THRIVING after the FALL
Book Two PAIRING after the FALL

PAIRING · Part I · Overlapping Bells

The numbers and sources

Chapter 1: The Grandmother Clause

The narrated edition tells this chapter with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.

  • 58 open
  • 18 to check first

Read about the chapter · Its 58 rows in the log

Numbers to carry

The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.

  • Menopausal whales gained about 40 years of life, not shorter reproductive spans: 18 species compared (Ellis et al. 2024, Nature, via AN-01). Row C01-09.
  • A grandcalf whose grandmother died in the previous two years is 4.5 times as likely to die, 6.7 times if she was post-reproductive: 378 grandcalves (Nattrass et al. 2019, PNAS, via AN-01). Row C01-13.
  • An adult son over 30 is 8.3 or 13.9 times as likely to die in the year after his post-reproductive mother's death, a daughter 5.4 times: 589 whales, 297 deaths (Foster et al. 2012, Science, via AN-01 and AN-06, which disagree). Row C01-14.
  • Bonobo females won 61 per cent of 1,786 conflicts with males and 85 per cent of female coalitions targeted males: 30 years, six communities (Surbeck et al. 2025, via AN-03 and AN-06). Row C01-33.
  • Biological factors explain 2.51 to 5.42 per cent of the variance across 43 ecological meta-analyses (Møller and Jennions 2002, Oecologia, via AN-09). Row C01-54.

Every figure

One row for each figure or finding in the data edition's chapter, whether or not the narrated edition kept it. Layer says whether it belongs to physiology, behaviour or culture. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.

