PAIRING · Part I · Overlapping Bells
The numbers and sources
Chapter 2: The Campfire Contract
The narrated edition tells this chapter with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.
- 80 open
- 35 to check first
Numbers to carry
The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.
- 45 populations: the maternal grandmother improves child survival almost everywhere it was measured, the father in about one third (Sear and Mace 2008, DH-08). Row C02-33.
- 183 of 185 societies assign cooking to women, and none assigns large-game hunting to women alone (Murdock and Provost 1973, DH-07). Rows C02-04 and C02-05.
- 12 per cent of adults unrelated in a camp where both sexes choose where to live, 0.6 per cent where one sex chooses (Dyble 2015, DH-03). Row C02-14.
- 17 women reproducing for every man whose paternal line survived, in the millennia around 5000 to 3000 BCE (Karmin 2015, DH-05, DH-12). Row C02-53.
- 25 homicides among about 1,500 Ju/'hoansi over 1920 to 1970, roughly 40 per 100,000 a year (Lee 1979, DH-02, DH-11). Row C02-67.
Every figure
One row for each figure or finding in the data edition's chapter, whether or not the narrated edition kept it. Layer says whether it belongs to physiology, behaviour or culture. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.
| Figure | What it measures | Study (authors, year, venue, N) | Document | Row | Layer | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hadza country north of Lake Eyasi, northern Tanzania | setting of the opening scene | general knowledge, not in the documents | none | C02-01 | culture | open |
| About 200,000 years of foraging bands | span of the unwritten ledger | Cieri et al. 2014, Current Anthropology; concept note §6 | DH-03 | C02-02 | culture | open |
| Men's arm muscle 75 to 90 per cent greater than women's | sex difference in muscle, concentrated in the arms | Lassek and Gaulin 2009, Evolution and Human Behavior | DH-01 | C02-03 | physiology | open, reports disagree (see below) |
| 50 activities, 185 societies, cooking female in 183 of 185, smelting, metalworking and large-game hunting male in 90 to 100 per cent | sex assignment of subsistence tasks across societies | Murdock and Provost 1973, Ethnology, 185 societies | DH-07, DH-10 | C02-04 | culture | robust |
| 0 of 185 societies assign large-game hunting to women alone | same tally | Murdock and Provost 1973 | DH-07 | C02-05 | culture | robust |
| Interruptibility: women's tasks are those compatible with childcare | explanation of the division | Brown 1970, American Anthropologist | DH-07 | C02-06 | culture | robust |
| Martu women hunting sand monitors provide the majority of calories in camp | women's hunting returns | Bliege Bird, Bird and Codding (Western Desert, Australia) | DH-02 | C02-07 | behaviour | robust |
| Women hunt in 50 of 63 foraging societies, large game in a third of those | prevalence of women's hunting | Anderson et al. 2023, PLOS ONE, 63 societies | DH-02, DH-11 | C02-08 | behaviour | contested |
| About 35 per cent of Anderson's societies not locatable in D-PLACE | rebuttal of the above | Venkataraman, Hames, Hagen and Kramer 2024, Evolution and Human Behavior | DH-02 | C02-09 | behaviour | contested |
| Wilamaya Patjxa, Peru: woman aged 17 to 19, about 9,000 years old, five projectile points and butchering kit; 27 comparable burials, 11 female, 16 male, read as 30 to 50 per cent female participation in big-game hunting | burial evidence for women hunting | Haas et al. 2020, Science Advances, 27 burials | DH-04 | C02-10 | physiology, reading is culture | contested |
| 30 Hadza adults, 17 women and 13 men: 2,649 against 1,877 kcal a day | daily energy expenditure by sex | Pontzer et al. 2012, PLoS ONE, N 30 (doubly labelled water is general knowledge, not in DH-02) | DH-02 | C02-11 | physiology | robust |
| Leisure divided within forager households with remarkable equality | time use by sex | Deb et al. 2024, Evolution and Human Behavior | DH-02 | C02-12 | behaviour | robust |
