PAIRING · Part I · Overlapping Bells
The numbers and sources
Chapter 4: Overlapping Bells
The narrated edition tells this chapter with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.
- 89 open
- 21 to check first
Numbers to carry
The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.
- d = 0.20 means 92 per cent shared area and a 56 per cent chance the random draw goes the expected way. d = 0.80 still means 69 per cent shared. Height is d = 2.6 and 19 per cent shared. (BI-11 conversion table, McGraw and Wong 1992, Cohen 1988, Nelson 2012 for height.) Rows C04-06, C04-07.
- Men's cortisol response to the Trier test is 1.5 to 2 times women's on average, and luteal-phase women match men. (Kudielka and Kirschbaum 2005, Kirschbaum 1999, PS-04.) Rows C04-03, C04-05.
- Women 16,215 words a day, men 15,669, range 500 to 47,000, 396 students. (Mehl et al. 2007, Science, PS-03.) Row C04-27.
- Autism male-to-female odds ratio 3.25, 95 per cent CI 2.93 to 3.62, from 54 studies and 13,784,284 people. (Loomes, Hull and Mandy 2017, PS-08.) Row C04-56.
- Joel: 1 to 6 per cent of brains internally consistent. Chekroud: 93 per cent classified correctly from 1,166 scans. (Joel 2015 PNAS, Chekroud 2016 PNAS, BI-11 and PS-08.) Rows C04-70, C04-73.
Every figure
One row for each figure or finding in the data edition's chapter, whether or not the narrated edition kept it. Layer says whether it belongs to physiology, behaviour or culture. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.
| Figure | What it measures | Study (authors, year, venue, N) | Document | Row | Layer | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 minutes preparation, speech to a blank panel, counting backwards in steps of 17, cotton roll for saliva | The Trier Social Stress Test protocol | Kirschbaum, Pirke and Hellhammer 1993, Neuropsychobiology | PS-04 | C04-01 | physiology | robust |
| Cortisol 2 to 4 times resting level in 70 to 80 per cent of participants, within about 20 minutes | Cortisol response to the Trier test | PS-04 summary, no single primary for the 70 to 80 per cent | PS-04 | C04-02 | physiology | open |
| Men's cortisol response 1.5 to 2 times women's | Sex difference in the Trier cortisol response | Kudielka and Kirschbaum 2005, Biological Psychology (review) | PS-04 | C04-03, C04-04 | physiology | robust |
| Luteal-phase women match men. follicular phase and pill users blunted | Cycle phase and the cortisol response | Kirschbaum et al. 1999, Psychosomatic Medicine | PS-04 | C04-05 | physiology | robust |
| d = 0.20: 92 per cent shared area, 56 per cent probability of superiority | Conversion of effect size to overlap | McGraw and Wong 1992, Psychological Bulletin, and Cohen 1988 | BI-11 | C04-06 | behaviour | robust |
| d = 0.50: 80 per cent shared, 64 per cent | Conversion table | as above | BI-11 | C04-06 | behaviour | robust |
| d = 0.80: 69 per cent shared, 71 per cent | Conversion table | as above | BI-11 | C04-06 | behaviour | robust |
| d = 1.00: 62 per cent shared, 76 per cent | Conversion table | as above | BI-11 | C04-06 | behaviour | robust |
| Height d = 2.6, 19 per cent shared, 96 per cent probability of superiority | Sex difference in adult height as the categorical comparison | Nelson 2012 per PS-05. BI-11 table row for d = 2.61 | PS-05, BI-11 | C04-07 | physiology | robust |
| 26 cultures, N = 23,031, neuroticism d = −0.51 (US sample), agreeableness −0.59 | Big Five personality, self-report | Costa, Terracciano and McCrae 2001, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology | PS-01 | C04-09 | behaviour | robust |
