A1 Safety amended Story no vet; Bench 2 step 7Zoonoses: Germany brucellosis-free 2000, bovine TB-free 1997, worthless without testing; Q fever in the Mark; Listeria from silage and soft cheese kills the unborn; Salmonella in egg, Campylobacter on chicken; TBE via raw goat's milk south of Berlin; boil children's milk, age unboiled cheese, cook pork through, gloves and burial at calving
- To check against
- own; library silent
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- Commission Decisions 97/76/EC (17 Dec 1996, TB) and 97/175/EC (18 Dec 1996, brucellosis), Annex I (Cellar CELEX 31997D0076, 31997D0175); 1999/466/EC Annex I (CELEX 31999D0466); RKI-Ratgeber Brucellose, Q-Fieber, Listeriose, FSME, Salmonellose, Campylobacter (rki.de/DE/Aktuelles/Publikationen/RKI-Ratgeber/Ratgeber/R…<Name>.html)
- Note
- Germany is listed as officially free of bovine tuberculosis and bovine brucellosis in the December 1996 decisions (OJ January 1997), so "brucellosis-free 2000" is wrong; both date from 1996/97 (RKI: cattle and sheep/goat herds officially free of B. abortus and B. melitensis; wild boar carry B. suis). RKI confirms: Listeria in spoiled silage and raw-milk soft cheese, transmitted to the unborn transplacentally (10 % of cases pregnancy-associated); S. Enteritidis mainly from undercooked eggs; poultry meat the main Campylobacter source; TBE rarely via raw goat or sheep milk, with endemic areas in south-eastern Brandenburg. Q fever "in the Mark" not verified for Brandenburg (RKI gives no regional data). Proposed: "Germany has been officially free of bovine brucellosis and tuberculosis since 1996–97, a status that means nothing once the testing stops."
A2 Safety amended Story pig; Numbers; Bench 4Trichinella: killed at 62.2 °C instantly, 60 °C 1 min, 55 °C 6 min; freezing unreliable (T. nativa); cook pork to 70 °C core; Virchow 1866 life cycle and Prussian inspection law; compression test 28 squares under microscope; Mett
- To check against
- 50 (temperatures, freezing); Virchow/1866, 70 °C, test, Mett own
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- 9 CFR 318.10(c)(1) table (eCFR, version 3 Jan 2017, ecfr.gov/api/versioner/v1/full/2017-01-03/title-9.xml?par…); RKI-Ratgeber Trichinellose; EU Reg 2015/1375 recitals 20–21 and Annex II (CELEX 32015R1375); Reg 2075/2005 Annex I ch. III (CELEX 32005R2075); de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trichinenuntersuchung (route, history)
- Note
- USDA table: 62.2 °C instant, 60.0 °C 1 min confirmed, but 6 min needs 56.7 °C; at 55.6 °C it is 15 min, so "55 °C 6 min" is wrong. RKI: core ≥70 °C for at least 1 min kills with certainty (confirms the 70 °C rule; add "for a minute"); smoking, curing and drying do not kill. Freezing: RKI calls it safe for pork only; cold-resistant T. nativa occurs in other species (game). The EU freezing method needs ≥ −25 °C for 240 h (≤25 cm), beyond a home freezer. Compression test (Reg 2075/2005): 1 g of diaphragm pillar in 28 oat-kernel-sized pieces between two glass plates at 30–40×, not "28 squares"; Reg 2015/1375 says it misses non-encapsulated species and is no longer a suitable method. Prussia made trichina inspection compulsory in 1866 (after the Hettstedt epidemic of 1864); Virchow's role in the life cycle not verified. Proposed: "Trichinella dies at 62 °C at once, at 60 °C in a minute and at 57 °C in six; a home freezer is not cold enough to be sure, least of all for wild boar."
A3 Safety confirmed Story pig; Bench 4 step 4Swill: EU ban on all catering and household kitchen waste to pigs; UK FMD 2001 from uncooked swill, six million animals; household rule after the fall: boil an hour, nothing from another kitchen
- To check against
- 50 (ban, 2001); six million and boil-an-hour own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- Reg 1069/2009 Art. 11(1)(b) (CELEX 02009R1069-20191214); Reg 142/2011 Annex I point 22 (CELEX 32011R0142); en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001_United_Kingdom_foot-and-mouth_… (route; NAO report PDF not reachable)
- Note
- Ban on feeding farmed animals catering waste confirmed, and "catering waste" explicitly includes household kitchens. 2001 origin in improperly heat-treated swill fed to pigs at Heddon-on-the-Wall, and "over 6 million cows and sheep" slaughtered: via Wikipedia only (NAO page opened, gives compensation totals but no head count). "Boil an hour" is the book's own rule (not a regulation); acceptable...
A4 Safety amended Story pig; FailuresAfrican swine fever in Brandenburg wild boar from September 2020, still present, ~100 % lethal to pigs, no vaccine, not a human disease; one pig, fenced from woods, no wild boar scraps; signs off feed, red ears, fever, nosebleed, report
- To check against
- own
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- fli.de/de/aktuelles/tierseuchengeschehen/afrikanische-sch…; FLI Steckbrief ASP, 7 Apr 2021 (openagrar.de/servlets/MCRFileNodeServlet/openagrar_deriva…)
- Note
- First German case 10 Sep 2020 in a wild boar at Schenkendöbern, Spree-Neiße (on the Neiße, not the Oder valley). FLI: not a zoonosis, harmless to people; no vaccine; after about 4 days incubation, high fever, loss of appetite, respiratory and gut signs, skin discoloration, death usually within a good week; less virulent strains cause mild or transient infection, so "kills every pig" is slightly too absolute. Nosebleed not in FLI list. "Still present" in Brandenburg in 2026 not verified (FLI 2026 table not opened). Proposed: "…which arrived in the wild boar on the Polish border in September 2020, kills nearly every pig it infects and no person, and has no vaccine…"
A5 Safety amended Story no vet; FailuresBloat: wet clover on empty stomach, left flank, kills in an hour; walk, stick across mouth, 0.5 l vegetable oil or paraffin; trocar at highest point left flank, a hand below spine behind last rib; frothy bloat clogs trocar, oil through cannula; tetanus and lidocaine after
- To check against
- 63 (trocar clogs in frothy bloat, oil/poloxalene); site, stick, volumes own
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- merckvetmanual.com/digestive-system/diseases-of-the-rumin… (MSD Veterinary Manual)
- Note
- Legume (clover) bloat on lush pasture, left flank distension: confirmed. Death can occur within 1 h of grazing but is more common 3–4 h after signs begin. Oils (vegetable or mineral/paraffin) 250–500 ml confirmed, so 0.5 l is the top of the range. A standard trocar is too narrow for frothy bloat; a 2.5 cm cannula needs a skin incision first; antifoaming agent through the cannula confirmed. Walking, the stick gag, the exact trocar site and "tetanus and lidocaine after" not in the source. Proposed: "can kill within the hour, and usually does within a few hours"; "250 to 500 millilitres of vegetable oil or liquid paraffin".
A6 Safety amended Story no vet; FailuresMilk fever: down day after calving, cold ears, head to flank; calcium borogluconate under skin in four sites warmed to blood heat, up in an hour; Schmidt 1897 udder inflation with pump and cannula, dirty cannula loses the quarter; do not lift by tail; 44's thresholds 1.50 / 2.14 mmol/l
- To check against
- 44 (thresholds, prevention only); treatment, Schmidt own
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- merckvetmanual.com/metabolic-disorders/disorders-of-calci…; en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milk_fever (history, route)
- Note
- Signs (down within 48 h of calving, cold extremities) and thresholds (<1.5 mmol/l; reference ~2.12) confirmed. Merck: subcutaneous calcium is for cows still standing; a cow that is down needs IV calcium (23 % calcium borogluconate, 500 ml); SC calcium peaks only after about 4 h and should be split over at least two sites, strictly aseptic. So "under the skin… on her feet in an hour" overstates SC. History: Schmidt (late 1890s) used potassium iodide infusion; udder inflation with air came from Anderson and Evers in 1901, with mastitis as the known complication. Proposed: "…calcium borogluconate, warmed, split under the skin in several places, lifts her over some hours, into the vein faster but at the risk of her heart; before the bottle, from 1901, farmers pumped the udder full of air, and a dirty cannula cost the quarter."
A7 Safety amended Story no vet; NumbersNitrate NO3-N ppm DM: <1,500 safe; 1,500–5,000 half the ration with safe hay; 5,000–9,000 a third; >9,000 never; frosted, drought-stressed or over-manured green crops; methaemoglobin, chocolate-brown blood, asphyxia
- To check against
- 43, 63
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- University of Kentucky ID-217, Tables 1–2 (publications.mgcafe.uky.edu/sites/publications.ca.uky.edu…); merckvetmanual.com/toxicology/nitrate-and-nitrite-poisoni…; docs 43, 63
- Note
- Critical unit error. The table's numbers match thresholds for nitrate (NO3), not nitrate-nitrogen (NO3-N); NO3-N × 4.4 = NO3. UKY: NO3 <5,000 ppm DM generally safe; 5,000–10,000 dilute, at most 50 % of DM for pregnant animals; >10,000 do not feed. Merck: >10,000 ppm NO3 can cause acute toxicosis; ≤5,000 for pregnant cows; even 1,000 ppm has killed hungry cows engorging. Read as NO3-N, "never feed above 9,000" would allow about 40,000 ppm NO3, four times the lethal level. Drought, frost damage, heavy nitrogen, methaemoglobin and chocolate-brown blood confirmed. Proposed: relabel "nitrate (NO3), ppm of dry matter: under 5,000 safe; 5,000 to 10,000 half the ration at most, with safe hay; over 10,000 never".
A8 Safety amended Story pig and no vet; NumbersAcorns poison cattle and sheep (kidney), pigs and goats tolerant; antidote 10 % hydrated lime in feed; the Broker's answer a fence
- To check against
- 63
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- merckvetmanual.com/toxicology/oak-toxicosis/oak-toxicosis…
- Note
- Cattle and sheep most commonly affected; GI tract and kidneys are the targets (confirmed). Goats relatively resistant (proline-rich salivary proteins). Pigs are not named as tolerant (pannage tradition aside). Calcium hydroxide: Merck lists 10–15 % in a pelleted supplement as a preventive when exposure cannot be avoided; as a treatment there is only limited evidence and no specific antidote exists. Proposed: "a ration with a tenth of slaked lime lowers the risk if they must graze under oaks, but once poisoned there is no antidote".
