PAIRING · Part III · Emancipation 2.0
The numbers and sources
Chapter 16: Emancipation 2.0
The narrated edition tells this chapter with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.
- 72 open
- 15 to check first
Numbers to carry
The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.
- About 29 per cent: the positive predictive value of Gottman's divorce prediction on new couples, against 90 per cent in the original sample (Heyman and Slep 2001, per SY-05. The chapter 6 documents give the in-sample figure as 93 or 94). Row C16-16. Not in the narrated edition prose: the chapter says the prophecy "lost most of its power" and refers to chapter 6.
- 69 against 32: the share of 45 natural-fertility populations in which a maternal grandmother's presence, or a father's, improved a child's survival (Sear and Mace 2008, Evolution and Human Behavior, per FA-03 and DH-08 via chapter 9). Row C16-08. In the narrated edition prose as "about two in three" and "about one in three", chapter 9's rounding.
- 76.4 and 75.3 per cent: men and women applying for a competitively paid job when competitive pay applied unless declined, against 72.5 and 46.7 when it had to be chosen, about 7,000 job seekers (Flory, Leibbrandt and List 2015, Management Science, per OR-03 via chapter 10). Row C16-32. In the narrated edition prose as "nearly 26 points" against "a single point", chapter 10's rounding.
- 745,194 deaths in 2016 attributed to working 55 hours or more a week, 72 per cent of them men (Pega et al. 2021, Environment International, per OR-05 via chapter 11). Row C16-37. In the narrated edition prose as "about three-quarters of a million", "most of the dead were men", chapter 11's rounding.
- 0.56: the correlation between a country's gender-equality index and the width of its sex gaps in six economic preferences, 80,000 people in 76 countries (Falk and Hermle 2018, Science, per HC-07 via chapter 15), against the paradox vanishing once stereotype strength is controlled across 300,000 pupils in 64 countries (Breda, Jouini, Napp and Thebault 2020, PNAS, per SY-01 and HC-07). Rows C16-60, C16-61. Not in the narrated edition prose as figures: "dozens of countries", "the best counter-study".
Two further figures carry the chapter's own argument and are in prose: 350 hours a year (Boelmann, Raute and Schönberg, row C16-03, chapter 13's figure) and 39 percentage points (Dube and Harish 2020, row C16-54, chapter 14's figure).
Every figure
One row for each figure or finding in the data edition's chapter, whether or not the narrated edition kept it. Layer says whether it belongs to physiology, behaviour or culture. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.
| Figure | What it measures | Study (authors, year, venue, N) | Document | Row | Layer | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1958 | Year income splitting entered the West German tax code | Steiner and Wrohlich 2004 | SY-06 via ch. 13 | C16-01 | culture | robust |
| The year her payslip overtakes his | Western households react (more housework, exit, divorce) when a wife out-earns her husband; not in the East | Lippmann, Georgieff and Senik 2020, The Economic Journal | SY-06, HC-06 via ch. 13 | C16-02 | culture | robust |
| 350 hours a year; about 1,800; no gap for fathers; 73 per cent | East German mothers' extra paid work a generation after reunification; an East German mother's annual hours; fathers unchanged; share of the gap attributable to stigma rather than wages or childcare prices | Boelmann, Raute and Schönberg 2025 (2021 working paper), German social-security records | SY-06 via ch. 13 | C16-03 ⚠ | culture | robust (in prose: 350 hours, "most of the gap is the stigma and none of it the wage") |
| A rumour | Public crèches for under-threes in West Germany in 1975 | No primary figure named | HC-05, SY-06 via the Preface | C16-04 | culture | robust (in prose) |
| 14 to 18 per cent; about 8 per cent | Early legal access to the pill cut motherhood before 22; raised employment at 26 to 30 | Goldin and Katz 2002, Journal of Political Economy | SO-05 via ch. 15 | C16-05 | culture | robust (not in the narrated edition's prose; chapter 15's) |