| Women do 70 to 90 per cent of household chores in wealthy countries | present-day chore share | no primary source named | DH-02 | C02-13 | behaviour | open |
| 1,863 Mbendjele and 4,055 Agta co-resident pairs; 12 per cent of adults unrelated when both sexes choose residence against 0.6 per cent when one sex chooses; observed Agta 11.2 per cent; Paranan farmers 4.2 per cent | kinship structure of camps as a function of who decides residence | Dyble et al. 2015, Science (DH-03 gives 191 Agta adults in 11 camps and 103 Mbendjele in 9) | DH-02, DH-03 | C02-14 | behaviour | robust |
| The Christmas ox, late 1960s, quotation "we cool his heart and make him gentle" | levelling by insult | Lee 1969, Natural History ("Canadian" and the date are general knowledge; wording to be checked) | DH-03 | C02-15 | culture | open, wording unchecked |
| 53 forager and tribal communities, reverse dominance hierarchy, sanctions in order: gossip, ridicule, ostracism, execution | levelling across societies | Boehm 1993, Current Anthropology, 53 communities (affiliation is general knowledge) | DH-03 | C02-16 | culture | robust |
| Self-domestication by execution of reactively aggressive men | theory of the levelling's effect on the species | Wrangham 2019; Wrangham 2018, PNAS | DH-03, DH-11 | C02-17 | physiology | contested, a theory |
| More than 1,400 crania, craniofacial feminisation over 200,000 years | skull change over time | Cieri et al. 2014, Current Anthropology | DH-03 | C02-18 | physiology | contested |
| 174 conversations, 122 by day and 52 at night; day 31 per cent economic and 34 per cent complaint and conflict; night 81 per cent stories, myth and healing, conflict near zero | content of Ju/'hoansi talk by time of day | Wiessner 2014, PNAS, 174 conversations | DH-03 | C02-19 | behaviour | robust |
| hxaro gift partnerships as the exit option | standing in several camps | no primary named in the row | DH-03 | C02-20 | culture | robust |
| Immediate-return against delayed-return economies | the hinge: storing means owning | Woodburn 1982, Man | DH-03 | C02-21 | culture | robust |
| Gini about 0.17 among foragers against 0.35 and above among farmers and herders; top-decile child 11 times likelier to stay in the top decile | wealth inequality and its inheritance across 21 societies | Borgerhoff Mulder et al. 2009, Science, 21 societies | DH-03, DH-05, DH-12 | C02-22 | behaviour | robust |
| About 13 million calories per child to independence | cost of a human child | Hrdy 2009 (affiliation is general knowledge) | DH-03 | C02-23 | physiology | robust |
| Humans among the roughly 3 per cent of mammal species that breed cooperatively | rarity of cooperative breeding | Hrdy 2005, 2009 | DH-01 | C02-24 | physiology | robust |
| Mothers and Others, 2009 | source of the cooperative-breeding argument | Hrdy 2009, Harvard University Press | DH-08 | C02-25 | culture | robust |
| Efe infant: 14.2 caregivers a day on average, range 5 to 24; 60 per cent of daylight with others at 18 weeks | number of hands on an infant | Ivey 2000, American Journal of Physical Anthropology | DH-08 | C02-26 | behaviour | robust |
| Aka fathers within arm's reach 47 per cent of the day, holding 57 minutes a day against mothers' 490 | fathers' share of infant care | Hewlett 1991, 15 families | DH-08 (DH-02 gives 22 per cent holding in camp, DH-01 gives 47 per cent) | C02-27 | behaviour | open, reports disagree |
| 10 per cent allocare reduces maternal care by 25 per cent and saves about 165 kcal a day | what other hands save a mother | Kramer 2018, Maya and Pumé | DH-08 | C02-28 | behaviour | robust |
| Grandmothers save a mother up to 216 kcal over nine hours | same | Meehan 2013 | DH-08 | C02-29 | behaviour | robust |