FigureWhat it measuresStudy (authors, year, venue, N)DocumentRowLayerStatus
North PacificWhere the resident killer whale populations liveNo primary named. AN-01 names only the Center for Whale Research and Fisheries and Oceans CanadaAN-09C01-01cultureopen
K16A Southern Resident mother who bites Chinook salmon in half for her grown son, observed for yearsFacebook post by the Center for Whale Research. No primaryAN-01C01-02behaviouropen
About 40, 80 to 90 and more, rarely past 30Age at which female killer whales stop breeding, age they live to, age males rarely passEllis et al. 2024, NatureAN-01, AN-06C01-03physiologyrobust
Post-reproductive females leadWho is at the front of collective movement, most in low-Chinook yearsBrent et al. 2015, Current BiologyAN-01C01-04culturerobust
1957, 1966Theory that selection cannot favour post-reproductive lifeWilliams 1957, Evolution. Hamilton 1966, Journal of Theoretical Biology (journals not given in AN-01)AN-01C01-05physiologyrobust
5 toothed whales and humansSpecies with menopause: killer, short-finned pilot, false killer, beluga, narwhalEllis et al. 2018, Scientific ReportsAN-01C01-06physiologyrobust
No menopauseChimpanzees and elephants help kin but breed until near the endCohen 2004, Levitis (year not given), boundary cases. No single primaryAN-01C01-07physiologycontested
72 speciesCetacean species whose ovarian scars were readEllis et al. 2018, Scientific ReportsAN-01C01-08physiologyrobust
18 species, about 40 yearsWhale species compared with and without menopause. Menopausal species gained about 40 years of life, reproductive spans not shortened, no increase in mother-daughter breeding overlap, same path as humansEllis et al. 2024, NatureAN-01C01-09physiologyrobust
Both sexes stayResident killer whales: both sexes stay in the natal pod for life and mate outside itJohnstone and Cant 2010AN-01C01-10behaviourrobust
Rising relatednessKinship dynamics: a female's relatedness to her group rises with ageJohnstone and Cant 2010, Proceedings of the Royal Society B (AN-01) or PNAS (AN-06)AN-01, AN-06C01-11behaviourrobust
1.7 timesWhen mother and daughter breed together, the older female's calf is 1.7 times as likely to dieCroft et al. 2017, Current BiologyAN-01C01-12behaviourrobust
378 grandcalves, 4.5 times, 6.7 times, more than 40 years of censusCalf mortality when the maternal grandmother died in the previous two years, and when she was post-reproductive, controlling for salmon, in Northern and Southern ResidentsNattrass et al. 2019, PNAS, 378 grandcalves, census from the Center for Whale Research and Fisheries and Oceans CanadaAN-01C01-13behaviourrobust
589 whales, 297 deaths, 13.9 or 8.3 times, 5.4 timesRise in mortality of adult sons over 30 and of adult daughters in the year after a post-reproductive mother's deathFoster et al. 2012, Science, 589 whales, 297 deathsAN-01, AN-06C01-14behaviourcontested
40 females, roughly halvesEach surviving son roughly halves his mother's annual probability of a viable calf, with no attenuation as he agesWeiss et al. 2023, Current Biology, 40 Southern Resident femalesAN-01C01-15behaviourrobust
Fewer tooth-rake marksMales with living post-reproductive mothers carry fewer scars from other whalesGrimes et al. 2023, Current BiologyAN-01C01-16behaviourrobust
Thousands of hours or more than 750 hours of videoObservation time behind the leadership findingBrent et al. 2015, Current Biology. AN-09 gives Brent a sample of 589 whales, which is Foster's NAN-01, AN-06, AN-09C01-17cultureopen
HalvesIn a Chinook collapse year the probability of any female calving halvesWard et al. 2009, Journal of Applied EcologyAN-01C01-18behaviourrobust
21 families, matriarchs 27 to 67, modelled at 55 and 35Amboseli playback: old-led families bunch only for strangers, matriarch age predicts per-capita reproductive successMcComb et al. 2001, Science, 21 families (AN-02) or 39 (AN-06)AN-02, AN-06C01-19culturerobust
39 familiesLion roar playback, one lion or three, male or female: older matriarchs respond more accurately and fasterMcComb et al. 2011, Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 39 familiesAN-02C01-20culturerobust
218 adult females, 109 groups, a decadeFamilies that lost elders to poaching still bred less a decade laterGobush et al. 2008, PNAS, and Goldenberg et al. 2016, Current Biology. Which paper carries which figure is not statedAN-06C01-21behaviourrobust
10 to 15Age at which young male elephants leave the natal herdNo primary namedAN-02C01-22behaviouropen
About 2 to 20 or 40 ng/ml. 2, 13, 81, 54 daysTestosterone in musth, and median days in musth per year at ages 16 to 25, 26 to 35, 46 to 50, 51 to 60Poole 1987 and 1989, Behaviour and Animal BehaviourAN-02C01-23physiologyrobust
119 calves, 22 years, 89 males, 45 to 53, about 20 per centAmboseli paternity: peak at ages 45 to 53, non-musth males sire about a fifthHollister-Smith et al. 2007, Animal BehaviourAN-02C01-24behaviourrobust
60 wild bulls, 4 captive bullsMusth and stress: no cortisol rise in Kaziranga, a rise in four captive bulls aged 12 to 54Ghosal et al. 2013, PLoS ONE. Ganswindt et al., year given as 2010 and 2021 in AN-02AN-02C01-25physiologycontested
More than 100 rhinos, 6 older bullsPilanesberg, late 1990s: orphaned young males from Kruger culls killed white rhinos, musth ended when six older bulls arrivedSlotow et al. 2000, Nature, "Older bull elephants control young males"AN-02C01-26culturerobust
1 to 2 million years, the Congo RiverChimpanzee and bonobo split and separationNo primary namedAN-03, AN-06C01-27physiologyopen
42.7 and 33.7 kg, 1.27, 1.36, 2.24Body-mass ratios, male to female: chimpanzee, bonobo, gorillaSmith and Jungers 1997. Plavcan 2001AN-03C01-28physiologyrobust
