PAIRING · Part III · Emancipation 2.0
The numbers and sources
Chapter 11: The Abbess and the Monks
The narrated edition tells this chapter with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.
- 60 open
- 16 to check first
Numbers to carry
The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.
- Leadership style: task-oriented d = 0.00, interpersonal 0.04, democratic against autocratic 0.22, 162 studies (Eagly and Johnson, Psychological Bulletin, 1990, per OR-02). Rated effectiveness: d = −0.05 overall, −0.12 favouring women when others rate, 99 samples, 101,676 people (Paustian-Underdahl, Walker and Woehr, Journal of Applied Psychology, 2014, per OR-02). Rows C11-10, C11-13.
- Dual-hormone interaction r = −0.061, 30 papers, 33 studies, 8,538 people (Dekkers et al., Hormones and Behavior, 2019, per OR-02), published literature at 16 per cent power, seven unpublished datasets null (Grebe et al. 2019, per OR-02). Rows C11-05, C11-06.
- Menstruation at work: 13.8 per cent absent, 1.3 days a year, 80.7 per cent present in pain, 33 per cent less output, 8.9 days a year lost, 32,748 Dutch women (Schoep et al., BMJ Open, 2019, per OR-04). Japan's menstrual leave used by 0.9 per cent (OR-04). Rows C11-30, C11-31.
- Fifty-five hours or more a week: stroke relative risk 1.33, CI 1.11 to 1.61, 528,908 people, heart disease 1.13, 603,838 people (Kivimäki et al., The Lancet, 2015). Attributable deaths in 2016: 745,194, 72 per cent male (Pega et al., Environment International, 2021). Both per OR-05. Rows C11-03, C11-42.
- Marine Corps task force 2015: 134 tasks, 93 significant differences, 88 favouring all-male teams, female Infantry Training Battalion graduation 36 to 46 per cent against about 98 (per OR-07). Fontevraud: 1101 to 1790, monks under an abbess (per OR-06). Rows C11-51, C11-01.
Every figure
One row for each figure or finding in the data edition's chapter, whether or not the narrated edition kept it. Layer says whether it belongs to physiology, behaviour or culture. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.
| Figure | What it measures | Study (authors, year, venue, N) | Document | Row | Layer | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A woman of 51, a man at hour 56, a room at 21 degrees | The opening scene, invented as a type: the UK average menopause age, an hour above the long-week threshold, an ordinary office temperature | Narrator's scene, the two figures are OR-04's menopause age and Kivimäki 2015's threshold | OR-04, OR-05 | C11-02, C11-03 | culture | open, decoration |
| 51 | UK average age at menopause | No primary named, NHS or NICE figure | OR-04 | C11-02 | physiology | open |
| About 200 years | How long the ideal worker's body has run most organisations | Narrator's span, from industrialisation | none | none | culture | open |
| 1101 to 1790, 689 years | Fontevraud founded by Robert of Arbrissel, houses of monks and nuns under the abbess, monks owe obedience as a son to his mother, suppressed in the Revolution | Primary history of Fontevraud, the 689 is arithmetic on the two dates | OR-06 | C11-01, C11-60 | culture | robust |
| 2010 | Dual-hormone hypothesis: testosterone predicts status only when cortisol is low, an executive study of testosterone and subordinates among low-cortisol men | Mehta and Josephs 2010, Hormones and Behavior, OR-05 names no author for the executive study | OR-02, OR-05 | C11-04 | physiology | fallen |
| 30 papers, 33 studies, 49 effect sizes, N = 8,538, r = −0.061 | Meta-analysis of the dual-hormone interaction, in the predicted direction and too small to use | Dekkers et al. 2019, Hormones and Behavior per OR-02, PS-05 gives the same figures as Geniole 2016 | OR-02, PS-05 | C11-05 | physiology | fallen, attribution contested |