| Ju/'hoansi birth interval about 44 months, 4.7 births, nursing close to three years | fertility under on-demand nursing | Konner and Worthman 1980, Science (nursing figure stripped in extraction; weaning 2.8 years in DH-02 and DH-08) | DH-08, DH-02 | C02-30 | physiology | open |
| Grandmother hypothesis, Hadza grandmothers 1980s and 1990s | why the human female outlives her fertility | Hawkes, O'Connell, Blurton Jones, Alvarez and Charnov 1998, PNAS (affiliation is general knowledge) | DH-01, DH-02 | C02-31 | behaviour | contested, a hypothesis |
| Male provisioning model | the rival account | Lovejoy 1981, Science | DH-01 | C02-32 | behaviour | contested |
| 45 populations: maternal grandmother improves child survival in nearly every population measured; father in about a third; paternal grandmother variable, sometimes negative | which relatives keep children alive | Sear and Mace 2008, Evolution and Human Behavior, 45 populations (concept note gives 69 per cent and 32 per cent, not used in this chapter; "in London" is general knowledge) | DH-08 | C02-33 | behaviour | robust |
| Minangkabau, West Sumatra, more than 4 million, largest matrilineal group | a matrilineal society | Sanday 2002 | DH-06 | C02-34 | culture | robust |
| Khasi, Meghalaya: youngest daughter (khatduh) inherits; women historically excluded from village councils | a matrilineal society | no primary named in the row | DH-06 | C02-35 | culture | robust |
| Mosuo, Yunnan: tisese walking marriage; brothers help raise sisters' children | a matrilineal society | no primary named in the row | DH-06 | C02-36 | culture | robust |
| Haudenosaunee clan mothers name and remove sachems, veto war | women's political authority | no primary named in the row | DH-06 | C02-37 | culture | robust |
| Bachofen 1861; Gimbutas's Goddess; Eller's critique; Çatalhöyük "zero evidence of a matriarchy" | the search for a matriarchy | Bachofen 1861; Eller 2000; Meskell and Nakamura on Çatalhöyük | DH-06, DH-05 | C02-38 | culture | robust |
| Myths of matriarchy as charters for male rule, Amazon and Melanesia | reading of the myths | Bamberger 1974 | DH-06 | C02-39 | culture | robust |
| Mosuo chronic inflammation: patrilineal villages 8.4 per cent of women against 3.2 per cent of men; matrilineal 3.6 per cent of women against 6.5 per cent of men | physiology following the descent rule | Reynolds, Mattison et al. 2020, PNAS | DH-06 | C02-40 | physiology | robust |
| Maasai: 50 per cent of men and 26 per cent of women choose to compete; Khasi: 54 per cent of women and 39 per cent of men | willingness to compete by descent rule | Gneezy, Leonard and List 2009, Econometrica (N per society stripped in extraction) | DH-06 | C02-41 | behaviour | robust |
| Dimasa: no gap; Mosuo against Yi: risk gap smaller but persists | replications of the above | Chakravarty; Gong and Yang 2012 | DH-06 | C02-42 | behaviour | contested |
| 93 societies, ten independent dimensions of women's status; 88 per cent bar women from formal political leadership | structure of women's standing | Whyte 1978 (DH-07 gives 93 societies and 10 dimensions, DH-10 gives 52 variables and 88 per cent) | DH-07, DH-10 | C02-43 | culture | robust |
| Sande and Poro societies, Sierra Leone and Liberia | parallel institutions | no primary named in the row | DH-10 | C02-44 | culture | robust |
| Gê of central Brazil: men's plaza at centre, women's houses at periphery, moieties bury each other's dead | village as two halves | Maybury-Lewis 1979 | DH-10 | C02-45 | culture | robust |
| Dogon, Mali: 736 consecutive days of hut visits, hormone assays on 93 women, hut attended for 86 per cent of true menses, never in pregnancy | menstrual seclusion against hormones | Strassmann 1996, Behavioral Ecology; 1997, Current Anthropology | DH-10 | C02-46 | physiology and behaviour | contested, the reading |
| Menstrual ritual as female coalition | rival reading | Knight 1991 | DH-10 | C02-47 | culture | contested |
