THRIVING after the FALL
Book Two PAIRING after the FALL

The Log · PAIRING · Read the chapter

Chapter 1: The Grandmother Clause

58 claims, 18 to check first

C01-01 Check first open §Opening

Resident killer whales located in the "North Pacific"

To check against
AN-09 gives "North Pacific"; AN-01 names only the Center for Whale Research and Fisheries and Oceans Canada. No primary source named for the place
The verdict
OPEN
C01-02 Check first open §Opening

K16, a Southern Resident mother, bites Chinook salmon in half for her grown son, observed for years

To check against
AN-01; source given is a Facebook post by the Center for Whale Research. No primary source
The verdict
OPEN
C01-06 Check first open §Forty years

Menopause found in exactly five toothed whales: killer, short-finned pilot, false killer, beluga, narwhal; and in humans

To check against
AN-01; Ellis et al. 2018 Scientific Reports. Discrepancy: AN-01 also says Ellis 2024 compared "four with documented menopause and 14 without"
The verdict
OPEN
C01-09 Check first open §Forty years, §Numbers

Ellis et al. 2024: 18 whale species compared; menopausal species gained ~40 years of life ("live long"), reproductive spans not shortened, no increase in mother-daughter breeding overlap; same path as humans

To check against
AN-01; Ellis et al. 2024 Nature
The verdict
OPEN
C01-12 Check first open §Forty years

Croft et al. 2017: when mother and daughter co-breed, the older female's calf is 1.7 times as likely to die

To check against
AN-01; Croft et al. 2017 Current Biology. First name (Darren) not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C01-13 Check first open §Forty years, §Numbers

Nattrass et al. 2019: >40 years of census (Center for Whale Research, Fisheries and Oceans Canada), 378 grandcalves; grandmother death in previous 2 years raises calf mortality 4.5x, 6.7x if post-reproductive; controls for salmon; holds in Northern and Southern Residents

To check against
AN-01; Nattrass et al. 2019 PNAS. Discrepancy: AN-09 attributes 4.5/6.7 to Brent et al. 2015 and ties 6.7 to low-salmon years. First name (Stuart) from Preface, not documents
The verdict
OPEN
C01-14 Check first open §Forty years, §Case against, §Numbers

Foster et al. 2012: 589 whales, 297 deaths; death of post-reproductive mother raises mortality of sons over 30 by 13.9x (AN-01) or 8.3x (AN-06); daughters 5.4x

To check against
AN-01 and AN-06 disagree on the son figure; Foster et al. 2012 Science. Carried as a range. First name (Emma) from Preface, not documents
The verdict
OPEN
C01-19 Check first open §Memory

McComb et al. 2001, Amboseli: 21 families, matriarchs 27–67, modelled at 55 vs 35; old-led families bunch only for strangers; matriarch age predicts per-capita reproductive success

To check against
AN-02 gives 21 families; AN-06 gives 39. McComb et al. 2001 Science. First name (Karen) not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C01-24 Check first open §Memory

Hollister-Smith et al. 2007, Amboseli: 119 calves over 22 years, 89 sampled males; paternity peaks at 45–53; non-musth males sire ~20%

To check against
AN-02; Hollister-Smith et al. 2007 Animal Behaviour
The verdict
OPEN
C01-26 Check first open §Memory, §In practice

Pilanesberg, late 1990s: young males orphaned by Kruger culls killed >100 white rhinos; six older bulls introduced; musth in young males ended; Slotow et al. 2000 Nature, "Older bull elephants control young males"

To check against
AN-02; Slotow et al. 2000 Nature
The verdict
OPEN
C01-30 Check first open §Sisters

Wilson et al. 2014: 18 chimpanzee and 4 bonobo communities, 152 killings; killing does not track human disturbance

To check against
AN-03; Wilson et al. 2014 Nature
The verdict
OPEN
C01-33 Check first open §Sisters, §In practice, §Numbers

