infant overnights to fathers, after McIntosh 2010 and 2013 | Warshak 2014, Psychology, Public Policy, and Law | SO-04 | C14-40 | behaviour | robust |
| No figure | Despotic decisions cost a group more than shared ones when members' interests differ | Conradt and Roper 2003, Nature (SO-07 also cites a 2005 Trends in Ecology and Evolution review) | SO-07 | C14-41 | behaviour | robust |
| No figure | Higher share of women in parliament goes with stricter climate policy and lower carbon emissions, instrumental variables | Mavisakalyan and Tarverdi 2019, European Journal of Political Economy | SO-07 | C14-42 | culture | contested |
| 194 countries, about half as many deaths | Women-led countries locked down earlier in the first wave of 2020 | Garikipati and Kambhampati 2021, Feminist Economics, 194 countries matched on wealth and demography | SO-07 | C14-43 | culture | contested |
| No figure | The countries which elect women are high-trust, low-hierarchy countries, which explains the pandemic and climate results | Windsor et al. 2020, venue not given | SO-07 | C14-44 | culture | open |
| 1,200 juror interviews, 353 capital cases, 14 US states | White male jurors most willing to sentence to death, women weigh mitigating evidence more heavily | Bowers et al., Capital Jury Project, venues and years not given | SO-07 | C14-45 | behaviour | robust, venues open |
| No figure | Men extended property rights and later the vote to women as the return on children's education rose | Doepke and Tertilt 2009, Econometrica, "Women's Rights: What's in it for Men?" | SO-05 | C14-46 | culture | robust |
| 140 studies | Women on boards: small positive relation with accounting returns, near zero with market performance | Post and Byron 2015, Academy of Management Journal, 140 studies | SO-07 | C14-47 | behaviour | robust |
| No effect | Women directors and equity risk in a large sample of US firms | Sila, Gonzalez and Hagendorff 2016, Journal of Corporate Finance | SO-07 | C14-48 | behaviour | robust |
| Fewer layoffs, lower short-run earnings | Norwegian quota boards | Matsa and Miller 2013, American Economic Journal: Applied Economics | SO-07 | C14-49 | behaviour | robust |
| 200 studies, 14,548 participants, 66 per cent male in the earlier stress literature | Tend-and-befriend, resting on oxytocin | Taylor et al. 2000, Psychological Review | SO-01 | C14-50 | physiology | contested |
| No figure | Economic-marginalisation theorists predict that equality for women in the dock means more women in prison | SO-04, no primary source named | SO-04 | C14-51 | behaviour | open |
The case for and the case against
The case the chapter makes
- Random reservation of village council chairs moved spending towards women's priorities and roughly doubled women's speaking at meetings (Chattopadhyay and Duflo 2004, SO-01, SO-07, C14-01, C14-02).
- A lapsed reservation left a woman about five times as likely to win the open seat (Bhavnani 2009, SO-01, C14-04).
- More women in Indian state legislatures cut neonatal mortality by a third of the baseline. National quotas cut maternal mortality by 8 to 12 per cent (Bhalotra and Clots-Figueras 2014, Bhalotra et al. 2023, SO-01, C14-05, C14-06).
- Close elections won by women went with faster growth, fewer criminal charges and slower asset accumulation (Baskaran et al. 2018 and 2023, SO-01, C14-08).
- Women reduce corruption only where electoral accountability is high, and are punished harder for scandal, so the effect is about the audience, not the sex (Esarey and Chirillo 2013, Esarey and Schwindt-Bayer 2018, Barnes and Beaulieu 2014 and 2018, SO-01, C14-10 to C14-12).
- The risk-aversion gap shrinks once publication bias is corrected, and the context-sensitivity claim failed replication (Nelson 2015, DellaVigna and Pope, SO-01, C14-14, C14-15).
- Polities under queens were 39 percentage points likelier to be at war, married queens as aggressors with the husband as co-executive, unmarried queens as targets (Dube and Harish 2020, SO-01, C14-18, C14-19).