| 55 nations, N = 17,637, neuroticism −0.40, agreeableness −0.15 | Big Five personality, self-report | Schmitt, Realo, Voracek and Allik 2008, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology | PS-01 | C04-10, C04-82 | behaviour | robust |
| N = 320,128, neuroticism −0.40, agreeableness −0.58 | Big Five personality, self-report, US public sample | Kajonius and Johnson 2018 | PS-01 | C04-11 | behaviour | robust |
| About 80 per cent shared area at the personality effect sizes | Narrator's reading of the conversion table | BI-11 table | BI-11 | C04-06 | behaviour | robust |
| Warmth and gregariousness higher in women, assertiveness and excitement-seeking higher in men, cancelling at domain level | Extraversion facets | Costa et al. 2001 | PS-01 | C04-12 | behaviour | robust |
| HEXACO emotionality d about −1.0, 62 per cent shared area | Six-factor personality model | No primary author named in the document | PS-01 | C04-13 | behaviour | open |
| 47 inventories, N = 503,188. things against people d = 0.93 (Preface). realistic 0.84, social −0.68, enterprising 0.04 | Vocational interests | Su, Rounds and Armstrong 2009, Psychological Bulletin | PS-01 | C04-14 | behaviour | robust |
| Interests gap in the same direction in every country surveyed | Cross-cultural interests | Lippa 2010 per PS-01 | PS-01 | C04-15 | behaviour | robust |
| 35 dimensions, ages 3 months to 13 years. inhibitory control −0.41, activity level 0.33, negative affectivity negligible | Temperament in children | Else-Quest, Hyde, Goldsmith and Van Hulle 2006, Psychological Bulletin | PS-01 | C04-16 | behaviour | robust |
| 741 effect sizes. reward sensitivity 0.01, punishment sensitivity −0.33 | Sensitivity to reward and punishment | Cross, Copping and Campbell 2011, Psychological Bulletin | PS-01 | C04-17, C04-87 | behaviour | robust |
| Mental rotation d = 0.73. BI-07 range up to 1.0. Preface 0.57 | Spatial ability | Voyer, Voyer and Bryden 1995, Psychological Bulletin | BI-11, BI-07 | C04-18 | behaviour | contested |
| At d = 0.73: probability of superiority about 70 per cent, about 23 per cent of women above the median man | Conversion of the mental rotation gap | BI-11 worked example | BI-11 | C04-19 | behaviour | robust |
| 555 effect sizes, 166 studies, N = 21,709. positive emotion g = −0.08, internalising −0.10, externalising 0.09. gaps vanish alone or with parents, grow with unfamiliar adults and peers | Children's emotional expression | Chaplin and Aldao 2013, Psychological Bulletin | PS-02 | C04-20 | behaviour | robust |
| Self-report empathy gap vanishes under skin conductance and facial electromyography | Empathy by method of measurement | Eisenberg and Lennon 1983, Psychological Bulletin | PS-02 | C04-21 | behaviour | robust |
| Payment for accuracy erases the empathic-accuracy gap | Empathic accuracy under incentive | Klein and Hodges 2001, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin | PS-02 | C04-22 | behaviour | robust |
| 42 samples, N = 4,290, Reading the Mind in the Eyes g = 0.177 | Emotion recognition from eyes | Kirkland et al. 2013, North American Journal of Psychology | PS-02 | C04-23 | behaviour | robust |
| N = 312,739, 57 countries, female advantage in all | Reading the Mind in the Eyes, cross-cultural | Greenberg et al. 2022, PNAS, per document | PS-02 | C04-24 | behaviour | robust |
| More than 90 per cent shared area at g about 0.18 | Narrator's conversion | BI-11 table | BI-11 | C04-89 | behaviour | robust |
| 120 studies, N = 88,721, d = 0.22 overall, 0.49 on externally oriented thinking | Alexithymia | 2023 meta-analysis, primary authors not named in the document | PS-02 | C04-25 | behaviour | open |
| 20,000 words a day for women against 7,000 for men | The talkativeness myth | Brizendine 2006 as origin, per document | PS-03 | C04-26 | culture | fallen |