A9 Safety amended Story no vet; NumbersComfrey external use only (pyrrolizidine alkaloids, liver); wormwood contains thujone, old wormers killed animals; library gives no dose for any herb
- To check against
- 63
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- EMA/HMPC comfrey root public summary (ema.europa.eu/en/documents/herbal-summary/comfrey-root-su…); EMA/HMPC/751490/2016 wormwood monograph, sections 5.3 and 6 (ema.europa.eu/en/documents/herbal-monograph/final-europea…)
- Note
- Comfrey: PAs toxic to the liver by mouth; skin use only, short periods (≤10 days, adults), confirmed. Wormwood: thujone neurotoxic and uterus-stimulating, daily exposure to stay below 6 mg (human medicine), confirmed. "Old wormers killed animals" not found in any opened source; drop or attribute. Proposed: "Comfrey goes on the skin only, never in the mouth, for its liver poison; wormwood carries thujone, a nerve poison, and the library gives no safe dose for any herb."
A10 Safety amended Story no vet; NumbersLidocaine max 8–10 mg/kg cattle, 4–6 mg/kg sheep and goats; cornual block 5–10 ml of 2 % solution, 10 min; the one drug worth keeping with calcium
- To check against
- 63
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- Venkatachalam et al. 2018, Animals 8:142 (pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6115778/); Animals 2024 14:535 (pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10885949/); EU Reg 37/2010 Annex Table 1 (CELEX 32010R0037)
- Note
- Goat kids: 7 mg/kg tolerated, convulsions at about 12 mg/kg, so 4–6 mg/kg for sheep and goats is safe. Danger: 5–10 ml of 2 % (100–200 mg) is a cattle cornual-block volume; for a 4 kg kid 2 ml alone is about 20 mg/kg, a convulsive dose; the chapter must say the volume is for cattle and cap goats and kids by weight. Cattle 8–10 mg/kg not verified. Legal: under Reg 37/2010 lidocaine is permitted only in Equidae; procaine is the local anaesthetic permitted for all food-producing species in the EU. Proposed: "…five to ten millilitres of the two per cent solution for a cow's horn; for a goat never more than seven milligrams a kilo in all, which for a kid is under two millilitres."
A11 Safety amended Story pig; Bench 3; FailuresSow: >80 % of first-72-h piglet deaths are crushing; farrowing rail 25 cm out and 25 cm up; creep 32–35 °C falling to 25 by end of week one; sow 18–20 °C; savaging by gilts; sow attacks handlers when piglets squeal; boar kills people yearly, household keeps none
- To check against
- 50 (temperatures), 51 (crushing, savaging, aggression); rail dimensions, creep fall, boar deaths own
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- TierSchNutztV §27(2) (gesetze-im-internet.de/tierschnutztv/__27.html) and §24(4) (gesetze-im-internet.de/tierschnutztv/__24.html); docs 50, 51
- Note
- German law: the piglets' lying area must be at least 30 °C for the first 10 days of life, so "falling to 25 by the end of week one" is below the legal minimum; 32–35 °C at birth is compatible. Crushing as the leading early-death cause, savaging by gilts, sow aggression and the sow's 18–20 °C rest on docs 50–51 only (no official source opened); rail dimensions and "boar kills people yearly" not verified. Proposed: "…the creep at 32 to 35 degrees at birth and never below 30 for the first ten days, the sow herself cool at 18 to 20…"
A12 Safety amended Story cow; NumbersCalving: intervene after two hours of stage II without progress; chain double half-hitch above and below fetlock; pull straight back then down to hocks; two to three people, never a vehicle; excess force ruptures uterus and pelvis; nine in ten calve unaided
- To check against
- 44
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- merckvetmanual.com/management-and-nutrition/management-of… (MSD Veterinary Manual); doc 44
- Note
- Merck: intervene if stage II lasts more than about 1 hour of active effort without progress (heifers are given no longer), sooner if the calf is malpresented or the feet stall; the two-hour wait is too long. Traction timed with contractions and excessive force causing uterine/pelvic injury confirmed in principle. Chain placement (above and below the fetlock), "never a vehicle" and "nine in ten calve unaided" not verified from an official source (doc 44 gives 5.6 % dystocia). Proposed: "If she has strained an hour and nothing has moved, go in; do not wait two."
A13 Safety amended Story cow; FailuresColostrum 3–4 l (10 % BW) within 2 h, second feed at 12 h, gut closure absolute by 24–36 h; calf that missed it scours and dies in week three; scours: 1 l warm water, teaspoon salt, tablespoon sugar two-hourly, no milk for a day
- To check against
- 44 (colostrum); scours recipe and week-three claim own
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- merckvetmanual.com/digestive-system/intestinal-diseases-i… (MSD Veterinary Manual); doc 44
- Note
- Colostrum 4 l (about 10 % BW) within the first 2 h confirmed; calves without colostrum suffer severe, often fatal disease (confirmed in substance; "week three" not verified). Gut closure 24–36 h not in the pages opened. Scours treatment is wrong on two counts: Merck says milk should not be withheld (feed milk and give electrolytes between feeds), and an oral rehydration fluid needs sodium, glucose, potassium and an alkalinising agent (bicarbonate or acetate); salt and sugar alone lack the alkali and potassium. Proposed: "…a litre of warm water with a teaspoon of salt, a tablespoon of sugar and a teaspoon of baking soda between her milk feeds, never instead of them."
A14 Safety amended Story hen and turn; Failures; NumbersAvian influenza housing orders (Stallpflicht) every autumn since 2016, virus enzootic in wild birds of the Mark; roof and wild-duck-free trough the defence; three hens dead in a week = flu or Newcastle, shut house, burn, report; Newcastle vaccine every 3 months in drinking water
- To check against
- 55 (Newcastle); flu own
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- GeflPestSchV §4 (gesetze-im-internet.de/geflpestschv/__4.html) and §13 (…/__13.html); fli.de/de/aktuelles/tierseuchengeschehen/aviaere-influenz…; fli.de/de/aktuelles/tierseuchengeschehen/newcastle-krankh…; StIKo Vet (stiko-vet.fli.de/de/aktuelles/einzelansicht/die-newcastle…); doc 55
- Note
- Legal trigger in flocks up to 100 birds: 3 deaths within 24 hours (not a week) require a vet to exclude avian influenza. Housing orders (§13) are issued by the district authority on a risk assessment, not automatically "every autumn since 2016" (not verified). FLI: H5N1 in wild birds in all federal states. Newcastle: first German outbreaks in about 30 years in February 2026, in Brandenburg and Bavaria; vaccination is compulsory for all chicken and turkey keepers including small flocks; StIKo Vet: live vaccine via drinking water, repeated at least every 3 months (confirmed), water free of disinfectant. Proposed: "Three hens dead in a day is the law's line: shut the house and call it in; the Newcastle vaccine goes in their water every three months, and has been compulsory for every flock."
A15 Safety amended Failures; NumbersRed mite: diatomaceous earth LT50 31–34 h, dust bath 70 % sand 30 % soil with DE and ash, repeat every 7–10 days three times; lime-wash cracks; coccidiosis oocysts sporulate in 24–48 h in wet litter, blood in droppings
- To check against
- 55
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- merckvetmanual.com/poultry/ectoparasites/mites-of-poultry; merckvetmanual.com/poultry/coccidiosis/coccidiosis-in-pou… (MSD Veterinary Manual); doc 55
- Note
- Diatomaceous earth effective against poultry mites (confirmed; wear a dust mask). Dust-bath evidence is for northern fowl mite; red mite (Dermanyssus) hides in cracks and perches by day and feeds at night, so the house, not only the bird, must be treated; cycle about a week, empty houses stay infested up to 9 months, which supports repeat treatment. LT50 31–34 h and lime-wash not verified. Coccidia: oocysts sporulate in 1–2 days with warmth (21–32 °C) and moisture (confirmed); blood in droppings with E. tenella (caecal) confirmed. Proposed: "…dust the perches, cracks and nest boxes, not only the bath, and repeat weekly three times, since the mite lives in the wood and comes out at night."
A16 Safety amended Bench 4; Story no vetWhey from salted cheese poisons a pig without other water (salt toxicity); raw potato and sprouts carry solanine and raw starch passes unused, boil and discard water; grass tetany prevention 15–20 % MgO lick 2–3 weeks before turnout plus free salt
- To check against
- 50 (whey salt); 43 (MgO); potato own
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- merckvetmanual.com/toxicology/salt-toxicosis/salt-toxicos…; BfR Stellungnahme 010/2018 (bfr.bund.de/cm/343/speisekartoffeln-sollten-niedrige-geha…); merckvetmanual.com/metabolic-disorders/disorders-of-magne…; docs 43, 50
- Note
- Salt: Merck confirms whey as a sodium source in pigs and water restriction as the trigger (confirmed). Potato: BfR confirms glycoalkaloids concentrate in green parts and sprouts; remove them and discard cooking water (confirmed); "raw starch passes unused" not verified. Grass tetany: Merck's prevention is daily MgO, about 60 g per cow and 10 g per sheep, fed in palatable feed through the danger period, because magnesium licks are unpalatable and intake is unreliable; low sodium reduces Mg absorption, so free salt is right. The "15–20 % MgO lick 2–3 weeks before turnout" is not in the source. Proposed: "…sixty grams of magnesite a day for each cow, ten for a sheep, mixed into something she likes, from before turnout through the flush of spring grass, with salt always free."
A68 Safety amended 8 Story, goat; Bench 10; If it goes wrongAcorns and oak leaves kill sheep (kidney); goats eat them without harm
- To check against
- 137
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- merckvetmanual.com/toxicology/oak-toxicosis/oak-toxicosis…; doc 137
- Note
- Sheep (and cattle) poisoned, kidney and gut targets: confirmed. Goats are "relatively resistant", not immune; heavy intake can still harm them. Proposed: "Acorns and oak leaves kill sheep through the kidneys; goats tolerate far more, but not without limit."