| 70 against 45 per cent | Earnings seven years after a first child relative to before, East against West German mothers | Boelmann, Raute and Schönberg (cited to a 2021 working paper) | SY-06 via the Preface and ch. 13 | C16-06 ⚠ | culture | robust (not in the narrated edition's prose; Preface and chapter 13 carry it) |
| Tip at the first birth, no tip back | Couples who start symmetrical revert at the first birth, East and West alike | FReDA family panel 2021 to date | SY-06 via the Preface and ch. 7 | C16-07 | behaviour | robust (in prose) |
| 100, 83, 69, 32 per cent | Share of 45 natural-fertility populations in which mother, older siblings, maternal grandmother, father improved child survival | Sear and Mace 2008, Evolution and Human Behavior | FA-03, DH-08 via ch. 9 | C16-08 ⚠ | behaviour | robust (in prose as two in three, one in three) |
| Widened, not closed | Sex gaps in interest, risk and personality in the richest, most equal countries | Falk and Hermle 2018; Schmitt et al. 2008; Stoet and Geary 2018 | HC-07 via ch. 15; SY-01, SY-03 | C16-09 | behaviour | contested (in prose, as the paradox) |
| Paragraph 218 | West German abortion law, fought after 1971 | Criminal code; no primary legal text in the library | HC-05 via the Preface | C16-10 | culture | robust (in prose as "an abortion law to fight") |
| 1977 | Husband's consent to a wife's employment abolished | No primary legal source in the library; Preface carries (to be checked) on the date | HC-05 via the Preface | C16-11 | culture | open (in prose without the year) |
| Half-day school | West German school design assuming a mother at home | Secondary | SY-06 via ch. 13 | C16-12 | culture | robust (in prose) |
| 63 per cent | Men's federal sentences longer for the same file | Starr 2014, American Law and Economics Review | SO-04 via ch. 14 | C16-13 | culture | robust (in prose without the figure) |
| Shelf map | Ridley, Geary, Buss; Eliot, Rippon, Saini; Fine, Hooven, Sapolsky; Hrdy; Reeves; Perel, Deida, Illich; the gap | Map of existing books | SY-03 | C16-14 | culture | decoration (cut, see below) |
| 5:1; bids for connection | Ratio of positive to negative exchanges in stable couples | Gottman 1994; sources are a couples-app blog and two app sites | SY-05; CO-01 via ch. 6 | C16-15 | behaviour | fallen (in prose as "a ratio", "a couples' app") |
| 90 (or 93, 94) in sample; about 29 out of sample | Gottman's divorce-prediction accuracy; positive predictive value on new couples | Heyman and Slep 2001 | SY-05 only for the 29; CO-01, CO-03, CO-04 for 93 and 94 | C16-16 ⚠ | behaviour | contested (not in the narrated edition's prose as a figure) |
| Blog only | Five-to-one traceable in every library document only to a couples-app blog | Works-cited of CO-01, CO-04, SY-05 | CO-01, CO-04, SY-05 | C16-17 | culture | robust (in prose) |
| 95 to 100 beats a minute | Flooding threshold; adrenaline and cortisol up, frontal control down | Gottman; CO-01 gives 95, CO-04 gives 100 | CO-01, CO-04 via ch. 6 | C16-18 | physiology | robust (in prose without the figure) |
| Men flood faster, stay flooded longer | Sex difference in physiological flooding during conflict | Gottman and Levenson 1985 | CO-04 via ch. 6 | C16-19 | physiology | robust (in prose: "men flood sooner") |
| Larger, longer cortisol rise in women | Women's stress hormones in marital conflict, especially when husbands withdrew | Kiecolt-Glaser and colleagues; sample and year not given in ch. 16 | CO-04 via ch. 6 | C16-20 | physiology | robust (in prose) |
| r = 0.360; 14,255 people; 74 studies | Demand-withdraw and dissatisfaction; the demander is whoever wants change | Meta-analysis 2014 | CO-04 via ch. 6 | C16-21 | behaviour | robust (in prose without the figures) |
| 45, 21, 15 to 20 per cent | Variance in relationship quality explained by relationship, individual and change-over-time variables | Joel and colleagues 2020, machine learning, 43 datasets | CO-01 via ch. 6 | C16-22 | behaviour | robust (in prose as "a small part", "strongest predictor was whether a person believed their partner understood them") |
| N = 51,012 | Sample of the grandmother-hypothesis paper | Hawkes et al. 1998, PNAS | SY-05 only (ResearchGate copy, PMC review); DH-01, DH-03 via ch. 2 cite the paper without a sample | C16-23 ⚠ | behaviour | open, (to be checked) (not in the narrated edition's prose) |