| 623 men, 51 populations: maternal lineages go back about twice as far as paternal | sex bias in deep ancestry | Lippold et al. 2014, Investigative Genetics | DH-12 | C02-48 | physiology | robust |
| 11 Neanderthals from Chagyrskaya and 2 from Okladnikov, Altai, about 54,000 years old, father and teenage daughter, groups of 10 to 20, more mtDNA than Y diversity | female-biased movement before our species | Skov et al. 2022, Nature, 13 individuals | DH-12 | C02-49 | physiology | robust |
| Gurgy, France: 94 individuals sequenced, 4850 to 4500 BCE, pedigree of 63 across seven generations, patrilineal, daughters absent, wives non-local by strontium | Neolithic patrilocality in one cemetery | Rivollat et al. 2023, Nature (DH-12: 94 of 128 and 63 individuals; DH-05: 94 of 110 and 64 individuals) | DH-12, DH-05 | C02-50 | physiology | open, reports disagree |
| Lech valley, southern Germany: 9 of 10 parent-offspring pairs male, mothers from up to 350 km, unrelated individuals buried without goods | Bronze Age patrilocality and status | Mittnik et al. 2019, Science | DH-12 | C02-51 | physiology | robust |
| Hazleton North, Britain, 5,700 years: one man, four women, six sons | a tomb organised around one man's sons | Fowler et al. 2021, Nature, 35 individuals | DH-12 | C02-52 | physiology | robust |
| 456 Y chromosomes, 110 populations: about 17 women per surviving male line, millennia around 5000 to 3000 BCE | the Y-chromosome bottleneck | Karmin et al. 2015, Genome Research (DH-05 dates it 8,000 to 4,000 years ago) | DH-12, DH-05 | C02-53 | physiology | open, dating disagrees |
| "The average man alive in 4000 BCE has no living descendant in the male line" | gloss on the bottleneck | report's own phrasing, no primary source | DH-12 | C02-54 | physiology | open |
| Clan warfare model of the bottleneck | explanation one | Zeng, Aw and Feldman 2018, Nature Communications | DH-05, DH-12 | C02-55 | culture | contested |
| Peaceful fission model of the bottleneck | explanation two | Guyon, Marchi, Heyer and Chaix 2024, Nature Communications | DH-05, DH-12 | C02-56 | culture | contested |
| Wealth-transmission coefficient 0.13 to 0.18 among foragers, 0.61 agropastoral; another document gives 0.37 to 0.45 | heritability of wealth by economy | Borgerhoff Mulder et al. 2009 | DH-05, DH-12 against DH-03 | C02-57 | behaviour | open, reports disagree |
| Bell Beaker into Iberia about 2500 BCE: about 40 per cent autosomal shift, 90 to 100 per cent Y replacement, same in Britain | sex-biased population replacement | Olalde et al. 2019, Science | DH-12 | C02-58 | physiology | robust |
| 89 tibiae and 78 humeri, 5300 BCE to 850 CE; Neolithic women's humeri stiffer than living elite rowers (11 to 16 per cent, carried in the Preface); up to five hours a day at the quern; legs about 12 per cent weaker by the Bronze Age | women's workload in bone | Macintosh et al. 2017, Science Advances | DH-05, DH-04 | C02-59 | physiology | robust |
| Varna, 4560 to 4450 BCE: sex-differentiated diet; Grave 43, man aged 40 to 50, more than 1 kg of gold | early wealth by sex | Higham 2007; Gaydarska 2022 | DH-04 | C02-60 | culture | robust |
| The plough as the turn against women's work | explanation | Boserup 1970 | DH-05, DH-07, DH-10 | C02-61 | culture | contested |
| Middle Assyrian Laws, about 1076 BCE, Law 40, veiling | first written rules on women | no primary named in the row | DH-05 | C02-62 | culture | robust |
| 1,231 societies: 186 strictly monogamous (about 15 per cent), 453 occasional polygyny, 588 frequent; polygyny permitted in about 85 per cent | mating systems in the ethnographic record | Murdock, Ethnographic Atlas (DH-01 about 85 per cent, DH-07 more than 80 per cent) | DH-09 | C02-63 | culture | open, reports differ |
| Chaco Canyon, New Mexico: nine individuals, 800 to 1130 CE, one mitochondrial genome across 330 years | a matrilineal dynasty | Kennett et al. 2017, Nature Communications | DH-12 | C02-64 | physiology | robust |