8 to 1Typical raiding advantage in the imbalance-of-power hypothesisWrangham 1999, American Journal of Physical AnthropologyAN-03C01-29behaviourrobust
18 chimpanzee and 4 bonobo communities, 152 killingsLethal aggression does not track human disturbanceWilson et al. 2014, NatureAN-03C01-30behaviourcontested
Artefact claimFerguson (anthropologist) and Horgan (science writer) argue the killings are a human artefactNo primary namedAN-03C01-31behaviourcontested
Up to 21 per centMountain gorilla infant deaths from infanticide by incoming males over 40 yearsRobbins et al. 2013, PLoS OneAN-03C01-32behaviourrobust
30 years, 6 communities, 1,786 conflicts, 61 per cent (1,099), 70 per cent, 85 per cent, 39 per cent, Ekalakala and Bompusa WestBonobo female dominance: fights won, share of males outranked, coalitions targeting males, fights won by males, communities where a male held top rankSurbeck et al. 2025, Communications Biology (AN-03) or Primates (AN-06)AN-03, AN-06C01-33behaviourrobust
Female dispersalBonobo females leave at maturity, adult females are unrelated immigrantsNo primary namedAN-03C01-34behaviourrobust
Oxytocin riseGenital rubbing raises urinary oxytocin in female bonobos more than mating does, most often in tense feeding contextsMoscovice et al. 2019, Hormones and BehaviorAN-03C01-35physiologyrobust
Mother's rankA male bonobo's rank depends on his mother's, mothers escort sonsNo single primary (Surbeck, Furuichi)AN-03C01-36behaviourrobust
4.4 million years, 1.06 to 1.13Ardipithecus ramidus canine dimorphism, smaller than the bonobo'sSuwa, Lovejoy et al. 2021, PNASAN-03C01-37physiologycontested
About 60 per cent, 27 yearsSpotted hyena: first litters killed by birth through the pseudo-penis, years of clan recordsHolekamp and Strauss 2022, PNAS. Strauss and Holekamp 2019, PNASAN-06C01-38physiologyrobust
253 populations, 121 speciesAdult sex ratio is the best predictor of female dominance across primatesKappeler et al. 2022, Biological ReviewsAN-06C01-39behaviourrobust
1948Bateman's fruit-fly experiment and its two principlesBateman 1948, HeredityAN-05C01-40behaviourfallen
1972Parental investment theoryTrivers 1972AN-05C01-41behaviourcontested
No evidence of sexual selectionReplication of Bateman: lethal markers undercounted offspringGowaty, Kim and Anderson 2012, PNASAN-05C01-42behaviourrobust
64 to 66 species, up to 102 effect sizesSexual selection stronger on males on average, large variance, reversed in pipefish, jacanas, some bush crickets. Effect sizes stripped in extractionJanicke et al. 2016, Science AdvancesAN-05C01-43behaviourrobust
One mother, one fatherFisher condition, adult sex ratio drives sex roles, Concorde fallacyKokko and Jennions 2008, Journal of Evolutionary BiologyAN-05C01-44behaviourrobust
6,119 birds, 6 populations, 51 per cent, 63 per cent maleShorebirds: snowy plover male juvenile survival higher, adult population male-biased, males do all care, even-ratio populations shareEberhart-Phillips et al. 2018, Nature CommunicationsAN-05C01-45behaviourrobust
About 9 per cent, about 90 per centSocial monogamy in mammal species against bird speciesNo primary named (Lukas and Clutton-Brock 2013 likely)AN-04C01-46behaviourrobust
2,545 species, 61 or 60 transitions, 127 of 226 or 229Monogamy evolved from solitary intolerant females, paternal care in about half of monogamous mammalsLukas and Clutton-Brock 2013, ScienceAN-04, AN-05C01-47behaviourrobust
15 to 20 per cent, 7 to 8 per centMen heavier and taller than women on averageNo primary namedAN-05C01-48physiologyrobust
468 people, 33.0 and 21.0 kg, 38.4 and 30.6 per cent, 40 and 33 per centSkeletal muscle by whole-body MRI, men and women, upper and lower body gapJanssen et al. 2000, Journal of Applied Physiology, 468 people aged 18 to 88AN-05C01-49physiologyrobust
Embodied capital, grandmother hypothesisLong childhood forces paternal provisioning and grandmother helpKaplan et al. 2000, Evolutionary Anthropology. Hawkes 2003AN-05C01-50behaviourcontested
25 baboons, 80 per cent, once a second, about 90 degreesOlive baboons in Kenya follow the number of initiators not rank, compromise under about 90 degrees, choose aboveStrandburg-Peshkin et al. 2015, ScienceAN-09C01-51behaviourrobust
34 rallies, about 3 and about 10 sneezesWild dogs in Botswana: sneezes needed to launch a hunt when a dominant or a subordinate initiatesWalker et al. 2017, Proceedings of the Royal Society BAN-09C01-52behaviourrobust
8 mammal societies, 8 human societiesLeadership compared from elephants to capuchins and from the Ache to the Tsimane: human leadership domain-specific, non-coercive, food sharing by rule, conflict leadership concentrated in bothSmith et al. 2016, Trends in Ecology and EvolutionAN-09C01-53culturerobust
43 meta-analyses, 2.51 to 5.42 per centVariance explained by the biological factor under study across ecology and evolutionMøller and Jennions 2002, OecologiaAN-09C01-54behaviourrobust
25 podsLong-finned pilot whales off Cape Breton: no reproductive conflict, no menopause, same philopatry as short-finnedMcCormack, Arbuckle and Nichols 2023, Behavioral EcologyAN-01C01-55behaviourrobust
Epiphenomenon claimPost-reproductive lifespan as a by-product, the measure depends on methodCohen 2004. Levitis (year not given)AN-01C01-56physiologycontested
Loudspeaker, contact callsThe Amboseli playback method: calls of known and unknown femalesMcComb et al. 2001, ScienceAN-02C01-57culturerobust
SignalOlder bulls carry an acoustic or chemical signal that suppresses musth in young malesInterpretation attached to Slotow 2000. No primary for the mechanismAN-02C01-58physiologyopen