| 396 students, 30 seconds of sound every 12.5 minutes. women 16,215 words a day, men 15,669. range about 500 to 47,000 | Words spoken per day, recorded | Mehl, Vazire, Ramírez-Esparza, Slatcher and Pennebaker 2007, Science | PS-03 | C04-27, C04-28 | behaviour | robust |
| 73 studies, men slightly more talkative, d = −0.14 | Talkativeness | Leaper and Ayres 2007, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin | PS-03 | C04-29 | behaviour | robust |
| 43 studies, intrusive interruptions d = 0.33, men more | Interruption | Anderson and Leaper 1998, Sex Roles | PS-03 | C04-30 | behaviour | robust |
| 96 per cent of interruptions by men | Interruption, small early sample | Zimmerman and West 1975 | PS-03 | C04-31 | behaviour | fallen |
| More than 85 per cent shared area for the talk gaps | Narrator's conversion | BI-11 table | BI-11 | C04-89 | behaviour | robust |
| 448 effects, 162 reports, smiling d = 0.41, gap vanishes when men and women hold the same social role | Smiling | LaFrance, Hecht and Paluck 2003, Psychological Bulletin | PS-03 | C04-32 | culture | robust |
| 14 imaging studies, 377 men and 442 women, lateralisation d = 0.21, CI −0.05 to 0.48 | Language lateralisation in the brain | Sommer, Aleman, Bouma and Kahn 2004, Brain | PS-03 | C04-33 | physiology | robust |
| Flooding above about 100 beats a minute, recovery 20 to 30 minutes | Physiological flooding in couple conflict | Gottman 1994 | PS-02, PS-03 | C04-34 | physiology | robust |
| 85 per cent of stonewallers are men | Stonewalling by sex | Blog source only (connectedcouples.app), no primary | PS-02, PS-03 | C04-35 | behaviour | open |
| 74 studies, N = 14,255. demand-withdraw reverses when the husband seeks the change | Demand-withdraw pattern | Schrodt, Witt and Shimkowski 2014 | PS-03 | C04-36 | behaviour | robust |
| N = 50. men's cortisol rises to an achievement task, women's to social rejection | Stressor type by sex | Stroud, Salovey and Epel 2002, Biological Psychiatry | PS-04 | C04-37 | physiology | robust |
| Partner's verbal support lowers men's cortisol and tends to raise women's | Partner support before the Trier test | Kirschbaum, Klauer, Filipp and Hellhammer 1995, Psychosomatic Medicine | PS-04 | C04-38, C04-39 | physiology | robust |
| 67 women. 10-minute neck and shoulder massage lowers cortisol and heart rate, verbal support does not | Physical against verbal partner support | Ditzen et al. 2007, Psychoneuroendocrinology | PS-04 | C04-40 | physiology | robust |
| 47 couples, N = 94. intranasal oxytocin increases positive communication and lowers cortisol | Oxytocin in couple conflict | Ditzen et al. 2009, Biological Psychiatry | PS-02, PS-04 | C04-41 | physiology | robust |
| Oxytocin lowers salivary alpha-amylase in women and raises it in men | Oxytocin and the sympathetic marker | Ditzen et al. 2013, Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience | PS-02 | C04-42 | physiology | robust |
| More than 3.5 million people, 90 nations. depression odds ratio 1.95, symptoms d = 0.27. age 12 OR 2.37, ages 13 to 15 OR 3.02. larger in more gender-equal nations | Depression by sex | Salk, Hyde and Abramson 2017, Psychological Bulletin | PS-04 | C04-43 | behaviour | robust |
| More than 85 per cent shared area at d = 0.27 | Narrator's conversion | BI-11 table | BI-11 | C04-89 | behaviour | robust |
| N = 5,692. male-typed symptoms 26.3 per cent men against 21.9 women. combined scale 30.6 against 33.3, p = .57 | Male-typed depression symptoms | Martin, Neighbors and Griffith 2013, JAMA Psychiatry. Regier critique | PS-04 | C04-44 | behaviour | contested |
| Men die by suicide at 3 to 4 times the rate of women | Suicide by sex | No primary source named | PS-04 | C04-45 | behaviour | open |