| Çatalhöyük: co-buried individuals often not close kin | burial not by kinship | Yaka et al. 2021, Current Biology | DH-12 | C02-65 | physiology | robust |
| 25 homicides among about 1,500 Ju/'hoansi, 1920 to 1970, 33 to 40 per 100,000 a year, 23 per cent over sexual jealousy, higher than violent US cities of the 1970s | forager homicide rate | Lee 1979 (DH-11 gives about 40 and the city comparison) | DH-02, DH-11 | C02-67 | behaviour | robust |
| Gebusi, New Guinea: 200 to 326 homicides per 100,000 | a far higher rate | Knauft 1987 | DH-11 | C02-68 | behaviour | robust |
| Aché life expectancy at birth 30 to 35 years | forager mortality | Hill and Hurtado 1996 | DH-02 | C02-69 | physiology | robust |
| Juvenile sex ratios: Agta 1.29, Aché 1.53, Batek 1.72 boys per girl | missing girls | Page and Dyble 2019 (the reading as neglect or infanticide is the chapter's, not the document's) | DH-02 | C02-70 | behaviour | open, the reading |
| Barí, Venezuela: 822 pregnancies, survival to 15 of 80 against 64 per cent (20 to 36 per cent dead, derived by subtraction) | child mortality | Beckerman 1998 | DH-08 | C02-71 | physiology | robust |
| 21 mobile forager band societies, 148 lethal events: 55 per cent single killer and victim, 85 per cent within own society, 10 of 21 with no multi-attacker killing | the case that war is not old | Fry and Söderberg 2013, Science (affiliation is general knowledge) | DH-03, DH-11 | C02-72 | behaviour | contested |
| About 15 per cent of deaths violent in non-state societies (Keeley and Pinker aggregate) used to model parochial altruism; 14 per cent from Bowles's own sample | the case that war is old | Bowles 2009, Science (the 14 per cent is not in any document and was marked (to be checked) in the data edition) | DH-11 | C02-73 | behaviour | open, (to be checked) |
| Crow Creek, South Dakota: about 60 per cent violent death, dated 1325 CE | the outlier in the aggregate, and the critique | Keeley; Pinker; Ferguson 2013 and 2015 | DH-11 | C02-74 | physiology | contested |
| Nataruk, west of Lake Turkana, Kenya: 27 individuals, about 10,000 years old, at least 10 with lethal trauma, pregnant woman with bound hands | foragers killing together | Mirazón Lahr et al. 2016, Nature (not in any DH document; carried from memory and marked (to be checked) in the data edition; the editor's note of 2026-09-30 finds it supported by SY-02, with ten of twelve intact skeletons showing lethal trauma, dated about 9,500 to 10,500 BP, and a taphonomic critique by Stojanowski et al. 2016) | none, SY-02 | C02-75 | physiology | open, (to be checked) |
| 378 crania, Neolithic Denmark and Sweden, 3900 to 1700 BCE: healed trauma 16.9 per cent of men, 9.4 per cent of women; perimortem trauma equal by sex | Neolithic violence by sex | Fibiger et al. 2013, American Journal of Physical Anthropology | DH-04 | C02-76 | physiology | robust |
| Talheim: 34 killed, struck from behind | a Neolithic massacre | no primary named in the row | DH-04, DH-05 | C02-77 | physiology | robust |
| Asparn-Schletz: 67 dead, left unburied, young women absent; Schöneck-Kilianstädten: 26 dead, legs broken, young women absent | abduction in bone | no primary named in the row | DH-05 | C02-78 | physiology | robust |
| Odds ratio 0.61 (CI 0.46 to 0.82) for developmental delay with kin alloparenting | present-day effect of other hands | Waynforth 2020, UK Millennium Cohort | DH-03 | C02-79 | behaviour | robust |
| Ghana Intestate Succession Law 1985 (PNDC Law 111), Akan: gap in hours worked between men and women widened by 41 per cent | what a written rule did to an unwritten one | no primary named in the row | DH-06 | C02-80 | behaviour | robust |
The case for and the case against
The case the chapter makes
- Foraging bands divided work by sex with great consistency across societies, and the division follows interruptibility, not strength alone: Murdock and Provost 1973 (C02-04, C02-05), Brown 1970 (C02-06), DH-07.