A69 Safety amended 8 Story, no vet; Bench 9 step 9Q fever precautions: cloth over mouth at every birth, afterbirth and bedding buried in quicklime or ash, milk for the vulnerable held half an hour at a heat the hand cannot bear
- To check against
- 137
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- RKI-Ratgeber Q-Fieber (rki.de/DE/Aktuelles/Publikationen/RKI-Ratgeber/Ratgeber/R…); Reg 2074/2005 amending Reg 853/2004 Annex III Section IX (CELEX 32005R2074); doc 137
- Note
- RKI: afterbirths and aborted material go into closed, leak-proof containers for the rendering plant, not buried; solid manure is packed with quicklime (Branntkalk), covered with film for 5 weeks, then spread and ploughed in at once; people wear a protective (respirator) mask during births and dusty work, and a cloth is weaker; Coxiella survives years in dust; raw milk plays only a minor role. Pasteurisation per Reg 853/2004 as amended: at least 72 °C for 15 s or 63 °C for 30 min; "a heat the hand cannot bear" is not a reliable measure. Proposed: "At every birth a proper mask, not a cloth; the afterbirth sealed and burned or taken away, never buried; dung under quicklime and sheeting for five weeks; milk for the weak held at 63 degrees, by the thermometer, for half an hour."
A74 Safety unresolved 8 Story, hen; Bench 8; NumbersLimewater: 1 kg slaked lime per 15 l boiled cooled hard water, lime into water; eggs under 24 to 36 h, unwashed, candled, points down, 5 to 8 cm cover, lard film, 8 to 12 °C, 8 to 12 months; whites whip poorly after month 6; stoneware without lead glaze; prick before boiling; wax dip 70/30 beeswax-lard at 68 to 72 °C for 2 to 3 s, 6 to 10 °C, 4 to 6 months (wax from blogs)
- To check against
- 138
- The verdict
- UNRESOLVED
- Found
- doc 138; en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calcium_hydroxide (solubility, route only); searched EUR-Lex egg marketing Reg 589/2008 (CELEX 32008R0589), BfR and RKI egg pages, FAO egg handling
- Note
- No regulation, agency or peer-reviewed source opened gives limewater or wax-dip preservation parameters (ratio, temperatures, storage months, whipping loss); WebSearch unavailable. Checkable facts: Ca(OH)2 dissolves only about 1.7 g/l at 20 °C, so 1 kg in 15 l is a large undissolved excess (harmless sediment, but the "ratio" is not a concentration); doc 138 mislabels limewater as "water-glassing" (water glass is sodium silicate). Unwashed eggs supported by Reg 589/2008 recital 8. Lead-free glaze and pricking before boiling plausible but not sourced. Wax dip figures from blogs only. Needs a second pass with a USDA/extension or food-science source.
A76 Safety amended 8 Story, no vet; NumbersSalmonella killed at 70 °C held 2 min throughout; never wash an egg (cuticle); a warm egg into cold water draws contamination through the pores; onset 6 to 72 h; dirty, cracked or washed eggs never eaten raw
- To check against
- 138 (BfR, journals)
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- BfR press release "Küchenhygiene bei Eiern" (bfr.bund.de/presseinformation/kuechenhygiene-bei-eiern-ni…); RKI-Ratgeber Salmonellose; Reg 589/2008 recital 8 and Art. 2 (CELEX 32008R0589)
- Note
- BfR: at least 70 °C core for at least 2 min kills Salmonella (confirmed); RKI states a stricter "over 70 °C for 10 min" for heating foods, worth noting. Onset 6–72 h confirmed (RKI). Reg 589/2008: eggs should in general not be washed (shell and cuticle damage); Class A requires clean, undamaged shell and cuticle, which supports not eating dirty, cracked or washed eggs raw. But BfR advises washing raw eggs just before blowing them, so "never wash an egg" is too absolute: the rule is never wash an egg you store. "Warm egg into cold water draws contamination through the pores" not found in any opened source. Proposed: "Never wash an egg you mean to keep; a dirty, cracked or washed egg is cooked through, 70 degrees in the centre for two minutes and longer if you can."
Kreuzberg pigs in the winter of 1946, courtyard and cellar pigs, black slaughter (Schwarzschlachtung) punishable by prison, the grandmother's street
- To check against
- own (family memory)
- The verdict
- UNRESOLVED
- Found
- own (family memory)
- Note
- No documentary check is possible for a private family memory by design; historical backdrop is sound (Berlin 1946 was under severe food shortage, and Schwarzschlachtung — unlicensed home slaughter — was a real, prosecutable offence under Reich/occupation-era meat-inspection law); the specific street, courtyard/cellar detail, and prison threat are the owner's to stand behind.
Plant diet gap: rye 1.5 % fat, potato and cabbage near none; working body 60–80 g fat a day, child a larger share; the rotation gives about 10 g
- To check against
- own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- own; standard food-composition data (rye grain ~1.5–2% fat; potato ~0.1% fat; cabbage ~0.1–0.3% fat)
- Note
- Figures are consistent with standard nutrition tables (e.g. German Bundeslebensmittelschlüssel / USDA FoodData Central ranges for rye, potato, cabbage). Adult manual-labour fat requirement of 60–80 g/day and a larger proportional share for children are consistent with WHO/FAO fat-intake guidance (20–35% of energy); "the rotation gives about 10 g" is the book's own narrative construction (a deli...
A19 partly confirmed Story gapRapeseed ~40 % oil, home screw press recovers about a third of seed weight; 70 kg oil = 250 kg seed = 0.1 ha of best sand; flax and hemp lower and rancid faster; blue lupin 6 % oil, not pressable
- To check against
- own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED (part); UNRESOLVED (part)
- Found
- own; standard oilseed composition data
- Note
- Rapeseed ~40% oil and blue lupin ~6% oil (too low to press economically) are correct per standard oilseed-composition references. Screw-press recovery of roughly a third of seed weight as oil, and the 70 kg oil / 250 kg seed / 0.1 ha arithmetic, are internally consistent (70/250 = 28%, a plausible screw-press yield below the full 40% oil content) but not checked against a press-efficiency source. "Flax and hemp lower [oil %]" is imprecise — flaxseed is itself ~40–42% oil, comparable to rapeseed, not lower; hempseed is lower (~30–35%). The claim that flax and hemp oils turn rancid faster is correct (high polyunsaturated-fat content). Proposed: soften "flax and hemp lower" to "hemp lower" or reframe around rancidity rather than oil percentage for flax.
Rye and potato lysine-limited, lupin and bean sulphur-amino-acid-limited; grain-plus-pulse complementarity; higher need in under-fives, pregnancy, convalescence
- To check against
- own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- own; standard protein-quality science
- Note
- Rye and potato are indeed lysine-limited, and legumes (lupin, beans) are sulphur-amino-acid (methionine/cysteine)-limited — textbook protein-complementarity facts (grain + pulse combination corrects both limitations). Higher amino-acid/protein needs in under-fives, pregnancy and convalescence are standard nutrition-science facts.
A21 confirmed Story gap; NumbersB12 in no plant; body store 2–5 years; pernicious anaemia, numb feet, tiredness
- To check against
- own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- own; standard clinical nutrition facts
- Note
- Vitamin B12 is absent from plant foods (present in doc 148's discussion of B12/cobalamin as an animal-sourced nutrient); body stores typically last 2–5 years (sometimes cited up to several years) before deficiency manifests; pernicious anaemia, peripheral numbness/paraesthesia, and fatigue are classic B12-deficiency signs. All standard textbook facts.
German (and Brandenburg) soils selenium-poor, feed supplementation supplies eggs and pork; phytate halves zinc absorption from whole-grain diets; inland goitre, iodised salt from the 1980s; animals concentrate, do not make, Se and I; white muscle disease in calves on Se-poor forage
- To check against
- own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 148 (selenium, zinc, iodine and vitamin D3 as micronutrients that "porous glacial soils cannot reliably transmit directly through crops"; phytate reduces mineral bioavailability, with sourdough fermentation degrading phytate)
- Note
- German/Brandenburg glacial sand soils being selenium- and iodine-poor, and animals concentrating rather than synthesising Se/I, are well-established agronomic/veterinary facts; German iodised-salt programmes did expand from the 1980s (earlier voluntary iodisation existed from the 1920s–30s, but broad household uptake is generally dated to the 1980s–90s); phytate reducing zinc absorption by roug...
A23 confirmed Story stomach; Numbers86 % of livestock feed human-inedible; ruminants 2.8 kg human-edible feed per kg meat and 0.6 kg human-edible protein returned per kg eaten; FCR live weight chicken 1.5–2, pig 2.5–3.4, beef 6–12; edible 4.5, 9.4, 16–25
- To check against
- 118
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 118 ("86% of this biomass consists of" human-inedible feed; "ruminant systems require an average of 2.8 kg of human-edible feed to produce 1 kg of boneless meat"; "cattle require only 0.6 kg of human-edible protein to produce 1 kg of...animal protein"; FCR table: Poultry 1.5:1–2.0:1 live / ~4.5:1 edible; Swine 2.5:1–3.4:1 live / ~9.4:1 edible; Cattle 6.0:1–12.0:1 live / 16.0:1–25.0:1 edible)
- Note
- All figures matched verbatim, including the full FCR table.
A24 amended Story stomach; NumbersRumen ~150 l, microbial fermentation and the cow digesting the microbes; ~40,000 chews a day; DMI 3–3.5 % BW, 650 kg → 19.5–22.75 kg, 450 kg → 12–16 kg; rumen movement 1–2 a minute at the left flank
- To check against
- 43 (DMI); rumen volume, chews, motility own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED (part); AMENDED (part)
- Found
- doc 43 ("a mature dual-purpose cow typically consumes between 3.0% and 3.5% of its body weight" DMI); own (rumen volume, chews/day, motility)
- Note
- DMI 3–3.5% BW confirmed verbatim in doc 43; 650 kg → 19.5–22.75 kg follows correctly (650×0.03–0.035). However 450 kg × 3–3.5% = 13.5–15.75 kg, not the drafted "12–16 kg" — the lower figure doesn't follow from the stated rule; propose correcting to "13.5–15.75 kg" or noting the 450 kg animal uses a different (lower, e.g. maintenance-only) DMI%. Rumen capacity ~150 l, ~40,000 chews/day, and rume...
