THRIVING after the FALL
Book Two PAIRING after the FALL

PAIRING

The numbers and sources

Preface: The Other Half of the Question

The narrated edition tells this chapter with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.

  • 1 confirmed
  • 57 open
  • 21 to check first

Read about the chapter · Its 58 rows in the log

Numbers to carry

The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.

The data edition of the Preface has no Numbers to carry list. The figures the narrated Preface keeps exact, and which the chapters rely on, are:

  • 374 women's faces on the Stern cover of 6 June 1971, "Wir haben abgetrieben!" (HC-05, P-01)
  • About 350 hours a year more paid work by East German mothers than West German mothers, a generation after reunification, and no gap for fathers (Boelmann, Raute and Schönberg 2025, AEJ: Applied, SY-06, P-10)
  • Seven years after a first child, an East German mother is back at 70 per cent of her pre-birth earnings, a West German mother at 45 per cent (Boelmann, Raute and Schönberg, SY-06, P-11)

Every figure

One row for each figure or finding in the data edition's chapter, whether or not the narrated edition kept it. Layer says whether it belongs to physiology, behaviour or culture. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.

FigureWhat it measuresStudy (authors, year, venue, N)DocumentRowLayerStatus
374 women, 6 June 1971Faces on the Stern cover, "Wir haben abgetrieben!", Romy Schneider among themStern issue 24/1971, organised by Alice SchwarzerHC-05P-01culturerobust
343 womenThe French manifesto of spring 1971 that the cover copiedAs P-01HC-05P-01culturerobust
1977Year the West German marriage-law reform ended the husband's say over his wife's employment§1356 BGB as amended 1957/58 and the 1. EheRG of 14 June 1976, in force 1 July 1977. HC-05 names no primary sourceHC-05P-02cultureopen
1958Introduction of Ehegattensplitting, secondary earner taxed at the partner's marginal rateSteiner and Wrohlich 2004, CESifo and DIW DP 421SY-06P-03culturerobust
Half-day schools, almost no public childcare under three, RabenmutterWest German institutions and stigmaRosenfeld, Trappe and Gornick 2004, Annual Review of Sociology (SY-06's own sources include a Reddit thread)SY-06P-04culturerobust
1949GDR constitution guarantees women the right to work and equal payBauernschuster and Rainer 2012, Journal of Population EconomicsSY-06P-05culturerobust
Nearly every child, late 1980sGDR public childcare coverageBauernschuster and Rainer 2012SY-06P-06culturerobust
1976, one paid yearBabyjahr with job guaranteeBauernschuster and Rainer 2012SY-06P-07culturerobust
SchmarotzerGDR label for stay-at-home mothersNo primary named (SY-06 source 11 is Reddit)SY-06P-08cultureopen
89 per cent GDR, 56 per cent FRG, 1989Female labour-force participation, working ageRosenfeld, Trappe and Gornick 2004HC-06P-09culturerobust
About 350 hours a year, no gap for fathersEast minus West maternal labour supply, a generation after reunificationBoelmann, Raute and Schönberg 2025, AEJ: Applied Economics, doi 10.1257/app.20220567, 50 per cent sample of social-security recordsSY-06P-10culturerobust
70 per cent East, 45 per cent West, seven years after first birthRecovery of pre-birth earningsBoelmann, Raute and Schönberg (SY-06 cites the 2021 ECONtribute working paper, check the published version)SY-06P-11cultureopen (paper version)
73 per centShare of the 350-hour gap attributed to working-mother stigmaBoelmann, Raute and Schönberg (SY-06 cites ECONtribute DP 405, 2026, confirm which paper carries it)SY-06P-12cultureopen (paper version)
Wife above 50 per cent of household income, SOEP 1991 to 2012, 21 yearsIn the West: more housework, job exit and divorce the following year. In the East: noneLippmann, Georgieff and Senik 2020, Economic Journal 130(629)SY-06, HC-06P-13behaviourrobust
Within a few yearsEast-to-West migrant mothers keep East behaviour, West-to-East migrants adopt itBoelmann, Raute and Schönberg 2025SY-06P-14culturerobust
N = 2,187, 541 N men, 329 N womenMean hand-grip strengthLeyk et al. 2007, European Journal of Applied Physiology 99:415 to 421HC-04P-15physiologyrobust