- The physical security of women predicts a state's peacefulness better than wealth, democracy or religion (Hudson et al. 2012, SO-01, C14-21).
- Outer-oriented societies under stress and war rely on hunting and fighting and subordinate women. The male supremacy complex. Normative monogamy reduces unmarried men and violence (Sanday 1981, Divale and Harris 1976, Henrich, Boyd and Richerson 2012, DH-07, SO-05, C14-23 to C14-27).
- Women's standing has about ten dimensions that barely correlate (Whyte 1978, DH-07, C14-29).
- Identical training produces about twice the stress fractures in women, nine times in light infantry. High-fitness individuals still complete the tours (Finestone et al. 2005 and 2014, SO-04, C14-31, C14-32, C14-34).
- Men receive sentences 63 per cent longer for the same file. French co-offender pairs show the same. More women judges shrink the gap (Starr 2014, "Breda 2020", SO-04, C14-35, C14-36).
- Joint custody outcomes favour children and reduce conflict. The 110-signature consensus on infant overnights (Bauserman 2002, Nielsen 2018, Warshak 2014, SO-04, C14-38 to C14-40).
- Shared decisions land nearer the group's median interest (Conradt and Roper 2003, SO-07, C14-41). Women in parliament go with lower emissions and earlier lockdowns (Mavisakalyan and Tarverdi 2019, Garikipati and Kambhampati 2021, SO-07, C14-42, C14-43). Mixed juries sentence to death less often (Capital Jury Project, SO-07, C14-45).
- Men extended rights to women when it paid them to (Doepke and Tertilt 2009, SO-05, C14-46).
The case against
- Boards, the best-measured mixed bodies, show a near-zero effect of sex composition on performance and risk (Post and Byron 2015, Sila, Gonzalez and Hagendorff 2016, SO-07, C14-47, C14-48). The one robust board finding is a priority, not a competence (Matsa and Miller 2013, SO-07, C14-49).
- The countries that elect women are high-trust, low-hierarchy countries, which explains the pandemic and climate results without the sex of the leader (Windsor et al. 2020, SO-07, C14-44).
- The Hudson correlation may run from wealth, stability and democracy to both women's security and peace (SO-01's own critics, C14-21).
- The risk-aversion gap was partly manufactured by publication bias (Nelson 2015, C14-14). The context-sensitivity claim fell (DellaVigna and Pope, C14-15). Tend-and-befriend rests on oxytocin, which the Preface's verdict undercuts (Taylor et al. 2000, SO-01, C14-50).
- The queens finding is one continent's early-modern reigns and the dual-executive mechanism is an inference from who attacked whom (Dube and Harish 2020, C14-18, C14-19).
Where the sources disagree
- Whether the Hudson correlation is cause, consequence or both from a third thing (SO-01's own critics, SY-05 for the figures). C14-21, C14-22.
- The roads finding in Chattopadhyay and Duflo: SO-01 says women's councils spent less on roads in Rajasthan, SO-07 says more on drinking water and roads in West Bengal. The SO fact sheet logs the same. C14-03.
- Whether the climate and pandemic results survive the culture-that-elects-women objection (Windsor 2020). C14-42 to C14-44.
- Whether the risk-aversion gap survives Nelson 2015, and whether tend-and-befriend (Taylor 2000) survives the Preface's oxytocin verdict. C14-13, C14-14, C14-50.
- The 80 to 84 per cent custody figure (no primary source) and the French study's attribution ("Breda 2020", table only), both SO-04. C14-36, C14-37.
- Everything that belongs in (SO-02, still to be written). C14-28.
- Becker's pastoralism paper: DH-07 gives Becker 2019, Review of Economic Studies, over 500,000 women in 34 nations, plus a 2024 working paper with 1.8 million respondents in 122 countries, while SO-05 gives Becker 2024, Review of Economic Studies, 1.3 million in over 100 countries. Not used in prose for that reason.