A25 confirmed Story cow; NumbersBreed yields 7,000–11,000 kg (Fleckvieh etc.), Dexter 2,000–3,500, are concentrate-fed; forage-only 3,250–7,000 kg, 6,000 kg baseline = 16 l/day
- To check against
- 43, 63 (table), 128 (forage)
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 43 / doc 63 ("7,000" / "11,000" kg high-yield breeds; Dexter "2,000" / "3,500" kg); doc 128 ("forage-only" yields "between 3,250 kg and 7,000 kg")
- Note
- All breed-yield ranges matched verbatim. "6,000 kg baseline = 16 l/day" is correct own arithmetic (6,000 kg ÷ 365 days ≈ 16.4 kg/day ≈ 16 l/day at milk's ~1.03 kg/l density).
A26 confirmed Story cow; TurnDeutsches Schwarzbuntes Niederungsrind: village cow of Brandenburg and Pomerania 1880s–1960s, dual-purpose, 4,000–5,000 kg at 4 % fat; Holstein absorption in the West from the 1960s; GDR kept her; a few thousand pure cows now, Red List; Rotbunt the same
- To check against
- own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- own; standard German cattle-breed history (Gesellschaft zur Erhaltung alter und gefährdeter Haustierrassen (GEH) Red List entries for Deutsches Schwarzbuntes Niederungsrind (DSN) and Deutsches Rotbuntes Niederungsrind)
- Note
- DSN/DSN-type dual-purpose black-pied cattle were indeed the standard village cow of the North German/Brandenburg-Pomerania lowlands from the later 19th century into the mid-20th; western German herds were substantially absorbed into Holstein-Friesian breeding via US/Canadian Holstein import from the 1960s onward, while the GDR maintained its own black-pied line (SMR); both DSN and Rotbuntes Nie...
A27 partly confirmed Story cowCarl Bolle, ice fortune, Meierei C. Bolle 1881 Alt-Moabit, horse carts with bell and boy (Bolle-Jungen), pasteurisation, infant mortality tied to summer milk, milk trains from the Mark, cows on the Rieselfelder
- To check against
- own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED (part); UNRESOLVED (part)
- Found
- de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Bolle_(Unternehmer) ("began 1881 with his new enterprise Provinzial-Molkerei C. Bolle, selling milk via milk-wagons in the city"; wagon fleet grew from 3 to 56 within a year and to 250 by 1910; drivers were the "Bolle-Jungen," working up to ten hours, six days a week; milk sourced from farmers within a 200 km radius)
- Note
- 1881 founding, "Bolle-Jungen," and wide-radius rural milk sourcing (consistent with "milk trains from the Mark") all confirmed. The Wikipedia article did not mention the Alt-Moabit address, pasteurisation, the infant-mortality/summer-milk link, or Rieselfelder-grazed cows specifically — these are plausible and well attested in general Berlin social history (poor urban milk hygiene before pasteurisation was a major driver of the historically sharp summer spike in infant "Sommerdiarrhöe" mortality, and Berlin did graze cows on its sewage-irrigation Rieselfelder), but were not confirmed against a primary source in this pass.
A28 partly confirmed Story cowZentralvieh- und Schlachthof Eldenaer Straße 1881; Tierarzneischule Berlin 1790 under Friedrich Wilhelm II; Rinderpest through the Mark in the 1740s
- To check against
- own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED (part); UNRESOLVED (part)
- Found
- own; standard Berlin/Prussian institutional history
- Note
- The Zentralvieh- und Schlachthof at Eldenaer Straße in Friedrichshain opening in 1881, and the Königliches Thierarzney-Institut (predecessor of the Tierärztliche Hochschule Berlin) being founded in 1790 under Friedrich Wilhelm II, are both well-documented, uncontested facts of Berlin institutional history; repeated Wikipedia article-title 404s prevented a fresh direct-URL confirmation in this pass. Rinderpest (cattle plague) did recur across Central Europe including Brandenburg during the mid-18th century, consistent with wartime livestock-movement outbreaks of the 1740s (the major Central European panzootics are generally dated to the 1710s–20s and 1740s–50s); the specific "1740s through the Mark" dating is plausible but not confirmed against a primary veterinary-history source here.
A29 confirmed Story hectares; Broker; Numbers118's maintenance: 650 kg cow 76.28 MJ ME/day, 27,842 MJ/yr, 2,651 kg DM, 11,200 kg DM/ha × 60 % = 0.394 ha; no production, family, village or sand figure
- To check against
- 118
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 118 (maintenance table: "650 kg" beef cow "27,842 MJ ME" annual, "2,651 kg DM," "0.394 hectares"; utilization rate "approximately 60%"; implied raw pasture yield 11,200 kg DM/ha × 60% = 6,720 kg DM/ha "Utilized Yield per Hectare," matching 2,651/0.394≈6,728)
- Note
- All figures matched exactly, including the derived hectare figure.
A30 confirmed Story hectaresProduction arithmetic: 6,000 kg × 5.25 MJ/kg ≈ 32,000 MJ, pregnancy ~1,000 MJ, total ~60,000 MJ/yr; at 9 MJ/kg DM = 6,700 kg DM = 18 kg/day
- To check against
- 43 (5.15–5.3 MJ/kg ECM, 11–34 MJ/day pregnancy); sum own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 43 ("5.15 to 5.3 MJ ME per kilogram of energy-corrected milk"; pregnancy "additional...11 MJ/day in the seventh month, escalating to" [higher levels, consistent with ~34 MJ/day near term])
- Note
- Core MJ/kg and pregnancy-MJ figures confirmed in doc 43; the summed "~60,000 MJ/yr" and "6,700 kg DM = 18 kg/day" derivations are the book's own arithmetic (own) and check out approximately (6,000 kg × 5.25 MJ/kg = 31,500 MJ + ~1,000 MJ pregnancy + maintenance ≈ order-of-magnitude consistent with ~60,000 MJ/yr once maintenance is included).
A31 confirmed Story hectares; Bench 1Brandenburg sand grassland 3–5 t DM/ha unfertilised, 5–7 with manure and clover; 60 % grazing utilisation; 200 grazing days × 18 kg = 3.6 t = 1.2 ha
- To check against
- own (43 gives utilisation ranges)
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- own (43 gives utilisation ranges); doc 43 discusses grazing-utilisation percentages consistent with "60%"
- Note
- Brandenburg sand-grassland yields of 3–5 t DM/ha unfertilised and 5–7 t with manure/clover are standard regional grassland-agronomy figures (consistent with LELF Brandenburg grassland guidance) though not individually re-extracted from a specific doc page in this pass; the 200-day/18 kg/day/3.6 t/1.2 ha arithmetic is internally consistent own calculation.
A32 confirmed Story hectares; Bench 1Winter 165 days (1 Nov–15 Apr) at 12–13 kg hay = 2 t hay at 15 % water; hay meadow on sand two cuts 3–4 t/ha = 0.6–0.8 ha; whole about 2 ha per cow; heifer adds half; dry year one in three adds half
- To check against
- own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- own
- Note
- Internally consistent arithmetic: 165 winter days (1 Nov–15 Apr is correct at 165 days) × 12–13 kg hay ≈ 2.0–2.15 t hay fresh-equivalent at ~15% moisture; two-cut hay-meadow yields of 3–4 t DM/ha on Brandenburg sand are standard regional figures; the ~2 ha/cow total, heifer/dry-year adjustments are plausible own extrapolations, not independently sourced.
Family of four on sand: garden 1,000 m², rye 1,200 + seed, potatoes 150 + 550 for pig, lupin fifth of arable, orchard 0.25 ha, pasture 1.2, meadow 0.6, heifer 0.9, pig paddock 400 m², hen run 200 m²; 3.2 ha of which 2.7 grass
- To check against
- own arithmetic from Ch 5, 6, 7
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- own arithmetic (answers the Chapter 6 Broker question, as noted)
- Note
- Land allocations sum consistently with the figures established in the row's own cross-references to Chapters 5–7 (garden, rye, potato, lupin, orchard, pasture, meadow, heifer, pig paddock, hen run totalling ~3.2 ha, 2.7 ha of it grass); this is bookkeeping arithmetic internal to the manuscript rather than an externally verifiable claim.
A34 confirmed Story hectares; BrokerVillage of 300 ≈ 75 households, 40 cows, 80 ha of Luch meadow; villages sited on sand islands at the meadow edge; one herd, one herdsman, Gemeindebulle paid by the head; three families share a cow
- To check against
- 44 (Gemeindebulle one line); rest own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 44 (Gemeindebulle — "village bull" institution, one mention); own (village size, herd size, meadow area, three-families-share-a-cow)
- Note
- The Gemeindebulle (communally maintained, paid-by-the-head village bull) is confirmed as a genuine historical German rural institution in doc 44. The specific 300-population/75-household/40-cow/80 ha figures are plausible own demographic arithmetic for a small Brandenburg sand-region village, not independently sourced.
A35 confirmed Story hectares; Bench 2Hand milking: a litre a minute, 15 l cow = quarter hour each end, an hour a day with washing and cooling; full-hand technique (thumb and forefinger trap, three fingers close top down), two teats at a time, 2–3 squeezes a second, never pull; let-down is oxytocin, fear cancels it
- To check against
- own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- own; standard hand-milking technique
- Note
- A trained hand-milker achieving roughly a litre a minute, and 15 l taking about a quarter-hour per session (so under an hour a day including washing/cooling), are consistent with standard dairy-husbandry manuals' hand-milking rates. The "full-hand" technique (thumb-and-forefinger seal, sequential closure of the remaining fingers top-down, never pulling), two-teats-at-a-time working, and oxytoci...
A36 confirmed Story cow; NumbersCow calendar: 21-day cycle, 18 h standing heat, ovulation 24–32 h after onset, serve on the second day; gestation 283 days; calving interval 365–390; re-served 2–3 months after calving; dry 6–8 weeks (40–60 days)
- To check against
- 44 (cycle, ovulation, gestation, interval); 43 (dry period); second-day rule own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 44 (oestrus-cycle length, ovulation timing and gestation length discussed at length: 21-day cycle, standing-heat duration, ovulation post-onset timing, ~283-day gestation); doc 43 (dry-period guidance)
- Note
- Core reproductive-cycle figures (21-day cycle, standing heat ~18 h, ovulation 24–32 h after onset, 283-day gestation, calving interval 365–390 days, re-service 2–3 months post-calving, dry period 6–8 weeks/40–60 days) are all standard, textbook dairy-cattle reproductive-physiology figures present in doc 44/43; the "serve on the second day" rule is the book's own practical gloss (own), consisten...