Surbeck et al. 2025: 30 years, six wild communities, 1,786 female-male conflicts; females won 61% (1,099); outranked 70% of males on average; 85% of coalitions target males; males won 39%; males held top rank in Ekalakala and Bompusa West with high-ranking mothers; "by no means the rule"

To check against
AN-03 gives Communications Biology; AN-06 gives Primates. First name (Martin) not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C01-42 Check first open §Ratio

Gowaty, Kim and Anderson 2012 replicated Bateman and found no evidence of sexual selection; lethal markers undercounted offspring

To check against
AN-05; Gowaty, Kim & Anderson 2012 PNAS
The verdict
OPEN
C01-43 Check first open §Ratio, §In practice

Janicke et al. 2016: 64–66 species, up to 102 effect sizes; sexual selection stronger on males on average with large variance; role-reversed in pipefish, jacanas, some bush crickets

To check against
AN-05; Janicke et al. 2016 Science Advances. Effect sizes stripped in the report and in the PDF text layer
The verdict
OPEN
C01-45 Check first open §Ratio, §In practice

Eberhart-Phillips et al. 2018: 6,119 shorebirds, six populations; snowy plover male juvenile survival 51% higher, adult population 63% male, males do all care, females desert; even-ratio populations share care

To check against
AN-05; Eberhart-Phillips et al. 2018 Nature Communications
The verdict
OPEN
C01-47 Check first open §Ratio

Lukas and Clutton-Brock 2013: 2,545 species; monogamy evolved 61 times (AN-04) or 60 (AN-05), always from solitary intolerant females; paternal care in 127 of 226 (AN-04) or 229 (AN-05) monogamous species

To check against
AN-04 and AN-05 disagree; Lukas & Clutton-Brock 2013 Science
The verdict
OPEN
C01-49 Check first open §Ratio

Janssen et al. 2000: 468 people aged 18–88, whole-body MRI; skeletal muscle 33.0 vs 21.0 kg; 38.4% vs 30.6% of body mass; gap 40% upper body, 33% lower

To check against
AN-05; Janssen et al. 2000 Journal of Applied Physiology
The verdict
OPEN
C01-51 Check first open §Who moves, §In practice

Strandburg-Peshkin et al. 2015: Kenya, 25 olive baboons collared (80% of adults and subadults), 1 Hz; following tracks number of initiators not rank; compromise under ~90 degrees, choice above

To check against
AN-09; Strandburg-Peshkin et al. 2015 Science
The verdict
OPEN
C01-03 open §Opening, §Forty years

Female killer whales stop breeding at about 39–40 and live past 80–90; males rarely past 30

To check against
AN-01 (39–40, 80–90+); AN-06 ("30s/40s", "into their 90s", males "rarely past 30"). Primary: Ellis et al. 2024 Nature; AN-06 "rarely past 30" sits oddly beside Foster's sons-over-30 cohort
The verdict
OPEN
C01-04 open §Opening, §Forty years

Post-reproductive females lead collective movement, most in low-Chinook years

To check against
AN-01; Brent et al. 2015 Current Biology
The verdict
OPEN
C01-05 open §Forty years

Williams 1957 and Hamilton 1966 set out the theory that selection cannot favour post-reproductive life

To check against
AN-01; Williams 1957 Evolution, Hamilton 1966 J Theor Biol (journals not given in AN-01)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-07 open §Forty years, §Case against

Chimpanzees and elephants help kin but have no true menopause

To check against
AN-01 (Cohen 2004, Levitis, boundary cases). No single primary named
The verdict
OPEN
C01-08 open §Forty years

Ellis et al. 2018 read ovarian scars across 72 cetacean species

To check against
AN-01; Ellis et al. 2018 Scientific Reports
The verdict
OPEN
C01-10 open §Forty years

Resident killer whales: both sexes stay in natal pod for life, mate outside it

To check against
AN-01 (bisexual philopatry, extra-group mating). Primary: Johnstone & Cant 2010
The verdict
OPEN
C01-11 open §Forty years