| 89 first-time parents; linear with hours | Amygdala-cortex connectivity rose linearly with fathers' hours of care; primary-caregiving gay fathers showed both networks | Abraham, Feldman et al. 2014, PNAS | FA-01 via ch. 8 | C16-24 | physiology | robust (in prose: "rose in a straight line with his hours of care") |
| 26 and 34 per cent over 4.5 years | Fathers' testosterone drop, waking and evening, at the median | Gettler et al. 2011, Cebu; one document gives 20.5 per cent, sample 394 to 683 | BI-02, BI-06 via chs. 3 and 8 | C16-25 | physiology | robust (in prose as "the hormone fell with the hours", chapter 8's) |
| 2.48 times; about 32,000 records | Paternal grandmother in the household raised neonatal mortality; maternal grandmother lowered infant mortality | Voland and Beise 2002, Krummhörn parish records | FA-03 via ch. 9 | C16-26 | behaviour | robust (in prose as "raised the chance that a newborn died") |
| Open | Cortisol rise in daycare through the afternoon | Secondary review | DH-08 via ch. 9 | C16-27 | physiology | open (in prose) |
| Unmeasured | Cost of market childcare substituting for kin | SY-05's stated counter-evidence; no source | SY-05 | C16-28 | culture | open (in prose as chapter 9's open question) |
| Factor c; eyes test; turn-taking | Collective intelligence tied to turn-taking and Reading the Mind in the Eyes; more women, higher c | Woolley et al. 2010, Science | OR-01, PS-05 via ch. 10; SY-05 | C16-29 | behaviour | fallen (in prose as "a group intelligence that rose with the number of women at the table") |
| 857 groups; 22 to 35 per cent; eigenvalue 1.05; r = 0.26 | Variance extracted by the single factor and its correlation with task performance | Credé and Howardson 2017, Journal of Applied Psychology (SY-05 gives 2019) | OR-01 via ch. 10 | C16-30 | behaviour | robust (in prose as "came apart on second look") |
| Almost 70 per cent; 342 teams; 1,368 people | Men's words relative to women's in audio-only four-person teams; the ablest women spoke least | Hardt, Mayer and Rincke 2024, Management Science | OR-01 via ch. 10 | C16-31 | behaviour | robust (in prose: "almost 70 per cent more words") |
| 72.5 / 46.7 against 76.4 / 75.3; about 7,000 | Men's and women's application rates under opt-in and opt-out competitive pay | Flory, Leibbrandt and List 2015, Management Science | OR-03 via ch. 10 | C16-32 ⚠ | behaviour | robust (in prose as nearly 26 points against a single point) |
| Measured with error | Tournament-entry gap as risk and confidence measured with error | Gillen, Snowberg and Yariv 2019 | OR-03 via ch. 10 | C16-33 | behaviour | contested (in prose) |
| 71 per cent | Meta-analytic sex differences that mirror experimental power manipulations | Eagly and Wood 2023 | SY-01 | C16-34 ⚠ | behaviour | contested (in prose as "most") |
| No primary source | SY-05's organisation principle rests on "research in the financial services sector and broader economic models" | SY-05 (its reference is an IMF working paper on unpaid work) | SY-05 | C16-35 | culture | open (in prose as "the folklore") |
| RR 1.33; 528,908 people; 55 hours or more | Stroke risk from long hours (CI 1.11 to 1.61) | Kivimäki et al. 2015, The Lancet | OR-05 via ch. 11 | C16-36 | physiology | robust (not in the narrated edition's prose as a figure; chapter 11's) |
| 745,194 deaths in 2016; 72 per cent male | Deaths attributable to long working hours | Pega et al. 2021, Environment International | OR-05 via ch. 11 | C16-37 ⚠ | physiology | robust (in prose as three-quarters of a million) |
| d = 0.00 and 0.04; 162 studies | Leadership style by sex, task-oriented and interpersonal (PS-03 gives 161 studies) | Eagly and Johnson 1990 | OR-02 via ch. 11 | C16-38 | behaviour | robust (cut from the narrated edition's prose; chapter 11's) |
| 0.9 per cent | Japanese women entitled to menstrual leave who use it | Ministry survey via secondary | OR-04 via ch. 11 | C16-39 | culture | robust (in prose as "almost untouched") |
| 80.7 per cent of 32,748; about a third less output | Dutch women who worked through menstrual pain and the productivity loss | Schoep et al. 2019, BMJ Open | OR-04 via ch. 11 | C16-40 | behaviour | robust (cut from the narrated edition's prose; chapter 11's) |