- The division is one of averages with large overlap: Martu women's hunting (C02-07), Anderson 2023 (C02-08), Haas 2020 (C02-10), DH-02 and DH-04.
- Neither sex was leisured: Pontzer 2012 (C02-11), Deb 2024 (C02-12), DH-02.
- Camps were built by two people deciding where to live, not by men's kinship: Dyble 2015 (C02-14), DH-02 and DH-03.
- Power was levelled by a coalition of the rank and file, with an exit: Lee 1969 (C02-15), Boehm 1993 (C02-16), Wiessner 2014 (C02-19), hxaro (C02-20), DH-03.
- The hinge is storable, heritable wealth: Woodburn 1982 (C02-21), Borgerhoff Mulder 2009 (C02-22, C02-57), DH-03, DH-05, DH-12.
- Cooperative breeding is the human invention and needed more than mothers: Hrdy 2009 (C02-23 to C02-25), Ivey 2000 (C02-26), Hewlett 1991 (C02-27), Kramer 2018 (C02-28), Meehan 2013 (C02-29), Konner and Worthman 1980 (C02-30), DH-01, DH-03, DH-08.
- The maternal grandmother is the relative who most reliably keeps children alive: Hawkes et al. 1998 (C02-31), Sear and Mace 2008 (C02-33), DH-01, DH-08.
- The ledger could be kept either way round, and physiology and behaviour follow the rule: Minangkabau, Khasi, Mosuo, Haudenosaunee (C02-34 to C02-37), Reynolds and Mattison 2020 (C02-40), Gneezy, Leonard and List 2009 (C02-41), DH-06.
- Complementarity is not equality: Whyte 1978 (C02-43), DH-07, DH-10.
- Patrilocality is older than our species and the Neolithic fixed it: Lippold 2014 (C02-48), Skov 2022 (C02-49), Rivollat 2023 (C02-50), Mittnik 2019 (C02-51), DH-12.
- The Y-chromosome bottleneck tracks heritable wealth whichever model is right: Karmin 2015 (C02-53), Zeng, Aw and Feldman 2018 (C02-55), Guyon et al. 2024 (C02-56), DH-05, DH-12.
- The farming turn is visible in women's bones and then in written law: Macintosh 2017 (C02-59), Boserup 1970 (C02-61), Middle Assyrian Laws (C02-62), DH-04, DH-05.
The case against
- Forager homicide rates exceeded those of violent modern cities: Lee 1979 (C02-67), Knauft 1987 (C02-68), DH-02, DH-11.
- Forager lives were short and not all children were wanted equally: Hill and Hurtado 1996 (C02-69), Page and Dyble 2019 (C02-70), Beckerman 1998 (C02-71), DH-02, DH-08.
- War may be old after all: Bowles 2009 and the Keeley and Pinker aggregate (C02-73), Crow Creek (C02-74), Nataruk, Mirazón Lahr et al. 2016 (C02-75), DH-11 and SY-02. Against this: Fry and Söderberg 2013 (C02-72), Ferguson's critique (C02-74), DH-03, DH-11.
- The Neolithic entries are no gentler: Fibiger 2013 (C02-76), Talheim (C02-77), Asparn-Schletz and Schöneck-Kilianstädten (C02-78), DH-04, DH-05.
- Women's hunting may be commoner than the tally admits: Anderson 2023 (C02-08) against Venkataraman 2024 (C02-09), DH-02.
- The grandmother hypothesis is a hypothesis with a rival: Lovejoy 1981 (C02-32), DH-01.
- Self-domestication is a theory: Wrangham (C02-17), Cieri (C02-18), DH-03, DH-11.
- The matrilineal reversals do not always replicate: Dimasa, Mosuo against Yi (C02-42), DH-06.
Where the sources disagree
The data edition's Contested list:
- Rates of violent death in prehistory: Fry and Söderberg 2013 (DH-03, DH-11) against Bowles 2009 and the Keeley and Pinker aggregate (DH-11) against Nataruk (not in the DH documents, SY-02 per the editor's note). Rows C02-72 to C02-75.