90 per cent of women below 95 per cent of menGrip-strength distributionsLeyk et al. 2007HC-04P-15physiologyrobust
About the 25th percentile of untrained menGrip strength of national-level female athletesLeyk et al. 2007HC-04P-15physiologyrobust
More than two standard deviationsGrip-strength gap as dSY-04 gives d above 2.0, SY-02 d about 2.5 (thesis source). Compute from Leyk 2007 means and SDsSY-04, SY-02P-16physiologyrobust in direction, open in size
About 60 per cent more muscle, most of it upper bodyMale minus female muscle massLassek and Gaulin 2009, Evolution and Human Behavior 30:322 to 328 (reports give 61 to 65 per cent)SY-01, SY-02, SO-05P-17physiologyrobust
Every famine and epidemic on recordFemale survival advantage under mortality crisesZarulli et al. 2018, PNAS 115(4)HC-01P-18physiologyrobust
11 to 16 per cent stronger humeriNeolithic Central European farming women against modern elite rowersMacintosh, Pinhasi and Stock 2017, Science Advances 3(11)HC-01P-19physiologyrobust
About 1.6 times men's body fatGluteofemoral fat as a DHA store for infant brainsLassek and Gaulin 2008, Evolution and Human Behavior 29:26 to 34SY-01P-20physiologyrobust
Menopause at around fifty, in humans and five toothed-whale species, almost no other mammalPost-reproductive lifespanEllis et al. 2024, NatureAN-01P-21physiologyrobust
Close to zero across 45 studiesCorrelation of baseline testosterone with aggressionGeniole et al. 2020, Hormones and Behavior 123 (point estimates lost in extraction, CI 0.028 to 0.080)AN-08P-22behaviourrobust
Rises with competition and winning, both sexesReactive testosteroneSY-01 via van Anders. Find Geniole et al. 2017, Hormones and BehaviorSY-01P-23physiologyrobust
Cebu cohort followed 4.5 yearsFatherhood lowers testosteroneGettler et al. 2011, PNAS 108(39). N given as 394 (SY-04), 465 (BI-02), 683 (BI-06), 624 (DH-01, DH-08). Median drops 26 per cent waking and 34 per cent evening (BI-02, DH-01, FA-03) or 20.5 per cent (CO-02)SY-04, BI-02, BI-06, DH-01, DH-08, FA-03, CO-02P-24physiologyrobust in direction, open in size
Prolactin and oxytocin rise in fathersPaternal endocrine shiftSY-01 via Hrdy, Father Time 2024. Primary studies to findSY-01P-25physiologyopen
Women in Zurich, 0.5 mg sublingual testosteroneFairer Ultimatum offers under the hormone, meaner under the beliefEisenegger et al. 2010, Nature 463:356 to 359. N given as 120 (SO-07) or 60 (BI-05)SO-07, BI-05P-26behaviourrobust
46 meta-analyses, 78 per cent small or near zeroPsychological sex differencesHyde 2005, American Psychologist 60(6)SY-01, SY-02, SY-04P-27behaviourrobust
106 meta-analyses, more than 12 million people, d = 0.21Average psychological sex differenceZell, Krizan and Teeter 2015, American Psychologist 70(1)SY-01, SY-05, CO-03P-28behaviourrobust
About 85 per cent overlap, woman outscores man 42 times in 100Arithmetic from d = 0.21SY-05's arithmetic. Recompute overlap coefficient and common-language effect sizeSY-05P-29behaviouropen (recompute)
d = 0.05 across 1.29 million pupilsMathsLindberg, Hyde, Petersen and Linn 2010, Psychological Bulletin 136(6)SY-01P-30behaviourrobust
d = minus 0.11Verbal ability, tilted to womenHyde and Linn 1988, Psychological Bulletin 104(1)SY-01P-31behaviourrobust
d = 0.93, N = 503,188Interest in things against interest in peopleSu, Rounds and Armstrong 2009, Psychological Bulletin 135(6)SY-04, HC-01P-32behaviourrobust
d about 0.45 (physical aggression), d about 0.57 (mental rotation)SY-05 via Zell 2015. HC reports give mental rotation from 0.56 to 1.0 (Voyer 1995). Settle on oneSY-05P-33behaviouropen (settle on one)
N = 10,261, Mahalanobis D = 2.71, overlap about 10 per centMultivariate personality difference, 16PFDel Giudice, Booth and Irwing 2012, PLoS ONE 7(1)SY-01, SY-04, HC-05P-34behaviourcontested
D = 2.06, overlap about 30 per centReplicationKaiser, Del Giudice and Booth 2020, Journal of Personality 88(3). HC-05 gives 2.06 or 2.10SY-01, HC-05P-35behaviourcontested
Male brains about 10 per cent larger, sex about 1 per cent of remaining structural variance"Dump the dimorphism"Eliot et al. 2021, Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews 125. AN-10 gives 11 per cent for sizeSY-01, AN-10P-36physiologyrobust