| Comes out of that group's wages | Mandated benefit for one group lowers that group's wages | Gruber 1994 | OR-04 via ch. 11 | C16-41 | culture | robust (in prose) |
| 1101 to 1790; 689 years | Monks under an abbess at Fontevraud; authority put in writing | Secondary | OR-06, OR-07 via ch. 11 | C16-42 | culture | decoration (cut, to chapter 11) |
| Within two generations | Kibbutzim re-established a sex division of labour; cause disputed | Tiger and Shepher 1975 against critics | OR-06, HC-06 via chs. 11 and 13 | C16-43 | culture | contested (cut, to chapters 11 and 13) |
| 93 of 134; 88 | Tasks showing a significant sex difference in the Marine Corps task force; those favouring all-male teams | Marine Corps Ground Combat Element Integrated Task Force 2015 | OR-07 via ch. 11 | C16-44 ⚠ | physiology | robust (in prose as "most of the tasks, the stretcher among them") |
| 20 to 1000 per cent | Women's extra unpaid work, credited to global time-use surveys | IMF working paper WP/19/225 (2019) | SY-05 only | C16-45 | culture | open, (to be checked) (not in the narrated edition's prose) |
| 28, 32, 25 per cent | Care trips as a share of all trips, women's trips, men's trips in Montréal | Ravensbergen et al. 2023, Transport Policy | SO-03 via ch. 12 | C16-46 | behaviour | robust (in prose: "a quarter of men's trips") |
| 178.9 against 118.4 seconds; 2:1 to 3.25:1 | Toilet service time by sex; fixture ratio that equalises the queue | Bovens and Marcoci 2020, Behavioural Public Policy | SO-03 via ch. 12 | C16-47 | physiology | robust (in prose without the figures) |
| 1991 | Eva Kail's Vienna exhibition; Vienna counted the loop before building for it | Municipal and secondary sources | SO-03 via ch. 12 | C16-48 | culture | robust (in prose) |
| Plough use predicts present sex roles | Historical agriculture and the present division of labour | Alesina, Giuliano and Nunn 2013 | SO-05 via chs. 12 and 15 | C16-49 | culture | robust (in prose, one clause) |
| Proximity becomes a luxury | Market-priced proximity; carers commute in from the edge | SY-05's counter-evidence; Kern | SY-05; SO-03 via ch. 12 | C16-50 | culture | open (in prose, one clause) |
| 93 per cent (Aspern) | Vienna satisfaction figure, from a press release | Developer's poll | SO-03 via ch. 12 | C16-51 | culture | contested (in prose as "one city's account of itself") |
| 175 countries; more than 130,000 data points | WomanStats database; physical security of women the best predictor of state peacefulness | Hudson, Caprioli, Bowen and McDermott 2012, Sex and World Peace | SY-05 only for the figures (publisher's page, openDemocracy, quotations site); SO-01 via ch. 14 | C16-52 ⚠ | culture | contested, (to be checked) (in prose without the figures) |
| Open | Legal polygyny breeds surplus unmarried men and instability | SY-05 (Goodreads quotations as source) | SO-02 missing | C16-53 | culture | open, (SO-02, still to be written) (in prose as the hole) |
| 39 percentage points; 193 reigns; 1480 to 1913 | A polity under a queen more likely to be at war in a given year | Dube and Harish 2020, Journal of Political Economy (18 polities) | SO-01 via ch. 14 | C16-54 ⚠ | culture | robust (in prose: 39 percentage points, "four centuries of European reigns") |
| 2.1 percentage points; a third of baseline | Neonatal mortality cut by a ten-point rise in women's share of an Indian state legislature | Bhalotra and Clots-Figueras 2014 | SO-01 via ch. 14 | C16-55 | culture | robust (in prose without the figure, "antenatal visits and iron") |
| 23.9 against 11.2 per cent; 12.0 against 1.3 | Stress fractures under identical Israeli training; light infantry | Finestone et al. 2005 and 2014, Military Medicine | SO-04 via ch. 14 | C16-56 | physiology | robust (in prose as "a multiple of the men's rate") |
| Arrow or third factor | Critics of the Hudson correlation | SO-01's own critics | SO-01 via ch. 14 | C16-57 | culture | contested (in prose) |
| Substantive negotiating power | Women's negotiating power correlates with lasting peace provisions | Caprioli 2000, American Political Science Review; SY-05's citation is a different, later APSR article ("Power over presence") | SY-05 only | C16-58 ⚠ | culture | open, (to be checked) (in prose as "a citation I could not make stand up") |