- Cause of the Y-chromosome collapse: Zeng, Aw and Feldman 2018 against Guyon, Marchi, Heyer and Chaix 2024 (DH-12). Rows C02-55, C02-56.
- Women hunting: Anderson 2023 against Venkataraman and colleagues 2024 (DH-02). Rows C02-08, C02-09.
- Menstrual seclusion as honesty device (Strassmann) or women's coalition (Knight) (DH-10). Rows C02-46, C02-47.
- Borgerhoff Mulder's wealth-transmission coefficient: 0.37 to 0.45 (DH-03) against 0.13 to 0.18 and 0.61 (DH-05). Row C02-57.
- Karmin's dating: 8,000 to 4,000 years ago (DH-05) against 5000 to 3000 BCE (DH-12). Row C02-53.
Report-to-report discrepancies logged in the data edition's working notes:
- Gurgy sample: 94 of 110 (DH-05) against 94 of 128 (DH-12); pedigree 64 (DH-05) against 63 (DH-12). The data edition carried 94 and 63 and named both denominators. The narrated edition carries "seven generations" only. Row C02-50.
- Borgerhoff Mulder's coefficient: 0.37 to 0.45 (DH-03) against 0.13 to 0.18 for foragers and 0.61 agropastoral (DH-05, DH-12). The data edition carried DH-05 and flagged DH-03. The narrated edition carries no figure. Row C02-57.
- Karmin's bottleneck dating: 8,000 to 4,000 years ago (DH-05) against 5000 to 3000 BCE (DH-12). Both editions use DH-12's dates. Row C02-53.
- Lassek and Gaulin's muscle figures: 61 per cent overall and 75 to 90 per cent arms (DH-01); 36 per cent lean mass and 65 per cent muscle (DH-03); 75 per cent upper body and 78 per cent upper arm (DH-11); 61 per cent, 78 per cent and 90 per cent strength (DH-09). The data edition used DH-01's arm range. The narrated edition carries no figure. Row C02-03.
- Lee's homicide rate: 33.3 to 40 per 100,000 (DH-02) against approximately 40 (DH-11). The data edition carried the range. The narrated edition carries the city comparison only. Row C02-67.
- Polygyny permitted: about 85 per cent (DH-01, DH-09 counts) against more than 80 per cent (DH-07). The data edition said about 85 per cent. The narrated edition cut the entry. Row C02-63.
- Hewlett's Aka fathers: 47 per cent within arm's reach (DH-01, DH-08), 22 per cent holding in camp (DH-02), 57 minutes a day holding (DH-08). The data edition used 47 per cent and 57 minutes. The narrated edition says "nearly half the day" and "a fraction of the time the mother does". Row C02-27.
- Dyble 2015: pairs (1,863 and 4,055, DH-02) against adults and camps (191 Agta, 103 Mbendjele, DH-03). The data edition used pairs. The narrated edition says "thousands of pairs of neighbours". Row C02-14.
- Whyte 1978: 93 societies and 10 dimensions (DH-07) against 52 variables and 88 per cent (DH-10). Row C02-43.
Open questions
marks for checking in the data edition (both removed from the narrated text, the facts carried without figures):
- Bowles 2009: "14 per cent of deaths as the figure from his own sample". Not in any DH document. SY-02 names no percentage for Bowles, only "exceptionally high" war mortality, so the 14 per cent stays to be checked against Bowles 2009, Science. Row C02-73. The narrated chapter gives no percentage.
- Nataruk: 27 people, about 10,000 years old, at least 10 with lethal trauma, pregnant woman with bound hands, Mirazón Lahr 2016, Nature. Not in any DH document; carried from memory at the parent's instruction. The editor's note of 2026-09-30 finds it supported by SY-02 (ten of twelve intact articulated skeletons with lethal trauma, about 9,500 to 10,500 BP) and notes the taphonomic critique by Stojanowski et al. 2016 in Nature. Row C02-75. The narrated chapter gives no counts.