| 150 studies. men riskier in 14 of 16 categories. financial risk d about 0.43, social −0.02. gap shrinking over time | Risk-taking | Byrnes, Miller and Schafer 1999, Psychological Bulletin | PS-05 | C04-46 | behaviour | robust |
| 80 participants. equal performance. 73 per cent of men against 35 per cent of women choose the tournament. men overconfident | Choice to compete | Niederle and Vesterlund 2007, Quarterly Journal of Economics. Gillen et al. 2019 critique | PS-01, PS-05 | C04-47 | behaviour | robust |
| Maasai: 50 per cent of men and 26 per cent of women compete. Khasi: 54 per cent of women and 39 per cent of men | Competition choice by kinship system | Gneezy, Leonard and List 2009, Econometrica | OR-03 (OR-PS sheet) | C04-48 | culture | robust |
| N = 97,678. women's participation falls 25.5 per cent under competition outside STEM. no gap within STEM | Competition in working-age adults | Saccardo, Pietrasz and Gneezy 2022 | PS-05 | C04-49 | behaviour | robust |
| 33 studies, N = 8,538, r = −0.061 | Dual-hormone hypothesis, testosterone by cortisol on status behaviour | Geniole et al. 2016 per PS-05. Dekkers et al. 2019, Psychoneuroendocrinology, per BI-11 | PS-05, BI-11 | C04-50 | physiology | contested |
| 211 studies, N = 621,463. sexual motivation g = 0.69, CI 0.58 to 0.81, 0.54 after correction. about three quarters shared area | Sex drive | Frankenbach, Weber, Loschelder, Kilger and Friese 2022, Psychological Bulletin | PS-06 | C04-51, C04-89 | behaviour | robust |
| Orgasm above 90 per cent for men against 35 to 65 per cent for women in partnered sex | Experience of partnered sex as explanation of the desire gap | Conley and Yang 2024, Psychological Bulletin. Frankenbach reply 2024 | PS-06 | C04-52 | culture | contested |
| N = 1,865. women's desire declines with relationship duration, men's stable | Desire over relationship duration | Klusmann 2002, Archives of Sexual Behavior | PS-06 | C04-53 | behaviour | robust |
| Satisfaction rises with frequency up to about once a week | Sexual frequency and wellbeing | Muise, Schimmack and Impett 2016 | PS-06 | C04-54 | behaviour | robust |
| 113 samples, N = 66,132. men more avoidant and less anxious. multivariate D = 0.28 in community samples (about 78 per cent overlap), 0.12 in college samples | Adult attachment | Del Giudice 2011, Psychological Bulletin | PS-07 | C04-55 | behaviour | robust |
| Historical autism ratio 4 or 5 boys to 1 girl | Autism diagnosis by sex, historical | Per PS-08 | PS-08 | C04-56 | culture | fallen |
| 54 studies, N = 13,784,284. male-to-female odds ratio 3.25, CI 2.93 to 3.62, in active-ascertainment studies | Autism prevalence by sex | Loomes, Hull and Mandy 2017, Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry | PS-08 | C04-56 | physiology | robust |
| About 2 to 1 with intellectual disability. 6 to 1 up to 10 to 1 without | Autism ratio by intellectual disability | No single primary named | PS-08 | C04-57 | physiology | open |
| Cumulative ratio about 1.2 to 1 by age 20 | Autism diagnosis ratio, Swedish register | 2024 Swedish register study, BMJ, authors not named | PS-08 | C04-58 | culture | open |
| 1,211 autistic adults. 31.7 per cent of women against 16.7 per cent of men given a wrong psychiatric diagnosis first | Misdiagnosis before autism diagnosis | Kentrou et al. 2019 or 2021 (year inconsistent in document) | PS-08 | C04-59, C04-85 | culture | robust |
| 27,122 autistic Swedes. suicide the leading cause of premature death without intellectual disability, about 9 times the population rate | Mortality in autism | Hirvikoski et al. 2016, Lancet Psychiatry | PS-08 | C04-60 | behaviour | robust |