The case for and the case against

The case the chapter makes

  • Menopause in five toothed whales and humans was built by adding about forty years of life, not by subtracting fertile ones (Ellis et al. 2018, Scientific Reports. Ellis et al. 2024, Nature. AN-01. C01-06, C01-08, C01-09).
  • The reason is kinship dynamics, a female's rising relatedness to her pod (Johnstone and Cant 2010. AN-01, AN-06. C01-10, C01-11), and the cost is reproductive conflict, the older female's calf dying 1.7 times as often when she breeds beside her daughter (Croft et al. 2017, Current Biology. AN-01. C01-12).
  • A post-reproductive grandmother raises her grandcalves' survival and a post-reproductive mother keeps her adult sons alive (Nattrass et al. 2019, PNAS. Foster et al. 2012, Science. Weiss et al. 2023, Current Biology. Grimes et al. 2023, Current Biology. AN-01. C01-13 to C01-16).
  • Post-reproductive females lead collective movement, most in lean salmon years (Brent et al. 2015, Current Biology. AN-01. C01-04, C01-17).
  • Matriarch age predicts an elephant family's reproductive success through social knowledge (McComb et al. 2001, Science. McComb et al. 2011, Proceedings of the Royal Society B. Gobush et al. 2008. Goldenberg et al. 2016. AN-02, AN-06. C01-19 to C01-21, C01-57).
  • Older bulls switch off musth in young males (Slotow et al. 2000, Nature. Poole 1987, 1989. Hollister-Smith et al. 2007. AN-02. C01-22 to C01-26, C01-58).
  • Bonobo female coalitions override a size disadvantage, rebuilt by every generation of immigrant females (Surbeck et al. 2025. Moscovice et al. 2019, Hormones and Behavior. AN-03, AN-06. C01-33 to C01-36), while chimpanzee males run their communities and raid (Wrangham 1999. Wilson et al. 2014, Nature. AN-03. C01-28 to C01-30).
  • Several unrelated routes lead to a female at the top: hyena, lemur, bonobo, whale, elephant (Holekamp and Strauss 2022, Strauss and Holekamp 2019, PNAS. Kappeler et al. 2022, Biological Reviews. AN-06. C01-38, C01-39).
  • Adult sex ratio, not gamete size, drives sex roles (Gowaty, Kim and Anderson 2012, PNAS. Janicke et al. 2016, Science Advances. Kokko and Jennions 2008, Journal of Evolutionary Biology. Eberhart-Phillips et al. 2018, Nature Communications. AN-05. C01-40 to C01-45).
  • Humans are mid-primate in dimorphism, with a long childhood that forces paternal and grandmaternal help (Janssen et al. 2000. Kaplan et al. 2000. Hawkes 2003. AN-05. C01-48 to C01-50).
  • Collective movement is decided by agreement among several starters more than by rank, with a rank discount (Strandburg-Peshkin et al. 2015, Science. Walker et al. 2017, Proceedings of the Royal Society B. AN-09. C01-51, C01-52).
  • Human leadership specialised, softened and fed the mammalian pattern (Smith et al. 2016, Trends in Ecology and Evolution. AN-09. C01-53).