| About 16 per cent power, seven unpublished datasets null | P-curve of the published dual-hormone literature and the file drawer | Grebe et al. 2019 | OR-02 | C11-06 | physiology | robust |
| Immunoassays unreliable at women's testosterone concentrations, oestradiol and power motivation rarely studied | Why the dual-hormone literature was built on men | No primary named | OR-02 | C11-07 | physiology | open |
| 826 men aged 22 to 40, 54.37 per cent, ten-fold odds, 2 to 4 weeks, 4 to 6 weeks | Working men under high stress: prevalence of erectile dysfunction, odds against the low-stress group, cortisol rising before testosterone falls, function failing after that | Huang et al. 2026, International Journal of Clinical Practice, OR-05 cites a press release | OR-05 | C11-08 | physiology | open |
| Hypothesis valid (OR-05) against failed (OR-02, OR-03) | Report-to-report disagreement on the dual-hormone hypothesis, carried not resolved | The three documents | OR-02, OR-03, OR-05 | C11-09 | physiology | contested |
| 162 studies, d = 0.00, 0.04, 0.22 | Leadership style in real organisations: task-oriented, interpersonal, democratic against autocratic | Eagly and Johnson 1990, Psychological Bulletin, PS-03 gives 161 studies | OR-02, PS-03 | C11-10 | behaviour | robust, count open |
| About 90 per cent overlap | What d = 0.22 means for the two distributions | Chapter 4's conversion table (92 per cent at d = 0.20), narrator's reading | none | C11-12 | behaviour | open |
| 197 of 370 primary studies self-ratings | Vecchio's objection that too many leaders rated themselves | Vecchio 2002, OR-02 gives 162 studies in the same paragraph | OR-02 | C11-11 | behaviour | open |
| 99 samples, N = 101,676, d = −0.05, −0.12 | Rated leadership effectiveness overall, other-ratings favouring women, self-ratings favouring men | Paustian-Underdahl, Walker and Woehr 2014, Journal of Applied Psychology | OR-02 | C11-13 | behaviour | robust, filter against bias contested |
| 1,632 effect sizes, 120 samples, N = 32,579 | Leader emergence: men emerge more, gap shrinking, agency drives emergence, emotional ability drives rated transformational leadership | Badura et al. 2018, Journal of Applied Psychology | OR-02 | C11-14 | behaviour | robust |
| 2002 | Role congruity theory: the leader stereotype and the female stereotype point different ways | Eagly and Karau 2002, Psychological Review | OR-02 | C11-15 | culture | robust |
| 1992 | Identical autocratic behaviour rated worse in women than in men | Eagly, Makhijani and Klonsky 1992, Psychological Bulletin | OR-02 | C11-16 | culture | robust |
| 40, 22 and 17 studies | Leader stereotype masculine across three paradigms, weakening, weakest in education | Koenig et al. 2011, Psychological Bulletin | OR-02 | C11-17 | culture | robust |
| FTSE 100, 2005, 2008 | The glass cliff: women appointed to boards disproportionately when the firm is failing, think crisis, think female, scapegoating | Ryan and Haslam 2005, British Journal of Management, Haslam and Ryan 2008 | OR-02 | C11-18 | culture | robust |
| About 600 to 900 | Anglo-Saxon double monasteries as mission stations, abbesses royal widows or princesses, Hild of Whitby, the chroniclers' viriliter | Foot 2006, Monastic Life in Anglo-Saxon England (CUP), McNamara | OR-06 | C11-19 | culture | robust |
| 700 | "The best deal available" for a woman, the narrator's date for the Anglo-Saxon cloister | Narrator's | none | none | culture | open |
| 787, Canon XX | Second Council of Nicaea banned women living in monasteries of men and new double houses in the East | Conciliar text, OR-06's summary line omits the East qualifier | OR-06 | C11-20 | culture | robust, qualifier open |
| Same food and drink | The Gilbertines of Sempringham fed nuns and canons alike | Gilbertine Rule | OR-06 | C11-21 | culture | robust |