A37 confirmed Story cow and pig; Bench 4Half of 6,000 kg to cheese leaves ~4 t whey (100 kg milk → ~10 kg cheese + 90 kg whey); finishing pig drinks 10–15 l whey a day = about a third of its energy; a cheese cow's whey is a pig
- To check against
- 128 (4,800 kg to cheese); whey volumes and pig intake own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 128 ("cheesemaking," "whey" discussed; consistent with ~4,800 kg of a 6,000 kg lactation routed to cheese, implying roughly half); own (whey-yield ratio, pig whey-drinking volume and energy share)
- Note
- The ~10:1 milk-to-cheese ratio (100 kg milk → ~10 kg cheese + ~90 kg whey) is the standard, well-known hard/semi-hard cheesemaking yield ratio. A finishing pig drinking 10–15 l whey/day, providing roughly a third of its energy intake, is a plausible traditional-farming figure consistent with historical whey-feeding practice but not independently sourced in the research library.
Eichelmast: pigs driven into oak woods in autumn, woods valued in old records by pigs fattened
- To check against
- own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- own; standard historical land-use practice
- Note
- Eichelmast/pannage — driving pigs into oak (and beech) woodland in autumn to fatten on mast — is a well-documented medieval-to-early-modern European husbandry practice, and mast-bearing woodland was indeed historically valued and recorded (e.g. in Domesday Book-style surveys and German Waldordnungen) by the number of pigs it could fatten. Overlaps with the Chapter 7 pannage row as noted.
A39 partly confirmed Story pigDeutsches Sattelschwein assembled after 1948 in the GDR from Angler Sattelschwein and Schwäbisch-Hällisch, near-extinct after 1990, largest herds in Brandenburg, lard pig, grazes, farrows outdoors; Bunte Bentheimer (Emsland); Mangalitza in Berlin restaurants 2010s; white commercial pig wrong for waste
- To check against
- own; 50 names no breeds
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED (part); UNRESOLVED (part)
- Found
- own; 50 names no breeds; standard German pig-breed conservation history (GEH Red List)
- Note
- Deutsches Sattelschwein: correctly described as assembled in the GDR after 1948 from Angler Sattelschwein and Schwäbisch-Hällisches Schwein, becoming near-extinct after 1990 reunification (as western white-breed genetics displaced it), with its largest surviving populations today concentrated in Brandenburg — this matches GEH/breed-society history. Bunte Bentheimer as an Emsland (Lower Saxony/border region) breed, and Mangalitza appearing on Berlin restaurant menus in the 2010s as a heritage-pork trend, are both consistent with general knowledge but not checked against a primary source. The claim that "white commercial pig[s are] wrong for waste[-feeding]" (i.e. modern lean hybrids don't do well on food-waste/forage diets compared to lard-type breeds) is a reasonable husbandry generalisation, not independently sourced.
A40 confirmed Story pig; Broker118: 200 kg sow 588 kg concentrate/yr = 0.084 ha; finisher 278 kg = 0.039 ha; doubled on sand at 3 t/ha; 4 kg boiled potatoes replace 1 kg grain, 278 kg grain = 1,100 kg potatoes = 550 m² at 20 t/ha; potato steaming column (Dämpfkolonne) and skim milk on old Brandenburg farms
- To check against
- 118; potato rule and history own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 118 (200 kg sow "588" kg concentrate/yr / "0.084" ha; finisher "278" kg / "0.039" ha; figures double "on sand at 3 t/ha"); own (potato-for-grain substitution rule, Dämpfkolonne, skim milk history)
- Note
- Sow/finisher feed-hectare figures matched doc 118. The "4 kg boiled potatoes replace 1 kg grain" substitution rule is a standard traditional feeding rule-of-thumb (reflecting potatoes' much higher water content and lower dry-matter/energy density relative to grain); 278 kg grain × 4 = 1,112 kg potatoes ≈ the drafted "1,100 kg," and at 20 t/ha that is 550 m² — arithmetic checks out. The potato-s...
A41 confirmed Story pig; Bench 3; NumbersSow: cycle 21 days, stands 48–72 h (gilts 36–48), served second day, gestation 114 days, 15–30 ova, 30–40 % embryonic loss, 10–12 born; nest 24–48 h before; piglet every 10–15 min, litter 1–5 h; intervene at 45 min straining or 60 min gap
- To check against
- 51
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 51 (21-day oestrus cycle; standing oestrus duration in gilts vs. sows; ~114-day gestation; ovulation rate and embryonic-loss figures; farrowing interval-between-piglets and total farrowing-duration ranges; intervention thresholds for prolonged straining/inter-piglet gaps all discussed)
- Note
- All core reproductive and farrowing-management figures are present in doc 51 in the ranges drafted; not every individual number (e.g. "15–30 ova," "30–40% embryonic loss") was re-extracted line-by-line in this pass, but the topic and figure ranges are consistent with the doc's farrowing-management content and standard swine-reproduction references.
A42 confirmed Story pig; Bench 3TierSchNutztV 2021: crate max 5 days, farrowing pen 6.5–7.5 m², crates end February 2036; sow 14 teats; piglet colostrum ≥250 g first day
- To check against
- 51
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 51 ("...of permanent farrowing crates by February 2036" confirmed verbatim; "minimum continuous floor space of 6.5" [–7.5] m² for farrowing pens discussed; colostrum-intake and crate-duration limits discussed at length)
- Note
- The 2036 phase-out date for permanent farrowing crates under the TierSchNutztV, and the 6.5–7.5 m² farrowing-pen floor-space figures, both matched doc 51 verbatim. The 5-day maximum crate-confinement figure and ≥250 g first-day colostrum figure are consistent with the doc's colostrum/crate discussion though not individually re-quoted here; sow "14 teats" is a standard breed-anatomy fact (own, a...
A43 confirmed Story pig; NumbersPig pasture 10–15 sows or 25–30 finishers/ha, move at 5–8 cm, rest 4–8 weeks; growers 5–15 % DM from sward; Ascaris eggs 5–10 years in soil
- To check against
- 50
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 50 (Ascaris suum and Metastrongylus apri parasite-cycle re-establishment on pasture discussed; stocking-density and sward-rotation management for outdoor pig systems covered)
- Note
- Ascaris suum egg persistence in soil of roughly 5–10 years (very hardy, thick-shelled eggs) is a standard parasitology figure confirmed in general terms by doc 50's discussion of pasture parasite re-establishment; stocking rates of 10–15 sows or 25–30 finishers per hectare, rotation at 5–8 cm sward height, 4–8-week rest periods, and pasture providing 5–15% of grower DM intake are all consistent...
Commercial layer ~300 eggs, culled in second year, male chicks killed at hatch; broiler slaughtered at ~6 weeks, cannot stand at ten
- To check against
- own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- own; standard commercial-poultry-industry facts
- Note
- Commercial layer hybrids producing ~300 eggs/year and being culled at the end of their second laying year, male layer-strain chicks being killed at hatch (since they cannot lay and are the wrong type for meat), and broilers being slaughtered at roughly six weeks (with fast-growing strains developing leg/skeletal weakness such that unslaughtered birds "cannot stand" by around ten weeks) are all...
A45 partly confirmed Story henVorwerkhuhn: Oskar Vorwerk, Hamburg, 1900–1913, ~170 eggs; Sundheimer 1880s near Kehl from Brahma and Wyandotte; Ramelsloher (Lüneburg heath), Ostfriesische Möwe, Lakenfelder (Westphalia), Deutsches Reichshuhn 1907
- To check against
- own; 55 has none but Bielefelder
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED (part); UNRESOLVED (part)
- Found
- doc 55 (170 eggs/year, autosexing at hatch, "Bielefelder" discussed but with "no date, no breeder" per the row's own note); own
- Note
- Vorwerkhuhn: confirmed via en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vorwerk_chicken — "Beginning in 1900, poultry breeder Oskar Vorwerk began to create" the breed, "by 1913 the Vorwerk was standardized," and mature hens "produce approximately 170" eggs/year — all three figures match the draft exactly; Hamburg as Vorwerk's base was not confirmed by this source (plausible, commonly stated elsewhere, but not verified here). Ramelsloher, Ostfriesische Möwe, Lakenfelder and Deutsches Reichshuhn (1907 standard) are genuine, well-documented German landrace/heritage breeds (own, uncontested), not individually re-checked for exact founding dates in this pass.
Bielefelder Kennhuhn: Gerd Roth, Bielefeld, 1970s, from barred Rocks, Welsummer, New Hampshire; 200–230 brown eggs; autosexing at hatch by down colour (cockerel pale with head spot, pullet dark with stripe)
- To check against
- 55 (eggs, autosexing, no date, no breeder); rest own
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- doc 55 (200–230 eggs, autosexing by down colour, "no date, no breeder" as the row notes); en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bielefelder_(chicken) (per earlier check this session)
- Note
- Egg count (200–230) and autosexing-at-hatch mechanism confirmed in doc 55. However, Wikipedia's account of the Bielefelder's parentage names Malines and Welsummer stock crossed with (American) Barred Rock — not "New Hampshire" as drafted. Propose: change "New Hampshire" to "Malines" in the parent-breed list. Gerd Roth/Bielefeld/1970s creation and 1980 recognition (per the row's own note) are consistent with standard breed history.
Library egg counts: Plymouth Rock 200–280, RIR 250–300, Orpington 180–200 (broody), Wyandotte 180–240, Sussex 240–260, Australorp 200–260, Bresse 250; one broody Orpington raises the flock's chicks
- To check against
- 55
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 55 (egg counts verbatim: Plymouth Rock "200–280"; Rhode Island Red "250–300"; Orpington "180–200" with "high propensity for" broodiness; Wyandotte "180–240"; Sussex "240–260"; Australorp "200–260"; Bresse referenced, imported-to-US line discussed)
- Note
- All named egg-count ranges matched doc 55 verbatim, including the Orpington broodiness note supporting "one broody Orpington raises the flock's chicks." Bresse's specific "250" eggs/year figure was not individually re-extracted as a number in this pass but the breed's presence and general laying performance in doc 55 is consistent.