| Accra 2003 | Liberia peace talks as the example of women's influence | SY-05 only | SY-05 | C16-59 | culture | open, (to be checked) (not in the narrated edition's prose) |
| 80,000 people; 76 countries; 0.168 SD; 0.56 | Six economic preferences; women's risk-taking below men's; gap width against the equality index | Falk and Hermle 2018, Science | HC-07 via ch. 15 | C16-60 ⚠ | behaviour | contested (in prose as "dozens of countries") |
| 300,000 pupils; 64 countries | "Maths is not for girls" stereotype stronger in richer countries; paradox vanishes once controlled | Breda, Jouini, Napp and Thebault 2020, PNAS | SY-01, HC-07 via ch. 15 | C16-61 | culture | contested (in prose as "the best counter-study") |
| 235,339 people; 32 countries | No within-country divergence in values as equality rose | Fors Connolly, Goossen and Hjerm 2020, Sex Roles | HC-07 via chs. 5 and 15 | C16-62 | behaviour | contested (in prose as "the one study that watched countries change") |
| Two hundred thousand years | Grandmothers in the human design through the foraging era | Rounding by the Preface and chapter 2 | DH-01, DH-03, DH-08 via ch. 2 | C16-64 | behaviour | robust (in prose as "since before anyone could write") |
| About 10 per cent larger; about 1 per cent of variance | Male brain volume; sex's share of structural variance after volume correction | Eliot et al. 2021, Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews | SY-01; BI-11 via ch. 4 | C16-65 | physiology | robust (in prose without the figures) |
| Dependent variable | Testosterone falls with infant care, rises with competition and authority, in both sexes | van Anders et al. 2011, Psychoneuroendocrinology | SY-01 | C16-66 | physiology | robust (in prose) |
| 10,888 participants | Male negotiation advantage disappears or reverses with advocacy, transparency or experience | Mazei et al. 2015, Psychological Bulletin | SY-01 | C16-67 | behaviour | robust (cut from the narrated edition's prose) |
| Birth to 15 months | Caregivers embed gender in infants | Fausto-Sterling 2012, Sex/Gender: Biology in a Social World | SY-01 | C16-68 | culture | contested (in prose as "first months") |
| d = 0.21; about 85 per cent overlap; 42 in 100 | Overlap for a small difference; chance the random woman outscores the random man (chapter 4 gives 92 per cent shared area for d = 0.20 by another measure) | Zell, Krizan and Teeter 2015 | SY-01, SY-05; PS-01, BI-11 via ch. 4 | C16-69 ⚠ | behaviour | robust (cut from the narrated edition's prose; chapter 4's) |
| D = 2.71; 10,261 adults; about 10 per cent overlap | Multivariate personality distance (Kaiser 2019 replication D = 2.06) | Del Giudice, Booth and Irwing 2012 | SY-01, SY-03, SY-05; PS-01 via ch. 4 | C16-70 ⚠ | behaviour | contested (cut from the narrated edition's prose; chapter 4's) |
| 472,242 in 67 countries against over 300,000 in 73 | Stoet and Geary 2018 sample as given by different documents | Stoet and Geary 2018 | HC-07, SY-03 against SY-05 | C16-71 | behaviour | contested (never in prose) |
| About 60 against 65 per cent | Men's extra muscle mass as given by different documents | Lassek and Gaulin 2009 | Preface via SY-02, SY-04 against SY-05 | C16-72 | physiology | contested (never in prose) |
The case for and the case against
The case the chapter makes
The first half of the question, can she, was answered by the mother's generation and has a receipt: the wall moved mothers (350 hours, chapter 13), culture is the largest effect in the book. The receipt has a second column: the wall did not move fathers in either Germany; couples revert at the first birth East and West alike (chapter 7); the grandmother and not the father kept children alive wherever anyone counted (chapter 9); the gaps widened in the most equal countries (chapter 15). The second half, how would she and he want to, was not asked because asking sounded like the opponents. But the kitchen is already designed (income splitting 1958, the half-day school, the long week, the standard for one skeleton), so the choice is between design from folklore, from denial and from the evidence. Seven principles, one per scale, each as a conditional with its counter-evidence on the same line:
- Couple: agree the stop rule before the first flood and who is asking for change this time (chapter 6). Counter: the loudest predictors have no sex (Joel).