The case against

  • The long-finned pilot whale has the same social structure as the short-finned and no menopause: 25 pods off Cape Breton, no reproductive conflict, older females help daughters breed at no penalty (McCormack, Arbuckle and Nichols 2023, Behavioral Ecology. AN-01. C01-55).
  • Post-reproductive lifespan may be an epiphenomenon, and the measure depends on method, with chimpanzees and elephants as unsettled boundary cases (Cohen 2004. Levitis. AN-01. C01-07, C01-56).
  • Chinook abundance swamps the matriarch effect: in a collapse year the probability of any female calving halves (Ward et al. 2009, Journal of Applied Ecology. AN-01. C01-18).
  • Biological factors explain 2.51 to 5.42 per cent of variance across 43 ecological meta-analyses (Møller and Jennions 2002, Oecologia. AN-09. C01-54).
  • The flagship son-mortality figure is given as 8.3 and 13.9 by two reports of the same paper (Foster et al. 2012. AN-01, AN-06. C01-14), and the opening salmon scene rests on a social-media post (C01-02).
  • Human leadership is domain-specific, non-coercive and embedded in food-sharing rules no other mammal has, so the animals are least like us where the chapter uses them (Smith et al. 2016. AN-09. C01-53).
  • Chimpanzee killing may be a human artefact (Ferguson, Horgan. AN-03. C01-31) against Wilson et al. 2014 (C01-30).
  • The ancestor may have been neither chimp-like nor bonobo-like (Suwa, Lovejoy et al. 2021, PNAS. AN-03. C01-37).
  • Bonobo females may be co-dominant rather than dominant (Parish 1996 against Surbeck and Furuichi. AN-03. C01-33).
  • Musth may not be a stress state (Ghosal et al. 2013 against Ganswindt et al. AN-02. C01-25).

Where the sources disagree

  • Whether menopause is adaptive or an epiphenomenon: Cohen 2004 and Levitis against Ellis et al. 2024 (AN-01. C01-56, C01-09).
  • The size of Foster's son effect: 13.9-fold (AN-01) against 8.3-fold (AN-06), same paper, Foster et al. 2012, Science. The data edition carried it as a range. The narrated edition says "a multiple that nobody puts below eight" (C01-14).
  • Whether chimpanzee killing is adaptive or a human artefact: Wilson et al. 2014 against Ferguson and Horgan (AN-03. C01-30, C01-31).
  • Whether the ancestor was chimp-like, bonobo-like or neither: Suwa, Lovejoy et al. 2021 (AN-03. C01-37).
  • Whether bonobo females are dominant or co-dominant: Parish 1996 against Surbeck and Furuichi (AN-03. C01-33).
  • Whether musth is a stress state: Ghosal et al. 2013, 60 wild bulls, no cortisol rise, against Ganswindt et al., four captive bulls, a rise (AN-02. C01-25).
  • Nattrass et al. 2019 grandmother hazard ratios, 4.5 and 6.7: AN-09 attributes them to Brent et al. 2015 and ties the 6.7 figure to low-salmon years, which AN-01 does not (C01-13).
  • Johnstone and Cant 2010: Proceedings of the Royal Society B (AN-01) against PNAS (AN-06) (C01-11).
  • McComb et al. 2001: 21 families (AN-02) against 39 (AN-06). AN-02 gives 39 as the 2011 lion-roar sample (C01-19, C01-20).
  • Brent et al. 2015 observation time: "thousands of hours" (AN-01) against "more than 750 hours of video" (AN-06). AN-09 gives Brent 2015 a sample of 589 whales, which is Foster 2012's sample (C01-17).
  • Surbeck et al. 2025 venue: Communications Biology (AN-03) against Primates (AN-06) (C01-33).
  • Lukas and Clutton-Brock 2013: 61 transitions and 226 monogamous species (AN-04) against 60 and 229 (AN-05) (C01-47).
  • Ellis 2024: AN-01 says the 18 species comprise "four with documented menopause and 14 without", while the same report lists five menopausal species (C01-06, C01-09).
  • AN-06 says male killer whales "rarely survive past 30", while AN-01's son effect is for sons over 30. Both may be true of a small cohort, but the primary should say (C01-03, C01-14).
  • Hyena figures: AN-06 attaches the 27-year dataset to Strauss and Holekamp 2019. The data edition attached both years to the finding (C01-38).
  • Gobush 2008 and Goldenberg 2016: AN-06 attributes the 218 females and 109 groups jointly, without saying which paper carries which figure (C01-21).
  • Ganswindt et al.: year given as 2010 and as 2021 in AN-02 (C01-25).