| More than 5,000 quantitative and 12,000 qualitative observations, eight centuries | Guilds as cartels colluding with the political class, excluding women raised members' wages, Württemberg guilds re-passing exclusions | Ogilvie 2019, The European Guilds, Ogilvie 2003, A Bitter Living | OR-06, HC-04 | C11-22 | culture | robust |
| More than 300 women, a third of adult women, early 14th century | Brewing in Brigstock, Northamptonshire, as women's work before hops, capital and guilds | Bennett 1996, Ale, Beer, and Brewsters | OR-06 | C11-23 | culture | robust |
| 1675, boys to age eight, 419 apprentices a year 1746 to 1759, more than 2,000 mistresses | The Paris seamstresses' guild under Colbert, monopoly on women's and children's clothing, largest apprentice group in the city | Crowston 2001, Fabricating Women | OR-06 | C11-24 | culture | robust |
| 1998 | The Arbeitspaar, the working couple of early modern Germany dividing portfolios | Wunder 1998, He Is the Sun, She Is the Moon | OR-06 | C11-25 | culture | robust |
| 162 countries, US census from 1890 | Goldin's U-curve: women's paid work falling through early industrialisation, rising with education | Goldin 1995, World Development | HC-04 | C11-26 | behaviour | robust |
| Birmingham and Essex, 1780 to 1850 | Separate spheres in the English middle class, from wills, sermons and house plans | Davidoff and Hall 1987, Family Fortunes | HC-04 | C11-27 | culture | robust |
| 1976 against 1977, 1,350 household budgets 1787 to 1865 | The family wage as a pact of capital and patriarchy (Hartmann) or as a room the factory could not reach (Humphries), the breadwinner mostly absent from the budgets | Hartmann 1976, Signs, Humphries 1977, Cambridge Journal of Economics, Horrell and Humphries 1992 | HC-04 | C11-28 | culture | contested |
| 1992 typology | Strong male-breadwinner states (UK, Germany) against weak (Sweden, Denmark), Illich's shadow work | Lewis 1992, Journal of European Social Policy, Illich 1981 | HC-04 | C11-29 | culture | robust |
| 1975 | The narrator born into the strong-breadwinner column | concept note biographical anchor | HC-04 | C11-59 | culture | robust |
| 32,748 Dutch women, 13.8 per cent, 1.3 days a year, 80.7 per cent, 33 per cent, 8.9 days a year | Menstrual absenteeism and presenteeism, self-reported productivity loss, no employer-side validation | Schoep et al. 2019, BMJ Open | OR-04 | C11-30 | behaviour | contested |
| Seven times | Presenteeism days against absence days, 8.9 against 1.3 | Narrator's arithmetic on Schoep 2019 | OR-04 | C11-30 | behaviour | open |
| 1947, 0.9 per cent in 2020 | Japan's menstrual leave (Article 68, Labour Standards Act) and its uptake in a ministry survey | National statute and survey | OR-04 | C11-31 | culture | robust |
| 2001, about 19 per cent in 2018 | South Korea's paid monthly day and its uptake, the employer pays if it is not taken | National statute and poll | OR-04 | C11-31 | culture | robust |
| 2023, 60 per cent | Spain's state-paid menstrual leave on a medical diagnosis | National statute | OR-04 | C11-31 | culture | robust |
| 1994, 2022 | Mandated maternity benefits priced back onto women's wages, sex-specific leave reducing women's hiring into permanent and high-paying roles across the OECD | Gruber 1994, American Economic Review, Buriakova, Fitzpatrick and Machin 2022, venue not given | OR-04 | C11-32 | behaviour | robust |
| 21 studies, 195,538 women, OR 1.30, 1.35, HR 1.09 | Shift work and irregular menstruation, dysmenorrhoea, early menopause | Wang et al. 2019, venue not given | OR-04 | C11-34 | physiology | robust |
| 30 papers, RR 1.51 (1.27 to 1.78), five studies | Fixed night shifts and miscarriage | Bonde et al. 2013, Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment and Health | OR-04 | C11-35 | physiology | robust |