- Polygyny permitted: "over 80 per cent" of Ethnographic Atlas societies (DH-07) against "approximately 85 per cent" (SO-05, Henrich). The data edition carried "about 85 per cent" with Henrich as source. The narrated edition carries "most". C14-27.
- Esarey and Schwindt-Bayer 2018: SO-01 text says American Journal of Political Science, the works-cited PDF filename says BJPS. C14-11.
- Eagly and Wood 1999 venue: American Psychologist (SO-04) against Psychological Bulletin (SO-05). Not used in prose.
- SCCS size: 186 societies (DH-07 introduction) against 185 (DH-07 on Murdock and Provost and on military leadership). C14-23.
- Mavisakalyan and Tarverdi: the Hofstede analysis (18 countries, 20 years) is attributed to them for 2019 but cited to a 2025 paper (SO-07). Not used in prose. C14-42.
- The 1937 sulfa-drug finding is attributed by SO-01's text to the 2023 JEEA paper and by its works-cited to a separate 2023 paper. C14-07.
- DellaVigna and Pope year: SO-01 says 2022, the works-cited NBER number (w35324) suggests 2025. C14-15.
Open questions
The data edition's marks for checking, with rows:
- Roads finding: SO-01 (fewer in Rajasthan) against SO-07 (more in West Bengal). C14-03.
- The 1937 sulfa-drug and early-suffrage finding: same 2023 JEEA paper (SO-01 text) or a separate 2023 paper (SO-01 works cited, UCLouvain). C14-07.
- DellaVigna and Pope year: SO-01 says 2022, the works-cited NBER number (w35324) suggests 2025. C14-15.
- Dube and Harish affiliations, not given in SO-01. C14-20.
- Hudson's co-authors (Caprioli, Bowen, McDermott) from SY-05, not SO-01. C14-22.
- WomanStats: 130,000 data points, 175 countries, from SY-05. C14-22.
- SCCS count: 186 (DH-07 on Murdock and White 1969) against 185 (DH-07 on military leadership). C14-23.
- Low: year and venue not given in DH-07. C14-26.
- den Boer: not in any library document. The marker stays in the chapter's (SO-02, still to be written) line, which the narrated edition keeps verbatim. C14-28.
- Norwegian 14 per cent by 2020 (DCAF report, SO-04). C14-30.
- Moran et al. 2012, US Navy about 10 against 3 per cent, and the "more than fourfold" hazard. C14-33.
- French sentencing study attributed to "Breda 2020" in a table only (SO-04). C14-36.
- 80 to 84 per cent custody figure, no primary source (SO-04). C14-37.
- Capital Jury Project venues and years (SO-07). C14-45.
- Windsor 2020 venue (SO-07). C14-44.
- Barnes and Beaulieu 2014 and 2018, Nielsen 2018, Hellum 2014: venues not given in the documents (no marker in the data edition's text, logged in rows). C14-12, C14-39, C14-30.
The data edition's open questions from its working notes:
- Whether the opening may say the chair was "decided at random" (SO-01 says "randomly reserved", the SO fact sheet says "drawn by lot"). Both editions say "at random".
- Den Boer is a named person in the chapter note but appears in no document in the library. She is named only inside the (SO-02, still to be written) paragraph. If SO-02 is re-run, her material fills the gap and the name moves into prose.
- Dube and Harish's affiliations are not in SO-01 and are not supplied in either edition.
The documents
- SO-01 Women in political power and what states do: the lotteries, the queens, corruption.
- SO-04 Where the law treats the sexes differently: conscription, sentencing, custody, leave.
- SO-07 Mixed versus single-sex decision bodies and collective risk: Conradt and Roper, climate, pandemic, juries, and the board nulls for the case against.
- DH-07 Cross-cultural databases: Whyte, Sanday, Divale and Harris, Low.
- SO-05 Cultural evolution: Henrich, Boyd and Richerson on monogamy, Doepke and Tertilt on men yielding rights (state and world scale only).
- SO-02 Sex ratios, polygyny and social stability: missing, see (SO-02, still to be written).