More than 1,400 brains, only a few per cent internally consistentMosaic brainJoel et al. 2015, PNAS 112(50). SY-01 gives 1.2 to 6 per cent, HC-02 0 to 8.2SY-01, HC-02P-37physiologycontested
93 per centClassifier predicting sex from structural MRIChekroud et al. 2016, PNAS 113(14)SY-01P-38physiologyrobust
1739, 1903, 1978Naturalistic fallacy (Hume, Moore), moralistic fallacy (Davis)Davis, B. D. 1978, "The moralistic fallacy", Nature 272:390. SY-02's sources are Wikipedia and a blogSY-02P-39culturerobust
No effect on testosterone, cortisol or risk-takingPower posing replicationCarney, Cuddy and Yap 2010. Ranehill et al. 2015, Psychological Science 26(5). Carney's 2016 statementSY-04P-40behaviourfallen
Null in hormone-measured replicationsOvulatory shift in preference for masculine facesSY-04 names no primary. Check Jones et al. 2018, Psychological Science, and Jünger et al. 2018SY-04P-41behaviourfallen
184 studies, 1.6 million pupils, 21 countriesSingle-sex schooling, trivial effects once controlledPahlke, Hyde and Allison 2014, Psychological Bulletin 140(4)SY-04P-42behaviourfallen (as an advantage)
396 students, women 16,215 words a day, men 15,669, range 500 to 47,000"Women talk more"Mehl et al. 2007, Science 317:82 (via PS-03 and OR-PS)SY-04, PS-03P-43behaviourfallen
No robust main effect on trust. Parochial altruism replicatesOxytocinNave et al. 2015, Perspectives on Psychological Science 10(6). De Dreu et al. 2010, Science 328:1408SY-04P-44behaviourfallen (trust), robust (parochial)
193 reigns, 18 polities, 1480 to 1913, 39 percentage pointsQueens more likely than kings to be at war in a given yearDube and Harish 2020, Journal of Political Economy 128(7)SO-01P-45culturerobust
17,637 people in 55 cultures. 80,000 people in 76 countriesGender-equality paradox in personality and preferencesSchmitt et al. 2008. Falk and Hermle 2018. Stoet and Geary 2018 (2020 correction)SY-01, HC-07, SY-04P-46behaviourcontested
About 300,000 pupils"Maths is not for girls" stereotype removes the paradoxBreda et al. 2020, PNAS 117(49)SY-01, SY-04P-47behaviourcontested
About 29 per centOut-of-sample positive predictive value of Gottman's divorce predictorsHeyman and Slep 2001, Journal of Marriage and Family 63(2)SY-01P-48behaviourrobust
45 populationsGrandmother presence raises child survival (maternal grandmother in 69 per cent of studies, father in 32, older siblings 83)Sear and Mace 2008, Evolution and Human Behavior 29(1)DH-08, FA-03P-49behaviourrobust
Share of women in a teamCollective intelligenceWoolley et al. 2010, Science 330:686. Questioned by Credé and Howardson 2017 (OR-01) or Credé et al. 2019 (SY-01)SY-01, OR-01P-50behaviourcontested
From 1991Vienna's gender-mainstreamed parks and transport, Eva KailCity of Vienna documentation to find (SO-03's sources include magazines and blogs)SO-03P-51culturerobust
175 countriesViolence against women as the best predictor of state peacefulnessHudson, Ballif-Spanvill, Caprioli and Emmett 2012, Sex and World Peace, WomanStatsSY-01P-52culturerobust
Laundry 71 per cent, cooking 58 per cent, about 20 per cent of over-burdened women contemplate separation, men with more routine domestic work report higher life satisfaction, reversion at first birthFReDA family panel, reunified GermanyBiB FReDA policy brief 2025 and Forum 1/2023SY-06P-54behaviourrobust
Sex explains about 1 per cent of brain structure, personality differs by a fifth of a standard deviationThe case against the book, restating P-36 and P-28Eliot et al. 2021. Zell et al. 2015SY-01P-36, P-28physiology, behaviourrobust
Twenty years since her last calf, Southern Resident podPlaceholder for the closing sceneCenter for Whale Research recordsAN-01P-58physiologyopen (placeholder)
18 toothed-whale species, lifespan extended about 40 yearsMenopause by lengthening life, not shortening reproductionEllis et al. 2024, Nature 627AN-01P-55physiologyrobust
13.9-fold or 8.3-foldAdult sons' mortality in the year after a post-reproductive mother's deathFoster et al. 2012, Science 337:1313. AN-01 gives 13.9, AN-06 gives 8.3AN-01, AN-06P-56behaviouropen (discrepancy)
4.5-foldGrandcalf mortality after a grandmother's deathNattrass et al. 2019, PNAS 116(52). AN-09 attributes the finding to Brent 2015AN-01, AN-09P-57behaviourrobust