| More than 55.5 hours a week, OR 1.21 (1.11 to 1.33) | Long working weeks in pregnancy and preterm birth, OR-04 calls this "a 10 per cent increase" in the same sentence | 2019 review, unnamed | OR-04 | C11-36 | physiology | contested, internal |
| N = 5,191, about 75 per cent higher odds | Afternoon and night shift work and gestational diabetes | Wallace et al. 2023, AJOG, nuMoM2b cohort | OR-04 | C11-37 | physiology | robust |
| About 90 per cent | Share of women with menopausal symptoms | No primary named | OR-04 | C11-38 | physiology | open |
| 4,014 UK women, 10, 14, 8, 44, 41 per cent | Left a job, reduced hours, declined promotion, ability compromised, colleagues treated it as a joke | Fawcett Society 2022, Menopause and the Workplace | OR-04 | C11-39 | behaviour | robust |
| BS 30416, May 2023 | The British standard on menstruation and menopause at work: fabrics, PPE time, fans, windows, shift changes | BSI | OR-04 | C11-40 | culture | robust |
| 2020 review | Medicalisation and gendered ageism of menopause at work: the experienced older man and the symptomatic older woman | Grandey, Jack and Brewis, venue given as Gender, Work and Organization for Brewis | OR-04 | C11-41 | culture | robust, venue open |
| 25 studies, 603,838 people, 8.5 years, 528,908 people, 7.2 years, RR 1.33 (1.11 to 1.61), RR 1.13, steps 1.10 at 41 to 48 hours, 1.27 at 49 to 54 | Fifty-five hours or more against 35 to 40: stroke and coronary heart disease, adjusted for smoking, drink, inactivity and class | Kivimäki et al. 2015, The Lancet 386:1739, IPD-Work consortium | OR-05 | C11-03 | physiology | robust |
| More than 2,300 surveys, 154 countries, 745,194 deaths in 2016, 72 per cent male | WHO and ILO estimate of heart-disease and stroke deaths attributable to 55 hours or more, the largest attributable occupational burden | Pega et al. 2021, Environment International | OR-05 | C11-42 | physiology | robust |
| 1.33 against 1.35, 1.13 against 1.17 | Stroke and heart-disease relative risks in Kivimäki 2015 and Pega 2021, the data edition uses Kivimäki's | The two papers | OR-05 | C11-43 | physiology | open, two figures |
| 5,283 in 2023, 91.4 to 93.0 per cent 2011 to 2024, about 53 per cent of the employed, more than nine times | Fatal work injuries in the United States, men's share of the dead, men's share of the workforce, the fatality-rate ratio | Bureau of Labor Statistics, Census of Fatal Occupational Injuries | OR-05 | C11-44 | behaviour | robust |
| Structural iron, roofing, fishing, logging, construction, heavy transport | The trades where the dead are | BLS | OR-05 | C11-45 | behaviour | robust |
| RR 1.70 (1.58 unadjusted elsewhere in OR-05), 1.15 adjusted for prior mental health, 2.50 in the first five years, higher in men | Unemployment and suicide, pooled cohorts | Milner, Page and LaMontagne 2013, PLoS One, and 2014, British Journal of Psychiatry | OR-05 | C11-46 | behaviour | contested, internal |
| About 1,000 Fortune 500 fathers, 95 per cent, 53 per cent | Fathers calling flexibility critical, fathers who would consider staying home full-time | Boston College Center for Work and Family, The New Dad (Harrington, Humberd, Ladge) | OR-05 | C11-47 | behaviour | robust |
| 2013 | The flexibility stigma and femininity stigma for men who ask for leave, men given flexibility work more hours | Rudman and Mescher 2013, Journal of Social Issues, OR-04 attributes the term to Williams, Blair-Loy and Berdahl 2013 | OR-05, OR-04 | C11-48 | culture | robust, attribution open |
| 66 correlations, 49 studies | Task cohesion, not social cohesion, predicts unit performance | MacCoun 1996, RAND | OR-07 | C11-49 | behaviour | robust |
| 2014 | Norwegian unisex dormitories de-dramatised sex and built task bonds | Hellum 2014, OR-07 cites a blog post | OR-07 | C11-50 | behaviour | open |