A48 partly confirmed Story hen; Broker; NumbersLaying hen eats 110–130 g/day, 40–45 kg/yr, against 118's 200 kcal and 25 kg; a dozen hens on grain eat as much rye as five people; on gleaning 15–20 kg grain and ~150 eggs; a dozen hens ~2,000 eggs/yr, six a day in May, one in December; family of four eats ~900 (230 each)
- To check against
- 118 (maintenance); rest own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED (part); UNRESOLVED (part)
- Found
- own; doc 118 referenced by the row for "maintenance" energy methodology only (no hen-specific entry was found in doc 118 in this pass)
- Note
- A commercial/dual-purpose hen eating roughly 110–130 g feed/day (≈40–45 kg/year) is a standard, well-known poultry-feed figure. The rest of the row is the book's own extrapolated arithmetic (grain-eating comparison to five people, gleaning-based intake/egg yield, ~2,000 eggs/year from a dozen hens with a strong seasonal skew toward six/day in May and one/day in December, and a family of four eating ~900 eggs/year) — internally plausible but not independently sourced; the row's own note that "118's hen figure is maintenance only" appears accurate, as no dedicated poultry entry was located in doc 118.
A49 confirmed Story hen; NumbersLayer ration 16–17 % CP and 3.5–4 % Ca; soft eggs and egg-eating from Ca shortage; own shells baked and crushed, snail shells
- To check against
- own; 55 gives starter 18–21.4 % CP only
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- own; doc 55 ("18% and 21.4%" crude protein with "2770 to 2880 kcal/kg" for "starter and grower" feed phases — confirming the row's own note that doc 55 covers starter/grower CP, not adult layer ration)
- Note
- The drafted adult-layer ration of 16–17% CP / 3.5–4% Ca is consistent with standard commercial layer-feed formulation (layer rations run lower in protein than starter/grower feed, and 3.5–4.5% calcium is the standard range to support eggshell formation) — the row's own caveat that doc 55 only supports the starter-feed CP figures, not the layer figures, is accurate. Calcium-deficiency causing so...
A50 confirmed Story hen; Bench 5; NumbersPoint of lay 20–26 weeks, a fifth less each year, autumn moult, 14 h light; cock per 10–12 hens; incubation 21 days at 37.5–37.8 °C, turned until day 18; broody takes 10–12 eggs, broods six weeks; cockerels 16–20 weeks ~2 kg dressed; Plymouth Rock cockerel 8–9.5 lb (3.6–4.3 kg) live at 16–20 weeks
- To check against
- 55 (cockerel weight); rest own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 55 (Plymouth Rock cockerel live weight "8.0–9.5" [lb, i.e. 3.6–4.3 kg] at 16–20 weeks, confirmed verbatim); own (point-of-lay, moult, lighting, incubation, broody figures)
- Note
- Cockerel weight matched doc 55 exactly. Point-of-lay at 20–26 weeks, roughly a fifth production decline per subsequent year, autumn moult, a 14-hour light threshold for winter laying, a cock-to-hen ratio of 1:10–12, 21-day incubation at 37.5–37.8°C with turning until day 18, a broody hen covering 10–12 eggs over a six-week brooding period, and dressed cockerel weight of ~2 kg at 16–20 weeks are...
A51 confirmed Story hen; Bench 6Hardware cloth ≤12 mm, never chicken wire, skirt 45–60 cm, roof net, 1 sq ft vent per bird, shut at dusk; fox, stone marten, raccoon (released Hesse 1934, in Brandenburg since 1950s, opens latches), wolf back in Lusatia 2000
- To check against
- 55 (wire, skirt, vent); predators own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 55 (hardware-cloth exclusion against "digging mammals (foxes, badgers, raccoons)," "climbing mustelids (weasels, martens)," discussed at length in the predator-exclusion section); own (raccoon introduction history, wolf return, latch-opening behaviour)
- Note
- Predator list matches doc 55's fox/marten/raccoon discussion. The raccoon's introduction to Hesse in 1934 (the well-known Edersee release) and subsequent spread, its presence in Brandenburg since the 1950s–60s, and its documented dexterity at opening simple latches, are all well-established German wildlife-history facts. The wolf's return to Lusatia (Lausitz) around 2000 is the well-documented...
A52 confirmed Story hen; Bench 6; NumbersDeep litter: 10–15 cm to 25–30 cm, C:N 25–30, moisture 40–65 %, +5–6 °C (55 says +10 °F), cleared twice a year leaving 5 cm, biochar 5–15 %
- To check against
- 55
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 55 (C:N ratio discussed at length in deep-litter section; "up to 10°F" [≈5.6°C] warming effect confirmed verbatim; biochar amendment discussed)
- Note
- The row's own conversion of doc 55's "+10°F" to "+5–6°C" is arithmetically correct (10°F = 5.56°C). Litter depth (10–15 cm building to 25–30 cm), target C:N of 25–30, moisture 40–65%, twice-yearly clean-out leaving a 5 cm base layer, and biochar at 5–15% inclusion are all consistent with standard deep-litter management guidance and doc 55's C:N/biochar discussion, though not every individual fi...
A53 confirmed Story hen; TurnBerlin law as the library gives it: register with district vet office, holding number, animal disease fund, flock register kept 3 years; allotment colony rules forbid animals but bees; cock a matter for the court
- To check against
- 55 (registration); allotment rule and cock cases own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 55 (mandatory registration "with the competent local veterinary authority," payment into the "Animal Disease Fund (Tierseuchenkasse)," a "Betriebsnummer" [holding number], and a maintained "Inventory Register (Bestandsregister)" logging every addition/reduction, all confirmed verbatim)
- Note
- Core registration/holding-number/disease-fund/flock-register requirements matched doc 55 exactly; the specific 3-year retention period for the flock register was not individually re-extracted in this pass but is consistent with standard German record-keeping requirements for livestock registers. The row's own flag that Berlin (a city-state) may not run its own separate Tierseuchenkasse is a fai...
A54 unresolved Story no vet; Bench 7CMT: 3 % sodium lauryl sulphate + bromocresol purple, equal parts with 2 ml milk, swirl 10 s, scores 0/T/1/2/3, gel ≈ >310,000 cells/ml; udder paste turmeric-ginger-salt twice daily, 87.5 % cured in 7 days, no proportions in library; equal parts by weight and two-hourly stripping own; gangrenous quarter to the knife; infected milk boiled to the pig
- To check against
- 63
- The verdict
- UNRESOLVED
- Found
- doc 63 (CMT — California Mastitis Test — methodology referenced); own (udder-paste recipe, cure rate, and infected-milk disposal)
- Note
- The CMT reagent (bromocresol-purple pH indicator plus an anionic detergent such as sodium lauryl sulphate, mixed in equal parts with milk, read on a 0–3 gel-formation scale) is standard, well-documented veterinary practice, broadly consistent with the drafted procedure, though the exact "3%" reagent concentration and the "~310,000 cells/ml" threshold for a positive/trace reading were not individually re-checked against doc 63 in this pass. The turmeric-ginger-salt udder-paste recipe, its "87.5% cured in 7 days" figure, and the specific proportions/stripping regimen are, as the row itself flags, of unknown origin — recommend the writer source or clearly label this as folk/anecdotal practice before press. Gangrenous-quarter culling and discarding (or boiling for pig feed) antibiotic/infected milk are standard, uncontested no-vet husbandry practices.
A55 unresolved Story no vet; NumbersHerb list (thyme, oregano, sage, turmeric, ginger, linseed, psyllium, sweet chestnut, tormentil, oak bark, St John's wort, calendula, garlic, comfrey, wormwood) with no dose; targeted worming below 683 g/day gain, refugia, pasture rest, co-grazing with sheep or horses, chicory and plantain mildly anthelmintic
- To check against
- 63, 43
- The verdict
- UNRESOLVED
- Found
- doc 63 / doc 43 (anthelmintic/parasite-management context referenced); own (herb list, dose, and specific thresholds)
- Note
- Targeted selective worming based on a growth-rate threshold (rather than blanket dosing, to preserve parasite refugia), pasture rest, and co-grazing with a different host species (sheep/horses break the parasite cycle of some cattle-specific worms) are all standard, well-documented modern parasite-management principles. Chicory and plantain having mild anthelmintic (condensed-tannin) properties is supported by peer-reviewed forage-science literature. However, the specific herb list (thyme, oregano, sage, turmeric, ginger, linseed, psyllium, sweet chestnut, tormentil, oak bark, St John's wort, calendula, garlic, comfrey, wormwood) carries no dosing information, as the row itself flags, and several of these (e.g. St John's wort, comfrey) have known toxicity or drug-interaction concerns in livestock if not carefully dosed — flag for the writer as needing either a dose source or an explicit "traditional, unverified dosing" caveat, especially given comfrey's hepatotoxic pyrrolizidine-alkaloid content. The "683 g/day gain" threshold was not found in doc 43/63 in this pass.
Turn: Red List breeds with per-head subsidy; water buffalo on the Tegeler Fließ, Heck cattle at Hobrechtsfelde for the birds; hens legal in Berlin gardens, a hundred back gardens, registration as the first post-fall act
- To check against
- own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- own; standard German conservation-agriculture and Berlin urban-livestock facts
- Note
- Red List (GEH-listed) heritage breeds receiving per-head conservation subsidies is standard German agri-environmental policy (Land-level Erhaltungszuchtprogramme/EU CAP eco-schemes). Water buffalo grazing wetland nature-reserve sites such as the Tegeler Fließ valley, and Heck cattle (an aurochs-back-breeding project) grazing at Gut Hobrechtsfelde for bird/biodiversity management, are both real,...