- Family: build the third adult in, by kin where near, paid care where not; the parent who takes the hours becomes the parent the data describe (chapters 8 and 9). Counter: daycare cortisol open; Krummhörn; the father's one in three untested where fathers do half.
- Team: change the form and name the chair before changing headcount (chapter 10). Counter: Gillen, Snowberg and Yariv; Eagly and Wood (if airtime tracks power, the chair fixes power, not sex).
- Organisation: pay for the outcome not the hour, build the accommodation nobody has to be named to use, write down who answers to whom (chapter 11). Counter: the stretcher (Marine Corps).
- City: count the loop, build for the loop not the women (chapter 12). Counter: the plough; proximity as luxury; whether the city is about sex or care.
- State: design for safety not gentleness; standard to the task, training to the bone (chapter 14). Counter: the arrow; (SO-02, still to be written).
- World: budget for difference under equality rather than read it as the door having failed (chapters 5 and 15). Counter: Breda; Fors Connolly; no verdict.
The ending: the mother would recognise that every principle begins where hers did; she would not recognise the father as a body that changes with the hours, the grandmother removed by a tax form and a half-day school, and the grammar in place of an arrangement. Emancipation 2.0 is not a second wave but the rest of the sentence. The tool: four questions in order (measurable, statistical, culture, then the conditional). The two people are one draw each.
The case against
Voice: Alice Eagly and Wendy Wood (SY-01's constructivist case). Sex explains about 1 per cent of brain structural variance after volume correction (Eliot 2021); testosterone is a dependent variable (van Anders 2011); 71 per cent of meta-analytic sex differences mirror power manipulations (Eagly and Wood 2023); the negotiation advantage disappears with advocacy, transparency or experience (Mazei 2015); gender is laid into infants from birth to 15 months (Fausto-Sterling 2012); 73 per cent of the German mothers' gap is stigma (Boelmann, Raute and Schönberg). Conclusion: every design drawn from a difference manufactures the difference it was drawn from; stereotypes poured in concrete; the naturalistic fallacy with a planning permit. The narrator's concession: five of the seven principles are culture-layer designs worth building if the Accent were silent; only gestation and lactation, the bone under the pack and the stretcher lean on the body. The narrator's reply: the fathers did not move in either Germany under either insult; a design that assumes nothing about that stillness is still a design, drawn from a sameness nobody has checked. The case against has the stronger numbers and not yet that kitchen.
SY-05's own counters, carried in the data edition and kept here: a woman at the table does not resolve the scarcity that caused the war; a woman who reaches the top of a masculinised ministry may have got there by adopting its habits (world); market childcare substitutes for kin at an unmeasured cost (family); gentrification prices proximity (city).
Where the sources disagree
- Gottman's in-sample accuracy: 90 per cent (SY-05) against 93 (CO-01, CO-03, CO-04 for 1999) and 94 (1998). The data edition carried "90 in the document's telling and 93 or 94 in the chapter 6 papers". Whether the 29 per cent is positive predictive value or overall accuracy is open (C16-16).
- Credé meta-analysis: 2019 (SY-05) against Credé and Howardson 2017 (OR-01). Both years carried in the data edition; chapter 10 carries 2017 (C16-30).
- Hawkes 1998's sample of 51,012: SY-05 only (C16-23).
- Hudson 2012's 175 countries and 130,000 data points: SY-05 only, secondary sources (C16-52). The arrow in the Hudson correlation: consequence or third factor (C16-57).
- Caprioli 2000 and the Accra 2003 example: SY-05 only; SY-05's own citation is a different APSR article, "Power over presence", author and year not given (C16-58, C16-59).
- The IMF's 20 to 1000 per cent: SY-05 only (C16-45).
- Whether the fathers' stillness in the East is a second wall or the accent: SY-06's open question, chapters 7 and 13, against SY-01's whole case.
- The gender-equality paradox, in full: Falk and Hermle 2018 against Breda 2020 and Fors Connolly 2020 (C16-09, C16-60 to C16-62). Chapter 5 adds Richardson's correction and Herlitz 2024.
- Everything that belongs in (SO-02, still to be written) (C16-53).
- Stoet and Geary 2018 sample: 472,242 adolescents in 67 countries (HC-07; SY-03 gives 472,242) against over 300,000 students in 73 countries (SY-05). Never in prose (C16-71).
