THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 229 · PAIRING · Cities, states and the world

Cities designed for both sexes

Reviews city design for both sexes. Sánchez de Madariaga's mobility of care, the chained trips of unpaid care work, makes up 15 to 30% of urban trips, which commuter-centred transit penalises. Women's toilet visits average 178.9 seconds against men's 118.4, so equal floor space produces queues (Bovens and Marcoci 2020). Vienna has planned with gender mainstreaming since Eva Kail's 1991 exhibition, redesigning parks girls leave after age nine. Whether street lighting cuts crime is contested (Welsh and Farrington 2008 against Steinbach et al. 2015), though it reduces women's fear.

Open the PDF 16 pages · 340 KB

Number
229
Letter code
SO-03
Book
PAIRING after the FALL
Shelf
Cities, states and the world
File
229 SO-03 Cities designed for both sexes.pdf
Pages
16

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 43 open
  • 9 to check first
  • C12-02 open Check first Montréal: caregiving 28 per cent of all trips, 32 per cent of women's daily trips, 25 per cent of men's, regional travel survey
  • C12-03 open Check first Washington DC: women 58 per cent of all WMATA transit users; female share 10 to 15 percentage points higher on off-peak chained trips; fare-card origin-destination data, first …
  • C12-09 open Check first 1991: Eva Kail, planner in the Vienna city administration, organised the photography exhibition "Who Owns Public Space – Women's Everyday Life in the City"
  • C12-11 open Check first 1999 Vienna municipal survey: men commute linearly, women's routines varied and tied to local infrastructure
  • C12-17 open Check first 2024 EVA report (Evaluierung aspern Die Seestadt Wiens): 93 per cent of residents rate their quality of life highly
  • C12-18 open Check first Girls largely disappear from Vienna's public parks after about age nine; observation by Eva Kail and Claudia Prinz-Brandenburg (landscape architect)
  • C12-22 open Check first Average toilet service time 178.9 seconds for women, 118.4 for men
  • C12-31 open Check first Welsh and Farrington 2008 Campbell Systematic Review (updating 2002): 13 studies, UK and US; 20 per cent crime reduction; OR 1.27, 95 per cent CI 1.09 to 1.47, p = 0.0008
  • C12-34 open Check first Steinbach et al. 2015: 62 local authorities in England and Wales, 2000 to 2013; switch-off, part-night, dimming and white LED; no association with crime (burglary, vehicle theft, …
  • P-51 open Vienna gender-mainstreamed parks and transport (Eva Kail, from 1991)
  • C12-01 open Inés Sánchez de Madariaga, urban planner, coined "mobility of care" in 2009 and set it out in a 2013 chapter of Fair Shared Cities: The Impact of Gender Planning in Europe …
  • C12-04 open Belo Horizonte: about 15 per cent of daily commutes care-related; 18 per cent of women's trips, 12 per cent of men's; 2012 household survey reanalysed 2018
  • C12-05 open Bogotá: care trips 11.8 per cent of all trips; lowest-income women travel most for care; municipal mobility survey
  • C12-06 open Care mobility is roughly 15 to 30 per cent of all urban trips
  • C12-07 open Per-boarding fares penalise trip-chaining; hub-and-spoke routing fails suburb-to-suburb care trips; carers forced into cars or time poverty
  • C12-08 open A father who is primary carer shows the same trip-chaining pattern as a mother
  • C12-10 open 1992: City Women's Office established; 1998: Co-ordination Office for Planning and Construction Geared to the Requirements of Daily Life
  • C12-12 open Vienna's "4-R" method: Representation, Resources, Realia, Rights
  • C12-13 open 2013 Manual for Gender Mainstreaming in Urban Planning and Urban Development, Urban Development Vienna (MA 18), authored by Eva Kail and Elisabeth Irschik; requirement profiles …
  • C12-14 open More than 60 pilot projects over three decades
  • C12-15 open Frauen-Werk-Stadt I and II, late 1990s, architect Franziska Ullmann and others; 359 subsidised flats; kindergarten, medical centre and shops on site; courtyards visible from …
  • C12-16 open Aspern Seestadt: planned for 20,000 residents and 20,000 jobs by 2028; gender criteria in developer competitions; firms without pram storage, communal areas or safe lighting …
  • C12-19 open Einsiedlerpark, 5th district: fences opened on several sides, paths widened, lighting improved, hammocks, seating platforms, volleyball nets, badminton courts; girls' dwell time …
  • C12-20 open Binding gender-sensitive guidelines for all Vienna park designs since 2005
  • C12-21 open Clara Greed, Town Planning Review, 2016 (87(5), 505–524, on public toilets and menstruation) and 2021
  • C12-23 open Reasons for the longer service time: menstruation, pregnancy, clothing, accompanying dependants
  • C12-24 open Men's rooms of equal floor area hold more fixtures (urinals); queues grow non-linearly near capacity
  • C12-25 open Fixture ratios of 2:1 to 3.25:1 in women's favour needed for temporal equity
  • C12-26 open Desegregated cubicle rooms: women's waits fall in every simulated case; men's fall or rise slightly depending on urinals
  • C12-27 open User acceptance of gender-neutral toilets varies by culture
  • C12-28 open IPEN Adult study: 11,615 participants in 14 cities; dense, connected, well-served neighbourhoods associated with meeting 150 minutes a week of activity
  • C12-29 open Women's physical activity responds more to public transport quality, separated cycle lanes and proximity of destinations; men's to street connectivity and absence of dead ends
  • C12-30 open Women report consistently higher subjective fear in urban space at night; fear restricts mobility regardless of objective risk
  • C12-32 open Night-time crime did not fall more than daytime crime; "community pride" mechanism proposed
  • C12-33 open Paul Marchant, statistician, critiques 2004, 2005, 2013: spatial correlation (over-dispersion) and regression to the mean
  • C12-49 open Leslie Kern, feminist urban geographer, Feminist City: Claiming Space in a Man-Made World (2020, Verso): 15-minute city without anti-displacement policy gentrifies and pushes …
  • C12-50 open Berlin Baugruppen: residents form a legal entity, cut delivery cost 25 to 35 per cent against the market; shared kitchens, gardens, childcare spaces and guest rooms almost …
  • C12-54 open Credentials as given: Welsh and Farrington criminologists; Marchant statistician; Kern feminist urban geographer; Ullmann architect; Prinz-Brandenburg landscape architect; Kail …
  • C16-46 open Ravensbergen et al. 2023, Transport Policy: care trips 28 per cent of all trips in Montréal, 32 per cent of women's and 25 per cent of men's
  • C16-47 open Bovens and Marcoci 2020: toilet service time 178.9 seconds for women against 118.4 for men; fixture ratio 2:1 to 3.25:1 equalises the queue
  • C16-48 open Eva Kail's Vienna exhibition of 1991; Vienna counted the care loop before building for it
  • C16-50 open Proximity priced by the market becomes a luxury; carers commute in from the edge
  • C16-51 open Vienna satisfaction figure rests on a press release