Johnstone and Cant 2010 "kinship dynamics" models: female relatedness to group rises with age

To check against
AN-01 gives Proc R Soc B; AN-06 gives PNAS. First names (Rupert, Michael) not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C01-15 open §Forty years

Weiss et al. 2023: 40 Southern Resident females; each surviving son roughly halves annual probability of a viable calf; no attenuation with son's age

To check against
AN-01; Weiss et al. 2023 Current Biology. First name (Michael) not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C01-16 open §Forty years

Grimes et al. 2023: males with living post-reproductive mothers carry fewer tooth-rake marks

To check against
AN-01; Grimes et al. 2023 Current Biology
The verdict
OPEN
C01-17 open §Forty years

Brent et al. 2015: observation time "thousands of hours" (AN-01) vs "more than 750 hours of video" (AN-06); AN-09 gives Brent 2015 a sample of 589 whales (Foster's N)

To check against
AN-01, AN-06, AN-09; Brent et al. 2015 Current Biology. First name (Lauren) not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C01-18 open §Forty years, §Case against, §In practice

Ward et al. 2009: in a Chinook collapse year the probability of any female calving halves

To check against
AN-01; Ward et al. 2009 J Applied Ecology. First name (Eric) not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C01-20 open §Memory

McComb et al. 2011: 39 families, lion roars (one vs three, male vs female); older matriarchs respond more accurately and faster

To check against
AN-02; McComb et al. 2011 Proc R Soc B
The verdict
OPEN
C01-21 open §Memory

Elephant families that lost elders to poaching still bred less a decade later: 218 adult females, 109 groups

To check against
AN-06 attributes jointly to Gobush et al. 2008 (PNAS) and Goldenberg et al. 2016 (Current Biology); which paper carries which figure is not stated
The verdict
OPEN
C01-22 open §Memory

Young male elephants leave the natal herd between 10 and 15

To check against
AN-02; no primary named
The verdict
OPEN
C01-23 open §Memory

Musth: testosterone rises from ~2 ng/ml to 20–40; median days in musth per year 2 (16–25), 13 (26–35), 81 (46–50), 54 (51–60)

To check against
AN-02; Poole 1987, Poole 1989 (journal given as Behaviour and Animal Behaviour in AN-02)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-25 open §Memory, §In practice

Musth and stress: 60 wild bulls in Kaziranga show no cortisol rise (Ghosal et al. 2013 PLoS ONE); four captive bulls do (Ganswindt et al.)

To check against
AN-02; Ganswindt year given as 2010 and 2021 in AN-02, four bulls aged 12–54
The verdict
OPEN
C01-27 open §Sisters

Chimpanzees and bonobos split 1–2 million years ago; separated by the Congo River

To check against
AN-03 (1–2 million years); AN-06 (Congo River). No primary named
The verdict
OPEN
C01-28 open §Sisters

Body-mass ratios: chimpanzee 42.7/33.7 kg = 1.27; bonobo 1.36; gorilla 2.24

To check against
AN-03; Smith & Jungers 1997, Plavcan 2001
The verdict
OPEN
C01-29 open §Sisters

Wrangham 1999 imbalance-of-power hypothesis; typical raiding advantage 8:1

To check against
AN-03; Wrangham 1999 American Journal of Physical Anthropology. First name (Richard) not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C01-31 open §Sisters

R. Brian Ferguson (anthropologist) and John Horgan (science writer) argue the killings are a human artefact

To check against
AN-03; no primary named
The verdict
OPEN
C01-32 open §Sisters, §In practice

Mountain gorilla infanticide by incoming males: up to 21% of infant deaths over 40 years

To check against
AN-03; Robbins et al. 2013 PLoS One
The verdict
OPEN
C01-34 open §Sisters

Bonobo females disperse at maturity; adult females of a community are unrelated immigrants

To check against
AN-03; no primary named
The verdict
OPEN
C01-35 open §Sisters, §Case against

GG-rubbing raises urinary oxytocin in female bonobos more than mating does; most often in tense feeding contexts