The case for and the case against

The case the chapter makes

  • The West German institutions of the 1970s (husband's consent until 1977, Ehegattensplitting since 1958, half-day schools, no crèches, Rabenmutter) made the working mother a deviant. HC-05, SY-06, P-02 to P-04.
  • The GDR took the opposite bet (right to work 1949, near-universal childcare, Babyjahr 1976, Schmarotzer) and the gap in behaviour outlived the state by a generation: 350 hours a year, 70 against 45 per cent of earnings, stigma as the main explanation, migrants carrying the East's norm with them. Boelmann, Raute and Schönberg 2025. SY-06, P-05 to P-12, P-14.
  • "Doing gender" in the West and not in the East. Lippmann, Georgieff and Senik 2020. SY-06, HC-06, P-13.
  • The body kept measuring: grip strength beyond two standard deviations (Leyk 2007), female survival in famines (Zarulli 2018), the metabolic bill of gestation and lactation, menopause. HC-04, HC-01, AN-01, P-15 to P-21.
  • The Endocrine Accent: testosterone responds rather than rules. Near-zero baseline correlation with aggression (Geniole 2020), rise with competition, fall with fatherhood (Gettler 2011), fairer offers under testosterone and meaner ones under the belief (Eisenegger 2010). AN-08, SY-01, BI-02, SO-07, P-22 to P-26.
  • The Overlapping Bells: most psychological differences small (Hyde 2005, Zell 2015), yet things-people interest large (Su 2009) and the multivariate distance large (Del Giudice 2012). SY-01, SY-04, SY-05, HC-05, P-27 to P-35.
  • The two fallacies, naturalistic and moralistic (Hume, Moore, Davis). SY-02, P-39.
  • What fell: power posing, ovulatory shifts, single-sex schooling, "women talk more", oxytocin as trust hormone. SY-04, P-40 to P-44.
  • The grandmother in front: menopause as lengthened life (Ellis 2024), and the cost to sons and grandcalves of losing her (Foster 2012, Nattrass 2019). AN-01, P-55 to P-57.

The case against

  • The wall wins: institutions and stigma move whole populations of mothers, while sex explains about 1 per cent of brain structure (Eliot 2021) and a fifth of a standard deviation of personality (Zell 2015). SY-01, AN-10, P-36, P-28.
  • Against the multivariate distance: the method aggregates many small differences into one large one (the data edition's own concession, P-34, P-35).
  • Against the gender-equality paradox: the "maths is not for girls" stereotype is stronger in richer countries and removes the paradox once controlled (Breda et al. 2020, about 300,000 pupils). SY-01, SY-04, P-47.
  • Against the chapter's own reply: the FReDA findings (laundry 71 per cent, cooking 58 per cent, reversion at first birth, about 20 per cent contemplating separation, men's higher satisfaction with more domestic work) are offered as evidence of a second wall or of the accent, and the data edition says it does not know which. SY-06, P-54.