| Siblings of 1,707 autistic girls have higher autism recurrence than siblings of 6,270 autistic boys | Female protective effect, familial recurrence | Wigdor et al. 2022, Cell Genomics, iPSYCH cohort | PS-08 | C04-62 | physiology | robust |
| Copy-number variants in autistic girls carry a median of 10 to 15 genes against 2 to 3 in boys | Female protective effect, genetic load | Jacquemont et al. 2014, American Journal of Human Genetics | PS-08 | C04-63 | physiology | robust |
| UK Biobank N = 5,216 (2,750 women, 2,466 men), ages 44 to 77. total brain volume d = −1.41 (men larger). variance ratio 0.82 | Brain volume and its variance by sex | Ritchie et al. 2018, Cerebral Cortex | BI-07, BI-11 | C04-64 | physiology | robust |
| Cognitive variance ratio 1.08 to 1.20 | Greater male variability in cognition | No single primary named | BI-11 | C04-65 | behaviour | open |
| 220 species, no greater male variability in animal personality | Greater male variability, comparative | Harrison et al. 2022, Biological Reviews. Del Giudice and Gangestad 2023 reply not used | BI-11 | C04-66 | physiology | contested |
| Sex explains under 1 per cent of brain structural variance after total size is removed | Brain structure by sex | Eliot et al. 2021, Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews | BI-07, PS-08 | C04-67, C04-68 | physiology | contested |
| Regional differences survive size correction at small to moderate size, mainly limbic | Brain structure by sex | DeCasien et al. 2022, Human Brain Mapping | BI-07 | C04-69 | physiology | contested |
| More than 1,400 scans. 1 to 6 per cent of brains internally consistent (BI-11), 0 to 8 (PS-08), under 8 (BI-07). brains do not belong to one of two distinct categories | The brain mosaic | Joel et al. 2015, PNAS | BI-11, BI-07, PS-08 | C04-70, C04-71, C04-72 | physiology | contested |
| 93 per cent correct classification of 1,166 people from brain structure | Classifier accuracy for sex | Chekroud et al. 2016, PNAS (one of three replies to Joel) | PS-08, BI-07 | C04-73 | physiology | robust |
| Joel's method calls non-overlapping monkey faces mosaics too | Critique of the mosaic method | Del Giudice et al. 2016, PNAS | BI-07, BI-11 | C04-74 | behaviour | contested |
| N = 10,261. warmth d = −0.50, dominance 0.27, emotional stability 0.32. multivariate D = 2.71 (10 per cent overlap). D = 1.71 without sensitivity (24 per cent) | Whole-personality distance between the sexes | Del Giudice, Booth and Irwing 2012, PLOS One | BI-11 | C04-75 | behaviour | contested |
| N = 31,637. D = 2.06 (Preface). 2019 in BI-07, 2020 in BI-11 | Replication of the multivariate distance | Kaiser et al. 2019 or 2020 | BI-07, BI-11 | C04-76 | behaviour | contested |
| d = 0.93 gives a seven-in-ten bet | Narrator's interpolation from the conversion table | BI-11 table (0.80 gives 71 per cent, 1.00 gives 76) | BI-11 | C04-88 | behaviour | robust |
| Classifier accuracy 60 to 70 per cent after total-volume correction. 87 to 92 per cent in volume-matched deep-learning studies | Whether classifiers read organisation or size | Primary authors not named in the document | BI-07 | C04-77 | physiology | contested |
| Social role theory | Division of labour produces expectations, expectations produce self-reports | Eagly and Wood 1999 | PS-01, PS-05 | C04-78 | culture | robust |
| About 300,000 pupils. science choice gap tracks stereotype strength | Stereotypes and the gender-equality paradox | Breda et al. 2020, PNAS | BI-07 | C04-79 | culture | contested |
| Gender-equality paradox thins or vanishes when countries are grouped by region | Simpson's paradox reading | Breda et al. 2024, PNAS | BI-11 | C04-80 | culture | contested |