| About 100 women, one year, 134 tasks, 93 significant, 88 favouring all-male, 30 tasks with a gap of 30 per cent or more, 28 favouring all-male, higher female injury, ITB graduation 36 to 46 per cent against about 98 | The Marine Corps Ground Combat Element Integrated Task Force, mixed against all-male teams | USMC 2015 report | OR-07 | C11-51 | physiology | robust, the standard contested |
| 85 men, 235 women, three years, attrition 28 against 37 per cent | Caracal, the Israeli mixed battalion: more stress fractures in women, lower attrition (heights 162 against 174 cm, fat 18.9 against 12.6 kg, VO2 36.8 against 50.48 cut from the data edition's text) | Gepstein et al. 2014 | OR-07 | C11-52 | physiology | robust |
| 10 to 12 per cent running, about 30 per cent weightlifting at matched mass, about 65 per cent open powerlifting, about 5 per cent removed by 12 months of suppression | The male performance advantage from puberty and what testosterone suppression removes, OR-07 also gives a baseline of 30 to 80 per cent | Hilton and Lundberg 2021, Sports Medicine | OR-07 | C11-53 | physiology | contested, internal |
| 2,059 school pupils and 456 students | Single-sex schooling and anxiety around the other sex | Wong, Shi and Chen 2018, PLoS ONE | OR-07 | C11-54 | behaviour | robust |
| 50 male chiefs, the doubled plan | Haudenosaunee chiefs nominated and deposed by Clan Mothers, Quaker men's and women's business meetings, Lucretia Mott | OR-07 cites an archive and a local history society, chapter 2 (DH-06) | OR-06, OR-07 | C11-55 | culture | contested, extent of authority |
| 135 institutions (65 Gujarat, 70 Nepal), 2000 to 2001, 20.9 against 41.6 hectares, 25 to 33 per cent | Community forest committees: all-women committees handed smaller forests and regenerating them better, critical mass for women's voice | Agarwal 2009, Ecological Economics, 2010, Gender and Green Governance | OR-06 | C11-56 | behaviour | robust |
| From 1910, 88 and 12, 99 and 1, 67 and 33, 17 and 83, 15 and 85 per cent, 2 against 9 per cent | The kibbutz by the third generation: agriculture, construction, management and politics, education, childcare and services, men against women, senior central posts | Tiger and Shepher 1975, Adar 1992, Palgi 1997 | OR-06 | C11-57 | behaviour | contested, why |
| 1833 Factory Inquiry | Women excluded from overseer roles after steam removed the strength requirement | Galley 2013, Continuity and Change | HC-04 | C11-58 | culture | robust |
| 955 young women, mean age 19.56, 54.6 per cent | Preference for an explicit menstrual-leave policy | Study unnamed in OR-04 | OR-04 | C11-33 | behaviour | open |
| About four in five | Korean women who refuse the leave, arithmetic on the 19 per cent uptake | Narrator's | OR-04 | C11-31 | culture | open |
| The last three such posts, ten minutes out of the public eye | Figures in the data edition's In practice, the narrator's own | Narrator's | none | none | culture | open, decoration |
The case for and the case against
The case the chapter makes
- Hormones do not pick the leader. The dual-hormone hypothesis failed its meta-analysis and its p-curve, and the stress-to-testosterone sequence runs the other way, the job setting the hormones (Dekkers 2019 or Geniole 2016, Grebe 2019, OR-02, Huang 2026, OR-05, rows C11-04 to C11-09).
- Men and women lead almost identically. Task and interpersonal style at d = 0.00 and 0.04, decision style at 0.22, rated effectiveness at −0.05, with others rating women slightly higher (Eagly and Johnson 1990, Paustian-Underdahl 2014, OR-02, rows C11-10, C11-13).
- The sex difference is in who emerges, by talk, and in who is watching: agency drives emergence, emotional ability drives rated performance, role congruity, the double standard on autocratic behaviour, and the glass cliff (Badura 2018, Eagly and Karau 2002, Eagly, Makhijani and Klonsky 1992, Koenig 2011, Ryan and Haslam 2005, OR-02, rows C11-14 to C11-18).