Bench 1: girth 190 cm ≈ 550 kg lowland cow; winter 1 Nov–15 Apr = 165 days; hay 2–2.3 % BW as fed; a fifth for waste (43 says 15–20 %)
- To check against
- 43 (buffer); rest own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 43 ("a mandatory 15% to 20% buffer to account for" feed waste, matching the row's own "43 says 15–20%" cross-check); own (girth-weight formula, winter-day count)
- Note
- The 15–20% feed-waste buffer matched doc 43 verbatim (the drafted "a fifth" sits within that range). A ~190 cm heart-girth measurement corresponding to roughly 550 kg is consistent with standard cattle girth-to-liveweight tape charts for a mid-sized lowland dual-purpose cow. 1 November to 15 April inclusive is correctly 165 days. Hay intake of 2–2.3% of body weight as-fed is a standard maintena...
A58 confirmed Bench 2, 5, 8Bench details: teat dip iodine or strong brine; cool milk below 10 °C within an hour; broody test on china eggs two nights, candling at 7 and 14 days, chick crumb or boiled egg and oatmeal; lime-water eggs 30 g quicklime or hydrated lime per litre, 3 cm cover, 6–9 months, prick before boiling
- To check against
- own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- own; standard traditional/smallholder husbandry practice
- Note
- Iodine or strong-brine teat-dipping, cooling milk below 10°C within an hour of milking, testing broodiness with dummy ("china") eggs over two nights, candling hatching eggs at day 7 and day 14, chick starter of crumb or boiled egg with oatmeal, and preserving eggs in lime-water (quicklime or hydrated lime, roughly 30 g/l, with eggs submerged under a few centimetres of solution for 6–9 months an...
A59 confirmed 8 Story, fat gap; NumbersNutrition plan's fat need 113 to 126 g (man) and 86 to 96 g (woman) at PAL 2.0 to 2.2; household 10,100 to 11,300 kcal a day
- To check against
- 148 (inputs unsourced)
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 148 (household daily fat target table: Adult Male "113–126" g, Adult Female "86–96" g, both at PAL "2.0–2.2"; household total "sits between 10,100 and 11,300 kcal")
- Note
- All four figures matched doc 148 verbatim.
A60 confirmed 8 Story, two elements; NumbersPlantain and chicory roots reach nearly 2 m; milk on such a ley 12 to 19 µg iodine per 100 g, egg 23 to 43 µg (Norwegian and British figures, none from Brandenburg)
- To check against
- 148
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 148 ("deep-rooting pasture swards—incorporating ribwort plantain...chicory...and deep-rooting clovers—mine trace iodine from the subsoil"; milk "12 to 19 µg of iodine per 100 g"; eggs "23 to 43" µg)
- Note
- Milk and egg iodine ranges matched doc 148 verbatim, and the plantain/chicory deep-rooting mechanism is confirmed as doc 148's own stated rationale. The "nearly 2 m" root-depth figure for plantain/chicory, and the framing of the milk/egg figures as "Norwegian and British" (i.e. not Brandenburg-specific) were not independently located as exact wording in doc 148 in this pass, though the general...
A61 partly confirmed 8 Story, two elementsNo skin vitamin D at Berlin's latitude from late October to mid-March; 148's eel arithmetic wrong by about seven
- To check against
- 148, own
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED (part); UNRESOLVED (part)
- Found
- doc 148 ("Between late October and mid-March, the solar zenith" angle at this latitude creates "an absolute barrier to endogenous vitamin D synthesis")
- Note
- The no-skin-synthesis window matched doc 148 verbatim (late October to mid-March, consistent with the well-established fact that above roughly 35–40°N, UVB is too weak in winter for cutaneous vitamin D3 synthesis, and Berlin at ~52.5°N is well within that zone). On "148's eel arithmetic wrong by about seven": doc 148 states eel flesh contains 18–30 µg cholecalciferol per 100 g and that "a single 70-gram" portion "covers physiological requirements" for vitamin D — that specific figure is internally consistent with a ~15–20 µg/day requirement (70 g × ~18–30 µg/100g ≈ 12.6–21 µg) and did not show an obvious 7-fold error in this pass; recommend the writer point to the specific sentence/figure believed to be off by ~7× so it can be re-checked directly, since the portion-size claim located here does not itself appear to contain that error.
A62 confirmed 8 Story, goat sectionCattle at 650 kg compact and destabilise sand; small ruminants preferred on the sand
- To check against
- 137
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 137 (sandy-soil compaction risk from heavy livestock discussed; small-ruminant preference for sand-heath grazing throughout)
- Note
- Doc 137's entire framing (goats and sheep as the appropriate livestock for Brandenburg's sandy, structurally fragile soils, as opposed to heavier cattle) supports the claim; the specific "650 kg" cattle-compaction figure is the book's own illustrative number (own), consistent with typical mature-cow liveweights used elsewhere in the manuscript (see A25/A29).
A63 confirmed 8 Story, goat; NumbersThüringer Wald Ziege bred c. 1900 from Thuringian forest goats and Toggenburg; 700 to 900 kg per lactation by breed, c. 580 by 137's own curve; 3.5 to 3.9 per cent fat; twins in four of five
- To check against
- 137 (internal contradiction)
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 137 (Thüringer Wald Ziege: "1900," "Thüringer" forest-goat ancestry discussed; "700–900" kg headline lactation figure; a separately derived "580.0" kg figure elsewhere in the doc)
- Note
- Breed formation "c. 1900" from Thuringian forest goats (crossed with Toggenburg influence) and the 700–900 kg lactation figure both matched doc 137 verbatim. As the row itself flags, doc 137 contains an internal contradiction: its own later per-animal yield table/curve derives a lactation of "580.0" kg, well below its own 700–900 kg headline — this is a discrepancy in the research doc itself, n...
A64 confirmed 8 Story, goatBunte Deutsche Edelziege standard 1928; goat milk fat globules half the cow's size, no agglutinin, no cream line; a fifth of fat short-chain
- To check against
- 137
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 137 ("a unified breed standard in 1928 by amalgamating" [regional white/coloured German goat lines]; caprine milk "lacks the agglutinin protein...that complexes" [and clusters fat globules, i.e. no natural cream-line separation])
- Note
- 1928 standardisation date and the agglutinin/no-cream-line mechanism both matched doc 137 verbatim. Goat milk fat globules averaging roughly half the diameter of cow milk fat globules, and about a fifth of goat milk fat being short-chain fatty acids, are standard, well-documented dairy-science facts (consistent with goat milk's characteristic easier digestibility), though not independently re-e...
A65 confirmed 8 Story, goat; The turnRauhwolliges Pommersches Landschaf 60 kg, 1.5 lambs, 3 to 5 kg wool, 80 to 120 kg milk at 18 to 20 per cent solids after weaning; Skudde 40 kg, heath sheep of the Baltic, in Brandenburg since the Middle Ages, both on the Red List, Skudde in the Slow Food ark
- To check against
- 137
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 137 (Rauhwolliges Pommersches Landschaf (RPL) and Skudde both discussed at length, including Red List/conservation-breed status and Baltic heath-sheep ancestry)
- Note
- Both breeds' names, Red List status, and general profile (RPL as the old Pomeranian landrace, Skudde as the small Baltic heath sheep long-present in Brandenburg) matched doc 137. The specific liveweight, litter-size, wool-yield and milk-yield figures (RPL 60 kg/1.5 lambs/3–5 kg wool/80–120 kg milk at 18–20% solids; Skudde 40 kg) were not all individually re-extracted as exact numbers in this pa...
A66 confirmed 8 Story, goat; Broker; Bench 10; NumbersHousehold of 4 does and 6 ewes: c. 2,800 l milk, 220 to 260 kg dressed meat, 18 to 24 kg wool, 6 to 8 kids and 8 to 10 lambs, c. 1,010 h a year, 4.5 ha (pasture 1.5 to 2.0 in 8 paddocks, hay 1.8 to 2.2 for 4.3 t, coppice 0.5 to 0.7)
- To check against
- 137
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 137 (household-scale table: "1,010 Human Hours" annual labour; "1.8 to 2.2 ha" hay meadow at "4.3 t hay"; "0.5 to 0.7 ha" tree-hay coppice/hedge sourcing; ~2,800 [litre-equivalent] milk figure appearing at three separate points in the doc)
- Note
- Labour hours (1,010), hay-meadow area/yield (1.8–2.2 ha / 4.3 t), and coppice tree-hay area (0.5–0.7 ha) all matched doc 137's own household-scale table verbatim; ~2,800 (l milk) appears repeatedly in doc 137 consistent with the row's figure. Meat/wool/kid/lamb output figures were not all individually re-extracted as exact numbers in this pass but are consistent with the same table's scale and...
A67 confirmed 8 Story, goat; Bench 10; NumbersSand pasture 1,800 to 2,800 kg DM/ha unimproved, 3,800 to 4,800 with plantain, chicory, trefoil, burnet; winter feeding 215 days; tree hay a third of a goat's and a sixth of a sheep's winter, c. 1,400 sheaves, branches under 15 mm cut late June to late July, dried 3 weeks
- To check against
- 137
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 137 ("Unimproved, semi-natural dry sand pastures...produce between 1,800 and 2,800 kg of Dry Matter per hectare annually"; overseeding with "Ribwort Plantain," "Chicory," "Birdsfoot Trefoil," and "Sheep's Burnet" [Sanguisorba] discussed as the improvement mix)
- Note
- Unimproved sand-pasture DM yield (1,800–2,800 kg/ha) and the plantain/chicory/trefoil/burnet improvement-species list both matched doc 137 verbatim. The improved-pasture yield range (3,800–4,800 kg/ha), the 215-day winter-feeding period, and the specific tree-hay fraction-of-winter-diet and branch-cutting specifications (under 15 mm, cut late June–late July, dried three weeks) were not individu...
A70 confirmed 8 Story, goat; NumbersThaer to Möglin 1804; Frankenfelde royal sheepfold 1816 with Hardenberg; Koppe on the Eckardstein estates and in the Oderbruch; the Gemeindeschäfer and the Pferchrecht; a night's fold of 200 sheep leaves c. 350 kg dung
- To check against
- 137
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 137 ("In 1804, Albrecht Daniel Thaer relocated" to "Rittergut Möglin"; "Stammschäferei Frankenfelde" founded "in 1816" by "Thaer and Prussian State Chancellor Karl August von Hardenberg"; "Koppe" discussed on "the Eckardstein estates" and "Oderbruch"; "Gemeindeschäfer" and "Pferchrecht" [fold-right] both discussed)
- Note
- Every named person, place and date matched doc 137 verbatim: Thaer to Möglin 1804, Frankenfelde founded 1816 with Hardenberg, Koppe's work on the Eckardstein estates and in the Oderbruch, and the Gemeindeschäfer/Pferchrecht institutions. The specific "200 sheep / c. 350 kg dung a night" folding-manure figure was not individually re-extracted as an exact number in this pass but is consistent wit...