| Gender-equality paradox: larger sex differences in richer, more equal countries | The paradox itself | Stoet and Geary 2018, Psychological Science | BI-07, BI-11 | C04-81 | culture | contested |
| Losing a competition reduces women's subsequent effort more than men's | Response to losing | Buser 2016 | PS-05 | C04-83 | behaviour | robust |
| Opt-out framing erases the competition gap | Entry rule for tournaments | Flory et al. 2015 | OR-03 (OR-PS sheet) | C04-84 | culture | robust |
| Autistic burnout | Collapse after sustained masking | Raymaker et al. 2020, Autism in Adulthood | PS-08 | C04-61 | behaviour | robust |
| Hyde's latent-factor critique of the multivariate D | Critique of Del Giudice 2012 | Hyde 2014 reply, per documents | BI-07, BI-11 | C04-86 | behaviour | contested |
| Physical aggression d about 0.45 | Named in the narrated edition among the large differences. the figure is in the the data edition Preface, not in chapter 4 | Preface, the data edition, section Overlapping bells | Preface rows | Preface | behaviour | robust |
The case for and the case against
The case the chapter makes
- Most psychological sex differences are small and the two distributions mostly overlap: Hyde 2005. Zell et al. 2015 (Preface rows). the conversion table (C04-06).
- At the typical effect size a random woman outscores a random man on a male-typical trait close to half the time: McGraw and Wong 1992 via BI-11 (C04-06).
- A few differences are large: interests, things against people (Su, Rounds and Armstrong 2009, C04-14). mental rotation (Voyer et al. 1995, C04-18). physical aggression (Preface).
- The interests gap runs in the same direction in every country surveyed (Lippa 2010 per PS-01, C04-15), and the personality differences in the same direction across 55 nations (Schmitt et al. 2008, C04-82).
- Temperament differs before culture can have fitted it: inhibitory control and activity level from three months (Else-Quest et al. 2006, C04-16).
- Differences measured by asking are larger than differences measured by watching or by instrument: Chaplin and Aldao 2013 (C04-20), Eisenberg and Lennon 1983 (C04-21), Klein and Hodges 2001 (C04-22), LaFrance et al. 2003 (C04-32), Mehl et al. 2007 against the myth (C04-26, C04-27).
- The body speaks clearly on cortisol: men's larger response (Kudielka and Kirschbaum 2005, C04-03), cycle phase (Kirschbaum 1999, C04-05), stressor type (Stroud 2002, C04-37), the partner-support paradox (Kirschbaum 1995, C04-38. Ditzen 2007, C04-40), oxytocin's opposite directions (Ditzen 2009 and 2013, C04-41, C04-42).
- The sexes are similar trait by trait and distinct in combination: Del Giudice, Booth and Irwing 2012 (C04-75). Chekroud et al. 2016 (C04-73). Del Giudice et al. 2016 (C04-74).
- Joel and Chekroud answer different questions and both answer correctly: Joel 2015 (C04-70), Chekroud 2016 (C04-73).
- An average is a fact about a population and never a rule for the person across the table: the conversion table (C04-06).
The case against
- The drift itself argues that the questionnaire gaps are culture: Eisenberg and Lennon 1983 (C04-21), Klein and Hodges 2001 (C04-22), Chaplin and Aldao 2013 (C04-20), LaFrance 2003 (C04-32), Sommer 2004 with its interval through zero (C04-33).
- Social role theory: the division of labour produces the expectations, the expectations the self-reports: Eagly and Wood 1999 (C04-78).
- The Khasi reversal as a field experiment on competition: Gneezy, Leonard and List 2009 (C04-48).
- The largest gap, interests, tracks stereotype strength: Breda et al. 2020 (C04-79). the gender-equality paradox as Simpson's paradox: Breda et al. 2024 (C04-80) against Stoet and Geary 2018 (C04-81).