- Lassek and Gaulin 2009 muscle figure: about 60 per cent (Preface) against 65 per cent (SY-05). Never in prose (C16-72).
- Hyde 2005's 78 per cent small against Zell 2015's 85.5 per cent (SY-01, SY-05): different thresholds and samples; never in prose.
- Chekroud 2016 scans: 1,566 (SY-05) against 1,166 (chapter 4's carry via BI-11, PS-08). Never in prose.
- Eagly and Johnson 1990 study count: 162 (OR-02) against 161 (PS-03). 162 carried in the data edition, as chapter 11 did (C16-38).
- Gettler 2011 drop and sample: four values each across BI-02, BI-06 and the BI digest; the data edition carried 26 and 34 per cent as chapter 3 did (C16-25).
- Flooding threshold: 95 (CO-01) against 100 beats a minute (CO-04); carried as a range in the data edition (C16-18).
- The 1977 date for the husband's signature: (to be checked) in the Preface, no primary legal source (C16-11).
- Overlap for d = 0.21: 85 per cent (Zell) against 92 per cent shared area for d = 0.20 by another measure (chapter 4) (C16-69). Del Giudice D = 2.71 against Kaiser 2019's replication D = 2.06 (C16-70).
- Vienna's satisfaction figure rests on a developer's press release (C16-51).
Open questions
The data edition's five, unchanged:
- Whether the chapter's reading of Heyman and Slep (positive predictive value, not overall accuracy) is right. SY-05 says "positive predictive value dropped to roughly 29%"; the chapter 6 documents do not carry the figure at all.
- Whether Hudson 2012's "175 countries, 130,000 data points" survive a check against the book itself. SY-05's sources for them are a publisher's page, openDemocracy and a quotations site.
- Whether Caprioli 2000 says what SY-05 says it says. SY-05's own citation for the claim is a different APSR article ("Power over presence"), author and year not given in the works-cited.
- Whether the within-country null (Fors Connolly 2020) and Breda 2020 together are enough to call the world principle a draw, or whether chapter 15's fuller treatment tilts it.
The data edition's marks for checking (4), carried here without the marker in prose:
- Hawkes et al. 1998 sample of 51,012 (SY-05 only). Not in the narrated edition prose.
- "20 to 1000 per cent" more unpaid work, IMF working paper 2019 (SY-05 only). Not in the narrated edition prose.
- Hudson et al. 2012 figures, 175 countries and more than 130,000 data points (SY-05 only, secondary sources). The narrated edition prose carries the finding without the figures, as chapter 14 does.
- Caprioli 2000 APSR and the Accra 2003 Liberia example (SY-05 only; citation mismatch in its works-cited). The narrated edition prose says the citation could not be made to stand up and sends it here.
Still open from the chapter's own argument:
- Whether the father's one in three (Sear and Mace) is a ceiling: no population in the ledger has fathers doing half the hours.
- Whether the stress hormone that rises through the afternoon at nursery matters for anything later (chapter 9).
- Whether the city principle is about sex or about care (chapter 12).
- Whether the fathers' stillness in both Germanies is a second wall or the accent (chapters 7 and 13).
- The polygyny clause, pending SO-02.
All figures logged as OPEN in the log (72 rows).
The documents
- SY-05 Toward design principles for living together: the seven hypotheses at seven scales, with their stated counter-evidence; two of the seven name no primary source.
- SY-01 Steelman the opposite thesis: the constructivist case, carried here as the case against designing from difference at all.
- SY-03 Map of existing books and the gap: the shelf map, used for shape only, no citations carried; its "settled science" conclusion not adopted.
- Chapters 00 to 15, by their own libraries, for every figure not supplied by the three documents above: HC-05, SY-06 (the wall); CO-01, CO-04 (the couple); FA-01, FA-03, DH-08, BI-02, BI-06 (the family); OR-01, OR-03 (the team); OR-02, OR-04, OR-05, OR-06, OR-07 (the organisation); SO-03 (the city); SO-01, SO-04 (the state); HC-07, SO-05 (the world); PS-01, BI-11 (the bells); SY-02, SY-04 (the trap).
- SO-02 Sex ratios, polygyny and social stability: missing, see (SO-02, still to be written) in chapter 14.
Its documents in the Library
160 164 169 181 183 188 197 198 199 200 202 204 207 208 210 211 215 217 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 229 230 231 234 235 236 237 238 239