To check against
AN-03; Moscovice et al. 2019 Hormones and Behavior
The verdict
OPEN
C01-36 open §Sisters

Male bonobo rank depends on his mother's rank; mothers escort sons

To check against
AN-03; no single primary named (Surbeck, Furuichi)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-37 open §Sisters

Ardipithecus ramidus, 4.4 million years, canine dimorphism ratio 1.06–1.13, smaller than bonobo's

To check against
AN-03; Suwa, Lovejoy et al. 2021 PNAS
The verdict
OPEN
C01-38 open §Sisters

Spotted hyena: females outrank males; pseudo-penis birth kills ~60% of first litters; 27 years of clan records

To check against
AN-06; Holekamp & Strauss 2022 PNAS, Strauss & Holekamp 2019 PNAS (27 years attached to 2019 in AN-06)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-39 open §Sisters, §In practice

Kappeler 2022: 253 populations, 121 primate species; adult sex ratio best predicts female dominance

To check against
AN-06; Kappeler et al. 2022 Biological Reviews
The verdict
OPEN
C01-40 open §Ratio

Bateman 1948 fruit-fly experiment and its two principles as stated

To check against
AN-05; Bateman 1948 Heredity. First name (Angus) not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C01-44 open §Ratio

Kokko and Jennions 2008: Fisher condition, adult sex ratio drives sex roles, Concorde fallacy

To check against
AN-05; Kokko & Jennions 2008 J Evolutionary Biology
The verdict
OPEN
C01-46 open §Ratio

Social monogamy in ~9% of mammal species vs ~90% of birds

To check against
AN-04; no primary named (Lukas & Clutton-Brock 2013 likely)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-48 open §Ratio

Men 15–20% heavier and 7–8% taller than women on average

To check against
AN-05; no primary named
The verdict
OPEN
C01-50 open §Ratio

Kaplan et al. 2000 embodied-capital argument; Hawkes 2003 grandmother hypothesis

To check against
AN-05; Kaplan et al. 2000 Evolutionary Anthropology, Hawkes 2003
The verdict
OPEN
C01-52 open §Who moves, §In practice

Walker et al. 2017: Botswana wild dogs, 34 rallies; ~3 sneezes launch if dominant initiates, ~10 if subordinate

To check against
AN-09; Walker et al. 2017 Proc R Soc B
The verdict
OPEN
C01-53 open §Who moves, §Case against, §In practice

Smith et al. 2016: 8 mammal societies (elephant, dolphin, chimpanzee, lion, meerkat, zebra, hyena, capuchin) and 8 small-scale human societies (Ache to Tsimane); human leadership domain-specific, non-coercive, food sharing by rule; conflict leadership concentrated in both

To check against
AN-09; Smith et al. 2016 Trends in Ecology and Evolution
The verdict
OPEN
C01-54 open §Case against, §Numbers

Møller and Jennions 2002: 43 meta-analyses; biological factors explain 2.51–5.42% of variance

To check against
AN-09; Møller & Jennions 2002 Oecologia
The verdict
OPEN
C01-55 open §Case against

McCormack, Arbuckle and Nichols 2023: 25 long-finned pilot whale pods off Cape Breton; no reproductive conflict, no menopause; same philopatry as short-finned

To check against
AN-01; McCormack et al. 2023 Behavioral Ecology
The verdict
OPEN
C01-56 open §Case against

Cohen 2004 and Levitis: post-reproductive lifespan as epiphenomenon; measure depends on method

To check against
AN-01; Cohen 2004, Levitis (year not given)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-57 open §Memory

Amboseli playback used a loudspeaker and contact calls of known vs unknown females

To check against
AN-02; McComb et al. 2001 Science
The verdict
OPEN
C01-58 open §Memory

Older bulls carry an acoustic or chemical signal that suppresses musth in young males

To check against
AN-02 (interpretation attached to Slotow 2000); no primary for mechanism
The verdict
OPEN