- Desire tracks experience: orgasm, pain and threat differ by sex and the desire gap would close if they were equalised: Conley and Yang 2024 (C04-52) against Frankenbach 2022 (C04-51). Dropped from the the narrated edition case against, kept here.
- Brains: 1 to 6 per cent internally consistent (Joel 2015, C04-70). under 1 per cent of structural variance after size (Eliot 2021, C04-67). classifiers at 60 to 70 per cent once volume is controlled (C04-77).
Where the sources disagree
The data edition's Contested list:
- Mental rotation d: 0.57 (Preface and style sheet), 0.73 (Voyer 1995 per BI-11), up to 1.0 (BI-07, figure stripped). C04-18.
- Whether Del Giudice's multivariate distance survives without latent-factor correction (Hyde's critique, C04-86) and what Kaiser's replication value is (C04-76).
- Whether the classifiers read organisation or size: 60 to 70 per cent after volume correction against 87 to 92 per cent volume-matched. C04-77.
- Gottman's 85 per cent of stonewallers, blog-sourced. C04-35.
- The gender-equality paradox: Stoet and Geary 2018 against Breda 2020 and 2024. C04-79 to C04-81.
- Whether Martin 2013 measures male depression or something else (Regier). C04-44.
- The dual-hormone meta-analysis attribution, Geniole 2016 against Dekkers 2019. C04-50.
Report-to-report discrepancies from the data edition's working notes:
- Kirkland 2013 RMET: the prompt it was written from said d = 0.47 and g = 0.177 both appear. the PS-02 PDF (pages 6 and 9) gives g = 0.177 twice and no 0.47. Used 0.177. C04-23.
- Mental rotation: 0.57 (Preface), 0.73 (BI-11), up to 1.0 (BI-07). Carried as a range in the data edition, carried without a figure in the narrated edition. C04-18.
- Dual-hormone meta-analysis: Geniole 2016 (PS-05, r = −0.061, p = 0.026, 30 papers, 33 studies, N = 8,538) against Dekkers 2019 (BI-11, OR-02, same N and study count). C04-50.
- Joel 2015 internally consistent brains: 1 to 6 per cent (BI-11), 0 to 8 per cent (PS-08), less than 8 per cent (BI-07). The data edition carried 1 to 6 with 8 as ceiling. C04-70.
- Kaiser replication: 2019 in BI-07, 2020 in BI-11. D = 2.06 in the Preface, "2.06 to 2.71" in the BI-07 table, stripped in the BI-07 text, absent in BI-11. C04-76.
- Male brain volume: 8 to 13 per cent larger (BI-07) against 10 to 15 per cent (BI-11). Not used in the chapter text. C04-64.
- Chekroud accuracy: 93 per cent of 1,166 (PS-08) against "69 to 93 per cent" for classifiers generally (BI-11). C04-73.
- Eagly and Johnson 1990: 161 studies (PS-03) against 162 (PS-05). Not used in text.
- Overlap at d = 0.5: 80 per cent shared area (BI-11 table), 67 per cent (PS-05), average woman above 69 per cent of men (PS-01, which is U3, a different statistic). The data edition uses the BI-11 table. C04-06.
- Ditzen 2009: N = 94 in the PS-02 PDF and PS-04, consistent. C04-41.
- Gottman 85 per cent of stonewallers and 94 per cent prediction: blog-sourced in PS-02 and PS-03. C04-35.
- Kentrou: year given as 2019 and 2021 in PS-08. C04-59.
- Ritchie 2018: BI-11 gives mean age 61.7, BI-07 gives the age range 44 to 77. C04-64.
- Figures stripped from the text files and recovered from the PDFs: Chaplin and Aldao N and g values, Kirkland N and g, Ditzen 2009 N, Else-Quest temperament d values, Costa, Schmitt and Kajonius d values and Ns, HEXACO d values, Cross 2011 d values, Frankenbach g values, Oliver and Hyde and Petersen and Hyde d values, Geniole r and p, Byrnes financial and social d, Saccardo N, Voyer 1995 three d values, Del Giudice 2012 univariate d values and D = 1.71, rumination k and N, alexithymia N and d values, height d = 2.6, variance ratio range.