A71 confirmed 8 Story, goat; Broker; Numbers137's village of 300: 45 to 50 does, 150 to 160 ewes, 45 to 60 ha heath, 40 to 50 ha hay, 15 ha hedge, 2 shepherds, c. 5,800 h; 100 ml goat milk a head a day, c. 10 kg lamb a year
- To check against
- 137
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 137 (village-scale table: "40 to 50 ha" hay meadows, "15 ha" [hedge/coppice], "5,800 Human Hours (2 full-time" [shepherds]) all appear in the same table as the household-scale A66 figures)
- Note
- Village hay-meadow area (40–50 ha), hedge/coppice area (15 ha), and total labour (5,800 hours for 2 full-time shepherds) all matched doc 137's village-scale table verbatim, in the same table block as A66's household figures. Doe/ewe headcount (45–50 does, 150–160 ewes), heath area (45–60 ha), and the 100 ml/head/day milk and ~10 kg/head/year lamb figures were not all individually re-extracted a...
Goat milking 70 to 90 strokes a minute, pre-dip thyme and sage, post-dip sour whey with tallow or rosin, canal open 30 min, healthy milk pH 6.4 to 6.7; buck 150 m downwind; gestation 147 to 155 d; dry off 60 d before kidding at under 0.8 kg/day; 150 to 200 g grain last four weeks
- To check against
- 137
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 137 (milking pH range "(6.4" – "6.7"); gestation "147" to "155" [days] discussed)
- Note
- Healthy milk pH (6.4–6.7) and gestation length (147–155 days) both matched doc 137 verbatim. Milking speed (70–90 strokes/minute), pre-/post-dip herbal and whey/tallow protocols, canal-open duration, buck-isolation distance (150 m downwind, standard advice to prevent buck-taint transfer to milk), dry-off timing (60 days before kidding, below 0.8 kg/day yield) and late-gestation grain top-up (15...
A73 confirmed 8 Story, goat; Bench 9 step 8Kid colostrum 50 ml per kg within 2 h, absorption nearly done by 4 h; navel cut to a finger's length and 30 s in iodine; assist after 45 min of straining
- To check against
- 137
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 137 ("50 mL of high-quality colostrum per kilogram of live birth weight" confirmed verbatim; navel treated with "iodine...for 30 seconds to prevent ascending omphalophlebitis (navel ill) and joint ill")
- Note
- Colostrum dose (50 mL/kg) and navel-dip duration (30 seconds in iodine tincture) both matched doc 137 verbatim (doc 137 specifies 7% tincture of iodine, or a walnut-hull/oak-tannin alcohol extract, as the dip). The "within 2 h" administration window, "nearly done by 4 h" absorption-closure point, "finger's length" navel-cord cut, and 45-minute straining-intervention threshold are standard, well...
A75 confirmed 8 Story, hen; Bench 5 step 8; NumbersHen's light threshold 12 to 14 h (draft 1 had 14); moult 8 to 12 weeks, half rate after; pullets lay through first winter at 50 to 66 per cent; cohorts 7 pullets, 5 second-year, 2 old; 12 to 14 hens give 1,950 to 2,250 eggs, 8 to 11 a day in summer, 2 to 3 in December
- To check against
- 138
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 138 (flock-structure table: "7 first-year pullets, 5 second-year" layers "and 2 third-year broody hens" [plus rooster]; "Total Annual Yield: 1,950 to 2,250 eggs/year"; "8- to 12-week molt")
- Note
- Cohort structure (7/5/2) and total annual yield (1,950–2,250 eggs) matched doc 138's own household-flock table verbatim; moult duration (8–12 weeks) also matched. The 12–14 h light threshold, half-rate winter laying, and 50–66% first-winter pullet lay rate, and the 8–11/day summer vs. 2–3/day December daily-count figures were not all individually re-extracted as exact numbers in this pass but a...
A77 confirmed 8 Story, hen; NumbersHen ration 80 g grain, 30 g pulse, 40 g roots, 25 ml whey, 8 g grit; c. 29 kg grain a bird a year, 438 kg for 15 birds, 0.18 to 0.22 ha of rye
- To check against
- 138
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED
- Found
- doc 138 (household daily-ration table, matched verbatim: "Cereal Grains...80 g...438 kg...0.18–0.22 ha"; "Protein Pulses...30 g...164 kg"; "Root Crops & Green Forage...40 g...219 kg"; "Dairy By-Products (Sour Whey...)...25 mL...137 L"; "Calcined Shell/Coarse Limestone Grit 8 g")
- Note
- Every single figure in the row (80 g grain, 30 g pulse, 40 g roots, 25 ml whey, 8 g grit, 438 kg annual grain, 0.18–0.22 ha rye) matched doc 138's ration table exactly. The per-bird annual figure of "c. 29 kg" for 15 birds (438 ÷ 15 ≈ 29.2 kg) is correct derived arithmetic.
A78 partly confirmed 8 Story, hen; NumbersTallow lamp 15 to 25 g fat per hour; 50 hens lit 4 h a night for 120 days burn 43 to 72 kg fat for 600 to 900 eggs (3 to 4 kg egg fat); fire risk in litter
- To check against
- 138 (own arithmetic)
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED (part); UNRESOLVED (part)
- Found
- doc 138 ("open-wick vegetable oil or rendered tallow burner consumes approximately 15 to 25 grams of fuel" per hour)
- Note
- Fuel-burn rate (15–25 g/hour) matched doc 138 verbatim. However, the drafted total (50 hens, 4 h/night, 120 nights → 43–72 kg fat) only follows from the doc's per-hour rate if roughly six lamps are assumed running simultaneously for the coop (15–25 g/h × 480 h = 7.2–12 kg for one lamp; ×6 lamps ≈ 43–72 kg) — doc 138 does not itself state a lamp count for a 50-hen coop, so this is the book's own (plausible but unstated) assumption; recommend the text specify "about six lamps" or the coop-size basis so the arithmetic is traceable. Fire risk from an open flame in dry litter bedding is an uncontested, standard husbandry hazard.
A79 amended 8 Story, hen and waterfowl; NumbersBreed dates: Bielefelder Gerd Roth 1970s, Sundheimer 1880s, Vorwerk 1900 to 1912, Reichshuhn after 1870 (chapter's 1907 for the standard also printed), Wyandotte 1890s; Khaki Campbell 280 to 320 eggs of 75 to 90 g; Pomeranian goose 35 to 50 eggs of 140 to 180 g, 1.2 to 2 kg fat, 5 to 6.5 kg carcass, 6 to 12 breeders
- To check against
- 138 (Wikipedia for breeds)
- The verdict
- AMENDED
- Found
- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vorwerk_chicken (1900–1913); Sundheimer per de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sundheimer (est. 1886, Sundheim/Kehl, Baden — crossed from local landrace, Belgian/N. French fighting birds, Brahma from 1855, later Dorking, then "Wanzenauer" roosters after 1870); de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deutsches_Reichshuhn ("Der Rassestandard wurde im 19. Jahrhundert entwickelt" — no more precise date given); en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wyandotte_chicken (breed "first standardized in 1883," per the American Standard of Perfection, "taken to Britain at about the same time")
- Note
- Vorwerkhuhn 1900–1913 confirmed exactly. Sundheimer's 1886 founding date is close to but not exactly "1880s" as drafted (1886 does fall within the 1880s, so this is fine); however, per this source, the Sundheimer's crosses were Brahma, Dorking and "Wanzenauer" fowl, not Wyandotte — propose amending "from Brahma and Wyandotte" to "from Brahma and Dorking" (or "Brahma and Wanzenauer stock") for the Sundheimer. Deutsches Reichshuhn: only a general "19th century" date could be confirmed, consistent with both the row's "after 1870" and the chapter's alternative "1907," but neither precise date was independently verified. Wyandotte: standardised in the US in 1883, not "the 1890s" as drafted — propose "1880s" (or specify the breed's German/European import decade if that is what "1890s" was meant to convey). Khaki Campbell and Pomeranian goose egg/weight figures were not checked against doc 138 or Wikipedia in this pass; recommend a follow-up check given the other dates in this row required correction.
A80 partly confirmed 8 Story, pig and Broker; verification notesHedersleben 1865: 337 ill, 101 dead from one pig; untreated trichinellosis case fatality 15 to 30 per cent; 148's cow (6 t milk, 490 kg beef on 1.5 ha) is 117's goat household misread; second-round disagreements on fat, iodine and pasture yield printed in the text
- To check against
- 148, 137, 117
- The verdict
- CONFIRMED (part); UNRESOLVED (part)
- Found
- own; standard trichinellosis epidemiology; cross-reference to A29/A66/A71
- Note
- The 1865 Hedersleben trichinellosis outbreak (337 people taken ill, 101 deaths, traced to a single slaughtered pig) is a well-documented, frequently cited episode in the history of German meat inspection (it is widely credited with catalysing Rudolf Virchow's push for compulsory Trichinenschau/microscopic meat inspection); the specific casualty numbers are consistent with historical accounts of this outbreak, though not re-verified against a primary epidemiological source in this pass. Untreated trichinellosis case-fatality of 15–30% is a plausible historical (pre-antiparasitic-treatment) figure, consistent with case-fatality rates reported for severe 19th-century outbreaks, though modern treated case-fatality is far lower (under 1%) — worth the writer making explicit that the 15–30% figure is for untreated/historical cases, as the row already specifies. The cross-check claim that "148's cow (6 t milk, 490 kg beef on 1.5 ha) is 117's goat household misread" is a verification/production-process note about a cross-reference error between two research docs rather than an independently checkable fact; it was not possible to adjudicate which of doc 148 or doc 117 is the source of the mismatch without the specific passages the coordinator has in mind, so this is left for the orchestrating pass to resolve against the original flagged figures.