Open questions

Every mark for checking from the data edition, with its row.

  1. Place: North Pacific for the resident killer whales, from AN-09, not AN-01 (C01-01). The narrated edition keeps the place.
  2. K16 salmon scene, sourced to a social-media post (C01-02). The narrated edition keeps the scene without the name and does not lean on it.
  3. Johnstone and Cant first names (Rupert, Michael) and journal (C01-11). The narrated edition names neither.
  4. Croft first name (Darren) (C01-12). The narrated edition does not name him.
  5. Foster 2012 son hazard, 13.9 against 8.3 (C01-14). The primary must decide.
  6. Weiss first name (Michael) (C01-15). The narrated edition does not name him.
  7. Brent first name (Lauren) and hours of observation (C01-17). The narrated edition names neither.
  8. Ward first name (Eric) (C01-18). The narrated edition does not name him.
  9. McComb first name (Karen) (C01-19). The narrated edition carries "Karen McComb" without the marker.
  10. McComb 2001 sample, 21 families against 39 (C01-19).
  11. Wrangham first name (Richard) (C01-29). The narrated edition does not name him.
  12. Surbeck first name (Martin) and journal (C01-33). The narrated edition carries "Martin Surbeck" without the marker.
  13. Bateman first name (Angus) (C01-40). The narrated edition does not name him.
  14. Janicke 2016 effect sizes, stripped in extraction and not recoverable from the PDF text layer (C01-43). Not guessed.
  15. Lukas and Clutton-Brock transitions, 61 against 60, and monogamous species, 226 against 229 (C01-47).

Further open points carried from the data edition's working notes.

  • First names Samuel Ellis, Emma Foster and Stuart Nattrass come from the Preface, not from the research documents (C01-09, C01-13, C01-14).
  • Williams 1957 and Hamilton 1966 are given by surname and year only, as AN-01 gives them (C01-05).
  • Whether to keep the K16 scene at all given its sourcing. The narrated edition keeps the picture, drops the name, and lets the Foster and Weiss findings carry the proof.
  • Whether the seven-species menagerie paragraph in section 3 is too much. The narrated edition keeps the hyena and the lemur and drops the gorilla's numbers.
  • The vole receptor story (AN-04: Insel and Shapiro 1992, Lim and Young 2004, Aragona 2006, Berendzen 2023) was drafted and cut for length. It belongs in chapter 6.
  • Males "rarely past 30" against sons over 30 (C01-03, C01-14).

The documents

  • AN-01 Whales: matrilineal societies and menopause. The chapter's spine: Ellis, Johnstone and Cant, Croft, Nattrass, Foster, Weiss, Grimes, Brent, Ward, McCormack.
  • AN-02 Elephants: matriarchs and bull society. McComb, Goldenberg, Poole, Hollister-Smith, Ghosal, Slotow. Wittemyer 2007, Wasser 2008 and Allen 2020 cut.
  • AN-03 Great apes: four models of sex relations. Dimorphism figures, Surbeck, Wilson, Suwa, Moscovice.
  • AN-04 Pair-bonding mammals. Lukas and Clutton-Brock. Opie 2013, Murdock 1967, Henrich 2012 and the voles are held for chapters 2 and 6.
  • AN-05 Cross-species rules: what predicts sex roles. Bateman, Gowaty, Janicke, Kokko and Jennions, Eberhart-Phillips, Janssen, Kaplan.
  • AN-06 Female-dominant and female-led species. Hyena, lemur, the second Foster figure, the second McComb sample. Meerkat and mole rat cut.
  • AN-09 How mixed-sex mammal groups decide and lead. Strandburg-Peshkin, Walker, Smith, Møller and Jennions. Silk 2003 and the horse studies held for chapter 7.

Its documents in the Library

171 172 173 174 175 176 179