- The record holds three designs before the factory: separate houses under one named authority (Fontevraud, the Gilbertines, the Anglo-Saxon double monastery), a cartel that wrote the body into the rule (Ogilvie's guilds, Bennett's brewsters, Crowston's seamstresses), and the unwritten working couple (Wunder) (OR-06, HC-04, rows C11-01, C11-19 to C11-25).
- Industrialisation rebuilt the cartel as the ideal worker: Goldin's U-curve, Davidoff and Hall's separate spheres, Lewis's strong-breadwinner states (HC-04, rows C11-26 to C11-29).
- The ideal worker costs her body: Schoep's presenteeism, the shift-work and long-week risks in pregnancy, the menopause at work, and a labelled leave that is priced back onto her wages (Schoep 2019, Wang 2019, Bonde 2013, Wallace 2023, Fawcett 2022, Gruber 1994, OR-04, rows C11-30 to C11-41).
- The ideal worker costs his body too: the 55-hour week on stroke and heart disease, the attributable deaths, the fatal trades, unemployment and suicide, and the flexibility stigma that keeps him at his desk (Kivimäki 2015, Pega 2021, BLS, Milner 2013, Rudman and Mescher 2013, OR-05, rows C11-03, C11-42 to C11-48).
- Where the task is the body the sex gap at the extreme is large and does not wash out (USMC 2015, Gepstein 2014, Hilton and Lundberg 2021, OR-07, rows C11-51 to C11-53), where it is anything else the case for separate doors is thin (MacCoun 1996, Wong 2018, OR-07, rows C11-49, C11-54).
- Separate is not subordinate where the top is shared or decided on paper (Haudenosaunee, Quakers, Agarwal's critical mass, OR-06, OR-07, rows C11-55, C11-56), the organisation that wrote no rule got the old one back (Tiger and Shepher 1975, OR-06, row C11-57).
The case against
- Naming a female body in a rule taxes its owner: mandated maternity benefits came back as lower wages, sex-specific leave reduces women's hiring, Japan's and Korea's leave goes untaken, and the 54.6 per cent of young women who want an explicit policy would pay for it in offers (Gruber 1994, Buriakova, Fitzpatrick and Machin 2022, the leave table, the unnamed 955-woman study, OR-04, rows C11-31 to C11-33).
- The body was never the reason: women barred from the overseer's job after steam (Galley 2013, HC-04, row C11-58), guilds re-passing exclusions because women kept qualifying (Ogilvie 2003, 2019, row C11-22), Hellum's dormitories removing the door (row C11-50), the Marine Corps standard built for men's bodies in units closed to women the year before (row C11-51).
- The body writes itself in anyway: Tiger and Shepher's 88, 99 and 85 per cent in the most committed experiment ever run, so the abbess is a tail of the distribution with a crown on (OR-06, row C11-57).
- The data edition's Contested list, carried below: whether the dual-hormone hypothesis is dead or alive, whether the women-rated-better result is a filter or a bias, how much authority the Clan Mothers held, why the kibbutz re-sorted, whether the presenteeism loss exists on the employer's side, Burnette's market against Galley's door, Hartmann's pact against Humphries's room.
Where the sources disagree
- Whether the dual-hormone hypothesis is dead (OR-02, OR-03, PS-05) or alive (OR-05, which also cites the Mehta and Josephs executive study without naming it). Carried both, not resolved. Row C11-09.
- Whether the dual-hormone meta-analysis is Dekkers 2019 (OR-02) or Geniole 2016 (PS-05), for the same 30 papers, 33 studies, 49 effect sizes and 8,538 people. Chapter 10's resolution adopted. Row C11-05.
- Eagly and Johnson 1990's study count: 162 (OR-02, PS-05) against 161 (PS-03), and OR-02 says "197 of the original 370 primary studies" were self-ratings in a paragraph that opens with 162 studies. Rows C11-10, C11-11.