- Whether to keep Nataruk at all, since no DH document carries it. The narrated edition keeps it, without figures, as the third position in the war paragraph.
- Whether Bowles's own 14 per cent should be replaced by the document's 15 per cent aggregate alone. The narrated edition sidesteps it by carrying no percentage.
- Sear and Mace 2008 is assigned by the concept note to chapter 9 as a headline number. This chapter uses "nearly every" and "about a third" (DH-08's wording), not the 69 per cent and 32 per cent, which chapter 9 can carry.
- Whether the Lee quotation (seven words) is acceptable as the chapter's one quotation. The narrated edition keeps it.
Facts supplied from general knowledge in the data edition, not from the documents, and carried into the narrated edition where the person is named:
- Affiliations: Boehm (University of Southern California), Hrdy (University of California, Davis), Hawkes (University of Utah), Sear ("in London"), Fry and Söderberg (Åbo Akademi University, Finland, in 2013). Lee's "Canadian" and "late 1960s" (the narrated edition keeps "late 1960s" and drops the name and nationality).
- "Lake Eyasi" for Hadza country (C02-01).
- "Doubly labelled water" for Pontzer 2012 (C02-11), cut from the narrated edition.
- First names supplied where the documents give only surnames: Randall Haas, Paula Ivey, Courtney Meehan, Melvin Konner, Carol Worthman, Sebastian Lippold, Laurits Skov, Maïté Rivollat, Alissa Mittnik, Monika Karmin, Tian Chen Zeng, Alan Aw, Marcus Feldman, Léa Guyon, Nina Marchi, Evelyne Heyer, Raphaëlle Chaix, Íñigo Olalde, Alison Macintosh, Cody Ross, Linda Fibiger, Abigail Page, Stephen Beckerman, Frank Marlowe, Kim Hill, Magdalena Hurtado, Bruce Knauft, Robert Cieri, Adam Reynolds, Siobhán Mattison, Sara Lowes, Brian Ferguson, Marta Mirazón Lahr. None of these names appears in the narrated edition's prose.
- Barí 20 to 36 per cent child deaths derived from DH-08's 80 and 64 per cent survival (C02-71).
- The reading of the juvenile sex ratios as neglect or infanticide is the chapter's, not the document's (C02-70). The narrated edition keeps the reading with "hard to read as anything but".
The documents
- DH-01 Human evolutionary trajectory of the sexes: arm muscle, provisioning models, grandmother hypothesis, cooperative breeding.
- DH-02 Contemporary foragers, division of labour and gender relations: Hadza energetics, women hunting, leisure, homicide, life expectancy.
- DH-03 How egalitarian societies keep power in check: Boehm, Lee's ox, Wiessner's fires, Woodburn, Borgerhoff Mulder, Dyble.
- DH-04 Archaeology of gender before writing: Wilamaya Patjxa, Varna, Fibiger, Macintosh's leg bones, Talheim.
- DH-05 The Neolithic turn, agriculture, property and patriarchy: Gurgy, Karmin, Boserup, mass graves, Assyrian law.
- DH-06 Matrilineal and matrilocal societies: Minangkabau, Khasi, Mosuo, Haudenosaunee, Reynolds, Gneezy, Akan law.
- DH-07 Cross-cultural databases and what correlates with women's status: Murdock and Provost, Brown, Whyte.
- DH-08 Ancestral child-rearing and alloparenting: Ivey, Hewlett, Kramer, Meehan, Konner and Worthman, Sear and Mace, Beckerman.
- DH-09 Human mating systems and sexual selection: Murdock's polygyny counts.
- DH-10 Ritual, myth and gender complementarity: Whyte's 88 per cent, Poro and Sande, Gê moieties, Strassmann.
- DH-11 Violence, warfare and the sexes: Lee's and Knauft's rates, Fry and Söderberg, Bowles, Keeley, Pinker, Ferguson.
- DH-12 What ancient DNA reveals about the sexes: Lippold, Skov, Rivollat, Mittnik, Hazleton, Olalde, Chaco, Çatalhöyük.
Also used, per the verification note: SY-02 (synthesis report) for Nataruk, supplying shape only, not a citation.