Where the sources disagree

  • Multivariate personality distance: D = 2.71 and overlap about 10 per cent (Del Giudice 2012) against D = 2.06 and overlap about 30 per cent (Kaiser 2020). HC-05 gives the replication as 2.06 or 2.10. P-34, P-35.
  • Gender-equality paradox (Schmitt 2008, Falk and Hermle 2018, Stoet and Geary 2018 with a 2020 correction) against Breda et al. 2020. P-46, P-47.
  • Mosaic brain: share of internally consistent brains given as 1.2 to 6 per cent (SY-01) or 0 to 8.2 per cent (HC-02). P-37.
  • Male brain size advantage: 10 per cent (SY-01) or 11 per cent (AN-10). P-36.
  • Collective intelligence and share of women (Woolley 2010) against Credé and Howardson 2017 (OR-01) or Credé et al. 2019 (SY-01). P-50.
  • Foster et al. 2012 son-mortality multiplier: 13.9-fold (AN-01) or 8.3-fold (AN-06). P-56.
  • Nattrass et al. 2019 grandcalf mortality: AN-09 attributes the 4.5-fold figure to Brent 2015. P-57.
  • Gettler et al. 2011 cohort size: 394 (SY-04), 465 (BI-02), 683 (BI-06) or 624 (DH-01, DH-08). Testosterone drop: 26 per cent waking and 34 per cent evening (BI-02, DH-01, FA-03) or 20.5 per cent (CO-02). P-24.
  • Eisenegger et al. 2010 sample: 120 (SO-07) or 60 (BI-05). The number was removed from the data edition's text. P-26.
  • Muscle-mass advantage: 65 per cent (SY-01), 61 to 65 per cent (SY-02), 61 per cent (SO-05). The data edition says about 60. P-17.
  • Grip-strength gap as d: above 2.0 (SY-04) or about 2.5 (SY-02, thesis source). P-16.
  • Mental rotation: d about 0.57 (SY-05 via Zell 2015) against 0.56 to 1.0 in the HC reports (Voyer 1995). P-33.
  • Boelmann, Raute and Schönberg: the 70 and 45 per cent earnings figures are cited to a 2021 working paper and the 73 per cent stigma share to ECONtribute DP 405, not to the published AEJ: Applied paper. P-11, P-12.
  • Sear and Mace 2008 shares: DH-08 gives maternal grandmothers as the most consistent helpers and fathers in about a third of populations. FA-03 gives mother 100 per cent of studies, maternal grandmother 69, father 32, older siblings 83. P-49.

Open questions

  • To be checked, from the data edition: husband's consent to a wife's employment until 1977. HC-05 gives no primary legal source. Check §1356 BGB as amended 1957/58 and the 1. EheRG of 1976/77. P-02.
  • To be checked, from the data edition: all Boelmann, Raute and Schönberg figures against the published AEJ: Applied version. P-10, P-11, P-12.
  • To be checked, from the data edition: the Foster et al. 2012 son-mortality figure, 13.9-fold or 8.3-fold. P-56.
  • To be checked, from the data edition: a named pod and matriarch for the closing scene, from AN-01 and the Center for Whale Research. "Southern Resident" and "twenty years since her last calf" are placeholders. The narrated Preface says "stopped having calves long ago" until this is settled. P-58.
  • To be checked, from the data edition: Lobberich as "a few kilometres from the Dutch border". The narrated Preface says "near the Dutch border". No row.
  • Recompute the overlap coefficient and common-language effect size for d = 0.21 (the data edition gives about 85 per cent and 42 in 100). P-29.
  • Settle on one mental-rotation effect size. P-33.
  • Find primary sources for Rabenmutter and Schmarotzer as stigma terms (SY-06's sources include Reddit). P-04, P-08.
  • Find the primary studies for prolactin and oxytocin rising in fathers. P-25.
  • Find the specific meta-analysis for testosterone rising with competition and winning (Geniole et al. 2017). P-23.
  • Find the hormone-measured replications of the ovulatory-shift finding (Jones et al. 2018, Jünger et al. 2018). P-41.
  • Find the City of Vienna's own documentation of Eva Kail's work. P-51.
  • The Davis 1978 citation rests on Wikipedia and a blog in SY-02. Check Nature 272:390. P-39.
  • The data edition's known weak points: the two German scenes are the book's own and the rest of the Preface leans on synthesis reports (SY). The grip-strength "more than two standard deviations" rests on SY-04 and SY-02, and Leyk 2007 is the safer citation. The Ellis 2024 "about forty years" is as AN-01 gives it.

The documents

The data edition of the Preface has no Library section. The research documents its verification rows cite are:

  • AN-01, AN-06, AN-08, AN-09, AN-10 (animals: whale menopause, orca mortality, testosterone and aggression, brain size)
  • BI-02, BI-05, BI-06 (biology: Gettler, Eisenegger)
  • CO-02, CO-03 (couples: Gettler, Zell)
  • DH-01, DH-08 (deep history: Gettler, Sear and Mace)
  • FA-03 (family: Gettler, Sear and Mace)
  • HC-01, HC-02, HC-04, HC-05, HC-06, HC-07 (history and culture: survival, mosaic brain, grip strength, the Stern cover and West German law, East-West participation and Lippmann, the paradox)
  • OR-01, OR-PS (organisations: Woolley and Credé, the Mehl word counts)
  • PS-03 (psychology: Mehl 2007)
  • SO-01, SO-03, SO-05, SO-07 (society: Dube and Harish, Vienna, muscle mass, Eisenegger)
  • SY-01, SY-02, SY-04, SY-05, SY-06 (synthesis: shape and candidates only, never citations)

Its documents in the Library

160 163 164 171 176 178 179 180 181 188 193 194 196 197 198 199 202 209 210 217 220 227 229 231 233 234 235 237 238 239