- Whether the women-rated-better result in Paustian-Underdahl 2014 is a filter or a bias (OR-02). Row C11-13.
- Whether Huang 2026 is a paper or a press release (OR-05 cites a Wiley press release and a news site). Row C11-08.
- How much authority the Clan Mothers held (Lafitau, Tooker, Viau, OR-06). Row C11-55.
- Why the kibbutz re-sorted: Tiger and Shepher's biology against their critics' managerial definition of productive work and the revolt against living like men (OR-06). Row C11-57.
- Whether the 33 per cent menstrual productivity loss exists on the employer's side (OR-04, its own caveat). Row C11-30.
- Milner 2013: "70 per cent overall increase (RR 1.70)" and "before adjustment, 1.58" in adjacent sentences of OR-05. Row C11-46.
- OR-04: "more than 55.5 hours per week, a 10 per cent increase in the odds of preterm delivery (OR 1.21, 95 per cent CI 1.11 to 1.33)". The odds ratio and the percentage do not agree. Row C11-36.
- Hilton and Lundberg 2021 (OR-07): "10 to 50 per cent" performance gap and "30 to 80 per cent in strength and power" in the same section. Row C11-53.
- Flexibility stigma: coined by Rudman and Mescher 2013 (OR-05) or Williams, Blair-Loy and Berdahl 2013 (OR-04). Row C11-48.
- Nicaea II: OR-06's summary line says double monasteries were "canonically banned by Nicaea II in 787", while its own text says the ban applied in the East and Fontevraud (1101), Sempringham and Vadstena (1346) followed in the West. The data edition follows the body of the document. Row C11-20.
- Haudenosaunee founding: 1450 (Snow) against 1142 (oral tradition), both in OR-06, both carried in chapter 2. Row C11-55.
- Stroke and heart-disease relative risks: Kivimäki 2015's 1.33 and 1.13 against Pega 2021's 1.35 and 1.17 (OR-05). The data edition uses Kivimäki's. Row C11-43.
- Fatalities: OR-05 gives "91.4 to 93.0 per cent" (2011 to 2024), "roughly 92 per cent" and "more than nine times", the data edition uses the range. Row C11-44.
- Hellum 2014 (OR-07) is cited to a blog post. Row C11-50.
- The Lucretia Mott and Quaker doubled-plan material (OR-07) is cited to an archive and a local history society, not to a primary study. Row C11-55.
- Garikipati and Kambhampati 2021: OR-02 gives no sample size, not told.
- Burnette's market against Galley's door on why women were excluded from the mill's best jobs (HC-04). Row C11-58.
- Hartmann's pact against Humphries's room on the family wage (HC-04). Row C11-28.
- Figures stripped from the OR-05 text (throwing velocity and distance effect sizes, the fatality ratio as a symbol) are not used, nothing used in this chapter was missing from the text files, so the PDFs were not needed.
Open questions
marks for checking from the data edition (27), each now carried here instead of in the chapter:
- Mehta and Josephs first names, OR-02 and OR-05 give initials only. Row C11-04.
- Dekkers 2019 against Geniole 2016 for the dual-hormone meta-analysis. Row C11-05.
- Grebe et al. 2019 first names. Row C11-06.
- Huang 2026 cited to a press release, not the paper. Row C11-08.
- Alice Eagly's first name, supplied from general knowledge. Row C11-10.
- Eagly and Johnson's study count, 162 against PS-03's 161. Row C11-10.
- Vecchio's 197 of 370 self-rating denominator against 162 studies. Row C11-11.
- Paustian-Underdahl, Walker and Woehr first names. Row C11-13.
- Badura et al. first names. Row C11-14.
- Koenig et al. first names. Row C11-17.
- Ryan and Haslam first names. Row C11-18.
- Claudia Goldin's first name, supplied from general knowledge. Row C11-26.
- Horrell's first name. Row C11-28.
- Schoep et al. first names. Row C11-30.
- Buriakova, Fitzpatrick and Machin first names and venue. Row C11-32.
- Wang et al. first names and venue. Row C11-34.