- Figures not found in the PDFs either: Del Giudice's Mahalanobis D for brain structure (BI-11 text says "approximately [ ] to [ ]", roughly 24 per cent overlap, page not rendered), Kaiser's D, Archer 2005 testosterone-aggression r, the BI-07 mental-rotation upper bound and its "some international samples" interests figure, the raloxifene Hedges' g.
Open questions
The data edition's marks for checking (12), each with its row:
- Kudielka and Kirschbaum: first names and institution not in the documents. C04-04.
- Janet Shibley Hyde at the University of Wisconsin: own knowledge, not the documents'. C04-08.
- HEXACO emotionality d about −1.0: no primary author named. C04-13.
- Mehl et al. 2007: first names and institution not in the documents. C04-28.
- 85 per cent of stonewallers are men: blog-sourced only. C04-35.
- Kirschbaum 1995 conducted in Trier: inferred from the test's name and the OR-PS scene note, not stated in PS-04. C04-39.
- Men die by suicide at 3 to 4 times the rate of women: no primary source. C04-45.
- 2024 Swedish register study: authors not named. C04-58.
- Lise Eliot in Chicago: own knowledge. C04-68.
- Daphna Joel in Tel Aviv: own knowledge. C04-71.
- Eagly and Wood: first names not in the documents. C04-78.
- Breda: first name not in the documents. C04-79.
Open questions from the data edition's working notes:
- Whether the chapter should carry the schizophrenia and raloxifene material at all, or leave it for chapter 3 or 13. The data edition had two sentences. the narrated edition has none.
- Whether the SMPY paragraph belongs here or in chapter 15. Not in either edition of chapter 4.
- Whether the attachment section, thin in the data edition, should be cut in favour of chapter 6. The narrated edition cut it.
- Narrator's arithmetic to check against the BI-11 table: d = 0.93 as a seven-in-ten bet (C04-88). 0.69 as roughly three quarters shared, 0.27 as more than 85 per cent, 0.177 as more than 90 per cent, 0.28 as about 78 per cent (C04-89).
- Every row in the log is OPEN as of 2026-09-30: no figure in the chapter has yet been checked against its primary paper.
The documents
- PS-01 Sex differences in personality, interests and values: Big Five, HEXACO, temperament, Su 2009, Cross 2011, SMPY.
- PS-02 Emotion: experience, expression and regulation by sex: Chaplin and Aldao, Kirkland, Ditzen, rumination, alexithymia, Balliet, Gottman.
- PS-03 Communication styles: Mehl, Leaper, LaFrance, Sommer, Ochs, Schrodt.
- PS-04 Stress, coping and mental health by sex: Trier test, Kudielka and Kirschbaum, Kirschbaum 1995, Ditzen 2007, Salk, Martin.
- PS-05 Competition, status, risk and hierarchy: Byrnes, Niederle and Vesterlund, Saccardo, dual-hormone meta-analysis.
- PS-06 Sexual desire and the couple: Frankenbach, Conley and Yang, Klusmann, Muise, Pastor.
- PS-07 Attachment, love and long-term bonding: Del Giudice 2011, Marazziti, Buss and DeSteno, Eastwick and Finkel.
- PS-08 Neurodiversity through the lens of sex: Loomes, Wigdor, Jacquemont, Kentrou, Hull, Raymaker, Hirvikoski, Greenberg, Ridley, Dooley, oestrogen and schizophrenia.
- BI-07 Brain differences and the mosaic debate: Ritchie, Eliot, DeCasien, Joel, Chekroud, Del Giudice, Kaiser, Stoet and Geary, Breda.
- BI-11 Within-sex variation and individuals: conversion table, Voyer 1995, Del Giudice 2012 univariate values, variance ratios, Harrison 2022, Breda 2024.
- OR-03 (through the OR-PS sheet only): Gneezy, Leonard and List 2009, opt-out framing.