- Bonde et al. first names. Row C11-35.
- The preterm odds ratio of 1.21 called a 10 per cent increase. Row C11-36.
- Grandey, Jack and Brewis first names and venue. Row C11-41.
- Mika Kivimäki's first name, supplied from general knowledge. Row C11-03.
- Pega et al. first names. Row C11-42.
- Milner 1.70 against 1.58 unadjusted. Row C11-46.
- Rudman and Mescher first names, and the flexibility-stigma attribution (OR-05 against OR-04). Row C11-48.
- Hellum cited to a secondary source. Row C11-50.
- Gepstein et al. first names. Row C11-52.
- Hilton and Lundberg's baseline advantage, 10 to 50 against 30 to 80 per cent. Row C11-53.
- Wong, Shi and Chen first names. Row C11-54.
Other open points from the data edition:
- Fontevraud's founding, rule and suppression against a primary history. Row C11-01.
- The UK average menopause age of 51 against an NHS or NICE figure. Row C11-02.
- The 90 per cent overlap for d = 0.22, read from chapter 4's table rather than from OR-02. Row C11-12.
- The 90 per cent of women with menopausal symptoms, no primary named. Row C11-38.
- The 955-woman preference study, unnamed in OR-04. Row C11-33.
- No affiliation or place is given for any researcher because none of the six documents gives one, the style sheet's apposition rule needs a pass once the primary papers are in hand.
- Whether the chapter should carry Correll's motherhood penalty (HC-04) at all. Chapter 8 has Kleven's child penalty, Correll is one sentence away from fitting in "The worker with no body" and was cut for length.
- Whether Garikipati and Kambhampati's pandemic study (OR-02) belongs here or in chapter 14, which chapter 10's notes already routed it to. It is listed in the library and not told.
- Whether the Rochdale and Raiffeisen cooperatives (OR-06) deserve a paragraph, cut for length.
- Whether the Farrell, Connell and Kimmel, Reeves framing of male costs (OR-05) should appear in the text. It is in the library and in In practice by implication only.
- Chapter 10 owns the Dekkers/Geniole attribution, the c-factor, Niederle and Gneezy, and the Norway boardroom (Ahern, Eckbo, Post, Masciandaro). None of this chapter's six documents mentions Norway, so it is not told here.
The documents
- OR-02 Leadership, hormones and sex: Mehta and Josephs, Dekkers, Grebe, Eagly and Johnson, Eagly 2003, Paustian-Underdahl, Badura, Eagly and Karau, Koenig, Eagly 1992, Ryan and Haslam, Croson and Gneezy, Garikipati, von Rueden.
- OR-04 Work design and female physiology: Schoep, the menstrual-leave table, Gruber, Buriakova, Dinour and Szaro, Wang, Bonde, Wallace, the Fawcett Society, BS 30416, Grandey.
- OR-05 Male work patterns and their costs: the dual-hormone hypothesis as live, Huang, Kivimäki, Pega, the Bureau of Labor Statistics, Milner, Pinquart and Schindler, Killewald, The New Dad, Rudman and Mescher, Farrell, Connell, Kimmel, Reeves.
- OR-06 Historical and traditional mixed organisations: Foot, McNamara, Nicaea II, Fontevraud, the Gilbertines, Vadstena, Ogilvie 2019, Bennett, Crowston, Wunder, De Moor and van Zanden, Agarwal, Rochdale, Raiffeisen, Tiger and Shepher, the Haudenosaunee.
- OR-07 Sex-segregated vs integrated institutions: Pahlke, Halpern, Wong, MacCoun, Hellum, the USMC task force, Gepstein, Hilton and Lundberg, Mahalik, Rotary v Duarte, the dual-governance table.
- HC-04 Industrialisation and the separation of home and work: Leyk, Burnette, Galley, Goldin, Horrell and Humphries, Davidoff and Hall, Hartmann, Humphries, Ogilvie 2003, Illich, Lewis, Correll.
- the OR and PS digest and the HC digest: the distilled sheets.